• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 23:43
CET 05:43
KST 13:43
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11[ASL22] Ro16 Preview: Holy Diver5
Community News
Dark completes military service, returns to SC211[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0Weekly Cups (October 19-25): Clem triples first in 5.0.175
StarCraft 2
General
No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 Greetings.. Serral's getting trashed by New Catsle's Mind Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?
Tourneys
Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16) RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery Shield Battery Server New Patch BW General Discussion Top Players of October 2026 (EBPD Rankings) Starcraft:Brood War Discord Servers
Tourneys
[BSL23] Ro16 Group C - Sunday 21:00 CET 2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players [$1250] International ShieldBattery League [Megathread] Daily Proleagues
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Nintendo Switch Thread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc List of Game Threads The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Trading/Investing Thread European Politico-economics QA Mega-thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 MLB/Baseball 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 9231 users

APA: Transgender Is No Longer A Mental Disorder - Page 6

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
Prev 1 4 5 6 7 8 37 Next All
Keep discussion objective and civil.

Blindly spewing uninformed non-sense will lead to moderation action.
NicolBolas
Profile Blog Joined March 2009
United States1388 Posts
December 04 2012 08:07 GMT
#101
On December 04 2012 16:57 sc2superfan101 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2012 16:53 corpuscle wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:46 sc2superfan101 wrote:
can't say that I agree with their conclusion. I don't think people should be discriminated against, obviously, but that shouldn't have any bearing on whether or not it is considered a disorder. and it is somewhat tiresome, as someone who has family who suffer from mental disorders, to listen to people talk about how it's offensive to be told they have a mental disorder. there is nothing wrong with having a disorder, and putting a negative stigma on it (while that may not be their intent) is really bad, imo.


I agree that mental disorders shouldn't be stigmatized unfairly, but calling transgenderism (I don't know what else to call it) a mental disorder is still disingenuous, just like homosexuality.

People who are depressed or suffer from ADD have a disorder (I have both), but someone who is trans is only "sick" in the respect that society doesn't accept them. Saying that someone who has transitioned and is happy with who they are still has an underlying mental disorder is degrading and unfair.

do we have any evidence that they are not suffering from some sort of genetic/mental disorder?


They are suffering from a genetic disorder. Specifically, their neurology doesn't agree with their physiology. Since changing neurology is difficult if not impossible (and even if it is possible, it would effectively change who the person is), changing physiology to match the neurology is the most effective way of dealing with the problem.
So you know, cats are interesting. They are kind of like girls. If they come up and talk to you, it's great. But if you try to talk to them, it doesn't always go so well. - Shigeru Miyamoto
PepperoniPiZZa
Profile Blog Joined October 2010
Sierra Leone1660 Posts
December 04 2012 08:09 GMT
#102
Reading that quote in the OP, I'm wondering. If you're born a girl but you want to be a man, how do you know what it feels like to be a man? I mean, I've read about people who had a sexchange but later reverted it, which kind of implies that it was all in their head. Like, I have zero idea about what it would be like to be a woman.
Quote?
sc2superfan101
Profile Blog Joined February 2012
3583 Posts
December 04 2012 08:12 GMT
#103
On December 04 2012 17:07 NicolBolas wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2012 16:57 sc2superfan101 wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:53 corpuscle wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:46 sc2superfan101 wrote:
can't say that I agree with their conclusion. I don't think people should be discriminated against, obviously, but that shouldn't have any bearing on whether or not it is considered a disorder. and it is somewhat tiresome, as someone who has family who suffer from mental disorders, to listen to people talk about how it's offensive to be told they have a mental disorder. there is nothing wrong with having a disorder, and putting a negative stigma on it (while that may not be their intent) is really bad, imo.


I agree that mental disorders shouldn't be stigmatized unfairly, but calling transgenderism (I don't know what else to call it) a mental disorder is still disingenuous, just like homosexuality.

People who are depressed or suffer from ADD have a disorder (I have both), but someone who is trans is only "sick" in the respect that society doesn't accept them. Saying that someone who has transitioned and is happy with who they are still has an underlying mental disorder is degrading and unfair.

do we have any evidence that they are not suffering from some sort of genetic/mental disorder?


They are suffering from a genetic disorder. Specifically, their neurology doesn't agree with their physiology. Since changing neurology is difficult if not impossible (and even if it is possible, it would effectively change who the person is), changing physiology to match the neurology is the most effective way of dealing with the problem.

does the research suggest that sex-changes (don't know the actual medical term) are the best treatment?
My fake plants died because I did not pretend to water them.
corpuscle
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States1967 Posts
December 04 2012 08:15 GMT
#104
On December 04 2012 17:12 sc2superfan101 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2012 17:07 NicolBolas wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:57 sc2superfan101 wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:53 corpuscle wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:46 sc2superfan101 wrote:
can't say that I agree with their conclusion. I don't think people should be discriminated against, obviously, but that shouldn't have any bearing on whether or not it is considered a disorder. and it is somewhat tiresome, as someone who has family who suffer from mental disorders, to listen to people talk about how it's offensive to be told they have a mental disorder. there is nothing wrong with having a disorder, and putting a negative stigma on it (while that may not be their intent) is really bad, imo.


