Pick Their Power Mafia - Page 184

On June 19 2011 20:00 deconduo wrote:
Any suggestions for PTP2?

On June 19 2011 22:50 Eternalmisfit wrote:


I think that list checking roles are just too powerful based on PTP and PYPI. This could have been handled in a couple of ways:
1. Make lists check return # of town instead of # of mafia. This would give the DT mafia + 3rd party in list which makes it harder to determine the scum exactly.
2. Reduce/Restrict number of list-checks.

I also think that if we had 3 assassins instead of 1 SK as Jackal was fake-claiming, the game would have been much closer for the mafia. 2 third party seemed quite low to me.

Finally, posting restrictions are fine and dandy but it becomes kind of annoying if too many people have those or these restrictions are too strong. It was impossible to determine Amber's alignment sans DT check and Torte might have been caught faster if not for him being restricted by 7 posts.

Well, that is all as far as my suggestions are concerned and since I am not the most experienced, someone of these might not be good too.

On June 20 2011 05:02 BloodyC0bbler wrote:


No list checks, incorporate pick their penalty, and shoot whoever gave me my role. Most wtf batman role I have ever seen. ALthough I didn't live to use my role into a night phase, the single best aspect of it was the rival condition bum had to meet if I died making me essentially unkillable via mafia.

Batman

You are Batman. You are the hero (insert city name here) deserves, but not the one it needs right now. So the town hunts you because you can take it. You are a silent guardian, a watchful protector, a dark knight. Role-claming as Batman at any point of the game will get you lynched. However, since you are well disguised as Bruce Wayne, role checks on you come back as Playboy Millionaire.

Every night you go ahead and protect the first person being targeted by a KP. However, you are truly incorruptible and do not let scum die out of some misplaced sense of self-righteousness and thus protect that person regardless of their alignment.

The Joker does not want to kill as you are too much fun. Thus, you are immune to kills from the regular mafia KP.


Notes:

1. Batman’s protection ability does not work on himself if he is the first person targeted by the kill ability.
2. The ‘bulletproof’ ability only works on regular mafia KP. It does not work on role-KP of other mafia members (since all mob members do not agree with Joker). Also, town KP (vigi-hits) can kill Batman.

On June 20 2011 06:53 Eternalmisfit wrote:


-_-



This was the original role I made (I did not know there was Joker in the game.. it was just added for fluff in text). Decon removed the mafia KP immune part and added the Joker link (retirement etc) later on w/o informing me. I made a role which could be used both as town and scum as the KP protect could have been used wisely by scum as well to save from vigi-hits.

On that note, it would be nice to know who made the roles for whom.

You are the Paranoid Paratrooper. You can choose to spend a night in your plane, immune to all night actions. On the first night you are visited, you gun down anybody visiting you at night. If you get hit by a vigilante, you both die in the firefight. If mafia targets you, whoever sent in the list dies with you.

On June 20 2011 06:58 BloodyC0bbler wrote:


Honestly the biggest beef I had was the name of batman. Had I not had that listed I would have been an not good not bad role. Saying I was batman though meant I should have had something else to my power. Making me able to choose who to save out of whoever was hit at night would have done it or giving me a kp ability or the like. The name batman implies badass beyond belief

On June 20 2011 16:21 DropBear wrote:
One other thing I forgot to mention.

Keep the game in the thread. Torte de Lini was being hassled when he posted in other forums. Noone should have to put up with that any time they post outside the Mafia forum. It's distasteful.

On June 20 2011 22:02 Amber[LighT] wrote:


That should be a general TL mafia rule...

On June 20 2011 22:14 deconduo wrote:


Yeah, this was the only thing that happened in the game that I got pretty mad at. Everything else was fine, but keep the game in the game.

On June 20 2011 23:01 Qatol wrote:

Can someone link this for me please? Sorry, I didn't really follow much of this game, but I want to see what you're talking about before I adjust anything in the model OP.

On June 20 2011 22:03 Mataza wrote:
When I proposed killing the shit out of you, you just left the game. Was I too late to threaten your life?