|
On July 21 2011 22:56 Drazerk wrote:
Not to defend Mr I have a graph you can't see but anyone else alarmed at how fast this bandwagon is picking up followers - three of them have hardly given any reasons to why they are voting for him bar "I fully agree with Mig".
he did not drink with me
he ain't matey u see
"He ain't drinkin' with mateys"
He ain't drinkin' with mateys
scum aboard gentlemen
he ain't drinkin' with us mateys
we need to purge him
he ain't drinkin' with my mateys
dying is his fatey, my matey
|
I think it'd be very scummy to oppose our bandwagon.
|
On July 21 2011 23:09 Palmar wrote:
I think it'd be very scummy to oppose our bandwagon.
why is that exactly? Isn't it even more scummy for everyone to unanimously vote along this bandwagon (as the flip then reveals nothing about anyone)?
|
|
|
On July 21 2011 23:01 flamewheel wrote:
Oh wow supersoft you got the 1337th reply. I wanted it.
awww I am so sorry, I didn't even notice that :D
|
On July 21 2011 23:13 Palmar wrote:
it reveals his red name.
it reveals whether hes a roleblocker or just a guard.
|
United Kingdom31255 Posts
On July 21 2011 23:09 Palmar wrote:
I think it'd be very scummy to oppose our bandwagon.
If people vote for someone with no real input other than the vote I will point them out on it. I did in XL and only saved myself by lynching the God farther. I learnt from that mistake and unless I see a reason along side a vote other than a blind agreement I will find it scummy. Just because this is a PM game does not give you an excuse and I don't intend to appose the bandwagon I already mentioned he has been acting stupidly but I won't let every scum get a free pass by voting for him.
|
On July 21 2011 23:17 Drazerk wrote:Show nested quote +On July 21 2011 23:09 Palmar wrote:
I think it'd be very scummy to oppose our bandwagon. If people vote for someone with no real input other than the vote I will point them out on it. I did in XL and only saved myself by lynching the God farther. I learnt from that mistake and unless I see a reason along side a vote other than a blind agreement I will find it scummy. Just because this is a PM game does not give you an excuse and I don't intend to appose the bandwagon I already mentioned he has been acting stupidly but I won't let every scum get a free pass by voting for him.
|
United States4714 Posts
Btw concerning clue analysis. Pretty sure it was joker who killed syllo. It says syllo and coag were killed in hilarious ways. We already know harley killed coag so it makes sense for harley/joker to kill people in hilarious ways. Along with that syllo was killed with a crowbar. The joker beat up/killed robin primarily using a crowbar in one of the most famous comic book deaths.
![[image loading]](http://www.toplessrobot.com/RobinDeath.jpg)
|
ROL is Joker, shot crjninja
Wiggles is Batman, shot me.
Youngmini is Raas Al Ghul, shot ROL
Mafia:
Mig killed notasmurf
VarysTheSpider killed syllogim
Other mafia killed curu
Curu killed Coag.
Justification:
Sad in kills denotes mafia kills.
ROL is 3rd party, no medic would save him. If he was vet, why lie.
Joker kill is clear, so either Raas or Batman shot ROL.
ROL is Joker, Batman shooting him would kill him so Raas shot him.
Clues:
Chest open indicates Mig, who has a picture of bender on his profile.
Joker uses Gasoline. Line from ROL's profile: 'Or does it explode?'
'Crow' bar, purposefully spaced. Feast of Crows -> everything on Varys' profile basically.
|
Wiggles + YM is more of intuition than anything else. I propose lynch ROL first which should remove those two from the game. Then we lynch Mig for being mafia, which would be confirmed via the QT stuff.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
GUYS WHAT THE FUCK!?!?!?!?!?
You guys have started a bandwagon simply because I was defending redFF? I didn't think he was scummy, and just because I was wrong doesn't automatically make me scum. My comments are in the green.
On July 21 2011 22:21 Mig wrote:Nisani is ridiculous scummy and should be killed asap. Nisani has done virtually 0 scum hunting and contributed absolutely nothing to the town this game. While repeatedly talking about how much work he is putting into his graph (which no one will ever get to see). A common scum tell is to talk about what analysis they are providing the town without every actually producing any. If that weren't enough look at these posts. Show nested quote +On July 20 2011 02:09 Nisani201 wrote:
Unless there's something I've missed (which is unlikely because I read through the thread 3x as slowly as I input everything into my node graph), the only evidence against redFF that isn't related to supersoft is the fact that he posts a lot of spam, which isn't enough to warrant a lynch at all. Show nested quote +On July 20 2011 01:54 Nisani201 wrote:
I really don't think we should be voting for redFF today. Most of the evidence against him has to do with supersoft, therefore lynching supersoft first will give us more information on him, and whether or not the lynch will be worth it. Show nested quote +On July 19 2011 04:11 Nisani201 wrote:
Supersoft has far too many scumtells to be ignored; however if he flips green then I would seriously consider lynching Curu D2, as he started the bandwagon.
