Newbie Mini Mafia XLV - Page 9

On August 02 2013 04:44 StiMaDDict wrote:
Bored. Waiting..

Alakaslam, does Templar drop work in SCII?

On August 02 2013 04:59 StiMaDDict wrote:
YOU VOTED ALAKASLAM?!

On August 02 2013 09:39 Umasi wrote:
dammit slam that's so irrelevant and funny.
you can't just go tell people memes/gifs are bad and then post something like that, slam. it's not okay!

On August 02 2013 09:45 Holyflare wrote:
I'd appreciate if you cut the pointless fluff posts please, I'm trying to formulate my post and updating it with new information from these night posts as I go along and you are just adding more confusion right now.

On August 02 2013 10:35 Holyflare wrote:
Well crap....

I am going to assume for balance reasons that there is a serial killer. That's 2KP.... with at least 4 total scum players that's 7 townies left. There could however be more than 4 scum...

On August 02 2013 10:39 Nightcat99 wrote:
The thing is i through he was town too but no one can be sure, and there is no way to ensure a lynch on any one else. I know i might be stubborn but i just cant agree with a peaceful no lynch.

I will be honest through, i dont think Sc_am is scum at all. First of all, hes obviously lurking and not busy. In that case, hes scum team would pressure him to play and give advice. I think you are much likely to do something, if you are 2 other scum and a coach on another forum pressuring you. And his lack of motivation is a tell of a horrible town.

i need to form a opinion on scums through, i will go dive filter for a bit.

On August 02 2013 10:40 Nightcat99 wrote:
Btw any suggestion whos filter you want me to dive first and give opinion on?

On August 02 2013 11:05 RDaneelOlivaw wrote:
As you can see I've been trying to pick up my posting in the past couple of pages. Started slow obviously.

I'm concerned a little about Stim still. I haven't seen an in-depth post from him, he's mostly just one liners, and nobody has called him out on it at all. I understand why you've looked at some of my posts, since most of them were pretty reactionary, but why has he gotten so little attention?

On August 01 2013 04:31 Zyrre wrote:
Was just about the post the same thoughts holy. Noting every single thought in the thread is a terrible idea if you are town.
As you say holy, its a simple way for scum to fit in since you dont really have to commit to any single post.
But also its not very productive. If you have a thought you should first pursue it yourself and compare against filters/other posts/votes etc and develop it in to an idea or theory, thats the work you are supposed to do as town.
Spamming single thoughts and nitpicking on a single post is largely useless.

On August 02 2013 11:16 Holyflare wrote:
I want you to read up on Nightcat, it would help make my job easier and I see you haven't really commented on him much.

On August 02 2013 11:21 RDaneelOlivaw wrote:
I found his filter to be scummy because of the how he kept talking about all the guides he had been studying. I honestly overestimated him as a player. As you all were quick to point out, he was either bad town or mafia, and his he claimed to be so well read on the game I assumed he was a mafia member who had not quite learned how to play his hand with subtlety. To be fair, I think I was probably a little hard on him, he did get thrown into a rough situation. My estimation of Deus was based off of the first couple of pages I read, where he was being aggressive against reps with what I saw as little reason, which is why I initally questioned his motives. Unwarranted aggression so early seems a bit scummy to me. As I dug in deeper to reps posts though I began to suspect him myself, for the above mentioned reasons, which is why I withdrew my statement against Deus and shifted my attention towards reps.

On July 31 2013 23:34 Nightcat99 wrote:
I will give some opinion.

Alakaslam: I have played with him one whole game, and 95% of the time i still have no idea what he is saying. Dont ask me read about him, Lynch him before LYLO.

Umasi is a little strange to, especiallyy at the middle of the night with slam, but he recovers in the morning, i am not getting alot of scum tell from him.

Gotard is being scumy, Infil made 1 post on day 1 and call a bunch of ppl netural, thats pretty much how you shall feel on day 1 and the throws a vote on him, kind of strange.

I am off rep for now, there was quiet a bit of scum tell imo, but the chance of him actually just being new is quiet high as well, but i would like to ask Rep to point some fingers and tell us what you feel about people instead of responding nonsense.

I would much lynch a lurker then any one thats posting at the moment, but there are still time, every one shall give some opinion on what is going on.

On August 02 2013 04:18 Nightcat99 wrote:
If we get a no Lynch because you move your vote on the last minute, you and rep is both going to be voted as scum team.

On August 02 2013 11:29 RDaneelOlivaw wrote:
Thought process through the posts:


As I mentioned, found Deus suspicious---obviously two of you had as well, and I wondered why you had withdrawn since I couldn't see a reason immediately.

Also, again with the suspicison of him trying to nail reps



Here is where I filtered and saw what reps had posted..basically about how much he had read and then all the sketchy signs he was giving off initially.
See here:



http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/postmessage.php?quote=262&topic_id=422313

All trying to play up his newbiness despite his claims that he's read through all these threads. Just didn't add up to me, which is why I switched to him

On August 02 2013 04:22 Nightcat99 wrote:
If Umasi posted something like this 5 to 6 hour ahead i would have been happy to consider a switch , because rep although scummy is no way on top of my radar, and i have stated before that a scum will have a scum team with coach and there is no way they would play like this.

But this is too late, there is no switching at this point.