I agree that mental disorders shouldn't be stigmatized unfairly, but calling transgenderism (I don't know what else to call it) a mental disorder is still disingenuous, just like homosexuality.

People who are depressed or suffer from ADD have a disorder (I have both), but someone who is trans is only "sick" in the respect that society doesn't accept them. Saying that someone who has transitioned and is happy with who they are still has an underlying mental disorder is degrading and unfair.

do we have any evidence that they are not suffering from some sort of genetic/mental disorder?


They are suffering from a genetic disorder. Specifically, their neurology doesn't agree with their physiology. Since changing neurology is difficult if not impossible (and even if it is possible, it would effectively change who the person is), changing physiology to match the neurology is the most effective way of dealing with the problem.

does the research suggest that sex-changes (don't know the actual medical term) are the best treatment?


The medical term is "GRS" (gender reassignment surgery), and, for the most part, it's a positive change, though there's obviously a lot of grey area. FtM transsexuals, for example, generally have a harder time integrating into normal society, because surgical science hasn't figured out how to make a functioning penis, which limits sexual options.
From the void I am born into wave and particle
jdseemoreglass
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
United States3773 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-12-04 08:25:04
December 04 2012 08:16 GMT
#105
afaik there's fairly conclusive evidence that trans people's brains are wired differently than "normal" people's.

These sorts of statements always strike me as odd and a little humorous.

After all, absolutely everything we think and do is dictated by our brains, so everything is "wired" in some way. The fact that I decided to have a tuna sandwich today could be deduced from my brain if the knowledge and technology was sufficiently advanced. People still have this idea that the thoughts and the hardware are somehow distinct and separate, and that discovering a difference in a brain proves that only certain thoughts are "wired" that way, instead of ALL thoughts.

I'm shying away from the term "wired" now, because I know people will make an arbitrary distinction between the brain's architecture and the signals within it. My point is, it is all determined by something, what difference does it really make what it is determined by?

On December 04 2012 17:12 sc2superfan101 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2012 17:07 NicolBolas wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:57 sc2superfan101 wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:53 corpuscle wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:46 sc2superfan101 wrote:
can't say that I agree with their conclusion. I don't think people should be discriminated against, obviously, but that shouldn't have any bearing on whether or not it is considered a disorder. and it is somewhat tiresome, as someone who has family who suffer from mental disorders, to listen to people talk about how it's offensive to be told they have a mental disorder. there is nothing wrong with having a disorder, and putting a negative stigma on it (while that may not be their intent) is really bad, imo.


I agree that mental disorders shouldn't be stigmatized unfairly, but calling transgenderism (I don't know what else to call it) a mental disorder is still disingenuous, just like homosexuality.

People who are depressed or suffer from ADD have a disorder (I have both), but someone who is trans is only "sick" in the respect that society doesn't accept them. Saying that someone who has transitioned and is happy with who they are still has an underlying mental disorder is degrading and unfair.

do we have any evidence that they are not suffering from some sort of genetic/mental disorder?


They are suffering from a genetic disorder. Specifically, their neurology doesn't agree with their physiology. Since changing neurology is difficult if not impossible (and even if it is possible, it would effectively change who the person is), changing physiology to match the neurology is the most effective way of dealing with the problem.

does the research suggest that sex-changes (don't know the actual medical term) are the best treatment?

This is actually a very interesting question... And the reason it is so interesting is because the best treatment and ALSO the best medical/social assessment is actually determined by what we are capable of doing.

For example, if decades ago there was discovered a drug that could "reverse" homosexuality, then homosexuality would still be classified as a mental disorder or illness and treated/eliminated. Since no such drug exists, and since reparative therapy doesn't work, we conclude that society is the problem and not the brain. Really interesting when you think about it, that the best treatment in some circumstances is to convince ourselves it isn't actually a problem at all, because we are powerless to change it.
"If you want this forum to be full of half-baked philosophy discussions between pompous faggots like yourself forever, stay the course captain vanilla" - FakeSteve[TPR], 2006
Masq
Profile Blog Joined March 2009
Canada1792 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-12-04 08:26:29
December 04 2012 08:24 GMT
#106
On December 04 2012 15:59 Troxle wrote:
I'll give it from my side. I got so dysphoric I contemplated cuttin' it off with a knife, but I thought the better of it cause I need it intact for SRS...). Its not somethin' we can control either. We can bury and smother them for years, but no matter what, they find their way to the surface and we get overwhelmed with dysphoria. Imagine the most traumatic event in your life and how it impacted you. Now imagine that event reoccurin' daily (I've been in the same buildin' as a shootin' as well as a car wreck that was less than a 6 inches shy of 5 dead people and suicides of a father-like figure and I still consider this to be the most traumatic thing in my life, it makes me cry more than the thoughts and fears of those other events).


I don't mean to come off as offensive (but I know this will), but don't you think wanting to mutilate yourself or any of the other things you mentioned could be considered a mental disorder?

