Pick Their Power Mafia - Page 35

On May 31 2011 12:27 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
I come back from work to see a derailed thread talking about pretty well nothing. I am so glad to see town is so easily led astray by nonsense.

To much time has been taken up by this nonsense about ambers role. If he is a dt style dog, he will merely sniff and growl at someone tomorrow if they are red, or sniff and wiggle his tail if they are town.

If he is a med dog he can hop around them and bark if he made a save and hop around and whimper if he didnt. If he is a vig style dog, he bites the dead body in thread and barks.

If he is another role he can figure out an appropriate action to do but there, ambers role dealt with. He can easily communicate agreement or discontent or the like easily enough in thread.


As for people posting base lists without any reasoning to them, Hi for fake activity. Anyone on the zodiac list should be there for a reason. Also no one is also mentioning a medic list with reasons behind it. huge FoS on that.

FoS on kita for FoSing people and trying to shut down talking without contributing seriously then begins to derail thread talking about mason role (which we don't know if exists in a good/serious way as the claimed one atm seems to suck). He also begins discussing the information mafia has on roles. Seriously shitty behaviour.

Once i am better caught up I shall post more comprehensive thoughts.

On May 31 2011 17:21 Mataza wrote:
I have been sleeping over this and it´s bugging me.
So here´s the thing:

There are things we are not expecting(yes obvious).
We have 33 people and 33 roles. Yet Mafia have only 1 Kill per night.
A reasonable amount of people for scumteam would be somewhere around 5-9. This is not slightly off balance, this is "WTF is this shit?".
Looking at these numbers, I would refuse to play the mafia side, because of pointlessness.

So my take is that there is a huge area we don´t know shit about.
I could think of several options, but the point is, this is not helpful.
I just mean to say we shouldn´t be surprised to either
1) see people killing without actually having a killing role.
2) see that mafia team has a strong density of killing roles.
3) find out that we have a rather high number of neutrals(like upwards of 4)

Now this info alone is useless. However it would become more useful if we had an idea about the number of existing killing roles.
Come the next day I would suggest claiming whether or not one assigned a misinformation or killing role. Because killing and misinformation are the antitown traits we should get a grip on them.


In another instance, I reread kitaman27, chaos13, meapak, varpulis and cthsazsa.
None of them scream red to me after rereading.
Varpulis has been a bit erratic since before the game.
cthsazsa has been extremely short in posting. Nothing much to work with, other than added unusefulness.
chaos13 seems rather legit. Other than asking why Karshe paid attention to his list, talking about the only person on the list he knows, there has been nothing odd.
Meapak was maybe a bad call by me to check in the first place. Without any meta knowledge I´d say he looks 100% ok. Then again, people often use past games to judge veterans and I didn´t.

Kitaman27 on the other hand is experienced and looks quite erratic. Rather short and unhelpful, while also very quick to vote. Unless some vets tell me that is normal, this is going down as scummy in my book.
His only longer post is about Mason roles in general. Everything else is short and choppy.

Barring an extraordinary defense, Kitaman27 is guilty in my eyes.

On May 31 2011 20:12 prplhz wrote:
I'm gonna agree with the FoS on kitaman27.

One of his first post is this:
+ Show Spoiler +

.. and I honestly do not know what to read into that. First time I read it I didn't even notice but I think it's a weird thing to say.

The following posts are all without content, telling people to stop talking about dog+list.

Then he just made his biggest contribution yet, in defense of himself. I consider this scummy.