• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 15:47
CEST 21:47
KST 04:47
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Power Rank - Esports World Cup 202529RSL Season 1 - Final Week8[ASL19] Finals Recap: Standing Tall15HomeStory Cup 27 - Info & Preview18Classic wins Code S Season 2 (2025)16
Community News
Weekly Cups (July 14-20): Final Check-up0Esports World Cup 2025 - Brackets Revealed19Weekly Cups (July 7-13): Classic continues to roll8Team TLMC #5 - Submission re-extension4Firefly given lifetime ban by ESIC following match-fixing investigation17
StarCraft 2
General
The GOAT ranking of GOAT rankings Power Rank - Esports World Cup 2025 RSL Revival patreon money discussion thread Esports World Cup 2025 - Final Player Roster Why doesnt SC2 scene costream tournaments
Tourneys
Esports World Cup 2025 Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) FEL Cracov 2025 (July 27) - $8000 live event RSL: Revival, a new crowdfunded tournament series
Strategy
How did i lose this ZvP, whats the proper response
Custom Maps
External Content
Mutation # 483 Kill Bot Wars Mutation # 482 Wheel of Misfortune Mutation # 481 Fear and Lava Mutation # 480 Moths to the Flame
Brood War
General
BW General Discussion Flash Announces (and Retracts) Hiatus From ASL BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ Corsair Pursuit Micro? Pro gamer house photos
Tourneys
[Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL 2v2] ProLeague Season 3 - Friday 21:00 CET The Casual Games of the Week Thread BWCL Season 63 Announcement
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers I am doing this better than progamers do.
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread [MMORPG] Tree of Savior (Successor of Ragnarok) Path of Exile CCLP - Command & Conquer League Project
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread Vanilla Mini Mafia
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Russo-Ukrainian War Thread The Games Industry And ATVI Stop Killing Games - European Citizens Initiative
Fan Clubs
SKT1 Classic Fan Club! Maru Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
[\m/] Heavy Metal Thread Anime Discussion Thread Movie Discussion! [Manga] One Piece Korean Music Discussion
Sports
2024 - 2025 Football Thread Formula 1 Discussion TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 NBA General Discussion
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List
Blogs
Ping To Win? Pings And Their…
TrAiDoS
momentary artworks from des…
tankgirl
from making sc maps to makin…
Husyelt
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 734 users

Free Will and Religion

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
1 2 3 4 5 47 48 49 Next All
Yes, this is a thread on TL that involves religion, but I hate to think that our policy should be to blindly close every such thread. Sam Harris is a writer whose books are both insightful and have sparked many good discussions in the past and as long as the thread doesn't derail I'd like to leave it open. This should be the basic premise for every such thread, no matter how high the odds of it derailing. In that light, these posts that just predict the downfall of this thread (whether it be pre-determined or not) are 1) Not contributing to the discussion 2) Backseat moderating 3) Annoying 4) Actually contributing towards derailing it. I'll keep 2 daying people for this.
paralleluniverse
Profile Joined July 2010
4065 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-03-05 13:48:21
March 05 2012 12:37 GMT
#1
Sam Harris is releasing an ebook on Free Will tomorrow.

http://www.amazon.com/Free-Will-Sam-Harris/dp/1451683405
http://www.samharris.org/blog/item/the-illusion-of-free-will

To preempt that, I felt that I should write down my own thoughts on free will.

I simply cannot see how free will can fit into what we know about the universe. The universe is governed by the laws of physics, therefore there is no scope for free will to exist. Everything in the universe, and hence every thought and action made by a human is simply the motion of particles obeying certain laws. Therefore, free will does not exist because we cannot choose how the particles that constitute our body move, they move in accordance with the laws of physics. Random or deterministic, it doesn't matter, because we cannot exert influence nor make choices independent of the motion of particles that are dictated by these laws in either case.

As with everything in the universe, every thought and action made by a person is not a result of free will, it's a result of the laws of physics acting on particles.

Not even the intrinsic randomness of Quantum Mechanics saves the free will hypothesis, as this would imply that your thoughts and actions are caused by fundamentally unpredictable random processes. If so, then they are the result of a universal RNG, thus they would still not be free.