I hope I don't come off as an asshole, I legitimately just can't really wrap my head around the subject. I have several gay friends but I think this is an entirely different ballpark. I also don't really understand how this is an issue of civil rights, if anyone cares to explain.
KrosusZorg
Profile Joined November 2011
Sweden25 Posts
December 04 2012 08:28 GMT
#107
To the people saying that its not scientific to not call it a disorder:

Wiktionary: Disorder is a physical or psychical malfunction.

Either you can take the stand that it is something wrong in their (the transgenders) mind, or that it is something wrong with their bodies. Since we tend to put greater emphasis on the mind when judging others, I say it is less damning to say its something wrong with their bodies (if you have to choose one). This is also in line with what the transgenders themselves feel. A more scientific approach would be to consider that the body in itself and the mind in itself, of a transgender, is perfectly fine. Then the best, the most precise description would be to state that for a transgender there is a mismatch between body and mind. And that is precisely what APA is saying.

Call it for what it is, avoid baggage, that is the scientific way.

Funnily enough, I have more problem with cosmetic surgery like breast and lip enlargement. Probably because those ideals seems to be pushed upon us externally, and are much less natural (and more akin to wanting to remove an arm). Btw, saying that wanting a sex-change is the same as wanting to remove an arm is similar to saying that women are amputees because they don't have a penis.

-You are a monster Zorg
corpuscle
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States1967 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-12-04 08:34:28
December 04 2012 08:32 GMT
#108
On December 04 2012 17:16 jdseemoreglass wrote:
Show nested quote +
afaik there's fairly conclusive evidence that trans people's brains are wired differently than "normal" people's.

These sorts of statements always strike me as odd and a little humorous.

After all, absolutely everything we think and do is dictated by our brains, so everything is "wired" in some way. The fact that I decided to have a tuna sandwich today could be deduced from my brain if the knowledge and technology was sufficiently advanced. People still have this idea that the thoughts and the hardware are somehow distinct and separate, and that discovering a difference in a brain proves that only certain thoughts are "wired" that way, instead of ALL thoughts.

I'm shying away from the term "wired" now, because I know people will make an arbitrary distinction between the brain's architecture and the signals within it. My point is, it is all determined by something, what difference does it really make what it is determined by?


I don't know if this is a useful analogy, but the "wiring" is sort of like the hardware of your PC. If you try to install 64bit software on a 32bit machine, it might kind of work, but it's a hell of a lot better to switch to 64 because that's what the hardware was meant to execute.

Show nested quote +
On December 04 2012 17:12 sc2superfan101 wrote:
On December 04 2012 17:07 NicolBolas wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:57 sc2superfan101 wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:53 corpuscle wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:46 sc2superfan101 wrote:
can't say that I agree with their conclusion. I don't think people should be discriminated against, obviously, but that shouldn't have any bearing on whether or not it is considered a disorder. and it is somewhat tiresome, as someone who has family who suffer from mental disorders, to listen to people talk about how it's offensive to be told they have a mental disorder. there is nothing wrong with having a disorder, and putting a negative stigma on it (while that may not be their intent) is really bad, imo.


I agree that mental disorders shouldn't be stigmatized unfairly, but calling transgenderism (I don't know what else to call it) a mental disorder is still disingenuous, just like homosexuality.

People who are depressed or suffer from ADD have a disorder (I have both), but someone who is trans is only "sick" in the respect that society doesn't accept them. Saying that someone who has transitioned and is happy with who they are still has an underlying mental disorder is degrading and unfair.

do we have any evidence that they are not suffering from some sort of genetic/mental disorder?


They are suffering from a genetic disorder. Specifically, their neurology doesn't agree with their physiology. Since changing neurology is difficult if not impossible (and even if it is possible, it would effectively change who the person is), changing physiology to match the neurology is the most effective way of dealing with the problem.

does the research suggest that sex-changes (don't know the actual medical term) are the best treatment?

This is actually a very interesting question... And the reason it is so interesting is because the best treatment and ALSO the best medical/social assessment is actually determined by what we are capable of doing.

For example, if decades ago there was discovered a drug that could "reverse" homosexuality, then homosexuality would still be classified as a mental disorder or illness and treated/eliminated. Since no such drug exists, and since reparative therapy doesn't work, we conclude that society is the problem and not the brain. Really interesting when you think about it, that the best treatment in some circumstances is to convince ourselves it isn't actually a problem at all, because we are powerless to change it.


Biology has (recently) taught us that gender, sex, and sexuality are very fluid. Sexuality/gender issues is one of the cutting edges of biology research, and we're learning more and more about how little we know every day.

I don't mean to come off as offensive (but I know this will), but don't you think wanting to mutilate yourself or any of the other things you mentioned could be considered a mental disorder?

I hope I don't come off as an asshole, I legitimately just can't really wrap my head around the subject. I have several gay friends but I think this is an entirely different ballpark. I also don't really understand how this is an issue of civil rights, if anyone cares to explain.


