EPT
Pick Your Power Interesting! - Page 33
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
prplhz
Denmark8045 Posts
| ||
|
JACCUZISPLAT
Uzbekistan76 Posts
yeah everyone's ignoring us  ( | ||
|
Radfield
Canada2720 Posts
Look at your filter. Other than your mayoral post, you only have 1 or 2 posts longer than 2 lines. That is why you are being ignored. One of you needs to step it up and contribute. | ||
|
bumatlarge
United States4567 Posts
1) The sandroba, mig, syllo thing is completely circular, and while I'm fairly certain the are not all scum, it's silly logic without proof, just "PM" reads, which cannot be taken too seriously by town. Claiming you think an individual is town ( and not just one in this instance), is useless information, and it has been stated many times before that we would rathe hear who is 50% scum rather then 99.9% town, even if it's to make them a mayor. Mayor is overrated yo, (pardoner may not be though :X) 2) Alright so that trio has been talking right? I'm sure if they have concluded that they are all town, then they must have been discussing reads as well. The first course of action a mayor takes is lynching someone, so even if it's not his most important job, it should be on the top of his to-do list to figure out. I haven't seen a clear-cut answer from them, which is a must, regardless of how important you make it out to be. Radfield is a close second, but I feel much more strongly about sandroba being scum then mig. I don't really fear either of them as mayor. Scum-mayors almost seem like more of a hassle for enemy scum rather then town, where mayor holds little sway. Pardoner seems directly bad for town, and a good townie pardoner would in most cases never use it. I'm still flipping through the candidates to who would be the best pardoner. Saying "I won't use it!" doesn't count. | ||
|
hiro protagonist
1294 Posts
My dream picks are Rad/mig for Mayor/pardoner right now. Both have put a good amount of effort into the thread or PMs. Both are good scumhunters (Well I dont know about Rad, Im going of reputation. but Mig is for sure). My only hang up about Mig is that prior to getting his role, he showed no interest into becoming Mayor. I might be overly paranoid, but I dont think any scum would have been gunning for the Mayor slot until they got there role. this makes me feel better about Jimbo, but I still dont want someone with a #3 pick in office. | ||
|
heist
United States720 Posts
On the subject of syllogism, sandroba, and mig, I'm pretty sure they legitimately think each other are town. I've played enough with them especially MercMini2 to know they immediately gravitate towards each other in PM games. | ||
|
bumatlarge
United States4567 Posts
| ||
|
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
I'm willing to lynch DropBear off his horrible Framer idea and then his defense for not letting it get banned. His logic is weak as fuck for his defense: [13:23] <DropBear> you guys need to think outside the box [13:23] <DropBear> there are 43% mafia in this game [13:24] <DropBear> i will be negating them [13:24] <DropBear> it is easy [13:24] <DropBear> i simply dont use my role the first couple of days [13:24] <DropBear> and use it later on when there are strong suspects [13:24] <DropBear> and redirect their actions [13:24] <kitaman27_> how do we know you're not using your role? [13:25] <chaoser> what makes you think you'll survive the first couple of days? [13:25] <chaoser> what makes you think you won't be roleblocked? [13:25] <mudkip> nobody sees the third party but you say you are [13:25] <chaoser> and then we're fucked [13:25] <kitaman27_> you could be masking scum as town and we would never know [13:25] <chaoser> cause do we believe you were actually roleblocked [13:25] <chaoser> or that you are lying [13:25] <mudkip> and if you dont get it should we just innately believe you [13:25] <chaoser> if you say you were thief-ed then what? [13:25] <chaoser> what about role swap? [13:25] <mudkip> theres too many things that can go wrong with town choosing framer [13:25] <chaoser> how are you goign to stop those? [13:26] <DropBear> ok [13:26] <DropBear> lets say i pick doctor [13:26] <DropBear> what happens if i get theifed? [13:26] <DropBear> or roleswapped? [13:26] <DropBear> the same fucking thing lol [13:26] <chaoser> if you pick doctor you wouln't be fucking claiming it in thread [13:26] <DropBear> what happens if i choose cupid? [13:32] <DropBear> kita [13:32] <DropBear> where does it say [13:32] <DropBear> that mafia kp is not redirected [13:32] <chaoser> i just posted [13:32] <chaoser> in thread [13:32] <DropBear> oh [13:32] <DropBear> thanks [13:32] <DropBear> well then fuck framer lol [13:33] <DropBear> that was the whole idea i had [13:33] <DropBear> fuck i gotta choose something different now -_- [13:33] <kitaman27_> the purpose of you taking it was for role denail [13:33] <kitaman27_> not because it was good for town Kita first introduced the idea for framer to be picked to deny it to mafia/honesty check. Dropbear quotes it and immediately says he wants to do it. I suggest that if he picks it that we should ban it from him to get it out of the game and immediately he is very much against it when it's a very protown thing to do. He then uses shitty logic and doesn't give up until the final real reason (redirecting KP) is shown to be impossible. | ||
|
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
On October 14 2011 02:16 chaoser wrote: And how would you go about doing this? How would you know who is mafia and who is not? How would you know that that particular mafia is going to be shooting? I assume since each mafia group only has 1 KP and 4 members that it will be RNG-ed between the members. Even if they did control who would go out to carry out the hit, they're just pick someone different to do it. How would you know? Do mafia get to pick which one of them goes to carry out the hit? I posted this as a question to him and he never responds to it, only that he can do it and asking where it says he can't redirect KP | ||
|
wherebugsgo
Japan10647 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + o/ | ||
|
Node
United States2159 Posts
On October 15 2011 10:52 heist wrote: Radfield has my vote for pure town presence. He's been very active, reasonable, and is quite a level-headed guy. On the subject of syllogism, sandroba, and mig, I'm pretty sure they legitimately think each other are town. I've played enough with them especially MercMini2 to know they immediately gravitate towards each other in PM games. They may legitimately think each other are town, but does that mean they are actually town? The only one that I know much of anything about in this game is sandroba, and jimbo did make some good points against him, though I'm less sure now since he backed off more-or-less completely. With the other two, it's completely heresay. I don't have a read either way, and it scares me that people are convincing themselves that they're town. Jimbo, if elected, do you still plan to lynch sandroba? If not, who? Why? Chaoser, are you even still running? What are you up to? I still have no idea what your platform is, beyond "I was good at hunting scum a couple of times". | ||
|
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
On October 15 2011 11:19 wherebugsgo wrote: Raise your hand if you believe chaoser is scum and is using bad logic to try and get a possible townie lynched + Show Spoiler + o/ Says the guy who tried to mine me for info and then when I asked him back he declined to reply. So who would you rather lynch? hiro? | ||
|
wherebugsgo
Japan10647 Posts
On October 15 2011 11:34 chaoser wrote: Says the guy who tried to mine me for info and then when I asked him back he declined to reply. So who would you rather lynch? hiro? I think you're smart enough to figure out both who I would want to lynch and why I gave you very little information. | ||
|
bumatlarge
United States4567 Posts
On October 15 2011 11:09 chaoser wrote: Ok, so since no one else wants to talk about it, I'll talk about it. Scum Hunting. I am horrible at picking plans and I'm horrible at talking about elections. The one thing I'm good at is scum hunting. I'm willing to lynch DropBear off his horrible Framer idea and then his defense for not letting it get banned. His logic is weak as fuck for his defense: [13:23] <DropBear> you guys need to think outside the box [13:23] <DropBear> there are 43% mafia in this game [13:24] <DropBear> i will be negating them [13:24] <DropBear> it is easy [13:24] <DropBear> i simply dont use my role the first couple of days [13:24] <DropBear> and use it later on when there are strong suspects [13:24] <DropBear> and redirect their actions [13:24] <kitaman27_> how do we know you're not using your role? [13:25] <chaoser> what makes you think you'll survive the first couple of days? [13:25] <chaoser> what makes you think you won't be roleblocked? [13:25] <mudkip> nobody sees the third party but you say you are [13:25] <chaoser> and then we're fucked [13:25] <kitaman27_> you could be masking scum as town and we would never know [13:25] <chaoser> cause do we believe you were actually roleblocked [13:25] <chaoser> or that you are lying [13:25] <mudkip> and if you dont get it should we just innately