|
On February 20 2011 01:23 chaoser wrote:
So there's 6 of us, probably GF and SK since Jbright and believer both died to the same guy. If we lynch SK today, it's 5. GF kills 2 at night, it's down to 3, we have awesome chance of winning. We need to lynch SK today though. Or we can try to sniff out GF.
Seriously, I'm like 99% sure insanious is SK.
|
Ok, so I'm reading through beefy's posts and a lot of them are either one liners, votes against gryf with no real reasons (you must really hate this guy, you pretty much voted against him every day, can I ask why?), or useless info about people from totalwar. This one post stands out to me:
On February 17 2011 23:15 beefy187 wrote:
Vote: Gryffindor
Regardless of his alignment, he must die.
I wouldn't cross off the Org players just from the kill pattern. Mafia can have a Quick topic where all the team members can discuss stuff. But I believe me and Fluffy is innocent because who ever was chosen GF wouldn't choose a outsider
Same goes for the style of writing.
I think he might be GF, definitely been lurking a lot.
I'll read over insanious' posts right now
|
For insanious, he writes (in a whopping 7 posts this entire game!)
I'd rather post meaningful posts that contribute to the town then continue to have to post nothing because people just want to see my name in the thread. What is there to contribute right now?
and then he contributes:
This is my role PM. I might not be able to help the town much since really... I'm bad at scum hunting when people don't post. At least having me around doesn't hurt the town, the town can still play after dying... so town alive simply = lives, but town dead = scum hunters.
Here, at least we can do two things:
1) Not look at me anymore
2) Have the mafia point their gun at me, instead of someone else... least I can do.
On February 18 2011 11:43 Insanious wrote:Show nested quote +On February 18 2011 11:41 GGQ wrote:
Interesting that you italicised the whole line 'you are town' instead of just the word 'town'. Guess I messed up putting in the code that no one else put in, even though its there... my bad.
and
On February 18 2011 11:56 Insanious wrote:Show nested quote +On February 18 2011 11:54 chaoser wrote:
Ok, 1 mistake I can understand, 2 I can understand, but three people with weird c/p of their PMs? That's a little weird. Is there some sort of faction that WANTS to die? There's no joke roles right? to be fair, my mistake wasn't a copy paste. any formatting doesn't carry over... being the bold and italicize. Very different than a copy paste "mistake"...
Basically he's done shit all game. I'm fine with lynching either him or beefy
|
On February 18 2011 12:33 SiNiquity wrote:
(2) Gryffindor: beefy187, thefluffyone93
(1) Believer: JBright
(3) thefluffyone93: GMarshal, Insanious, SiNiquity
Day will end at Friday, Feb 18 8:00am EST. Sadly I'm turning in now.
Wanna quote this as well. Everyone else voted fluffy I think, can someone check on that? Only beefy and fluffy didn't. (nvm, gryf didn't vote for anyone). But even still, feels like mafia stacking votes
|
+ Show Spoiler +On February 20 2011 02:28 chaoser wrote:For insanious, he writes (in a whopping 7 posts this entire game!) Show nested quote +I'd rather post meaningful posts that contribute to the town then continue to have to post nothing because people just want to see my name in the thread. What is there to contribute right now? and then he contributes: Show nested quote +This is my role PM. I might not be able to help the town much since really... I'm bad at scum hunting when people don't post. At least having me around doesn't hurt the town, the town can still play after dying... so town alive simply = lives, but town dead = scum hunters.
Here, at least we can do two things:
1) Not look at me anymore
2) Have the mafia point their gun at me, instead of someone else... least I can do. Show nested quote +On February 18 2011 11:43 Insanious wrote:On February 18 2011 11:41 GGQ wrote:
Interesting that you italicised the whole line 'you are town' instead of just the word 'town'. Guess I messed up putting in the code that no one else put in, even though its there... my bad. and Show nested quote +On February 18 2011 11:56 Insanious wrote:On February 18 2011 11:54 chaoser wrote:
Ok, 1 mistake I can understand, 2 I can understand, but three people with weird c/p of their PMs? That's a little weird. Is there some sort of faction that WANTS to die? There's no joke roles right? to be fair, my mistake wasn't a copy paste. any formatting doesn't carry over... being the bold and italicize. Very different than a copy paste "mistake"... Basically he's done shit all game. I'm fine with lynching either him or beefy
No one has done anything this game... look at everyone's posts. Sure they might have a lot of posts, but over all they say nothing. There hasn't been a single true analysis done of a single player this game. half of peoples posts are voting or going "I wonder who the mafia are, hurp-a-derp".
