|
On September 27 2012 04:52 Sinensis wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 04:45 phagga wrote:On September 27 2012 03:35 thrawn2112 wrote:On September 27 2012 00:16 phagga wrote:On September 26 2012 06:07 thrawn2112 wrote:
sup. how about that LoL? I fear we may all be out of a job soon On September 26 2012 06:38 thrawn2112 wrote:
i would be down for rando lynch
i will flip a coin.
heads it's me, and tails it's you? On September 26 2012 11:34 thrawn2112 wrote:
most boring start to a mafia game i've been a part of yet. at least we're not spending forever talking about lurkers tho
who wants me to write walls of text barf text this game? don't test me, i'll do it. On September 26 2012 23:10 thrawn2112 wrote:
yeah but I'd assume that goes without saying So much for talking about "useless shit". Also I was trying to shut the discussion about time zones down immediatly. Meanwhile all you have done (besides the quotes above) is talking about hammering someone, and you are just echoing others. How about you start contributing some? Do you actually think those posts aren't contributions or are you just jumpy because I ragged on something you were posting about? I see you've made a nice spin-doctored and out of context version of my filter. Serious question btw Texting from mobile cause cable modem is broken. Yes they are out of context, but they don't improve when read in context. . I quoted them because you said I was posting useless stuff, when you had done exactly that yourself. I just wanted to show that you were contradicting yourself. But tell me, thrawn, who is a scummy person in this game, and why? Do you already see someone? You guys have spent several posts shifting around blame for nothing. I'm just making a note of it.
"just making a note of it"
Wanna say anything further than that?
|
Okay, back from school, ate dinner and took a bath and so it's mafia time.
Suspicions
I'm currently interested in Ottoxlol and austinmcc.
austinmcc: He might be scum because he hasn't done ANY scum-hunting, just useless role discussion that won't get us anywhere unless there IS the role.
Ottoxlol: Has a suspicion on SnB, better then austinmcc, but the reason why?
On September 27 2012 19:08 Ottoxlol wrote:
My take on SnB is that he really has to step up his game or I will vote him.
First he suggest a random lynch, he doesnt reply to why would anyone do that, then comes out with this "scum would freak out", I ask him why would they, he doesnt reply. Then says I am scum because I write short posts and doesnt contribute:
SnB, out of all the players why did you choose me? At that moment there was plenty of players with less or around the same content/posts as me. For example you had only one post (the last one, calling shiaopi and me out) other then the whole random lynch thing.
First reason, he points out why SnB is scum, but doesn't point out that the point he pointed out is neccesarily scummy. Second, completely unrelated with why SnB is scum, "why me? why lynch me?!". These points I think are scummy because this post feels like it's a post that want's to dodge giving information to town.
As well as, besides his suspicion post, his post's are all about Hammering etc, and they are truly short. This point is scummy because he's just spending time posting useless post's that won't help finding and killing scum.
Out of the both, austinmcc seems more likely to be town then Ottox to me.
##FoS: austinmcc and Ottoxlol
|
@thrawn,
do you has scum reads? The only thing you pointed out is that one of SnB's post's are trying to fish blues, as well as in the same post you say random lynch is useless while you yourself propoed a random lynch earlier.
+ Show Spoiler +On September 27 2012 07:14 thrawn2112 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 04:45 phagga wrote:But tell me, thrawn, who is a scummy person in this game, and why? Do you already see someone? This post struck me as weird: Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 05:27 strongandbig wrote:shiaopi i am calling you out. last game we played together you derped your way through because you were blue, then you solved the game but it was too late. If you're town I call on you to play this whole game for reals even if you are blue, you've shown you can do good analysis (even if your case wasn't very well presented, you did solve the game) so people are going to want you to keep doing it now. what do you think about ottoxlol. When I read that it seemed like it could be a cleverly written request for better play and it's hiding that strongandbig's actually fishing to try and make a blue read. Like if strongandbig is mafia, and he knows shiaopi is town (which is what I'm getting from the way strongandbig talks to shiaopi) and he's got a meta blue-shiaopi read, then he's baiting shiaopi who he considers might be blue into posting more in order to get his blue read. And his random lynch post seemed pointless... enough people have seen random lynch suggestions in games to know why they're made so if he's town I don't see why he'd think it'd work. And as a discussion starter, same thing. It's been seen enough that when it's made people will instead just talk about the meta of random lynch suggestions. strongandbig what is your read on shiaopi?
|
On September 27 2012 10:50 Sinensis wrote:
@ ShaoPi: SnB explained himself perfectly clearly and without being a dick. That goes a long way. All I wanted was for him to explain why he wanted to rng, and he did. And honestly it makes sense and is something I may try in future games myself. It has produced discussion.
