I'm waiting for Sn0 to come back and hear who he thinks the last scum is. To me, it's between JJD and you and JJD is making a lot more sense right now.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12971 Posts

March 01 2014 18:11 GMT

#691

If you're scum you know Xatalos is going to get a red check on you. The only way you could win is if you could convince two of me/JJD/Sn0 that Xatalos was the real cop. The only player that was an enigma that could still help you from this dire position is me because I hadn't shown where I stood yet. A wildcard is better than anyone that isn't in your favour. You knew you weren't going to win the cop war so you decided to risk it on this.

I think from all the players alive you're most likely to risk shooting the real cop because you needed a game changer. You could be banking the game on me making the wrong decision which given you don't know where I stand and you knew where the others stood regarding Sylencia could be your best move.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12971 Posts

March 01 2014 18:13 GMT

#692

Like how do you think shooting me gives you the best chance of lynching Xatalos today? Xatalos would have a red check on you, JJD already indicated he was 99% certain Xatalos was the real cop and Sn0 also said he was inclined to believe Xata more. You had a better chance of getting one mislynch on someone than Sylencia did.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12971 Posts

March 01 2014 18:21 GMT

#693

Also there's a plan I have that I don't want to tell until everyone's here because I want everyone to instantly agree to it so scum won't have time to adjust to it.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12971 Posts

March 01 2014 18:32 GMT

#697

I think it's better if JJD responds to you as he's the only other potential scummer to me. Will give you a better chance to prove your case as well.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12971 Posts

March 01 2014 20:39 GMT

#700

Oats can you tell me when I ever said that Xatalos was clearly town until after the flip? I even voiced some suspicion for him earlier. If you're saying my friendly behaviour to him earlier in the thread means I had him as clear town then you were mistaken, or at least it was never my intention to show it. Sn0, was it obvious to you that I supported Xala's side?

Also, as JJD says, if you thought Xata looked townier by a country mile why did you say Sylencia was the town guy? Makes no sense.

tbh I'm pretty tempted to just skip the plan and hammer syl and oats. It seems pretty clear cut.
##vote Sylencia

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12971 Posts

March 01 2014 20:39 GMT

#701

I'm also disappointed in the lack of baby seals.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12971 Posts

March 01 2014 20:42 GMT

#703

Oats if you ARE town you need to provide a better case on JJD because you already used the it looks too clean thing on Xala.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12971 Posts

March 01 2014 22:43 GMT

#707

I've devised a new plan that I think is better than the old plan. Will post it at deadline.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12971 Posts

March 02 2014 00:37 GMT

#710

You didn't need to convince the thread that Sylencia was the real cop though, you just needed enough doubt so he wouldn't be protected and you'd have a shot without getting cop checked. Seems to me like there's plenty of scum motivation for that.

Again, you need to create a strong case against JJD for me to reconsider. That, or my plan might exonerate you. It depends!

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12971 Posts

March 02 2014 00:47 GMT

#713

I had some doubt but it wasn't because Sylencia was doing anything good. There's a few points I mentioned on Xala that I found odd, particularly his early game. He was pretty damn town after the cop claim for me though.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12971 Posts

March 02 2014 00:49 GMT

#715

Bussing Syl would lose you the game right there though. You were going to get cop checked the next night and you would've been dead. Who else could've been checked? You were the question mark that was left on Xalatos' mind.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12971 Posts

March 02 2014 00:51 GMT

#716

I need to know of you and of JJD if you're going to be around at deadline. Sn0 could execute it too though if I die as long as he follows the instructions.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12971 Posts

March 02 2014 00:54 GMT

#719

On March 02 2014 09:53 Oatsmaster wrote:

Show nested quote +

I wasnt gonna get cop checked for sure. Where was Xata thinking Im scum before d1?

I mean on N1. JJD and I were looking very townie, Sylencia was the opposing cop claim and Sn0 was already checked. Who else would he check? You were an extremely likely check.