I haven't posted a lot, because there hasn't been anything to post about. Pick ANY player, and read what they have posted... truely do it.
Hell, I went through deconduo's posts last night and he had 39 spam posts (consiting of things from "my university actually runs random.org" to posts where he quotes others and doesn't actually say anything, to him just posting "why?" only one word.
his other posts are simply him quoting every post a player had and going "I don't know if they are scum..."
So helpful.
Lets look at your posts shall we?
You have 35 posts, with such gems as...
On February 14 2011 15:43 chaoser wrote:
BACK! I will 100% read and analyze tomorrow, you can hold me to that, if I don't you can lynch me =p
No analysis followed...
On February 16 2011 14:31 chaoser wrote:I will say that I'm not scum though, I just have no idea how to play this particular game. No role flips, no clues, weird rules/restrictions for every person that we can't speak about or tell people, maybe multiple factions? @sin + Show Spoiler +On February 13 2011 06:41 SiNiquity wrote:
Ironically, my character profile states I don't have much time for mafia anymore LOL so true. But anyway, I just caught up with the thread and there's a shit ton of Kita bashing for no apparent reason. You guys are dumb if you think he's mafia. On February 13 2011 06:46 SiNiquity wrote:Show nested quote +On February 11 2011 19:12 Coagulation wrote:
SiNiquity
an average quality player. leaves a little bit to be desired as far as amount of posting he does.
not an inactive player by any stretch but hes not gonna be posting alot of shit to analyze.
No shit, because when I post I'm right. So no, I don't make a ton of haphazard posts saying "Well what about this itty bitty thing over here that someone said that makes me tingle in funny places? And it's not my SPIDEY SENSEEEE" because let's face it, I don't have a need to crap all over the thread like the rest of you. On February 13 2011 07:59 SiNiquity wrote:Show nested quote +On February 13 2011 07:41 Coagulation wrote:
SiNiquity did you even post a single time during the first day?
No. 100% inactive. thats unacceptable. Get off your High horse and get your shit together.
i pushed zerroth and had him lynched.
you will be next if you dont start posting.
Yes mum. Sorry mum. Show nested quote +On February 12 2011 10:06 Coagulation wrote:
No problem man. everyone makes mistakes.
Show nested quote +On February 12 2011 10:07 Coagulation wrote:
this thread makes my nose tickle. Show nested quote +On February 12 2011 10:08 Coagulation wrote:
believer i close you sleepy so sleepy -_- On February 14 2011 11:42 SiNiquity wrote:Show nested quote +On February 14 2011 10:49 kitaman27 wrote:On February 14 2011 10:45 GGQ wrote:
vote GGQ
sorry, busy today Self vote two days in a row?  Hmm. also on top of what you already said about misder his only post from the start of the day: Show nested quote +On February 14 2011 02:35 Misder wrote:
Vote thefluffyone93
I'll be back later. Lies. you haven't said much of anything either
or even
On February 18 2011 11:54 chaoser wrote:
Ok, 1 mistake I can understand, 2 I can understand, but three people with weird c/p of their PMs? That's a little weird. Is there some sort of faction that WANTS to die? There's no joke roles right?
Your posts add NOTHING to the game, you are just posting for the sake of posting... just like everyone else.
At least I chose not to clutter up the thread with my "zomg I don't know who the mafia are" this is litterally like russian roulette where we randomly kill people hoping they are mafia.
Only the fluffy vote had any actual reasoning behind it... every other one was just a bandwaggon simply because the town has no idea who is who.