believe you [13:25] <chaoser> if you say you were thief-ed then what? [13:25] <chaoser> what about role swap? [13:25] <mudkip> theres too many things that can go wrong with town choosing framer [13:25] <chaoser> how are you goign to stop those? [13:26] <DropBear> ok [13:26] <DropBear> lets say i pick doctor [13:26] <DropBear> what happens if i get theifed? [13:26] <DropBear> or roleswapped? [13:26] <DropBear> the same fucking thing lol [13:26] <chaoser> if you pick doctor you wouln't be fucking claiming it in thread [13:26] <DropBear> what happens if i choose cupid? [13:32] <DropBear> kita [13:32] <DropBear> where does it say [13:32] <DropBear> that mafia kp is not redirected [13:32] <chaoser> i just posted [13:32] <chaoser> in thread [13:32] <DropBear> oh [13:32] <DropBear> thanks [13:32] <DropBear> well then fuck framer lol [13:33] <DropBear> that was the whole idea i had [13:33] <DropBear> fuck i gotta choose something different now -_- [13:33] <kitaman27_> the purpose of you taking it was for role denail [13:33] <kitaman27_> not because it was good for town Kita first introduced the idea for framer to be picked to deny it to mafia/honesty check. Dropbear quotes it and immediately says he wants to do it. I suggest that if he picks it that we should ban it from him to get it out of the game and immediately he is very much against it when it's a very protown thing to do. He then uses shitty logic and doesn't give up until the final real reason (redirecting KP) is shown to be impossible. Dropbear might be stupid or he might be scum, or even both, but this seems more like you using dropbear's poor play as a trampoline. I don't think dropbear is scum at the moment regardless of his bad logic, but I am very suspicious of you making this a viable out. This lynch is rimmed with uncertainty. You are willing to lynch him, but you hardly seem convinced. Actually scumhunt when you say you will and then lynch them because they are scum. Are you still running chaoser? | ||
|
heist
United States720 Posts
On October 15 2011 11:20 Node wrote: They may legitimately think each other are town, but does that mean they are actually town? The only one that I know much of anything about in this game is sandroba, and jimbo did make some good points against him, though I'm less sure now since he backed off more-or-less completely. With the other two, it's completely heresay. I don't have a read either way, and it scares me that people are convincing themselves that they're town. Jimbo, if elected, do you still plan to lynch sandroba? If not, who? Why? Chaoser, are you even still running? What are you up to? I still have no idea what your platform is, beyond "I was good at hunting scum a couple of times". I'm not saying I think they are town. I'm simply saying I don't find it scummy or suspicious that the three of them think each other are town. At this point, if you are running for mayor, I think you need to propose a lynch target and depending on how many votes you have, we can start discussing the merits. On October 15 2011 05:54 supersoft wrote: okay, i vote for Mig as mayor. my reasoning is simple. I know mig from former PM games and he's active all the time. I don't trust anyone because we have like a 40% scumrate. If someone disagrees with that, I am in irc for further discussion. Can you expound more on this? Your only reason is activity which is not even purely a town quality (as opposed to something like scum-hunting, scum reads, etc). Have you had any conversations with him? If so, I'd also like Syllo's take on Supersoft. | ||
|
heist
United States720 Posts
| ||
|
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
| ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6789 Posts
On October 15 2011 11:37 wherebugsgo wrote: I think you're smart enough to figure out both who I would want to lynch and why I gave you very little information. You've been rather defensive in your last several posts wbg. Rather than acting like you're above us all, why don't you tell us who you want to lynch since it seems like you have someone in mind. | ||
|
chaoser
United States5541 Posts
On October 15 2011 11:49 Meapak_Ziphh wrote: You've been rather defensive in your last several posts wbg. Rather than acting like you're above us all, why don't you tell us who you want to lynch since it seems like you have someone in mind. I think he's trying to say that he wants to lynch me | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
He just voted for Radfield I'm sorry guys but none of you give me a warm fuzzy feeling. I'm going to hold my vote for a while until I see who may end up as Pardoner. | ||
| ||
