EPTOn December 18 2012 23:35 Eywa- wrote:
Given Recent Events,
I'd like to give the following hypothesis:
Djodref or Kush (either or is scum)
Djodref and Kush don't appear to be on the same team, however, they both seem scummy.
hapahauli and Mr.Cheesecake or DoYouHas and MrZentor
Other Possible - drazak, Jie Xian
Hapahauli has had many slips and has not always done well under pressure, I'm not sure if this is due to him being a scum bag, it's still something I consider very reasonable. He also has a very strong attachment to Mr.Cheesecake who is even more scummy than hapahauli... To sum up cheesecake's posting history... Not very well thought out.
For a moment I thought that DoYouHas didn't look scummy at all... But then I was trying to put together the pieces on his obsession with MrZentor and I found that... Why would anyone push for that lynch? To prove innocent. In the scenario where DoYouHas would be scum, MrZentor is as well given that they've kind of been on with their little side show for quite some time. I mean there's no reasonable explanation as to why DoYouHas just went after MrZentor other than MrZentor is a guaranteed non-lynch. By this, he throws out a vote while not bothering the disputing players (me and hapahauli + CC). MrZentor then throws his vote at DoYouHas knowing that before the day is over, there will be enough proof going for DoYouHas to disprove him being a mafia member. Now this is highly advanced play, so I kind of doubt it's the reality.
Jie Xian - This guy is all over the place, the biggest reason for me to think he is mafia is that there is always something that triggers people who swear they want him dead so bad to switch targets, people look at him and are like "yeah, he's definitely scum" (which I don't buy 100%)... but then one of the keen players always finds a reason to switch off of him... Is this due to some other attachment? I'm not sure.
Drazak is thrown into the mix because I have no idea what is game play is... He's a lurker and typically there is a negative connotation given to lurkers.
Given Recent Events,
I'd like to give the following hypothesis:
Djodref or Kush (either or is scum)
Djodref and Kush don't appear to be on the same team, however, they both seem scummy.
hapahauli and Mr.Cheesecake or DoYouHas and MrZentor
Other Possible - drazak, Jie Xian
Hapahauli has had many slips and has not always done well under pressure, I'm not sure if this is due to him being a scum bag, it's still something I consider very reasonable. He also has a very strong attachment to Mr.Cheesecake who is even more scummy than hapahauli... To sum up cheesecake's posting history... Not very well thought out.
For a moment I thought that DoYouHas didn't look scummy at all... But then I was trying to put together the pieces on his obsession with MrZentor and I found that... Why would anyone push for that lynch? To prove innocent. In the scenario where DoYouHas would be scum, MrZentor is as well given that they've kind of been on with their little side show for quite some time. I mean there's no reasonable explanation as to why DoYouHas just went after MrZentor other than MrZentor is a guaranteed non-lynch. By this, he throws out a vote while not bothering the disputing players (me and hapahauli + CC). MrZentor then throws his vote at DoYouHas knowing that before the day is over, there will be enough proof going for DoYouHas to disprove him being a mafia member. Now this is highly advanced play, so I kind of doubt it's the reality.
Jie Xian - This guy is all over the place, the biggest reason for me to think he is mafia is that there is always something that triggers people who swear they want him dead so bad to switch targets, people look at him and are like "yeah, he's definitely scum" (which I don't buy 100%)... but then one of the keen players always finds a reason to switch off of him... Is this due to some other attachment? I'm not sure.
Drazak is thrown into the mix because I have no idea what is game play is... He's a lurker and typically there is a negative connotation given to lurkers.
DYH + MrZ
I don't think there's a link between DYH and MrZ. On the one hand yes, they're rather concerned with one another. Though I think that arises out of DYH's "cases" against MrZ and simply MrZ's replies. Based on their individual play, I'm more inclined to think that a scum DYH is pushing a MrZ (town) mislynch. That seems like the most logical and reasonable explanation behind the events.
Djo + Kush
Djo seems town. Other than his sleep-schedule not lining up with the rest of us, he's posting rather often, building cases... etc. It seems like he's genuinely trying to find mafia.
Kush on the other hand hasn't done much to make me think he's town. His play is really lacking so far. One concern I have is that his scum-games in the past have been very whiny/emotional/etc. While this game is none of that, his uselessness so far speaks volumes.
Scum #3
For me this is down between JieXian, Mr.CC, and Drazak. I'm not sure on this one yet.
I need to get some answers from JieXian regarding some of his D1 actions. In addition, his OMGUS seems pretty uncharacteristic of the last town game I played with him (Newbie XX). He wasn't all this ragey, but I do see traces of his town play and mentality in this game. I'm leaning town on JieXian.
Drazak... is... lurky. I have to sit down and go through his filter again.
I think you guys are more right about Mr.CC than I first gave you credit for. It's not so much his voting actions that are scummy though - it's his lack of content in his filter. He just hasn't done much. When he's been in the thread, he's been fighting with Eywa as opposed to doing anything productive. I'm worried that this could just be a frustrated townie though. Now that things are calmer, I'll have to see what he's going to do scum-hunting wise.