One could argue that the drive to self-mutilation is a societal issue, not a psychiatric one. If we accept that trans people have a right to be who they are, and aren't discriminated for it, then s/he wouldn't have any impulse to self-mutilate; trained doctors would perform the procedure, covered by insurance.
From the void I am born into wave and particle
Joedaddy
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
United States1948 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-12-04 08:34:07
December 04 2012 08:33 GMT
#109
On December 04 2012 15:59 Troxle wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2012 14:56 RockIronrod wrote:
I'm mixed on this.
There's nothing wrong with being uncomfortable with your gender role, and identifying better with the other genders'. Not following social constructs isn't a mental disorder, in a civilized society they aren't really needed for survival anymore, we can safely evolve past them as a people.
However, the body dysphoria part I can't get on board with. The want to physically change your body so radically should be considered a mental illness in my opinion, regardless of how/why. If someone identifies as another race, then I'm all on board with them following the cultures of that race, but if you're that bodily disgusted with yourself you'd resort to surgery to appear that race, I'd say you were mentally ill.
I don't want to sound like a bigot, and I don't think transgender people should be discriminated against (hell, my favourite musicians are Yohio, tissue-hime and Boy motherfucking George), but I honestly think that being that insecure about your body is beyond something that should be regarded as mentally stable.

I guess as a tl;dr it could be said I draw the line on mentally sound and mentally ill on the willingness to get surgery.

I'd love to hear what I sound like from a third person perspective, because I don't want to be THAT guy, I kind of want to hear if I sound reasonable


I'll give it from my side.

I don't exactly have issues with how I look other than I look male. I know I am an attractive/cute male. I get complimented about it all the time. But that's not me. I identify as a female, and feel that my body should have been female to match as well. The options to correct it are rather simple honestly. I'll take some anti-androgens to stop the testosterone from further masculinizin' me and I'll take estradial to put estrogen in my system. This will give me softer skin, less muscle mass, and breasts so I will appear outwardly, as a cisfemale (someone who was born female and does not identify under the trans umbrella). As far as surgery goes, I will not opt for FFS (facial feminization surgery) because I don't have cosmetic issues with myself, sure my chin could probably use it and so could my forehead, but I'll look female without it and I'm not vain enough to care. As far as SRS/GRS (Sex Reassignment Surgery/Genital Reassignment Surgery) goes, I do plan to get this. I guess you could call it a cosmetic reason, because I don't want to be walkin' around in tight women's clothes with a bulge in my pants that makes onlookers skeptical. It also feels very foreign to me when my male bits are bein' active (whether masturbatin' or durin' sexual penetration). Now I plan to pay for that on my own, but that's my choice. For some people, they really can't stand their male parts and have gone to drastic lengths (I've had a few episodes where I got so dysphoric I contemplated cuttin' it off with a knife, but I thought the better of it cause I need it intact for SRS...). Its not somethin' we can control either. We can bury and smother them for years, but no matter what, they find their way to the surface and we get overwhelmed with dysphoria. Imagine the most traumatic event in your life and how it impacted you. Now imagine that event reoccurin' daily (I've been in the same buildin' as a shootin' as well as a car wreck that was less than a 6 inches shy of 5 dead people and suicides of a father-like figure and I still consider this to be the most traumatic thing in my life, it makes me cry more than the thoughts and fears of those other events).

Show nested quote +
On December 04 2012 15:57 dUTtrOACh wrote:
On December 04 2012 15:35 Alay wrote:

20k+/- depending on the surgeon.

It likely will affect neither availability nor price, nor insurance coverage in the short term.


Thanks for the reply. So, insurance covers this, or is it considered cosmetic? It would be a shame if it is, in fact, out of pocket.


Depends on the company, the country and the surgeon. And that's the price for male to female. If I remember correctly, female to male surgery starts around $70k and only jumps up?


I've always wondered about this and this seems like an appropriate place to ask so~

When someone does the female > male or male > female surgery, what is sex like? Vagina's are pretty crazy things and I guess a penis is too, but can you actually "get off" like a natural born male or female? Can the doctors make it where a female > male is able to ejaculate? Does it get hard on its own? Or is there some kind of thing they do to make it hard? Can the male > female women cum? I understand wanting to look like the sex you identify with, but the actual act of having sex is a major part of daily (or in some cases monthly) lives of people. I would be shocked if people were giving up the ability to have an orgasm to have the surgery, but if they are then its a testament to their dedication to this life changing procedure.

I know that sounds kind of vulgar, but again, I grew up in a really sheltered part of the world in a really sheltered family. I'm pretty clueless about this stuff and the first link I tried looked innocent but it was like searching lemonparty or whitehouse @.@ (cannot unsee).

Seems strange to me that they were ever considered mentally ill in the first place. So, its good that they don't have that cloud of persecution hanging over their heads anymore.
Thanks <3
I might be the minority on TL, but TL is the minority everywhere else.
blug
Profile Joined February 2011
Australia623 Posts
December 04 2012 08:43 GMT
#110
It should be considered a mental disorder.