I have no idea what snb's meta is. Based on the bolded part I'm thinking you see snb's meta as unclear and dickish? So if that is your impression of his meta then why, when he deviates from that meta, would it not set off alarm bells?
|
On September 27 2012 21:49 Bluelightz wrote:
@thrawn,
do you has scum reads? The only thing you pointed out is that one of SnB's post's are trying to fish blues, as well as in the same post you say random lynch is useless while you yourself propoed a random lynch earlier.
I don't see how my earlier post about rnd lynch makes you think I was seriously proposing the idea. And yeah right now I'm most wary of snb.
|
On September 27 2012 21:53 thrawn2112 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 21:49 Bluelightz wrote:
@thrawn,
do you has scum reads? The only thing you pointed out is that one of SnB's post's are trying to fish blues, as well as in the same post you say random lynch is useless while you yourself propoed a random lynch earlier. I don't see how my earlier post about rnd lynch makes you think I was seriously proposing the idea. And yeah right now I'm most wary of snb.
Besides the point you pointed out, anything else on SnB?
|
That, and I'm confused as to the interactions between snb and shaopi (riiiiight here) and there's this: On September 27 2012 07:14 thrawn2112 wrote:And his random lynch post seemed pointless... enough people have seen random lynch suggestions in games to know why they're made so if he's town I don't see why he'd think it'd work. And as a discussion starter, same thing. It's been seen enough that when it's made people will instead just talk about the meta of random lynch suggestions.
strongandbig what is your read on shiaopi?
|
On September 27 2012 21:46 Bluelightz wrote:Okay, back from school, ate dinner and took a bath and so it's mafia time. Suspicions I'm currently interested in Ottoxlol and austinmcc. austinmcc: He might be scum because he hasn't done ANY scum-hunting, just useless role discussion that won't get us anywhere unless there IS the role. Ottoxlol: Has a suspicion on SnB, better then austinmcc, but the reason why? Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 19:08 Ottoxlol wrote:
My take on SnB is that he really has to step up his game or I will vote him.
First he suggest a random lynch, he doesnt reply to why would anyone do that, then comes out with this "scum would freak out", I ask him why would they, he doesnt reply. Then says I am scum because I write short posts and doesnt contribute:
SnB, out of all the players why did you choose me? At that moment there was plenty of players with less or around the same content/posts as me. For example you had only one post (the last one, calling shiaopi and me out) other then the whole random lynch thing. First reason, he points out why SnB is scum, but doesn't point out that the point he pointed out is neccesarily scummy. Second, completely unrelated with why SnB is scum, "why me? why lynch me?!". These points I think are scummy because this post feels like it's a post that want's to dodge giving information to town. As well as, besides his suspicion post, his post's are all about Hammering etc, and they are truly short. This point is scummy because he's just spending time posting useless post's that won't help finding and killing scum.
Out of the both, austinmcc seems more likely to be town then Ottox to me. ##FoS: austinmcc and Ottoxlol
I don't understand this one, its the same as SnB, you had 3 posts before this one, one is a question, the other 2 are excuses. How can you call out others on things you do as well?
|
TAIWAN NUMBAH WAN5955 Posts
@thrawn:
from what I got from the last game I played with SnB he is neither dickish nor too unclear as scum. So I would say that the remark from sinensis was unrelated to meta, especially since he was not referring to it anyway.
What strikes you as confusing in the little talk between SnB and me? I would also be interested in your read on ottoxlol.
|
On September 27 2012 22:39 ShiaoPi wrote:
@thrawn:
from what I got from the last game I played with SnB he is neither dickish nor too unclear as scum. So I would say that the remark from sinensis was unrelated to meta, especially since he was not referring to it anyway.
What strikes you as confusing in the little talk between SnB and me? I would also be interested in your read on ottoxlol.
My bad I was confusing you with Sinensis in that post about their interactions. Here was his post: On September 27 2012 10:50 Sinensis wrote:
@ ShaoPi: SnB explained himself perfectly clearly and without being a dick. That goes a long way.
So that post about interactions between you and snb + Show Spoiler +On September 27 2012 21:49 thrawn2112 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 10:50 Sinensis wrote:
@ ShaoPi: SnB explained himself perfectly clearly and without being a dick. That goes a long way. All I wanted was for him to explain why he wanted to rng, and he did. And honestly it makes sense and is something I may try in future games myself. It has produced discussion. I have no idea what snb's meta is. Based on the bolded part I'm thinking you see snb's meta as unclear and dickish? So if that is your impression of his meta then why, when he deviates from that meta, would it not set off alarm bells?
