Hehe, some roles sound fun, but I'd like to propose an other one:

Zombie - once killed, comes back the next night and takes one person of his choice to his chilly grave.

Can be 1 or 2. Good role to take vengeance on someone.

Since Mafia too has a medic now, another role could be:

The diseased - once killed (either by a Vigi or Mafia) will infect the person killing him, who in turn, will die on next night, unless cured by either a medic or a corrupt doc. If a Medic protects the diseased, he will be cured permanently, and loses his abilities to infect. The diseased only has 5 days to live, and dies by himself on 5th night.

Also, count me into this one.

ydg

United States690 Posts

December 28 2008 02:07 GMT

#29

7 mafia vs 52 townies? where are the other 13 people :p
you should totally add more roles like
the plant: you can plant a clue that incriminates another player once a night
the teacher: you can "hold night class" once per game. once you "hold night class" (during the night) you will be informed of your students (max 4? so you know 4 innocent townies). however, the mafia can have on their hitlist "teacher," and if you are holding class, you and all your students die. if you aren't holding class, the hit fails.
the sniper: has a kill power of 1. must send in own hit. does not leave behind clues. (maybe overpowered)
the stalker: can stalk one person per night. will be informed if the stalkee is active during the night. if the stalker is killed, the person he is stalking is killed as well (and vice versa) unless the stalkee is mafia.
etc.

BloodyC0bbler

Canada7876 Posts

December 28 2008 02:13 GMT

#30

Caller, one thing that would be an interesting option is rather than tell the town how many mafia there are, say something like "there are between 7 and 11 mafia" or the like. Makes it harder to guess how many there are, or have the just reg mafia flip as green, and special role mafia flips as special role, or the like. Makes it alot harder to a degree, but means you can have less mafia and make it challenging.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

December 28 2008 03:35 GMT

#31

I'm in too!

Scaramanga

Australia8091 Posts

December 28 2008 03:42 GMT

#32

Count me in

Silencer-prevents Ace (and other people) from talking. Stays the same as in BloodyCobbler’s game.

LOOOOOOL

Caller

Poland8075 Posts

December 28 2008 03:54 GMT

#33

On December 28 2008 11:13 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
Caller, one thing that would be an interesting option is rather than tell the town how many mafia there are, say something like "there are between 7 and 11 mafia" or the like. Makes it harder to guess how many there are, or have the just reg mafia flip as green, and special role mafia flips as special role, or the like. Makes it alot harder to a degree, but means you can have less mafia and make it challenging.

that's the thing hehehehehe :D

Caller

Poland8075 Posts

December 28 2008 04:03 GMT

#34

On December 28 2008 09:29 Qatol wrote:
Ok some thoughts on the rest your roles:

Martyr:
How does he interact with a veteran if 1 hit is given? Who takes that hit?

Jack:
Can he be insane as well? (Probably better not to have this, but it would be kinda funny if this were the case)

Anarchist:
How do medics work with this guy? (I think everyone should die when the house burns down including medics, the doc, or the martyr)

NRA member:
Define "visit." Is that rolechecks/protection/vigi/mafia hits?

Rock Star:
Does the rock star know who his bodyguards are and vice versa? Is the rock star immune to conversion while protected? (I think this should probably be the case)

Godfather:
Does he lose a conversion attempt if the target is protected? (probably should)

Silencer:
Are you seriously giving the silencer 5 uses that can hit the same person every time again? That seemed excessive.

Village Idiot:
Is he mafia? Or is he neither green nor red?

Martyrs take the hits regardless of medics or vet status.
Insane Jack would just go crazy lol
Anarchists act as reverse suicide bombers, so yes, medics will die as would the doc.
The NRA member's interpretation is correct.
Rock Star is like Mayor, he knows the BGs and vice versa and he is immune to conversion.
Godfather does lose the conversion attempt if the target is protected.
Yes the Silencer has 5 uses but there will be clues pointing to the silencer's actions this time, i.e.
"Ace and Caller were sitting in a room chillaxing. Suddenly, a large monster-wurm creature that breathed fire and hoarded treasure snuck out of the darkness in the room and with one hand sliced Caller's head off while burning Ace's lips off. The lips won't heal for another day."
guess who these clues are pointing to ^^

Village Idiot is just his own faction. However, he can associate with townies to make a deal with them, or vice versa.

Jimtudor

Canada259 Posts

December 28 2008 04:12 GMT

#35

Sign me up please.

LTT

Shakuras1095 Posts

December 28 2008 04:24 GMT

#36

Some more questions:

Village Idiot:
Can the Godfather recruit the Village Idiot or does immunity from night killing also mean immunity from conversion? If he can be recruited, is he still immune from night kills? If so, would a post-recruitment Village Idiot just trample over NRA members and Anarchists? A converted Village idiot seems to be pretty tricky. You might want to consider making him immune to conversion as well...

Is he immune from the suicide bomber? If so, what happens if the suicide bomber attempts to detonate on him?

NRA Member:
Is Godfather recruitment included in his auto-kill trigger list?

Anarchist:
Can he invite everyone playing for an all night party?

Edit: For that matter, what about any converted special role? Do they retain their power?

Caller

Poland8075 Posts

December 28 2008 04:45 GMT

#37

On December 28 2008 13:24 LTT wrote:
Some more questions:

Village Idiot:
Can the Godfather recruit the Village Idiot or does immunity from night killing also mean immunity from conversion? If he can be recruited, is he still immune from night kills? If so, would a post-recruitment Village Idiot just trample over NRA members and Anarchists? A converted Village idiot seems to be pretty tricky. You might want to consider making him immune to conversion as well...

Is he immune from the suicide bomber? If so, what happens if the suicide bomber attempts to detonate on him?

NRA Member:
Is Godfather recruitment included in his auto-kill trigger list?

Anarchist:
Can he invite everyone playing for an all night party?

Edit: For that matter, what about any converted special role? Do they retain their power?

The godfather cannot recruit the Village Idiot.
The suicide bomber does not die and he will be usable the following day/night.
Yes, the NRA member can kill the godfather if he tries to recruit ^^
Anarchist:
Hell yes.