If somebody is willing to stuff themselves with drugs to get tits and a figure that sort of resembles a female then I believe that those people have something wrong with them.

Also... Transgender from female to male is fucked up, have you seen what they do? They get these fake shrivelled up dicks.

Male to Female they just chop your dick off and do a few other things, however I believe any form of self mutilation to be something you are not is screwed up.

I'm sure if I had surgery to be changed from a human to dolphin, people would say I was mentally unstable.

Male to Dolphin Reference: http://www.southparkstudios.com/clips/154792/dolphinoplasty

Also, mega bias is here since Scarlett is transgender.

User was temp banned for this post.
Derp
Kaorix
Profile Joined December 2011
Canada13 Posts
December 04 2012 08:49 GMT
#111
On December 04 2012 17:43 blug wrote:
It should be considered a mental disorder.

If somebody is willing to stuff themselves with drugs to get tits and a figure that sort of resembles a female then I believe that those people have something wrong with them.

Also... Transgender from female to male is fucked up, have you seen what they do? They get these fake shrivelled up dicks.

Male to Female they just chop your dick off and do a few other things, however I believe any form of self mutilation to be something you are not is screwed up.

I'm sure if I had surgery to be changed from a human to dolphin, people would say I was mentally unstable.

Male to Dolphin Reference: http://www.southparkstudios.com/clips/154792/dolphinoplasty

Also, mega bias is here since Scarlett is transgender.


you know nothing about these surgeries and should limit your opinions to what you know
Kaorix
Profile Joined December 2011
Canada13 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-12-04 09:08:31
December 04 2012 08:59 GMT
#112
On December 04 2012 17:33 Joedaddy wrote:
I've always wondered about this and this seems like an appropriate place to ask so~

When someone does the female > male or male > female surgery, what is sex like? Vagina's are pretty crazy things and I guess a penis is too, but can you actually "get off" like a natural born male or female?
yes, for the most part
Can the doctors make it where a female > male is able to ejaculate?

orgasm, yes. ejaculate, no.
Does it get hard on its own? Or is there some kind of thing they do to make it hard?
the testosterone-enlarged clitoris/penis gets hard, if they chose a metoidioplasty, their penis is cut free from the clit hood and is basically a functioning micropenis. the trans guys that get phalloplasty to have a more penetrative penis need a pump installed inside it to get hard
Can the male > female women cum?
yes
I understand wanting to look like the sex you identify with, but the actual act of having sex is a major part of daily (or in some cases monthly) lives of people. I would be shocked if people were giving up the ability to have an orgasm to have the surgery, but if they are then its a testament to their dedication to this life changing procedure.


losing the ability to orgasm is a risk that we take and have to weigh, but it's not an especially large risk with the advances in medicine and surgery technology

also, for the record, not every trans person wants or needs surgery.. some are perfectly content with the equipment they were born with, as long as they are treated as their identified gender
Kerotan
Profile Blog Joined May 2008
England2111 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-12-04 09:03:45
December 04 2012 09:03 GMT
#113
It seems like a big discussion over semantics, should people who want to change their sex be still treated?: yes, and should people still not discriminate against members of the transsexual and transgender community?: yes.
Now will this stop anyone who should transition from transitioning, or result in a body (public or private) preventing them? Highly unlikely. Will this stop anyone who is prejudiced towards the trans community because it was classified as a disorder? Also highly unlikely.
So maybe it will stop prejudice, but I'm a sceptic in this regard.
Nerdette // External revolution - Internal revolution // Fabulous // I raise my hands to heaven of curiosity // I don't know what to ask for // What has it got for me? // Kerribear
NicolBolas
Profile Blog Joined March 2009
United States1388 Posts
December 04 2012 09:15 GMT
#114
On December 04 2012 17:16 jdseemoreglass wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2012 17:12 sc2superfan101 wrote:
On December 04 2012 17:07 NicolBolas wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:57 sc2superfan101 wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:53 corpuscle wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:46 sc2superfan101 wrote:
can't say that I agree with their conclusion. I don't think people should be discriminated against, obviously, but that shouldn't have any bearing on whether or not it is considered a disorder. and it is somewhat tiresome, as someone who has family who suffer from mental disorders, to listen to people talk about how it's offensive to be told they have a mental disorder. there is nothing wrong with having a disorder, and putting a negative stigma on it (while that may not be their intent) is really bad, imo.


I agree that mental disorders shouldn't be stigmatized unfairly, but calling transgenderism (I don't know what else to call it) a mental disorder is still disingenuous, just like homosexuality.

People who are depressed or suffer from ADD have a disorder (I have both), but someone who is trans is only "sick" in the respect that society doesn't accept them. Saying that someone who has transitioned and is happy with who they are still has an underlying mental disorder is degrading and unfair.

do we have any evidence that they are not suffering from some sort of genetic/mental disorder?


They are suffering from a genetic disorder. Specifically, their neurology doesn't agree with their physiology. Since changing neurology is difficult if not impossible (and even if it is possible, it would effectively change who the person is), changing physiology to match the neurology is the most effective way of dealing with the problem.

does the research suggest that sex-changes (don't know the actual medical term) are the best treatment?

