Some concerning signs of several players being removed. Retirements incoming? Note only changes are listed here, for a list of full players, see the May roster.
On June 14 2012 13:30 GTR wrote: Oh, and Ggaemo is on waivers due to being on Hwaseung before going to ACE. Don't think anyone is going to pick him up, effectively making him retired.
WAT
Perhaps he is sad there are no longer mines for him to run Hydras over in SCtoo T.T
Whoa, so surprised to see Rush and Grape on there with their current OSL runs, and just with them being up and comers. I guess the switch to SC2 must have really done them in? Does this mean their no longer on the team, or just not being fielded in the proleague this season as they're most likely behind and focusing heavily on BW for the OSL?
Be sad for them to leave so quickly with so much untapped potential.
Woah both Grape and Rush gave up on ProLeague and now they are even unlisted from the bench. I always liked Grape, he looked so handsome from the OSL intro. Rush displayed some sick Terran vs Protoss strategy against Mini a la Iloveoov. Why are Rookies leaving the scene left and right? They are still young!
On June 14 2012 13:57 2yph0n wrote: Woah both Grape and Rush gave up on ProLeague and now they are even unlisted from the bench. I always liked Grape, he looked so handsome from the OSL intro. Rush displayed some sick Terran vs Protoss strategy against Mini a la Iloveoov. Why are Rookies leaving the scene left and right? They are still young!
As far as I'm also sad, i believe that them being young is the exact point, why they choose to check themselves in other things. Korean e-sport isn't that big to accept any ex-gamer as caster, journalist or kespa-vip. Only the best could still make their own living later on with only e-sports. Most of them will finish as 30 years old guys with no good references and education, no job experience. So for me it's more of a evidence that they just want to start real life. Not the life of probe stacked in room with other guys and computers for 14 hours a day
On June 14 2012 14:35 raga4ka wrote: Doesn't mean they are retiring , they are just send to the B-teams for now , maybe to improve their SC2 ?
with grape, I don't really see a point to demote someone from A roster but not promote anyone else. I mean, grape didn't play fantastic or anything but generally the pessimist in me doesn't look highly on a semi-steady A-teamer being removed.
rush maybe is less pessimistic, as there was internal movement and where also moved down. And it's not like he played in the playoffs/even last season except for once. He may have just not invested much in sc2 with osl.
On June 14 2012 13:38 OopsOopsBaby wrote: surprised to see rush and grape. considering they are potential royal roaders.
How well they play in BW is irrelevant. It makes a lot of sense for them to retire, since they worked so hard in BW and just got their break. They did all that hard work for nothing. Grape, Mini, Rush, Reality, Last, Soulkey, Snow etc are the big losers in this switch, since they were the next generation. I'm surprised that not more players are retiring, we've had like 5 major retires now after the switch, but more of them will retire when this season is over. The question is how many more.
On June 14 2012 13:38 OopsOopsBaby wrote: surprised to see rush and grape. considering they are potential royal roaders.
How well they play in BW is irrelevant. It makes a lot of sense for them to retire, since they worked so hard in BW and just got their break. They did all that hard work for nothing. Grape, Mini, Rush, Reality, Last, Soulkey, Snow etc are the big losers in this switch, since they were the next generation. I'm surprised that not more players are retiring, we've had like 5 major retires now after the switch, but more of them will retire when this season is over. The question is how many more.
Sigh. So much young talent going to waste. Sad times.
On June 14 2012 13:38 OopsOopsBaby wrote: surprised to see rush and grape. considering they are potential royal roaders.
How well they play in BW is irrelevant. It makes a lot of sense for them to retire, since they worked so hard in BW and just got their break. They did all that hard work for nothing. Grape, Mini, Rush, Reality, Last, Soulkey, Snow etc are the big losers in this switch, since they were the next generation. I'm surprised that not more players are retiring, we've had like 5 major retires now after the switch, but more of them will retire when this season is over. The question is how many more.
Soulkey might be okay, he seems to be adapting okayish to SC2. But for the rest, I can't blame them for quitting while they're ahead. It was hard to be noteworthy in BW with TLBS around, but it'll be even harder to be noticed in SC2, just because they now also have to compete with the current crop of SC2 players.
Hmm I don't get it why is kt hiring so many rookies in to the team suddenly ? I have a bad feeling about this more retirements even from my favourite team ??? noooooo
Grape and Rush? Guess they did not achieve as much as they wanted in the OSL... Or have they decided that it would be their last one regardless of achievements? Sad for them either way.
WHY GGAEMO, WHY? Who will lost infinite hydras to mines now
On June 14 2012 21:31 Kittan wrote: Grape and Rush? Guess they did not achieve as much as they wanted in the OSL... Or have they decided that it would be their last one regardless of achievements? Sad for them either way.
