On April 18 2017 08:20 The_Red_Viper wrote: The funny thing is that while people complain about that, they also complain about the new "villain" because he isn't menacing enough. So what do you wants? Another darth vader which would be a complaint about similarity, or something "new" by having a villain who is conflicted, rather new to the force as well, etc (which then is new) Ofc execution of these aspects matters a lot, but it was fairly well done i think. People really just don't like adam drivers looks i guess :/ .
This is what makes me freaking hate critics, especially for the last 2 modern Star Wars films.
If they change nothing, it's a rehash, if they do something new, it doesnt feel like Star Wars.
Just very very bored with that particular criticism.
On April 18 2017 08:20 The_Red_Viper wrote: The funny thing is that while people complain about that, they also complain about the new "villain" because he isn't menacing enough. So what do you wants? Another darth vader which would be a complaint about similarity, or something "new" by having a villain who is conflicted, rather new to the force as well, etc (which then is new) Ofc execution of these aspects matters a lot, but it was fairly well done i think. People really just don't like adam drivers looks i guess :/ .
This is what makes me freaking hate critics, especially for the last 2 modern Star Wars films.
If they change nothing, it's a rehash, if they do something new, it doesnt feel like Star Wars.
Just very very bored with that particular criticism.
The impossible task of building a villain that can be as impactful as one with a 30 year relationship with the fan base.
It is why I loved Rogue One’s villain. A middle manager who is willing to create a genocide cannon just to get a promotion. A meek villain that is also speaks to the most terrify part of authorities regimes, the banal evil those regimes empower.
I already am feeling a bit fatigue of the star wars movies. I don't see myself stayed hyped for next few ones if they really do bring one every year-ish
I was gonna say if only Rogue One didn't completely change their script....but it still ends up better than jarjarAbram's TFA, episode7 truly turned into a huge pile of shit at this stage. I just absolutely hate the mary sue ray, think Mark Hamill too said similar thing about the no training bit too.
And the new trailer...can it be more underwhelming? It is actually quite late for a move that is coming out in year ends, are they rushing it? i have to say, i truly dont feel like giving any money to Disney anymore (their recent works disgusted me too).
On April 18 2017 08:20 The_Red_Viper wrote: The funny thing is that while people complain about that, they also complain about the new "villain" because he isn't menacing enough. So what do you wants? Another darth vader which would be a complaint about similarity, or something "new" by having a villain who is conflicted, rather new to the force as well, etc (which then is new) Ofc execution of these aspects matters a lot, but it was fairly well done i think. People really just don't like adam drivers looks i guess :/ .
This is what makes me freaking hate critics, especially for the last 2 modern Star Wars films.
If they change nothing, it's a rehash, if they do something new, it doesnt feel like Star Wars.
Just very very bored with that particular criticism.
Critics? Last I check both of the last 2 movies were well received by the critics for what they are, entertaining dumb movies. The fans are the one who bitched and moaned about these films because their expectations can never be realistically met.
As someone neutral about SW but who likes the universe, I just wished they could do something else with it, something with a great story and characters I can get invested in. And on that front both movies (maybe all of them) failed me.
On April 20 2017 07:10 BurningSera wrote: I was gonna say if only Rogue One didn't completely change their script....but it still ends up better than jarjarAbram's TFA, episode7 truly turned into a huge pile of shit at this stage. I just absolutely hate the mary sue ray, think Mark Hamill too said similar thing about the no training bit too.
About the change on the script of Rogue one. What exactly are you referring to ? I keep reading this, but people seem to be unaware that Gareth's first ending to Rogue one was because he thought that disney wouldn't let him to do what he actually did. Most of the other stuff is actual normal post-production proccess.
Mark Hamill's Luke was pretty much a Gary Stu aswell (seriously, i don't even want to start pointing out the flaws in this, at the end is "what happens when the force is strong with you" which is literally "IDDQD bitches" and Gareth portrayed this perfectly imo), he has been somewhat angry because his character was used as a marketing bait for TFA but never got any use (yeah, JJ for me is like Lucas but withouth the talent to integrate special effects that Lucas has, but those lens flare ) . He also said that he wasn't confident on how they were going with his character on TLJ, but that after seeing the result he was wrong, so there's that.
On April 19 2017 07:14 Godwrath wrote: I am sure i am in the very minority here, Rogue one is the best one for me (ESB close second). It took me some extra-views to reach that point, but i really appreciate what Gareth did with it and how he took the chance by himself to fill some of the holes in a way i found pleasant and enjoyable.
Yea I watched Rogue One for the first time this weekend and really enjoyed it. Kind of depressing to watch + Show Spoiler +
It blew my mothers mind when i was like ya know everyone dies right? and shes all wow no spoilers and i was like come on dude how many of them did you see in the next movie?
On April 19 2017 07:14 Godwrath wrote: I am sure i am in the very minority here, Rogue one is the best one for me (ESB close second). It took me some extra-views to reach that point, but i really appreciate what Gareth did with it and how he took the chance by himself to fill some of the holes in a way i found pleasant and enjoyable.
Yea I watched Rogue One for the first time this weekend and really enjoyed it. Kind of depressing to watch + Show Spoiler +
It blew my mothers mind when i was like ya know everyone dies right? and shes all wow no spoilers and i was like come on dude how many of them did you see in the next movie?
EPT