This is actually a very interesting question... And the reason it is so interesting is because the best treatment and ALSO the best medical/social assessment is actually determined by what we are capable of doing.

For example, if decades ago there was discovered a drug that could "reverse" homosexuality, then homosexuality would still be classified as a mental disorder or illness and treated/eliminated. Since no such drug exists, and since reparative therapy doesn't work, we conclude that society is the problem and not the brain. Really interesting when you think about it, that the best treatment in some circumstances is to convince ourselves it isn't actually a problem at all, because we are powerless to change it.


Yes and no. Once you start deciding that you can just modify people's brains, especially if it is against their will (and if it's not, there would be plenty of homosexuals who would refuse "treatment" and still want civil rights, so nothing will have been eliminated), to conform to your own ideas of normalcy, you're starting to get into very dangerous waters.

As an example, there are deaf people who actually strongly dislike parents getting cochlear implants for their deaf children so that they can hear. These people consider such implants as "genocide" (yes, some of them use that word) against deaf culture. Now personally, I disagree with such a position, as there's a very clear and objective problem with deafness.

But something similar is true for people with high-functioning Autism. Many of them see the effort to find a drug to diminish or cure such Autism to be anathema to letting such people develop naturally.

I think at this point, there are real concerns about the idea of "curing" such people with mind-affecting drugs, even if a "cure" was discovered that actually worked. You know, without the psychological scarring and such that modern "treatments" cause.

On December 04 2012 17:43 blug wrote:
It should be considered a mental disorder.

If somebody is willing to stuff themselves with drugs to get tits and a figure that sort of resembles a female then I believe that those people have something wrong with them.


Yes. Something is wrong with them. Their brains are squatting in the wrong bodies. That's the point. They want to change their bodies to match their brains.

On December 04 2012 17:43 blug wrote:
Also... Transgender from female to male is fucked up, have you seen what they do? They get these fake shrivelled up dicks.

Male to Female they just chop your dick off and do a few other things, however I believe any form of self mutilation to be something you are not is screwed up.


So, your basis for believing it's a mental disorder has nothing to do with scientific inquiry, facts, or evidence of any kind. It's because you find it personally repulsive.



That's the other kind of issue people have. Not so much a "it's their choice, and I can be a dick to people for their choices" as a "transpeople freak me out."

Somehow, I can't bring myself to care if they freak you out.

On December 04 2012 17:43 blug wrote:
I'm sure if I had surgery to be changed from a human to dolphin, people would say I was mentally unstable.

Male to Dolphin Reference: http://www.southparkstudios.com/clips/154792/dolphinoplasty


Nice strawman, but that doesn't actually deal with any argument presented here. Thanks for playing.

On December 04 2012 18:03 Kerotan wrote:
It seems like a big discussion over semantics, should people who want to change their sex be still treated?: yes, and should people still not discriminate against members of the transsexual and transgender community?: yes.
Now will this stop anyone who should transition from transitioning, or result in a body (public or private) preventing them? Highly unlikely. Will this stop anyone who is prejudiced towards the trans community because it was classified as a disorder? Also highly unlikely.
So maybe it will stop prejudice, but I'm a sceptic in this regard.


A big part of science (which people seem to forget is what Psychology is) is classification. Biological classification is all about documenting the relationship between species, as this can offer insights into them and so forth.

It's important to psychology to know what is and is not "behavior within expected human norms". Indeed, drawing that line is half of the point of the entire field. "Behavior within expected human norms" are things psychologists should not be trying to "fix" in patients.

By declassifying it as a disorder, it means that psychology no longer considers it a mental problem. If a psychologists detects gender dysphoria in a patient, the DSM-V now states that this is not something they should be trying to cure or treat in some way.

So no, it's not mere semantics. Or rather it is, but it's semantics in a way that matters. It's saying that the stomach isn't part of the respiratory system; it's in the digestive system. So you should go see an expert on the digestive system, not a pulminologist when you have stomach problems.
So you know, cats are interesting. They are kind of like girls. If they come up and talk to you, it's great. But if you try to talk to them, it doesn't always go so well. - Shigeru Miyamoto
Twilight Sparkle
Profile Joined August 2012
Australia235 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-12-04 09:23:46
December 04 2012 09:21 GMT
#115
On December 04 2012 17:03 ninini wrote:
When I hear talk of not feeling like your gender, or that the brain is of the wrong gender, you lose me. Biologically, gender is pretty straightforward. Except for mutations, you are either male or female, no exceptions, and it's impossible to confuse the two.

Feminism tries to make male and female into the same thing, while the concept of transgender goes the other way, claiming that if you don't relate to your gender, you should change.

Neither of these concepts would exist if we just saw the genders for what they actually were, and got rid of the stereotypes. I don't see any reason why a man couldn't wear a dress, put on a lot of makeup, and overall act in a stereotypical female way, without having to question his gender. Why let stereotypes confuse you?

