EPTOn November 23 2012 06:37 marvellosity wrote:
Christ that's awful. You do me a disservice.
Christ that's awful. You do me a disservice.
Sorry I'm not well versed in insult-ology.
Chrono Trigger Mafia - Page 80
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Keirathi
United States4679 Posts
Sorry I'm not well versed in insult-ology. | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36160 Posts
| ||
|
Acrofales
Spain17959 Posts
On November 23 2012 06:36 marvellosity wrote: It's quite interesting that sandroba hasn't really fought against the accusation really either. Yeah. I did mention that a couple of pages back. | ||
|
phagga
Switzerland2194 Posts
On November 23 2012 06:38 Clarity_nl wrote: Zbo, why the silent vote on Sand? I was wondering about that too. | ||
|
Acrofales
Spain17959 Posts
On November 23 2012 06:34 Clarity_nl wrote: Wait, I think syllo is scum now? You need to read the thread more. Okay, maybe your hypothetical confused me. I don't see the reasoning in your question if you believe Syllo is town... but now that I think about it I don't think I see the reasoning in your question either way. Never mind about it. | ||
|
Acrofales
Spain17959 Posts
| ||
|
strongandbig
United States4858 Posts
On November 23 2012 06:39 marvellosity wrote: you've talked to me plenty enough that you should be, dear ^^ not everything you want to share with Keirathi is so easily communicable (see keirathi there you go) | ||
|
Clarity_nl
Netherlands6826 Posts
On November 23 2012 06:42 Acrofales wrote: Okay, maybe your hypothetical confused me. I don't see the reasoning in your question if you believe Syllo is town... but now that I think about it I don't think I see the reasoning in your question either way. Never mind about it. I think both syllo and hapa are town. But hapa says he'll take me on the team and syllo is saying he won't reveal his team. I am seriously considering switching to hapa but I need him to answer my question about GK. How do you not see the reasoning? I was asking marv about syllo's idea, not syllo. | ||
|
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
It's mostly based on what I've already said though. Hold on. | ||
|
Acrofales
Spain17959 Posts
On November 23 2012 06:44 Clarity_nl wrote: I think both syllo and hapa are town. But hapa says he'll take me on the team and syllo is saying he won't reveal his team. I am seriously considering switching to hapa but I need him to answer my question about GK. How do you not see the reasoning? I was asking marv about syllo's idea, not syllo. The problem with this reasoning is that if syllo is scum, he already KNOWS how this mission is going to turn out: it will be a failure. The WHY he picked the players is not going to change. Plus, if this mission fails, as Marv said, the first person I suspect for scum is Syllo himself. | ||
|
kitaman27
United States9244 Posts
 | ||
|
risk.nuke
Sweden2825 Posts
| ||
|
Clarity_nl
Netherlands6826 Posts
On November 23 2012 06:48 Acrofales wrote: The problem with this reasoning is that if syllo is scum, he already KNOWS how this mission is going to turn out: it will be a failure. The WHY he picked the players is not going to change. Plus, if this mission fails, as Marv said, the first person I suspect for scum is Syllo himself. I understand the argument of why witholding the names isn't bad, I fail to see the reasoning of why it's good. Again though, hapa is willing to take me, and I'm 100% town to myself, obviously. | ||
|
GreYMisT
United States6736 Posts
There will be a post in the thread when I will ask you to refrain from posting | ||
|
Clarity_nl
Netherlands6826 Posts
On November 23 2012 06:49 risk.nuke wrote: Switching from syllo at this point seems futile. For at least a few hours now it's pretty much already been decided, for better or worse he was going to be elected. I'm so glad you showed up just to say it's pointless to discuss stuff. | ||
|
Acrofales
Spain17959 Posts
On November 23 2012 06:50 Clarity_nl wrote: I understand the argument of why witholding the names isn't bad, I fail to see the reasoning of why it's good. Again though, hapa is willing to take me, and I'm 100% town to myself, obviously. | ||
|
phagga
Switzerland2194 Posts
Kita, are you still running with the same team? Or is it possible you'll switch someone out? Now, I finally need to drive home, it's almost 11pm and I'm still at work. I ought to be home in about 30 minutes, will therefore be online again before deadline if nothing crazy happens. | ||
|
Acrofales
Spain17959 Posts
Explain your town read on Hapa. Now I am really really leaving | ||
|
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