The only reason theologians and religious people latch on to the completely unscientific notion of free will is to "explain" why bad things happen. If God is good, then why did he let the genocide in Rwanda happen? Why does he not intervene in the the mass-murder being conducted by the Syrian government, as we speak? Why is there evil in the world. Because God gave us free will, allegedly. This is then neatly tied into the Original Sin myth, whereby Eve exerted free will and chose to eat from the Garden of Eden, and this frivolous reason somehow necessitated that Jesus die on the cross.

Religions abuse this nonexistent notion of free will in an attempt to explain away the gaping flaws of the God hypothesis and the existence of evil.
Skilledblob
Profile Joined April 2011
Germany3392 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-03-05 12:49:30
March 05 2012 12:43 GMT
#2
is it my decision to move? yes it is, nothing could force me to lift my leg. Instead if I make the conscious decision to move my leg my brain will send out electric impulses that start the biochemic reactions that take place in my muscles so that I can move my leg.

There is no outer force or atomic movement involved here which I can not control. I move because I want to and not because an electron randomly decides to move down my spine into my leg.

so I think your point is invalid.


on the point of free will in religion. Take islam for example there is no consens in that religion if we have free will or not. Some say we do and some say we dont and based on that the texts are different. And the islam is based on the old testament, so it's not as convinient as you make it out jsut because some like to think that religion begins and ends with Christianity.


the only things that you have to do in life is eat, shit, sleep and die the rest is optional.
Timmsh
Profile Joined July 2011
Netherlands201 Posts
March 05 2012 12:48 GMT
#3
@ Skilledblob
It's not your decision to move, at least not in the way you say it is.
We talk about it as if it is our decision, but the 'decision' to move starts in the brain, and it is a reaction on something which makes you move.
Ofcourse there can be internall reasons to make yourself move, but it's not a decision by 'you' (as the overlord controlling the body), merely it's simply cause and effect.
Which causes and which effects is hard to determine, but it's there.

To the OP, i compeletely agree with your post and maybe this is an interesting video on Youtube you want to add on your post:
Abort Retry Fail
Profile Joined December 2011
2636 Posts
March 05 2012 12:49 GMT
#4
Thousands and thousands of TL posts on religion and freewill.
None ended or will end up well.
That is the nature of serious topic vs internet anonymity. It's bound to get messy soon.

On topic, slightly, I've been following Sam Harris since Project Reason and have read his End of Faith. Nothing really earth-shattering though.

User was temp banned for this post.
BSOD
Skilledblob
Profile Joined April 2011
Germany3392 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-03-05 12:52:33
March 05 2012 12:51 GMT
#5
On March 05 2012 21:48 Timmsh wrote:
@ Skilledblob
It's not your decision to move, at least not in the way you say it is.
We talk about it as if it is our decision, but the 'decision' to move starts in the brain, and it is a reaction on something which makes you move.
Ofcourse there can be internall reasons to make yourself move, but it's not a decision by 'you' (as the overlord controlling the body), merely it's simply cause and effect.
Which causes and which effects is hard to determine, but it's there.


you argue like a priest. "I dont know why it is this way but it has to be this way!" because of XYZ uncontrollable power
Heweree
Profile Joined July 2011
United Kingdom497 Posts
March 05 2012 12:53 GMT
#6
We make rational decisions in an absurd world.

That's my thought on it.
zalz
Profile Blog Joined February 2011
Netherlands3704 Posts
March 05 2012 12:56 GMT
#7
Free will cannot exist inside the context of an all knowing all powerfull god.

But there is no god and we can make our own choices.

Altough one can argue that we are all simply reactions of the long chain of events that came before us. But that would be nature V nurture.
Doublemint
Profile Joined July 2011
Austria8503 Posts
March 05 2012 12:58 GMT
#8
On March 05 2012 21:53 TanTzoR wrote:
We make irrational decisions in an absurd world.

That's my thought on it.