If someone feels like they don't belong to their gender, then maybe they should try redefining their ideas about what gender really is, rather than changing themselves. I just think it's sad, because you can't question your gender without questioning your existence.

Anyway, don't get me wrong. I'm not against transgenders. I'm not gonna decide what is allowed to do with your own body, but when someone says that a certain part of them feels like and qualifies them as the other gender, it doesn't make sense, and it shows a lack of understanding in genetics.

It's not about gender roles. Everything you said about what gender really is is absolutely correct. There's no reason that a man can't wear makeup and a dress other than ridiculous social bullshit telling him that it's somehow emasculating. But that doesn't have anything to do with transsexualism. Being trans is primarily about your physical sex; there are plenty of butch trans women and effeminate trans men out there. I myself am totally happy acting in a way which society dictates is masculine. I sit around on the internet watching Starcraft, playing DotA, swearing at people, not socialising much or having any close friendships. I make dick jokes constantly, watched the shit out of The Avengers and have no interest in chick flicks, rom-coms, whatever, I have no particular interest in skirts and dresses or makeup or pink, I do watch MLP but that's a show for guys nowadays. I'm not trans because I want to do 'girl stuff', it's because, for some reason that nobody, including me, truly understands, on some basic level some part of my brain just requires that I be female. Which means doing all the nerdy guy stuff that I do right now except I'm physically female and people call me she. That's about it.

That being said, there are plenty of trans women who act in a feminine way too, and trans men who act masculine, just like there are plenty of cis (ie, not trans) men and women who act in accordance to their gender roles. A majority, in fact. But there are also a decent number of trans people like me who don't fit into the gender role of their preferred sex, so saying that we all just need to abandon society's ideas of what men/women should do doesn't work.
Kaorix
Profile Joined December 2011
Canada13 Posts
December 04 2012 09:31 GMT
#116
On December 04 2012 18:21 Twilight Sparkle wrote:But there are also a decent number of trans people like me who don't fit into the gender role of their preferred sex, so saying that we all just need to abandon society's ideas of what men/women should do doesn't work.


fuck yes well said
StarStrider
Profile Joined August 2011
United States689 Posts
December 04 2012 09:31 GMT
#117
Maybe someone could explain more clearly why I'm wrong, but even though I am the biggest proponent in the world (family member is trans), I fail to see how a mental disconnect like feeling like the gender of your conciousness doesn't match your body ISN'T a disorder qualifying for treatment under DSM? I mean, if we are offering a slough of medical treatments for this identity issue, then there should be a medical diagnosis based on a disorder. It is in no way the same to me as homosexuality, which isn't something that should even involve a doctor's input.

Hell, how can we diagnose a child or teen and allow them to begin social transition without defining it as a doctor diagnosed medical issue? How can we give hormone blockers for something that isn't even a disorder?
Spontaneous Pneumothorax sucks, please keep MVP sC in your thoughts. sC fighting! 힘내세요
BrTarolg
Profile Blog Joined June 2009
United Kingdom3579 Posts
December 04 2012 09:44 GMT
#118
On December 04 2012 17:59 Kaorix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2012 17:33 Joedaddy wrote:
I've always wondered about this and this seems like an appropriate place to ask so~

When someone does the female > male or male > female surgery, what is sex like? Vagina's are pretty crazy things and I guess a penis is too, but can you actually "get off" like a natural born male or female?
yes, for the most part
Show nested quote +
Can the doctors make it where a female > male is able to ejaculate?

orgasm, yes. ejaculate, no.
Show nested quote +
Does it get hard on its own? Or is there some kind of thing they do to make it hard?
the testosterone-enlarged clitoris/penis gets hard, if they chose a metoidioplasty, their penis is cut free from the clit hood and is basically a functioning micropenis. the trans guys that get phalloplasty to have a more penetrative penis need a pump installed inside it to get hard
Show nested quote +
Can the male > female women cum?
yes
Show nested quote +
I understand wanting to look like the sex you identify with, but the actual act of having sex is a major part of daily (or in some cases monthly) lives of people. I would be shocked if people were giving up the ability to have an orgasm to have the surgery, but if they are then its a testament to their dedication to this life changing procedure.


losing the ability to orgasm is a risk that we take and have to weigh, but it's not an especially large risk with the advances in medicine and surgery technology

also, for the record, not every trans person wants or needs surgery.. some are perfectly content with the equipment they were born with, as long as they are treated as their identified gender

I think it is quite the opposite actually

People who goes through trans therapy, either through hormones or a combination with surgery etc. often feel extremely liberated and happy for the first time in their life, and their sexual desire and ability to experience orgasms is usually increased through their transition, not the other way around.
jdseemoreglass
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
United States3773 Posts
December 04 2012 09:52 GMT
#119
On December 04 2012 18:15 NicolBolas wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2012 17:16 jdseemoreglass wrote:
On December 04 2012 17:12 sc2superfan101 wrote:
On December 04 2012 17:07 NicolBolas wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:57 sc2superfan101 wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:53 corpuscle wrote:
On December 04 2012 16:46 sc2superfan101 wrote:
can't say that I agree with their conclusion. I don't think people should be discriminated against, obviously, but that shouldn't have any bearing on whether or not it is considered a disorder. and it is somewhat tiresome, as someone who has family who suffer from mental disorders, to listen to people talk about how it's offensive to be told they have a mental disorder. there is nothing wrong with having a disorder, and putting a negative stigma on it (while that may not be their intent) is really bad, imo.