Nothing much about ottoxlol other than his defense to bluelightz was bad and I want to see a better one. Just because something is hypocritical doesn't mean that it's invalid.
|
TAIWAN NUMBAH WAN5955 Posts
So are you pegging SnB as likely scum at the moment or just suspicious?
|
On September 27 2012 23:07 ShiaoPi wrote:
So are you pegging SnB as likely scum at the moment or just suspicious?
I wouldn't go so far as "likely" but I'd say most suspicious looking dude. And if he's scum then I'd be pretty suspicious of Sinensis. I wanna see his (sinensis) response to what I asked him.
|
On September 27 2012 23:18 thrawn2112 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 23:07 ShiaoPi wrote:
So are you pegging SnB as likely scum at the moment or just suspicious? I wouldn't go so far as "likely" but I'd say most suspicious looking dude. And if he's scum then I'd be pretty suspicious of Sinensis. I wanna see his (sinensis) response to what I asked him.
are you seriously doing association shit already.
how about this we find fucking scum first before we try to start making links between players.
|
Actually you know what i don't think town members try to make links between players on day one like you blatantly did.
## Vote Thrawn
|
On September 27 2012 23:28 iamperfection wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 23:18 thrawn2112 wrote:On September 27 2012 23:07 ShiaoPi wrote:
So are you pegging SnB as likely scum at the moment or just suspicious? I wouldn't go so far as "likely" but I'd say most suspicious looking dude. And if he's scum then I'd be pretty suspicious of Sinensis. I wanna see his (sinensis) response to what I asked him. are you seriously doing association shit already. how about this we find fucking scum first before we try to start making links between players.
Isn't analyzing interactions between players part of figuring out who is scum?
|
On September 27 2012 23:30 thrawn2112 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 23:28 iamperfection wrote:On September 27 2012 23:18 thrawn2112 wrote:On September 27 2012 23:07 ShiaoPi wrote:
So are you pegging SnB as likely scum at the moment or just suspicious? I wouldn't go so far as "likely" but I'd say most suspicious looking dude. And if he's scum then I'd be pretty suspicious of Sinensis. I wanna see his (sinensis) response to what I asked him. are you seriously doing association shit already. how about this we find fucking scum first before we try to start making links between players. Isn't analyzing interactions between players part of figuring out who is scum?
how do scum players interact with each other?
|
TAIWAN NUMBAH WAN5955 Posts
Hmm...dunno about this vote on Thrawn yet.
Not clearly enough scum motivated in his posts until now for me to join your vote Iamperfection. Not wanting to exonerate him, but he could very well be just doing this as town.
I'm off to bed...was a long day :S
|
On September 27 2012 23:33 iamperfection wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 23:30 thrawn2112 wrote:On September 27 2012 23:28 iamperfection wrote:On September 27 2012 23:18 thrawn2112 wrote:On September 27 2012 23:07 ShiaoPi wrote:
So are you pegging SnB as likely scum at the moment or just suspicious? I wouldn't go so far as "likely" but I'd say most suspicious looking dude. And if he's scum then I'd be pretty suspicious of Sinensis. I wanna see his (sinensis) response to what I asked him. are you seriously doing association shit already. how about this we find fucking scum first before we try to start making links between players. Isn't analyzing interactions between players part of figuring out who is scum? how do scum players interact with each other?
in the instance I was talking about, a strange/unexplained/contradictory changing of a read from suspicious to not suspicious
|
On September 27 2012 23:34 ShiaoPi wrote:
Hmm...dunno about this vote on Thrawn yet.
Not clearly enough scum motivated in his posts until now for me to join your vote Iamperfection. Not wanting to exonerate him, but he could very well be just doing this as town.
I'm off to bed...was a long day :S
You say there's not enough in my posts that are scum motivated for you to vote for me, so obviously you must think some things look scum motivated. What looks scummy?
|
On September 27 2012 23:43 thrawn2112 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 27 2012 23:34 ShiaoPi wrote:
Hmm...dunno about this vote on Thrawn yet.
Not clearly enough scum motivated in his posts until now for me to join your vote Iamperfection. Not wanting to exonerate him, but he could very well be just doing this as town.
I'm off to bed...was a long day :S You say there's not enough in my posts that are scum motivated for you to vote for me, so obviously you must think some things look scum motivated. What looks scummy?
he went off to bed dear.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
