EPT[Manga] One Piece - Page 1590
| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
This is a thread that is dedicated to discussing One Piece. Do not read this thread if you are not currently caught up as there are spoilers in here. If an episode or a chapter has already been officially released, then it is not necessary to post using spoilers. If you have knowledge on a chapter that has not been officially released yet, do NOT post it in this thread. Ignoring this public note will result in a mod action. | ||
|
Zooper31
United States5711 Posts
| ||
|
Archeon
3260 Posts
On November 11 2021 09:22 Zooper31 wrote: I'll hold my breath and opinion until I see how they do with Cowboy Bebop. That'll be there first american full live action series and not just a movie. If they do good there, I'll have hope for One Piece. I do appreciate the casting choices for One Piece, alot of them look like the characters they are playing, without any makeup/clothing/special effects etc. I don't think CB is a good benchmark because CB doesn't really have super powers and is strongly influenced by English media anyways. To boot CB is originally one season and there arguably is already a live action series with strong similarities in firefly. | ||
|
Zooper31
United States5711 Posts
On November 11 2021 10:53 Archeon wrote: I don't think CB is a good benchmark because CB doesn't really have super powers and is strongly influenced by English media anyways. To boot CB is originally one season and there arguably is already a live action series with strong similarities in firefly. I mean the base of One Piece is just a young boy wanting to be a pirate, it doesn't get super heavy with powers until later on. They could more easily do OP than CB imo, space and all the futuristic cities are alot more CGI intensive than some devil fruit powers. They don't have to even go very far with the first season of OP, however long it takes to get Luffy to meet Sanji realistically which is only like 20 episodes of the anime. | ||
|
cLutZ
United States19574 Posts
On November 11 2021 12:08 Zooper31 wrote: I mean the base of One Piece is just a young boy wanting to be a pirate, it doesn't get super heavy with powers until later on. They could more easily do OP than CB imo, space and all the futuristic cities are alot more CGI intensive than some devil fruit powers. They don't have to even go very far with the first season of OP, however long it takes to get Luffy to meet Sanji realistically which is only like 20 episodes of the anime. Practical effects and sets (which would IMO make the Merry look much better) don't have a great track record with netflix though. The thing about OP is a live action is its a combination of realism and over the topness. Like, the first episode of the series would be just a bunch of guys in a bar drinking, a boy eating a nasty rubber fruit. Then those pirates just murdering some bandits and then a fucking sea dragon appears. | ||
|
evilfatsh1t
Australia8711 Posts
| ||
|
sharkie
Austria18478 Posts
On November 11 2021 05:46 Archeon wrote: I thought the Japanese Deathnote live action was good and the Phoenix Wright one was at least funny. But I get your point and these are much much easier to do than OP. Also both were Japanese productions, I've heard only bad things about netflix anime live action adaptions. Really? I really loved kakegurui | ||
|
Archeon
3260 Posts
There is a live action kakegurui? All I could find was an anime. On November 11 2021 12:08 Zooper31 wrote: I mean the base of One Piece is just a young boy wanting to be a pirate, it doesn't get super heavy with powers until later on. They could more easily do OP than CB imo, space and all the futuristic cities are alot more CGI intensive than some devil fruit powers. They don't have to even go very far with the first season of OP, however long it takes to get Luffy to meet Sanji realistically which is only like 20 episodes of the anime. Imo CB is pretty low on the futuristic elements and there was a lot of space based scifi in the past, including a lot of series without a ton of budget. You can do a lot with practical effects instead of CGI, especially in a series like CB which doesn't have a ton of space fights, exclusively humans and where buildings etc are mostly based on already existing ones. CB's depiction of the future is mostly about introducing interstellar travel and else moving cultural elements into the future. A lot of planets have basically no scifi elements at all unless you count Spike flying around in his fighter. Luffy without Gum Gum on the other hand sounds really odd to me and I really struggle to imagine how that's ever gonna look good in a live action movie. Or like others said how they're going to hit the over-the-top tongue in cheek humor of one piece. There's no doubt which project I'd rather direct between a ragtag family of misfits in space with film-noir elements and an over the top pirate adventure with superpowers. One of these two is way closer to normal mainstream US television and can lean on star trek and firefly. | ||
|
Zambrah
United States7366 Posts
I also think early OP is weaker, it doesnt really hit it's stride until Arlong Park, and even then the point I start watching One Piece from is Water 7. Theres so much content to get to before all of the pay off stuff... I don't see how One Piece can really be adapted successfully? It'd require a colossal amount of pruning and some Dennis Villeneuve level aesthetic adaptation intelligence. | ||
|
oEkY
Germany649 Posts
On November 11 2021 17:54 Archeon wrote: Luffy without Gum Gum on the other hand sounds really odd to me and I really struggle to imagine how that's ever gonna look good in a live action movie. imo the biggest issue is Zorro, how should a human being cut someone with a sword between his teeth in a real live adaption? | ||
|
Hyperbola
United States2540 Posts
Did you know that Keanu Reeves wanted to do a Cowboy Bebop movie a while ago? It never happened because of budgetary issues, but then we got John Wick instead. Now obviously they're not the same story, but they definitely rhyme in major ways. I'm glad they're making major changes to the premise. It might still be shit, but it has a much higher chance of succeeding. | ||
|
Zambrah
United States7366 Posts
| ||
|
Archeon
3260 Posts
On November 20 2021 04:43 Zambrah wrote: One Piece's version of what dinosaurs did when they were alive is what I wish they did in reality. Best part of the chapter for me. Felt like else there didn't happen a lot. | ||
|
Zambrah
United States7366 Posts
Maybe it'd be like, launching his teeth like bullets, or uh, somethin' to do with tiny T-rex arms? | ||
|
Zambrah
United States7366 Posts
Seems like Zoro isn’t gonna be descended from Wano after all. Nice. | ||
|
evilfatsh1t
Australia8711 Posts
| ||
|
herMan
Japan2053 Posts
I'm fairly certain Zoro is descendent from Wano. Did you already forget the Zoro looking dude from the flashbacks? He's also just the right age to be born outside of Wano after Kaido took over. | ||
|
Zambrah
United States7366 Posts
| ||
|
RenSC2
United States1065 Posts
| ||
|
herMan
Japan2053 Posts
| ||
|
Slaughter
United States20254 Posts
| ||
| ||