WHY GGAEMO, WHY? Who will lost infinite hydras to mines now
Given that there will be some sort of spider mine in HotS, I'm especially sad
On June 14 2012 13:41 MountainDewJunkie wrote: GGaemo too? This is pretty much the worst news since Killer retired. Which was the worst news since Hiya retired, which....
... was the worst news since Hwaseung disbanded, which was the worst news since BackHo retired...
I think we all expected more retirements, and it seems we're getting them. Sad news, but all the news is sad these days.
On June 14 2012 13:41 MountainDewJunkie wrote: GGaemo too? This is pretty much the worst news since Killer retired. Which was the worst news since Hiya retired, which....
... was the worst news since Hwaseung disbanded, which was the worst news since BackHo retired...
I think we all expected more retirements, and it seems we're getting them. Sad news, but all the news is sad these days.
Bias.
I can think of at least five other things within the last 12 months that have had a bigger impact or stink of stupidity.
I cheered for ggaemo ever since he started for ACE and beat Sea around two years ago. I always believed he would be able to clutch any win even against overwhelming odds. Hope you succeed elsewhere.
KeSPA teams really need to get on the recruitment trail and pick up the Koreans leaving the current SC2 teams. Feels like there are hardly any progamers left outside the successful ones in PL.
I saw "Bong" on a menu at a restaurant in Korea and I had to ask the guy I was with what it was. Apparently it was a chicken wing or something like that (his English wasn't so great). Point being, I'm pretty sure he's not referring to a weed smoking device
On June 14 2012 13:41 MountainDewJunkie wrote: GGaemo too? This is pretty much the worst news since Killer retired. Which was the worst news since Hiya retired, which....
... was the worst news since Hwaseung disbanded, which was the worst news since BackHo retired...
I think we all expected more retirements, and it seems we're getting them. Sad news, but all the news is sad these days.
Bias.
I can think of at least five other things within the last 12 months that have had a bigger impact or stink of stupidity.
Joke.
I can think of one thing these five things listed all have in common.
To think I spent all that time writing about how Grape had to step it up to be Khan's 3rd Protoss in line this season with Brave gone... and then this happens.
Khan's mighty Protoss line has declined to half its previous size. Gone are the days where they can send out P in 68% of the games they play :<
On June 15 2012 07:06 Kiett wrote: To think I spent all that time writing about how Grape had to step it up to be Khan's 3rd Protoss in line this season with Brave gone... and then this happens.
Khan's mighty Protoss line has declined to half its previous size. Gone are the days where they can send out P in 68% of the games they play :<
On June 14 2012 13:38 OopsOopsBaby wrote: surprised to see rush and grape. considering they are potential royal roaders.
How well they play in BW is irrelevant. It makes a lot of sense for them to retire, since they worked so hard in BW and just got their break. They did all that hard work for nothing. Grape, Mini, Rush, Reality, Last, Soulkey, Snow etc are the big losers in this switch, since they were the next generation. I'm surprised that not more players are retiring, we've had like 5 major retires now after the switch, but more of them will retire when this season is over. The question is how many more.
I never thought of it this way, basically they were the new generation after (correct me if I'm wrong) Jaedong/Flash dominance era and they definitely got the short end of the stick. Imagine if in any sport, they just cut an entire generation of young players. (I guess part of the problem is RTS players don't have lasting and enduring careers since they lose their edge as they age in nerves and reflexes, so it's less apparent that an entire wave of newcoming talent are getting totally shafted.)
I hope they take the skills they learned in video gaming to other fields.
a) Removed players (like Rush and Grape) are retiring because they don't like SC2, and BW is essentially dead
b) Removed players are getting a break, being demoted to the B-Team temporarily
c) Removed players don't like the hybrid system and would like to focus their full attention on SC2 and leave the KeSPA system, and join perhaps a Korean SC2 which offers much more freedom
On June 15 2012 09:51 bokchoi wrote: c) Removed players don't like the hybrid system and would like to focus their full attention on SC2 and leave the KeSPA system, and join perhaps a Korean SC2 which offers much more freedom
There's no reason to leave a KeSPA team (which pays) for a GOM team (which doesn't), and none of the people who retired are likely to be able to join foreign teams.
It's either
1. Removed players don't like SC2, and have decided to step down rather than play it 2. Removed players are not good at SC2, and have been demoted to B-team until they shape up. 3. Removed players are thinking of retiring anyway, and it has nothing to do with SC2 (this is unlikely, but who knows)
Yeah I hope not all of them are retirements. Maybe some players just can't handle the hybrid league format and stepped down from the PL lineup to cool down a bit and just practice sc2 instead of having the stress to compete and put up results in both BW and sc2. But it feels like this is wishful thinking.