You make it seem like I'm the only one who isn't posting... really no one is posting, they are just trying to seem active.
|
here goes Insanious saying he has nothing to post again like his last post where I pointed him out. Really? No one did anything constructive? Look at deconduo.
On the contrary you really had nothing to analyze through a whopping 48 pages of this game? Man even if there were spam posts and you are bad at scum hunting at least TRY to do an analysis or else you wouldn't ever get good at it anyways.
Just sayin.
|
On February 20 2011 03:33 ilovejonn wrote:
here goes Insanious saying he has nothing to post again like his last post where I pointed him out. Really? No one did anything constructive? Look at deconduo.
On the contrary you really had nothing to analyze through a whopping 48 pages of this game? Man even if there were spam posts and you are bad at scum hunting at least TRY to do an analysis or else you wouldn't ever get good at it anyways.
Just sayin.
Can someone show me what deconduo actually did? Really show me... I looked through his posts and I saw litterally nothing.
39 spam posts
15 posts that were simply him quoting every post a player made (or close too) and then saying they could or could not be scum. This isn't helpful. The scum in Pokemafia used this tactic to look like town, all they did were HUGE analysis that no one really read and said nothing, and they STOMPED the town.
Look in mafia XXXV, annul did the EXACT same kind of analysis, and the only reason he lost that game was because 2 of the mafia went inactive and were mod killed.
This kind of analysis is NOT helpful, and is used by scum ALL the time.
Now PLEASE, quote posts where deconduo did ANYTHING... hell, quote posts by ANY player that did any thing.
Throught this whole thread there have been like 4 useful posts...
GMarshal decoding why's message.
chaoser pointing out fluffy's missing "you are town".
This was done through 2 posts by each player.
EVERY other post in this who thread... are spammy and useless. Please, help me. Show me posts where someone did anything besides these two scenarios.
|
So...what you are saying is, because they aren't doing anything or posting anything useful, you feel that you should do the same... why? Oh maybe to look like you're the same alignment as them.
|
United States22154 Posts
I just checked, Insanious is Crazed Rabbit.
|
On February 20 2011 03:58 GMarshal wrote:
I just checked, Insanious is Crazed Rabbit.
Does that mean something? Anyway, I'm just a dead player. Since I can't reveal anything more than I have since I was alive, I'll stop posting and leave it to whatever town player is left to decide what's best for them because I probably have not built up any credibility so far anyways.
|
On February 20 2011 03:54 ilovejonn wrote:
So...what you are saying is, because they aren't doing anything or posting anything useful, you feel that you should do the same... why? Oh maybe to look like you're the same alignment as them.
No what I'm saying is that, if people don't post anything worth while, there is nothing worth while to look at and you end up with this scenario where there is nothing for me to post about.
I COULD just go "zomg, player X doesn't say anything ever... he must be mafia" but when EVERY player does it, it shows nothing...
When there is nothing to analyze, because no one has posted anything, then anything I post will be about nothing as well... its a catch 22.
On February 20 2011 03:58 GMarshal wrote:
I just checked, Insanious is Crazed Rabbit.
which is exactly what I said earlier in this thread btw.
|
On February 20 2011 04:08 Insanious wrote:Show nested quote +On February 20 2011 03:54 ilovejonn wrote:
So...what you are saying is, because they aren't doing anything or posting anything useful, you feel that you should do the same... why? Oh maybe to look like you're the same alignment as them. No what I'm saying is that, if people don't post anything worth while, there is nothing worth while to look at and you end up with this scenario where there is nothing for me to post about. I COULD just go "zomg, player X doesn't say anything ever... he must be mafia" but when EVERY player does it, it shows nothing... When there is nothing to analyze, because no one has posted anything, then anything I post will be about nothing as well... its a catch 22. Show nested quote +On February 20 2011 03:58 GMarshal wrote:
I just checked, Insanious is Crazed Rabbit.
which is exactly what I said earlier in this thread btw.