A) He strongly defends scum Redff, trying to repeatedly push the lynch off of him. OH NO I'M DEFENDING SOMEONE!!!! I MUST BE SCUM!!!!B) He tries to get supersoft lynched with the reasoning that it will give us more information ( I am sure if we lynched supersoft and he flipped green he would have used that to defend red) Incorrect. I stated in the past that one of them was Mafia; if supersoft flipped green I would have been all over redFF.C) The worst thing by far is he calls supersoft incredibly scummy but then says that we should lynch curu if super flips green. Remember this is the exact same strategy redff was using. Red was strongly attacking curu so that when super flipped green he could use that to try and get the town to mislynch curu day2. Also after he made this post syllo called him out on it and he completely disappeared from the thread. That was a mistake; I told Curu in a PM conversation that I don't think that anymore.Nisani has provided nothing to the town while promising analysis that we will never see. Defended and tried to push the lynch off of a confirmed scum. And he used the same strategy as Redff in trying to prepare a mislynch of curu day 2, despite the fact that he himself called Super scummy.
##vote Nisani
I don't like you, Mig. Ever since you requested the vet list I have been suspicious. The lynch suspects (RoL and I think Pyo) is already here so there is no need to write analysis (especially because RoL has so few posts).
The fact that this bandwagon has taken place so fast also seems strange, doesn't it? Palmar just randomly votes for me and then suddenly a bunch of people follow after with extremely minimal evidence.
You guys are losing a very valuable player. Don't waste it.
|
Rol doesn't need to be lynched, I basically proved that he's 3rd party, so the wolves can eat him. If he isn't dead tomorrow we just lynch him.
you however, soft defended your mafia scumbuddy, for no reason whatsoever. You even proved that you don't read the thread, there was plenty of evidence against redFF, not just the fact that he defended supersoft, it was HOW he defended supersoft that was scummy.
And then, like an idiot, you still try to get the wagon off redFF to supersoft, again for no reason but some very vague idea that "we will get more information" from it.
You're using bad logic, you're not helping, how the hell do you consider yourself a valuable player at the moment?
I want you dead.
|
On July 22 2011 00:33 Nisani201 wrote:GUYS WHAT THE FUCK!?!?!?!?!? You guys have started a bandwagon simply because I was defending redFF? I didn't think he was scummy, and just because I was wrong doesn't automatically make me scum. My comments are in the green. Show nested quote +On July 21 2011 22:21 Mig wrote:Nisani is ridiculous scummy and should be killed asap. Nisani has done virtually 0 scum hunting and contributed absolutely nothing to the town this game. While repeatedly talking about how much work he is putting into his graph (which no one will ever get to see). A common scum tell is to talk about what analysis they are providing the town without every actually producing any. If that weren't enough look at these posts. On July 20 2011 02:09 Nisani201 wrote:
Unless there's something I've missed (which is unlikely because I read through the thread 3x as slowly as I input everything into my node graph), the only evidence against redFF that isn't related to supersoft is the fact that he posts a lot of spam, which isn't enough to warrant a lynch at all. On July 20 2011 01:54 Nisani201 wrote:
I really don't think we should be voting for redFF today. Most of the evidence against him has to do with supersoft, therefore lynching supersoft first will give us more information on him, and whether or not the lynch will be worth it. On July 19 2011 04:11 Nisani201 wrote:
Supersoft has far too many scumtells to be ignored; however if he flips green then I would seriously consider lynching Curu D2, as he started the bandwagon.
A) He strongly defends scum Redff, trying to repeatedly push the lynch off of him. OH NO I'M DEFENDING SOMEONE!!!! I MUST BE SCUM!!!!B) He tries to get supersoft lynched with the reasoning that it will give us more information ( I am sure if we lynched supersoft and he flipped green he would have used that to defend red) Incorrect. I stated in the past that one of them was Mafia; if supersoft flipped green I would have been all over redFF.C) The worst thing by far is he calls supersoft incredibly scummy but then says that we should lynch curu if super flips green. Remember this is the exact same strategy redff was using. Red was strongly attacking curu so that when super flipped green he could use that to try and get the town to mislynch curu day2. Also after he made this post syllo called him out on it and he completely disappeared from the thread. That was a mistake; I told Curu in a PM conversation that I don't think that anymore.Nisani has provided nothing to the town while promising analysis that we will never see. Defended and tried to push the lynch off of a confirmed scum. And he used the same strategy as Redff in trying to prepare a mislynch of curu day 2, despite the fact that he himself called Super scummy.
