| Forum Index > LoL General |
|
baneling
Canada56 Posts
Most people playing LoL aren't going to report someone for no reason, and if these are the cases where multiple people are reporting someone, and it's happening repeatedly in game after game, odds are they deserve a punishment. It'll be a rare occurrence that someone gets reported by multiple people game after game but it all turns out to be unfounded and deserve a pardon. | ||
|
Dyme
Germany523 Posts
This sounds like a very stupid idea to me. Would be like making random people moderate teamliquid. | ||
|
spinesheath
Germany8679 Posts
And part of those reports for mild offenses land on players who also get reported for serious offenses, so you hit punish anyways. | ||
|
phyvo
United States5635 Posts
Was hitting the punish button on everything really that bad? Spine: the cases we get are filtered. Right now we only get to judge the worst cases in order to protect the innocent from possible mob lynching. | ||
|
Mogwai
United States13274 Posts
 . wtf | ||
|
Two_DoWn
United States13684 Posts
| ||
|
Irave
United States9965 Posts
On May 27 2011 01:15 Mogwai wrote: I have 0 cases too . wtfThey appeared to be slow at reseting it today, I was finally able to review some a bit ago. Hopefully the email we are supposed to get with our reward comes soon. | ||
|
phyvo
United States5635 Posts
This person came into the game with the intent of trolling. He was mentioning things like "If my team sucks, I'll make sure my team loses" and "I'm the elo police; I make sure teams that don't deserve to win don't win" and etc. I finally got Nasol Moment. He has quite the colorful history... A few more entertaining moments... xXLordPredatorXx [All] [00:44:06]: omg shitt amumu never use ult pwoerrr xXLordPredatorXx [All] [00:44:09]: motehr fck shitt - xXLordPredatorXx[All] [02:21:13]: i ivntie shaco custom game 1 vs 1 ? xXLordPredatorXx[All] [02:21:16]: INVITE U ? xXLordPredatorXx[All] [02:21:19]: ONLY U AND ME xXLordPredatorXx[All] [02:21:22]: CSUTOM GAME ? xXLordPredatorXx[All] [02:21:26]: ACCEPT SHACO SHITT ? - xXLordPredatorXx[All] [14:55:16]: IS MUCH TO BRAIN ? xXLordPredatorXx[All] [14:55:20]: IS VEYR AHRD TOA SHTIT ? xXLordPredatorXx[All] [14:55:22]: WOW I think it's trying to speak English. | ||
|
Kaniol
Poland5551 Posts
I'm always amazed at people's ability to find excuses o.o | ||
|
Gandling
United Kingdom126 Posts
Teammate: What? Jax is in your lane Then chat went strangely silent for a minute or two. :D | ||
|
dnastyx
United States2707 Posts
| ||
TheYango
United States47024 Posts
On May 27 2011 07:13 dnastyx wrote: Got Nasol moment today. I didn't realize ELO policing involved calling people fags D: Nasol apparently didn't read the ELO police thread very carefully. All of Caller's examples involve doing things that piss of your team but AREN'T actually bannable (e.g. stealing farm, baiting teammates, etc.). If you follow the spirit of the law, but not the letter, you're a vigilante, not a policeman. | ||
|
Two_DoWn
United States13684 Posts
| ||
|
Brees
Marshall Islands3404 Posts
| ||
|
Blitzkrieg0
United States13132 Posts
On May 27 2011 09:03 Brees wrote: Erky Timbers[All] [02:32:51]: i need to work on my anger issues, last game i smashed a glass jar over my head and now i just about punched my screen I hope you pardoned him for that. He might commit suicide if he got banned... | ||
|
phyvo
United States5635 Posts
0pherion The basic goal of the IP award is to be roughly equivalent to the IP received for the equivalent amount of time spent in game. I am working with our internal customers to: 1. Prove that our summoners are spending more than 1 minute / case file. 2. Get an average amount of time spent by summoners to determine what a more appropriate award would be. source: http://eu.leagueoflegends.com/board/showthread.php?p=2285699#post2285699 So basically you won't get any more IP for tribunal than you would have for just playing the game, unless you do what they don't want you to do and do your tribunal in queue and champ select where you hardly have the time to make a proper decision with a grey area case. Personally I don't enjoy reading most of the chat logs. This basically means every moment I'm *working* in the tribunal I could be playing the game *for fun* and get exactly the same reward. As long as this is Riot's policy there is no incentive for me to continue helping them. Moreover, I think this is deeply flawed for the public in general. If Tribunal doesn't reward people more than playing the game there's no reason for the average person to do it. If you asked someone to choose between being paid $3/hour for tribunal or being paid the same for playing LoL the answer is obvious. Finally, if you earn the same amount of IP over time in tribunal as you do in game their incentive to make correct decisions is meaningless. So what if you're so good you have 100 cases a day? I can earn the same amount of average IP as you do with 1 case a day if I just play the game instead! And if I hit ban or pardon every time at 1 minute, depending on how lucky I am, I can earn more IP on average than you do! These flaws are incredibly obvious and I can't see how it will work out unless the playerbase is ignorant or somehow there are enough altruistic people (or people who can correctly judge cases during game queue) to take care of things by themselves. | ||