Can you post your PM sans red text?
|
On February 18 2011 11:32 Insanious wrote:Show nested quote +
You are Crazed Rabbit
One of the veterans from the very early days, you originally had a reputation for never lying. You would always tell the truth. It led to complicated situations when you were mafia. Recently you’ve hosted some very interesting games
You are Town
Victory condition: You win when all anti-town forces have been eliminated.
Quoted exactly from what I posted before, didn't even change the messed up italicize people got angry at me for before.
|
congratulations on figuring out the code guys! i really didn't think anyone would get it. you can ask me questions, but i doubt i'll be able to answer any of them...
|
On February 20 2011 03:46 Insanious wrote:Show nested quote +On February 20 2011 03:33 ilovejonn wrote:
here goes Insanious saying he has nothing to post again like his last post where I pointed him out. Really? No one did anything constructive? Look at deconduo.
On the contrary you really had nothing to analyze through a whopping 48 pages of this game? Man even if there were spam posts and you are bad at scum hunting at least TRY to do an analysis or else you wouldn't ever get good at it anyways.
Just sayin. Can someone show me what deconduo actually did? Really show me... I looked through his posts and I saw litterally nothing. 39 spam posts 15 posts that were simply him quoting every post a player made (or close too) and then saying they could or could not be scum. This isn't helpful. The scum in Pokemafia used this tactic to look like town, all they did were HUGE analysis that no one really read and said nothing, and they STOMPED the town. Look in mafia XXXV, annul did the EXACT same kind of analysis, and the only reason he lost that game was because 2 of the mafia went inactive and were mod killed. This kind of analysis is NOT helpful, and is used by scum ALL the time. Now PLEASE, quote posts where deconduo did ANYTHING... hell, quote posts by ANY player that did any thing. Throught this whole thread there have been like 4 useful posts... GMarshal decoding why's message. chaoser pointing out fluffy's missing "you are town". This was done through 2 posts by each player. EVERY other post in this who thread... are spammy and useless. Please, help me. Show me posts where someone did anything besides these two scenarios.
I caught fluffy, GGQ and I'm going to get you. I helped crack why's code. I got people to start talking (sorta) I've done a lot behind the scenes. I've helped promote discusion. I've done my best, made an effort in this game. You say 39 spam posts, thats bullshit. At most ten posts out of 70 could have gone without being posted, if even that.
You've had 2 non-spam posts in the 9 days this game has been running, and even then they didn't contribute anything. All you did was complain that people didn't post enough. How ironic.
This is one of your first posts:
On February 15 2011 13:37 Insanious wrote:
People need to post more in general, and need to post longer posts to give people something to actually write about.
I'll post in the future when I have something to say, but right now... I have nothing to work with, nothing to analyze, and as such have nothing to say.
Guess what, you never did.
I also find it amusing that you are desperately trying to defend yourself by trying to say I did nothing.
|
@Insanious Did you kill why?
|
I'll be gone/busy tonight so lets start voting yes? Insanious is probably SK or at the very least not pro-town; I'm actually fairly certain of this given just how much he has posted (7 posts before today) He claims that he'll post when he has more to say but guess what, he never does. His defense is that REALLY GUYS! THERES NOTHING TO TALK ABOUT!! Weak.
What do you guys think about beefy? No one's really commented on my posts about him and he's oddly silent today.
|
On February 20 2011 05:57 deconduo wrote:
@Insanious Did you kill why?
no I did not
|
On February 20 2011 06:00 chaoser wrote:
I'll be gone/busy tonight so lets start voting yes? Insanious is probably SK or at the very least not pro-town; I'm actually fairly certain of this given just how much he has posted (7 posts before today) He claims that he'll post when he has more to say but guess what, he never does. His defense is that REALLY GUYS! THERES NOTHING TO TALK ABOUT!! Weak.
What do you guys think about beefy? No one's really commented on my posts about him and he's oddly silent today.
I think theres a pretty good chance he is godfather, but its much more important to kill insanious today as he is guaranteed. If you don't kill GF or SK today you lose, hence killing the almost confirmed SK is vital.
|
On February 20 2011 06:07 Insanious wrote:no I did not
Ah well I was hoping your personality wouldn't allow you to lie, shame.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
