Newbie Mini Mafia VIII - Page 11

On April 20 2012 06:48 KharadBanar wrote:

He isn't considering Dittert's check to be real, he considers it to be very likely fake but you even more likely mafia. Even though I don't agree with him as much as he'd probably like, my opinion has since swung again in favour of him because you haven't been quite as active in saving me as I originally thought.

On April 20 2012 06:51 funcmode wrote:
If there's one thing I've come as close as possible to convincing myself of tonight, it's that Dittert can't have been telling the truth with his DT claim.

If Dittert was telling the truth and he was town, and if Willz is scum would have known Dittert was town, and would have been happy for Dittert to be lynched (especially so if he was DT). The fact that he didn't, and went to all this effort to instead get people to switch to vote you instead (citing he'd still be happy for a Dittert lynch) suggests to me that Dittert can't possibly be telling the truth.

I might even vote for Dittert right now but I'm unsure of any implications this might have in regards to other people switching votes and what might result.

On April 20 2012 07:01 KharadBanar wrote:

It's exactly the same situation for me right now. If you are lying, then Willz and Dittert are Mafia. If you are telling the truth, then you and Dittert are Mafia. The only logical conclusion is for me to vote for Dittert right now.

HOWEVER! Mafia is going to see this distribution of posts and laugh as loud as they can before they switch to the townie with the vote on him at the last minute. So the only conclusion is for everyone to make up their minds and put their votes on one player they really believe to be Mafia. I have an extremely hard choice between you and willz right now, therefore I'm asking if you are willing to switch to Dittert all together so we can avoid the unpleasant scene we would have otherwise.

On April 20 2012 07:06 KharadBanar wrote:
If you switch your vote to me, the votes will probably remain stacked on you because I can't cast a useful vote on Dittert at that point, and if you are really town then scum will rub their hands about this and not even have to do anything to win.
If you switch to Dittert, we at least still have a decent chance of getting out of here alive.

On April 20 2012 07:09 willz22912 wrote:
So now Xatalos is trying to weasel out of his lynch by voting anyone he can, sigh. Town you really disappoint me. KB, we can avoid your doomsday changevote scenario by just voting Xatalos and confirming his lynch.

If either of you have any further questions, just please take a look at Xatalos' filter for the last couple of pages, his logic is all over the place.

He says he possibly believes in Dittert's DT case against KB (ergo KB is 100% Mafia checked by a DT) but decides to vote me instead? D3 he was all for voting me and it was at a 2-2 standoff, but then Dittert came in with his DT claim, Xatalos switches to Dittert, but now he switches back to me (even though if he doesn't believe Dittert's fakeclaim that means Dittert is 100% Mafia and by his own previous reasoning, was the justification to lynch Dittert over me today)

On April 20 2012 06:23 KharadBanar wrote:
The main reason why I don't think of willz as that likely scum anymore is that he actively helped me defend myself and get out of Dittert's fake accusation when he could have easily switched his vote over to me and more or less assured a scum victory if any townie had taken the bait and voted for me.
No scum would have ever done that. Not even Dittert. They would have thrown their victory away.

On April 20 2012 07:24 vonKlaust wrote:
Alright, I don't really know about this. I can't say I lean either way on Willz vs Xatalos really. I'm gonna trust my gut feeling, which says that Dittert is DT, and vote for KB.

##Vote: KharadBanar