Liquid City Mafia - Page 141

On October 13 2012 14:05 Z-BosoN wrote:

Or have you no comment on one of your top reads?

On October 13 2012 14:16 VisceraEyes wrote:


Done with you. Move along.

On October 13 2012 14:15 Coagulation wrote:
no i dont think ve is scum. but I have been wrong about him every time hes been scum in the past.

On October 13 2012 08:13 Kreb wrote:

First bolded part: Im not sure why you say Im suspecting ZB. I never said that, dotn put words in my mouth please. And quite frankly, even if I said towards the end "ZB look really scummy because of this and I have strong suspicions of him", what makes it so that I cant agree on points he make anyway?

Second bolded part: LOL? Is your argument that Im trying to shift suspicions VEs way without committing myself? If anything, I've been pretty damn clear of my suspicions of VE whole game. If you want to hold that against me, fine (I've been questioning my own tunneling a fair bit tbh, so if you do the same thats natural). But you accuse me of doing the opposite? "indirect doubt on VE without actually saying it"? The fuck?

Oh, and you're pretty damn right Im trying to cast doubts on VE. Thats because I have pretty big doubts of him and I want him lynched. If that wasnt clear Im not sure how I could make it clear. And how exactly has are my conclusions not based on events?

Meanwhile, this is the second time you strangely try to start suspicions of people. First time on BC where you backed off very soon. This time your whole post seem to have been provoked by VE asking a broad question of what people think of me. Is that really the best you can do, cant you initiate any reads at all rather than jumping on other possibilities opening up?

Oh, and you still havent said a word about why you voted Matt. Im waiting.

On October 10 2012 17:25 Kreb wrote:

That is actually an incredibly weak defense when I read through it again though lol (might have ro re-evaluate my 10min old claim of VE/Boson exhange being less scummy.....).

On October 11 2012 21:25 Kreb wrote:
Theres strange things going on with these claims. There a seemingly massive amount of Blues in the game (does mafia have something else to balance the possible town advantage of plenty of blues then? if so, what?) while still being 4 unclaimed roles (hitman, coroner, detective, arsonist). Thats one 3rd party, but could be another blue among the rest.

Cant really put my finger on what it could be though. All claims seem somewhat valid, but that doesnt feel right either.

On October 13 2012 09:25 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
In any exchange I would always be offed first given the massive suspicion on me and it would confirm your theory while removing what everyone believes an anti town influence from the game. Yet instead you opted to check SOMEONE WHO HAS ALREADY CLAIMED. Who no one has doubted the claim of. Unlike any other player in the game, it has been proven I cannot be scum, thus if you are mafia and believe I am third party you would have to guess at my role. If you are town you would receive my role.

On October 13 2012 09:52 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
There are 13 players alive by my count.

Removing 4 of those from a pool of suspects? you have 9 players that could combine the remaining scum. Not just that based on the amount of shots on average per night, it looks like top kp is 2 atm by scum. IE of 3 remaining players from the situation I outlined, at least 1 would still be alive or two depending on the situation. It also allows everyone to begin analyzing on the only people in the game that matter as they would be the only remaining players that could be scum. Any player who gives a shit as town would at least attempt to prove them self not scum in some manner, while scum would be eventually fucked quite quickly.

On October 13 2012 15:03 Coagulation wrote:
if ve was scum he would of faked a check on someone more experienced and a bigger threat than kush. lets face it scum would never trade ve for kush. it would have been a fake check on someone who was pro town and a hard lynch plus deadly scum hunter not kush. kush was regarded as scummy by the entire thread. he would be an easy mislynch. theres no incentive to fake the check on him at all.

On October 13 2012 15:52 Z-BosoN wrote:
So Kei, while I agree that's certainly plausible, how do we go about it?
If we lynch VE, we won't know anything for certain, as he will pop up PI.
If we lynch mementoss, and he's scum, GG. If he's town, we just lost a Medical Examiner.
Since it might be either BC/Coag, it's riskier lynching these two.
So if you are really balls out on that theory, mementoss is the best lynch slot, no?

On October 13 2012 15:58 VisceraEyes wrote:
Coroner dead. If we're assuming scum had the ability to change flips around, then we're assuming they did so for Kush and that they did so with Kush because no night-kills.