I slightly fixed that for you .


solidbebe
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
Netherlands4921 Posts
March 05 2012 12:58 GMT
#9
I feel like there's something missing, your point is that we don't have free will and then your conclusion is religions abuse it. But that wasn't your original point at all.
That's the 2nd time in a week I've seen someone sig a quote from this GD and I have never witnessed a sig quote happen in my TL history ever before. -Najda
Timmsh
Profile Joined July 2011
Netherlands201 Posts
March 05 2012 12:58 GMT
#10
On March 05 2012 21:51 Skilledblob wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 05 2012 21:48 Timmsh wrote:
@ Skilledblob
It's not your decision to move, at least not in the way you say it is.
We talk about it as if it is our decision, but the 'decision' to move starts in the brain, and it is a reaction on something which makes you move.
Ofcourse there can be internall reasons to make yourself move, but it's not a decision by 'you' (as the overlord controlling the body), merely it's simply cause and effect.
Which causes and which effects is hard to determine, but it's there.


you argue like a priest. "I dont know why it is this way but it has to be this way!" because of XYZ uncontrollable power

Sorry dude but you missed the point,
I said i don't know the cause,
but i do know there is a cause!
Which is the most important thing in this discussion, because if you know there is a cause to your decisions,
you cannot believe in an 'external controller' you say it is.

You said, it's my decision to move, as if you are external of this universe and just control your body.
I only said that's not true, and the universe has influence on your decisions in such a way, you only THINK your in controll.
hypercube
Profile Joined April 2010
Hungary2735 Posts
March 05 2012 13:02 GMT
#11
On March 05 2012 21:43 Skilledblob wrote:
is it my decision to move? yes it is, nothing could force me to lift my leg. Instead if I make the conscious decision to move my leg my brain will send out electric impulses that start the biochemic reactions that take place in my muscles so that I can move my leg.

There is no outer force or atomic movement involved here which I can not control. I move because I want to and not because an electron randomly decides to move down my spine into my leg.



That's not how it works. In reality, more often than not, your leg moves first, then your conscious mind comes up with a justification why you want your leg to move and records a false memory where the after-action justification becomes the cause of the movement.
Well, that's what the best data says anyway, there's still some ambiguity. Look up the Libet experiment and the neuroscience of free will.

This is slightly different from the philosophical debate of how deterministic physical laws and the possibility of free will relate to each other.
"Sending people in rockets to other planets is a waste of money better spent on sending rockets into people on this planet."
QuestSeekers
Profile Joined April 2010
United States39 Posts
March 05 2012 13:03 GMT
#12
Your belief in determinism was determined by the predetermined motion of atoms in your brain, as is Skilledblob's disbelief. So the ultimate explanation for our thoughts and beliefs do not come down to how well we pursue truth or science, but by the happenstance of atomic motion.
strategy is distinct from tactics; tactics is concerned with the conduct of an engagement, while strategy is concerned with how different engagements are linked.
zalz
Profile Blog Joined February 2011
Netherlands3704 Posts
March 05 2012 13:05 GMT
#13
On March 05 2012 21:58 Timmsh wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 05 2012 21:51 Skilledblob wrote:
On March 05 2012 21:48 Timmsh wrote:
@ Skilledblob
It's not your decision to move, at least not in the way you say it is.
We talk about it as if it is our decision, but the 'decision' to move starts in the brain, and it is a reaction on something which makes you move.
Ofcourse there can be internall reasons to make yourself move, but it's not a decision by 'you' (as the overlord controlling the body), merely it's simply cause and effect.
Which causes and which effects is hard to determine, but it's there.


you argue like a priest. "I dont know why it is this way but it has to be this way!" because of XYZ uncontrollable power

Sorry dude but you missed the point,
I said i don't know the cause,
but i do know there is a cause!
Which is the most important thing in this discussion, because if you know there is a cause to your decisions,
you cannot believe in an 'external controller' you say it is.

You said, it's my decision to move, as if you are external of this universe and just control your body.
I only said that's not true, and the universe has influence on your decisions in such a way, you only THINK your in controll.


You state it as if it is a fact.