I agree that mental disorders shouldn't be stigmatized unfairly, but calling transgenderism (I don't know what else to call it) a mental disorder is still disingenuous, just like homosexuality.

People who are depressed or suffer from ADD have a disorder (I have both), but someone who is trans is only "sick" in the respect that society doesn't accept them. Saying that someone who has transitioned and is happy with who they are still has an underlying mental disorder is degrading and unfair.

do we have any evidence that they are not suffering from some sort of genetic/mental disorder?


They are suffering from a genetic disorder. Specifically, their neurology doesn't agree with their physiology. Since changing neurology is difficult if not impossible (and even if it is possible, it would effectively change who the person is), changing physiology to match the neurology is the most effective way of dealing with the problem.

does the research suggest that sex-changes (don't know the actual medical term) are the best treatment?

This is actually a very interesting question... And the reason it is so interesting is because the best treatment and ALSO the best medical/social assessment is actually determined by what we are capable of doing.

For example, if decades ago there was discovered a drug that could "reverse" homosexuality, then homosexuality would still be classified as a mental disorder or illness and treated/eliminated. Since no such drug exists, and since reparative therapy doesn't work, we conclude that society is the problem and not the brain. Really interesting when you think about it, that the best treatment in some circumstances is to convince ourselves it isn't actually a problem at all, because we are powerless to change it.


Yes and no. Once you start deciding that you can just modify people's brains, especially if it is against their will (and if it's not, there would be plenty of homosexuals who would refuse "treatment" and still want civil rights, so nothing will have been eliminated), to conform to your own ideas of normalcy, you're starting to get into very dangerous waters.

As an example, there are deaf people who actually strongly dislike parents getting cochlear implants for their deaf children so that they can hear. These people consider such implants as "genocide" (yes, some of them use that word) against deaf culture. Now personally, I disagree with such a position, as there's a very clear and objective problem with deafness.

But something similar is true for people with high-functioning Autism. Many of them see the effort to find a drug to diminish or cure such Autism to be anathema to letting such people develop naturally.

I think at this point, there are real concerns about the idea of "curing" such people with mind-affecting drugs, even if a "cure" was discovered that actually worked. You know, without the psychological scarring and such that modern "treatments" cause.

You are assuming the treatment has to be an after the fact cure. Well then, suppose the treatment was something preventative instead of retroactive. Suppose for example a mother could take a pill which would guarantee a straight child.
"If you want this forum to be full of half-baked philosophy discussions between pompous faggots like yourself forever, stay the course captain vanilla" - FakeSteve[TPR], 2006
I_Love_Bacon
Profile Blog Joined August 2009
United States5765 Posts
December 04 2012 09:53 GMT
#120
I keep typing up something to post, then deleting it. I honestly can not figure out where to stand on this. Obviously, the ruling from more of a PC stance to remove discrimination is a good thing, and thus I have no issues with it.

How to actually view transgendered people and their problems are a completely different and complex issue. The trains of thought that this discussion uses move on quickly to a metaphysical discussion of what makes you actually you. Whether or not I think it's a mental disorder isn't even relevant, really. A person has the right to try and be happy and in the meantime it's not like we have anything resembling a fix to the feelings a trans-person feels about their body.... so as weird as surgery is I can't really fault a person for taking that path.
" i havent been playin sc2 but i woke up w/ a boner and i really had to pee... and my crisis management and micro was really something to behold. it inspired me to play some games today" -Liquid'Tyler
Prev 1 4 5 6 7 8 37 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 5h 17m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
NeuroSwarm 123
Ketroc 92
StarCraft: Brood War
Rain 2307
GuemChi 1638
Hyuk 448
PianO 338
Bale 30
sOs 15
Force[name] 6
Icarus 6
LuMiX 3
Dota 2
monkeys_forever468
League of Legends
JimRising 704
Counter-Strike
taco 407
Super Smash Bros
C9.Mang01391
ArmadaUGS154
Mew2King103
Other Games
summit1g12360
WinterStarcraft424
Maynarde132
RuFF_SC228
[ Show 10 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
League of Legends
• Rush803
Other Games
• Shiphtur355
Upcoming Events
SOOP
5h 17m
soO vs FanTaSy
WardiTV Weekly
7h 17m
Replay Cast
18h 17m
Monday Night Weeklies
1d 12h
PiGosaur Cup
1d 20h
The PondCast
2 days
GSL
3 days
Replay Cast
3 days
KCM Race Survival
4 days
RSL Revival
5 days
[ Show More ]
BSL
5 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
6 days
BSL
6 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Individual League
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
YSL S4
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
SC4ALL II: Brood War
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 6
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.