I don't like how syllo is not being transparent AT ALL, based on "don't want scum to know", which makes little sense to me, especially when he made the psot (4 hours to go). Imo, that would have been almost the perfect time to give us his town reads. Sand has not been exactly graceful in this regard, but like I said, I feel that if he's scum he'll be too hard to pin down. I know that I'm saying this a lot, without too much back it up, but out of the candidates I feel best on him. I agree with his read on GK, especially after hapa's post on him. ##Vote sandroba. Btw guys, Strongandbig is likely scum. First of all, this is bullshit: On November 23 2012 03:35 strongandbig wrote: holy shit this thread Anyone interested in a late switch to Marv? I've got a pretty strong town read on him right now, and I can't say that I like Syllo's election platform. marv if you were magically blasted into being a serious candidate would you tell people your picks so they can evaluate whether they agree with your reads or would you do a syllo and keep them secret? I'm also a little T_T that no one has talked any more about platforms/ideas for "party composition themes" like Sandro had, I do think having been in a successful party is a statistical indicator of townieness and the idea of spreading that out makes sense. That said, I'm not voting for Sandroba until he actually takes Syllo's case a little bit more seriously - seems like it's a reason people are dropping off his campaign wagon but he really has barely even mentioned it. there's some pretty srs reasoning there. Strong town read on marv? Really? If marv hadn't told be beforehand he wasn't gonna take this game seriously, I would have gone with scum read on marv. He spends a ton of time arguing with cave fellow for no reason at all, the guy is and has been a lost cause since he began posting. He's not nearly as active and as involved as his other games. He's not willing to run for party. I've reread his filter and there is nooooo way you can get a town read on marv that fast, with that kind of bad reasoning. Someone else had a town fast, with zero reasoning. Especially SNB, who's played with him a ton of times. SnB's filter though seems pretty much like his town filter from last game, in terms of low activity and post coutn, but I haven't played with him much. Marv, do you have any meta read on him? Another player that's come up as scum to me is Adam4167. He has an extremely low post count. This alone doesn't kill anyone of course, but his posts seem to me like just someone trying to fake a contribution. His reasoning for voting sandroba is just... contrived: On November 23 2012 01:16 Adam4167 wrote: Why yes, I can. I agree that it looks like sandroba is phoning it in. He seems to be genuinely interested in figuring this game out. I like that he is not entirely confident in his reads at this point, because I'd be less inclined to vote someone claiming to have it 'all figured out' considering what's been put into the thread in the last 24 hours. I like that he's trying to figure out the mafia's strategy, even if I do consider that futile. I consider it more likely from a townie, rather than mafia faking it. Like, how does he like that he's not entirely confident in how sandroba is posting? The guy gives more arguments to who he wants to not vote rather to the guy he's voting. It feels like he is just voting for syllo due to some other agenda rather than his own. He says he's not gonna vote for someone claiming to have it "all figured out" as a pretext of not voting for sand, which firstly doesn't make sense to me, and secondly, if anyone has given me an impression to have it all figured out, it's syllo. Syllo seems extremely confident in his shallow "scum might attempt to sabotage my party" argument and to me it feels a bit unnatural. (syllo's post I'm referring might have been made later than Adam's, I'm lazy to check this out.) But the main point is: Why doesn't Adam comment on the person he's voting, rather on the person he's NOT voting, especially when asked by phagga on his vote on sylla? This makes 0 sense to me from a town perspective. His next post on kita seems to me like the definition of scum trying to blend in: On November 23 2012 01:25 Adam4167 wrote: You say that you are not willing to call them scum yet, then what is the deal with this post: link I am perplexed by this post. You go on to say further that it was 'hardly a joke campaign', so... what was the point of it? New scum, that is. I mean, isn't it kind of obvious the point of the campaign was to.. make his case on why he's a better candidate? He's pretty much echoing suspicion from hapa, only to go ahead and disappear. Pretty much fits the bill of a lurking scum. tl;dr I don't get how the hell it is that town can kill people this game (dunno if it's just roles or has something to do with the event). But if you guys have killing roles, go ahead and kill Strongandbig and Adam4167. These are my top two scum reads for now. Phagga has explained himself adequately and his posting seems townie-oriented, not gonna go too balls out on him. I was a bit suspicious of Prom before, but I feel like he's genuinely trying to participate. Strongandbig Adam4167 Bam bam bam | ||
|
Hapahauli
United States9305 Posts
On November 23 2012 05:40 Promethelax wrote: Hapa, you will not get my vote today. You come to late to change this election and I don't like that you push us away from Sand/Syllo but don't mention Kita except as a 'joke' It is a joke. Give me a reason to take him seriously and I will do so. Also, you need to hash out your read on me because I have no idea WTF you're thinking. You mentioned I'm "easy to read," that you are comfortable reading me and whatnot, but your rationale thinking I'm "suspicious" or whatever is absurd. For example, you mentioned that I'm not the "confrontational town hapa" when in fact I'm also super-confrontational as scum. Then I see things like this, where you don't mention a damn thing about the important parts of my candidacy (namely my proposed partY) and go off on how you just don't like my attitude on Kita or some crap like that. | ||
| ||
