Towns rarely lynch Scum on Day 1 - why would you expect us to be able to pick out who is Town so quickly? Unless their are roles that can act now that reveal information on other players then it's a crap shoot.

"Find a person we all agree is Town" = "Pick the most outspoken player".

I'd rather go random.

Acrofales

Spain18320 Posts

April 13 2012 07:57 GMT

#223

WTF. This started fast. There are some seriously big guns doing nothing much interesting for about 3 pages. That makes me think all that talk about veterans is code for spammer. Spammers make bad captains (true story).

So yeah, I'm throwing in my name for the captain chair. Here is my campaign:
[image loading]

Who better to clean up this mess than the most kickass janitor in space?

One last thing: this is not a roleclaim as janitor, Roger Wilco, sanitation officer extraordinaire, just happens to be more kickass than Jean-Luc Picard and James Kirk put together.

This is my campaign theme song. Look forward to hearing it out the ship speakers every day that I am captain:

A vote for me is a vote for scum out the airlock!

Ace

United States16096 Posts

April 13 2012 08:00 GMT

#224

Bill Murray level of posting going on here

wherebugsgo

Japan10647 Posts

April 13 2012 08:22 GMT

#225

On April 13 2012 17:00 Ace wrote:
Bill Murray level of posting going on here

You including your own posts in that?

Kurumi

Poland6130 Posts

April 13 2012 08:39 GMT

#226

Jackal hates biomass

risk.nuke

Sweden2825 Posts

April 13 2012 09:45 GMT

#227

I like EchelonTee. MrZentor vs Chaoser, why don't we kill both?

I'll probably vote for him or sandroba.

risk.nuke

Sweden2825 Posts

April 13 2012 09:49 GMT

#228

Actually you should vote for me because I got something like an eleven game townspree. I'm practicly an innocent child.

always townie, never not townie!

froggynoddy

United Kingdom452 Posts

April 13 2012 09:51 GMT

#229

Hello people of TL,

This is my first game either playing or observing where a mayor is involved. At first glance it seems a pretty bad thing for town (particularly day 1 as its easiest for scum to blend in) but I guess we don't have a choice (right?).

What I hate about Day 1 (in all three games I've played -_-) is the tendency for town to get worked up over nothing. In the last game I played (SoaF) Day 1 bacame a pissing contest between two players, with scum and noobs sheeping either for fear of putting their heads out. A good mayor in my eyes would, though not discourage people from pressurising others (how else are we gonna get information on people's alignment) but keep it from devolving into the War of the Roses (note both players in my previous example were town).

I also don't like how in my previous games Day 1 lynches have been foccussed (usually) on one player, or at least people are too scared to argue for there n°1 scum choice as the dominating town players are only foccussed on their own pick. It seems reasonable to have a policy 'vote who you believe is most likely to be scum, until the last X hours where, as a lynch is good for town, we need to compromise for the good of the town.'

If you are wiling to do these things you have my vote.

Are we voting in this thread for mayor or in voting thread?

Acrofales

Spain18320 Posts

April 13 2012 10:21 GMT

#230

Time to discuss some policy! If you vote for me as the captain of the Antioch I promise to be harsh on lurkers. I don't think a lynch all lurkers policy makes sense, because invariably at the end of D1 there is a better candidate in any case. I prefer to vig shot lurkers, because there is little to be learned from votes on them. I am good at keeping tabs on people and seeing where they stand on things, whether their posting makes sense and am tireless in the pursuit of scum. True lurkers will be flushed out of hiding, forcing them to show their true colors, or shot for insidious lurkering.

Regardless of who ends up captaining this ship, we need to hunt scum, so the captain has someone to toss out the airlock.

Everybody may be joking about lynching Ace, but his posts have been silly oneliners. If that is his plan for this game, I am not opposed to flushing him straight into space. It will get rid of one non-contributing player, and in addition be hilarious!

wherebugsgo

Japan10647 Posts

April 13 2012 10:27 GMT

#231

anyone who wants to talk to me please PM me or get me on skype @ wherebugsgo

for now I sleep. Most of the discussion in the thread so far has been useless so I'm probably going to be staying active in PMs rather than here ala PYP:I.

Acrofales

Spain18320 Posts

April 13 2012 10:52 GMT

#232

Okay. Roger Wilco is going back to hiding in the broom closet. This PM game is a bit too confusing for me as a mayor.

Maverick32x

United States311 Posts

April 13 2012 11:26 GMT

#233

On April 13 2012 13:32 sandroba wrote:
@maverick Fuck you got me. I'm trying to SNEAKILY get you to add me on skype muahahaha.
So that's the reason I got on your "don't vote list". Makes perfect sense. For real dude?

This is the first game I've played that has allowed outside chat, So maybe it's common practice... To me though...I don't see much point to just start randomly communicating on Skype or otherwise.... Either way, it's day 1, and I'm simply pointing out things that caused me hesitation in voting.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

April 13 2012 11:43 GMT

#234

Is this the first time you played mafia, however? How is willingness to talk to anyone or trying to get plans into motion a scum trait or untrustworthy? Also that's the literal opposite of sneaky. Your reasoning just doesn't make sense, first time with pms or not. You just got basically anyone who ever proposed to be captain and found a random reason for them to be a bad vote.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

April 13 2012 11:59 GMT

#235

On April 13 2012 19:21 Acrofales wrote:

Everybody may be joking about lynching Ace, but his posts have been silly oneliners. If that is his plan for this game, I am not opposed to flushing him straight into space. It will get rid of one non-contributing player, and in addition be hilarious!

pffft I'd love to see you try