|
On November 10 2010 07:39 Coagulation wrote:
1) Lynching inactives
generally from what i have seen so far lynching inactives only gets a town role killed.
i dont think lynching an inactive is the way to go in any mafia game and i have never ever used it as a reason. if your lynching inactives you might as well just lynch the most active
2) Old plan, should the king be forced to follow the town's opinion?
no the king needs to vote who he feels he personally needs to vote. this is the best aspect of the game that puts it in towns favor. a vote outside the influince of the scums grasp
3) New plan, do you agree? Disagree?
I dont think the king should be forced to role claim. i think it only gives the scum extra information that they can use when there is absolutely no reason at all that town needs to know who the king is during a lynch debate. [/red][/b][/i]
1. Wrong. This is a 9 people game. We can't have one dude hiding and giving him the benefit of a doubt. If there were 30+ people I'd get it, but in a small game such as this you have to play your role. You just have to. We just can't have one or two players not being active (thus never drawing suspicion by posting/contributing) and not being punished for it. I'm not gonna have any of this.
2. Yes and no. King should have a stronger hand in voting, but shouldn't go on his own. I mean he could, but he should and probably will be held accountable for any dumb moves.
3. I'm fine either way. But all kings should do the same or pick from the same two options in our plan.
|
I'll take a compromise plan if it means taking some power away from them. Also it's not matter of having perfect strategy - there hardly is never one except in broken setups - it is just trying to eliminate unnecessary variables and default back to what is familiar.
Also will try to get my opinion on Coagulation and others later on. Nothing wrong with diversifying our interests I guess.
|
Right so no more discussion?
Shouldn't we lynch someone soon? Please remember that if king doesn't make a move in time, HE will be lynched instead.
And I don't think it's a good idea to lose Dr.H. Wake up!
|
i think we should use random lynch
random lynch would have a higher chance of hitting a red than lynching me im gonna tell you this right now im not a fucking red dont waste the lynch on me its just gonna slow town down.
|
Well no offence Coag, but nobody wants to get lynched.
And if we were to use Excalibur, then even the king, the kingmaker and the town hero is in danger of being slain. Why would we bother with that instead of picking someone who hasn't been active, helpful, etc.
So far it's just 6-7 pages of posts, so the lynch is gonna be mostly random anyway, but I'd rather lynch someone who looks particularly scummy or not helpful, then risk losing the hero/kingmaker which might be the strongest weapons that the town have.
Heck, even if the king chooses to lynch the town hero, we'd still have one blue confirmed out of 8 (12,5%) remaining, which is better than Excalibur killing him and being sure of 0/8.
|
what happens if the kingmaker is killed?
|
a new kingmaker is assigned
|
BrownBear
orgolove
Pandain
Hesmyrr
Amber[Light]
What do you think of Coagulation?
|
Hesmyrr is flying a little bit under the radar, kinda parroting points, not really contributing much. I'd consider lynching him over Coagulation if Coag wasn't such a nuisance on both sides of the coin.
I feel bad for Coag though, if this keeps up he'll be day 1 lynch in every game he plays.
|
what have i done this game to be a nuisance? i dont understand.. you guys asked me to answer some questions i did.
|
I don't think Coag is the new Bill Murray... I think we're too focused on him honestly. I'd have him as a execute-if-we-have-no-better-options candidate.
Honestly, I'd go with Hesmyrr or LSB over Coag.
|
|
|
It's more of a meta-thing, but I feel like he's posting out of character, and a lot of his posts just rehash stuff already said, ask other people for their opinion, or correct other people, rather than add new content. He could be a mafia flying under the radar, or I could just be paranoid.
Either way, I'll look at his posts later. Tired now.
|
On November 11 2010 11:22 BrownBear wrote:
It's more of a meta-thing, but I feel like he's posting out of character, and a lot of his posts just rehash stuff already said, ask other people for their opinion, or correct other people, rather than add new content. He could be a mafia flying under the radar, or I could just be paranoid.
Either way, I'll look at his posts later. Tired now.
Very interesting. I understand the posting out of character.
But can you please tell me about this 'rehashing'? Or flying under the radar?
|
1 hour until Day 1 ends. Make haste dear King or the Villagers shall pluck your wings!
|
|
|
Oh noes, that is not the right command! Be quick my King and play a new hand!
|
|
|
Tip, type [b]Execute: Coagulation[/b]
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