The two cannot be distinguished, that is why people keep discussing it.
Tanukki
Profile Joined June 2011
Finland579 Posts
March 05 2012 13:05 GMT
#14
The universe is very old and complex, our observational ability isn't good enough to fully predict even the interactions of a couple atoms. I'd say with our current level of understanding, it'd be nothing but hubris to admit to something like determinism. Even if we admitted to it, it wouldn't change anything. Unable to explain the ultimate causes of our actions, we'd still have to rely on the concept of free will.
Firebolt145
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Lalalaland34490 Posts
March 05 2012 13:07 GMT
#15
Simplified, computers make decisions based on a set based of rules that have been programmed in. The decisions are then reflected by pixels shown on the screen. The most advanced AIs simply are able to reprogram those rules that initially impact the decision, but the methods that it uses to reprogram those rules are still other rules, so to speak.

I think that the human brain is simply an incredibly advanced super computer that we cannot fully comprehend. Instead of wires, we have neurones in the brain. The way that our neurones are wired is based upon our past experiences as well as the way the brain has evolved over millions of years. Any decision that we make is purely based upon how the electrical signals travel in the neurones and where they end up.

To me, the concept of free will is simply an easy way to explain all the decisions that we make that we cannot understand. However, I think that in the future, if we were able to examine the brain under a super microscope, we would be able to understand every single decision made based upon the way that our neurones connect and change based on experiences.

I am fully open to being wrong however. I also suggest that the OP take away the 'religion' from the topic title as this discussion seems to be more focused on free will than religion.
Moderator
sorrowptoss
Profile Blog Joined June 2011
Canada1431 Posts
March 05 2012 13:08 GMT
#16
OK. Fair enough. So what's the problem? What is the inconvinience of living like that? What is the problem with not fully controlling oneself because of what was explained in the OP, and living alongside an infinite amount of illusions? What's wrong with religion abusing this? I don't see any real problem arising from this debate, honestly. Now I'll go play SC2... Oh wait, it isn't actually me playing. So what? I really don't care.
paralleluniverse
Profile Joined July 2010
4065 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-03-05 13:11:20
March 05 2012 13:10 GMT
#17
On March 05 2012 21:43 Skilledblob wrote:
is it my decision to move? yes it is, nothing could force me to lift my leg. Instead if I make the conscious decision to move my leg my brain will send out electric impulses that start the biochemic reactions that take place in my muscles so that I can move my leg.

There is no outer force or atomic movement involved here which I can not control. I move because I want to and not because an electron randomly decides to move down my spine into my leg.

so I think your point is invalid.


on the point of free will in religion. Take islam for example there is no consens in that religion if we have free will or not. Some say we do and some say we dont and based on that the texts are different. And the islam is based on the old testament, so it's not as convinient as you make it out jsut because some like to think that religion begins and ends with Christianity.


the only things that you have to do in life is eat, shit, sleep and die the rest is optional.

Your decision to move is caused by electrical signals between synapses in your brain, these electrical signals are caused by biochemical reactions, these biochemical reactions are caused by the motion of particles, the motion of these particles are dictated by the laws of physics.

At no point in the chain of actions is your will exerted.

Every action in this chain has a prior cause, and if we trace this back, we end up at the motion of particles, of which you have no conscious control over.
Skilledblob
Profile Joined April 2011
Germany3392 Posts
March 05 2012 13:10 GMT
#18
and I dont understand why someone has to bring up religion all the time. Religion is no answer, religion is an option. If some more understood this then we could stop lots of these childish religion yes/no discussions.
Timmsh
Profile Joined July 2011
Netherlands201 Posts
March 05 2012 13:10 GMT
#19
On March 05 2012 22:05 zalz wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 05 2012 21:58 Timmsh wrote:
On March 05 2012 21:51 Skilledblob wrote:
On March 05 2012 21:48 Timmsh wrote:
@ Skilledblob
It's not your decision to move, at least not in the way you say it is.
We talk about it as if it is our decision, but the 'decision' to move starts in the brain, and it is a reaction on something which makes you move.
Ofcourse there can be internall reasons to make yourself move, but it's not a decision by 'you' (as the overlord controlling the body), merely it's simply cause and effect.
Which causes and which effects is hard to determine, but it's there.


you argue like a priest. "I dont know why it is this way but it has to be this way!" because of XYZ uncontrollable power

Sorry dude but you missed the point,
I said i don't know the cause,
but i do know there is a cause!
Which is the most important thing in this discussion, because if you know there is a cause to your decisions,
you cannot believe in an 'external controller' you say it is.