##vote Nisani I don't like you, Mig. Ever since you requested the vet list I have been suspicious. The lynch suspects (RoL and I think Pyo) is already here so there is no need to write analysis (especially because RoL has so few posts). The fact that this bandwagon has taken place so fast also seems strange, doesn't it? Palmar just randomly votes for me and then suddenly a bunch of people follow after with extremely minimal evidence. You guys are losing a very valuable player. Don't waste it.
RoL is just a dumb idea at this point. Another third party will always target him and if he doesn't die we can target him the day after.
Pyo is suspect as are you. Mig pretty much built the case against redFF and has contributed throughout the thread. You however haven't. Care to share your plans for town if not you? You have suggested only one name so far which is Pyo, who is less suspect than you.
|
I'll admit I haven't read through the past few pages yet. Damn trolls in the IRC told me that I was dead so I skimmed through it, only to find a bunch of baseless votes for me.
I'm going to read through everything now.
|
On July 21 2011 18:27 Palmar wrote:
Here's my logic.
RoL wasn't worth saving, no Medic would ever think he was some kind of a high priority target for mafia, as he was detrimental and not beneficial to town on day one. And I doubt any medics out there are trying to save random lurkers who they think might get sniped by vigis or 3rd parties.... that'd be insane.
No medic would protect you, and ignore great players like Curu, notasmurf and syllogism, people who have actively contributed in and out of the thread. It simply doesn't add up.
You see, I think one part is true, I think you did take a shot.
And I think you're afraid the vigi who shot it might point it out and come after you, so better claim it yourself.
Problem is, you didn't get saved, you're just immune to night hits, you see where I'm going with this? I think we can lower hostile KP's by one just by hanging you tonight.
Important
If you are the doctor who did indeed save RoL, you need to find a way to stop us from lynching him, as it's simply unreasonable to think he actually got saved at the moment.
Here's how you do that. You claim to the person you think is most pro-town in the thread, and he will then confirm in the thread that the Doctor has whispered to him and confirmed RoL did indeed get saved. Just go with your own instinct on finding a pro-town player.
The disclaimer is that any doc claims made by the Insane Inmates trio, will be ignored.
Conclusion
I think RebirthOfLeGenD is almost definitely third party. I think he did take a hit last night, and I think he's immune to night kills. I think he should hang.
Waiting for a Medic to prove me wrong, until then, my vote remains.
You are advocating medic claims to defend me from a bad lynch? You are retarded.
|
On July 22 2011 00:58 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:Show nested quote +On July 21 2011 18:27 Palmar wrote:
Here's my logic.
RoL wasn't worth saving, no Medic would ever think he was some kind of a high priority target for mafia, as he was detrimental and not beneficial to town on day one. And I doubt any medics out there are trying to save random lurkers who they think might get sniped by vigis or 3rd parties.... that'd be insane.
No medic would protect you, and ignore great players like Curu, notasmurf and syllogism, people who have actively contributed in and out of the thread. It simply doesn't add up.
You see, I think one part is true, I think you did take a shot.
And I think you're afraid the vigi who shot it might point it out and come after you, so better claim it yourself.
Problem is, you didn't get saved, you're just immune to night hits, you see where I'm going with this? I think we can lower hostile KP's by one just by hanging you tonight.
Important
If you are the doctor who did indeed save RoL, you need to find a way to stop us from lynching him, as it's simply unreasonable to think he actually got saved at the moment.
Here's how you do that. You claim to the person you think is most pro-town in the thread, and he will then confirm in the thread that the Doctor has whispered to him and confirmed RoL did indeed get saved. Just go with your own instinct on finding a pro-town player.
The disclaimer is that any doc claims made by the Insane Inmates trio, will be ignored.
Conclusion
I think RebirthOfLeGenD is almost definitely third party. I think he did take a hit last night, and I think he's immune to night kills. I think he should hang.
Waiting for a Medic to prove me wrong, until then, my vote remains. You are advocating medic claims to defend me from a bad lynch? You are retarded.
Don't worry about it, the wolves will take care of you.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