|
baneling
Canada56 Posts
Basically he's a douche in every game, he's constantly talking down to his teammates and the other team pretty much from the start of the game. He swears a bit, no racial slurs or anything completely out of line. He did afk one game but it only happened once. So on one hand I feel like, he didn't get out of line too bad, he swore but no racial slurs that I saw. But on the other hand he was reported a lot and is obviously ruining or degrading the game experience for a lot of people and generally seems like someone not very fun to play with. In the end I've decided to click punish. The reasoning being the tribunal is judgement by a jury of your peers, and while he may not have got out of hand in any single game I feel the culmination of it all makes it clear enough to me that he is not someone of value to the community. | ||
|
rwrzr
United States1980 Posts
2) ????? 3) Profit Seriously though hopefully Tribunal will take some burden off of the game servers so they don't explode as often | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On May 27 2011 23:02 phyvo wrote: source: http://eu.leagueoflegends.com/board/showthread.php?p=2285699#post2285699 So basically you won't get any more IP for tribunal than you would have for just playing the game, unless you do what they don't want you to do and do your tribunal in queue and champ select where you hardly have the time to make a proper decision with a grey area case. Personally I don't enjoy reading most of the chat logs. This basically means every moment I'm *working* in the tribunal I could be playing the game *for fun* and get exactly the same reward. As long as this is Riot's policy there is no incentive for me to continue helping them. Moreover, I think this is deeply flawed for the public in general. If Tribunal doesn't reward people more than playing the game there's no reason for the average person to do it. If you asked someone to choose between being paid $3/hour for tribunal or being paid the same for playing LoL the answer is obvious. Finally, if you earn the same amount of IP over time in tribunal as you do in game their incentive to make correct decisions is meaningless. So what if you're so good you have 100 cases a day? I can earn the same amount of average IP as you do with 1 case a day if I just play the game instead! And if I hit ban or pardon every time at 1 minute, depending on how lucky I am, I can earn more IP on average than you do! These flaws are incredibly obvious and I can't see how it will work out unless the playerbase is ignorant or somehow there are enough altruistic people (or people who can correctly judge cases during game queue) to take care of things by themselves. This all assumes that every moment you are punishing people in the Tribunal, you could be playing a game. I can log onto the Tribunal at work, where I can't play LoL, indiscriminately punish people and get IP. Or lets say I don't have time to play LoL, but I do have 3 minutes to click Punish 3 times. Free IP, little effort. | ||
|
phyvo
United States5635 Posts
Multitasking between champ select, queue, and being dead will also be discouraged eventually because they've stated they want you to set aside a chunk of time to do it. Moreover, multitasking will tend to make the more difficult judgements less accurate which isn't good at anybody. It's nice that you have a job where you can do tribunal at work. It's also possible for some people to do it on the train. That might be a nice bonus for Riot, but that's hardly a reason to count on it like they are now. Riot end goal is that we put *effort* into our tribunal judgements so that judgements are accurate and we provide meaningful information. They will see to it that we will have to expend this effort to get rewards from the system. But if it requires real effort and the reward is the same $0.02/hr as we get for playing the game I do not see how this system will work for most people. | ||
| ||
RSL Revival
Season 4: Playoffs Day 7
Maru vs RogueLIVE!
MaxPax vs TBD
[ Submit Event ] |
|
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Zeus Dota 2 2850firebathero  1833Shuttle 589Larva  378Sharp 60NaDa 53Shinee 50Aegong 47sSak 46zelot 33[ Show more ] Counter-Strike Heroes of the Storm Organizations Counter-Strike Other Games StarCraft: Brood War StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War |
|
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
BSL
Afreeca Starleague
Wardi Open
Replay Cast
Sparkling Tuna Cup
Kung Fu Cup
The PondCast
Replay Cast
Replay Cast
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