You said, it's my decision to move, as if you are external of this universe and just control your body.
I only said that's not true, and the universe has influence on your decisions in such a way, you only THINK your in controll.


You state it as if it is a fact.

The two cannot be distinguished, that is why people keep discussing it.


First of all, i don't really know what you mean by 'the two'
Second of all, if they cannot be destinguished, then we both talk about the same
we just call it differently.
My question to skilledblob is then: do you believe in an external force which can manipulate particles in the brain, which is not influenced by the universe?


Heweree
Profile Joined July 2011
United Kingdom497 Posts
March 05 2012 13:11 GMT
#20
On March 05 2012 21:58 Doublemint wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 05 2012 21:53 TanTzoR wrote:
We make irrational decisions in an absurd world.

That's my thought on it.


I slightly fixed that for you .




No, there are rational. Doesn't mean they are good. But they are made upon the idea of benefit/cost.
1 2 3 4 5 47 48 49 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 14h 14m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
Harstem 60
ForJumy 45
MindelVK 43
Nathanias 24
StarCraft: Brood War
Barracks 685
Mini 559
Larva 487
Bonyth 85
Aegong 71
scan(afreeca) 28
NaDa 4
League of Legends
Grubby3780
Dendi902
syndereN40
Counter-Strike
fl0m1941
Foxcn349
byalli340
oskar219
flusha186
Stewie2K133
Heroes of the Storm
Liquid`Hasu578
Khaldor348
Other Games
summit1g6911
FrodaN2044
ceh91129
Hui .252
C9.Mang0201
ToD190
Trikslyr55
Sick23
Organizations
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 21 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• davetesta107
• LUISG 29
• IndyKCrew
• sooper7s
• Migwel
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Kozan
StarCraft: Brood War
• 80smullet 24
• Michael_bg 4
• FirePhoenix4
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
• BSLYoutube
Dota 2
• masondota21298
• WagamamaTV599
League of Legends
• Doublelift1572
• TFBlade1125
Other Games
• imaqtpie1110
• Shiphtur506
Upcoming Events
Esports World Cup
14h 14m
ByuN vs Zoun
SHIN vs TriGGeR
Cyan vs ShoWTimE
Rogue vs HeRoMaRinE
Clem vs Solar
Reynor vs Maru
herO vs Cure
Serral vs Classic
Esports World Cup
1d 14h
Esports World Cup
2 days
CranKy Ducklings
3 days
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
3 days
CSO Cup
3 days
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
3 days
Bonyth vs Sziky
Dewalt vs Hawk
Hawk vs QiaoGege
Sziky vs Dewalt
Mihu vs Bonyth
Zhanhun vs QiaoGege
QiaoGege vs Fengzi
FEL
4 days
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
4 days
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
4 days
Bonyth vs Zhanhun
Dewalt vs Mihu
Hawk vs Sziky
Sziky vs QiaoGege
Mihu vs Hawk
Zhanhun vs Dewalt
Fengzi vs Bonyth
[ Show More ]
Sparkling Tuna Cup
6 days
Online Event
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

CSL Xiamen Invitational
Championship of Russia 2025
Murky Cup #2

Ongoing

Copa Latinoamericana 4
Jiahua Invitational
BSL20 Non-Korean Championship
Esports World Cup 2025
CC Div. A S7
Underdog Cup #2
FISSURE Playground #1
BLAST.tv Austin Major 2025
ESL Impact League Season 7
IEM Dallas 2025
PGL Astana 2025
Asian Champions League '25

Upcoming

CSLPRO Last Chance 2025
CSLPRO Chat StarLAN 3
BSL Season 21
RSL Revival: Season 2
SEL Season 2 Championship
uThermal 2v2 Main Event
FEL Cracov 2025
HCC Europe
ESL Pro League S22
StarSeries Fall 2025
FISSURE Playground #2
BLAST Open Fall 2025
BLAST Open Fall Qual
Esports World Cup 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall Qual
IEM Cologne 2025
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Disclosure: This page contains affiliate marketing links that support TLnet.

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.