On June 15 2012 09:51 bokchoi wrote: c) Removed players don't like the hybrid system and would like to focus their full attention on SC2 and leave the KeSPA system, and join perhaps a Korean SC2 which offers much more freedom
There's no reason to leave a KeSPA team (which pays) for a GOM team (which doesn't), and none of the people who retired are likely to be able to join foreign teams.
It's either
1. Removed players don't like SC2, and have decided to step down rather than play it 2. Removed players are not good at SC2, and have been demoted to B-team until they shape up. 3. Removed players are thinking of retiring anyway, and it has nothing to do with SC2 (this is unlikely, but who knows)
Unless you're a Top A-class level player, or S-class level player your salary is pretty low or even non-existant. Also, B-Teamers only get housing and necessities covered (the same you would get on a Korean SC2 team). Remember Action saying he didn't get any salary on eStro? Yeah, eStro was one of the poorer teams, but he was their ACE. Just think about that.
The KeSPA life style is a lot harder than the non-KeSPA lifestyle, but the KeSPA pro gamers are offered a bit more security in exchange. Most of the Korean SC2 players say they would never return to the KeSPA lifestyle, but who knows if thats true. Most of them (not counting July, BoxeR, NaDa) were even getting a salary when they played BW so that could be a huge factor.
On June 15 2012 10:30 Gosi wrote: Yeah I hope not all of them are retirements. Maybe some players just can't handle the hybrid league format and stepped down from the PL lineup to cool down a bit and just practice sc2 instead of having the stress to compete and put up results in both BW and sc2. But it feels like this is wishful thinking.
Could be that some teams are saying this format is so stupid they're not going to take it seriously anymore, and just focus on being the next season winner.
Plus practicing for OS2L. Very few KeSPA players have a chance of qualifying with the GOM players able to compete. It would be humiliating if the Ro32 in the OS2L were entirely non-KeSPA players. Naniwa's in Korea, and Thorzain might be, and even Stephano might be attracted by a his-if-he-wants-it Code S invite alongside an OS2L. SC2 is a different game from BW, but for a KeSPA player to be knocked out of the qualifiers by a foreigner would be so bad.
So, it's entirely possible, I guess, that they're just going to focus on a full switch now, and try to be ahead of the curve.
On June 15 2012 13:31 GTR wrote: So uh, I just read on FOMOS that Grape is going to retire from BW and move into a house with Brave and Point to play League of Legends or some shit.
What the fuck?
EDIT: A side note about ex-BW players playing LoL, Tazza from former hite Sparkyz is on one of the larger-sponsored LoL teams in Korea now.
On June 15 2012 13:31 GTR wrote: So uh, I just read on FOMOS that Grape is going to retire from BW and move into a house with Brave and Point to play League of Legends or some shit.
That just seems so bizarre. Flamewars aside, BW ==> SC2 has to be an easier transition than BW ==> LoL. Maybe he thinks LoL is more long-term viable because it's bigger in Korea? Or maybe he just loves LoL a whole lot.
edit : the trend use to be bw retires that means he is impliedly is going to play sc2 however since LoL is growing more popular in korea than sc2 they are instead going to carry their career in to LoL . Which is good news to me ....
On June 15 2012 10:30 Gosi wrote: Yeah I hope not all of them are retirements. Maybe some players just can't handle the hybrid league format and stepped down from the PL lineup to cool down a bit and just practice sc2 instead of having the stress to compete and put up results in both BW and sc2. But it feels like this is wishful thinking.
Could be that some teams are saying this format is so stupid they're not going to take it seriously anymore, and just focus on being the next season winner.
Plus practicing for OS2L. Very few KeSPA players have a chance of qualifying with the GOM players able to compete. It would be humiliating if the Ro32 in the OS2L were entirely non-KeSPA players. Naniwa's in Korea, and Thorzain might be, and even Stephano might be attracted by a his-if-he-wants-it Code S invite alongside an OS2L. SC2 is a different game from BW, but for a KeSPA player to be knocked out of the qualifiers by a foreigner would be so bad.
So, it's entirely possible, I guess, that they're just going to focus on a full switch now, and try to be ahead of the curve.
This post has been invalidated, apparently. KeSPA doesn't want their precious stars having to play SC2 pros in the qualifiers. ಠ_ಠ
That's humiliating, honestly. If I were a KeSPA player, I'd be pretty embarrassed about being babied like that. For all the Elephant in the Room talk, no one seems to have much confidence in the KeSPA players right now. Must be a bummer. Not only are you forced to play a new game, but you're expected to fail.
On June 15 2012 10:30 Gosi wrote: Yeah I hope not all of them are retirements. Maybe some players just can't handle the hybrid league format and stepped down from the PL lineup to cool down a bit and just practice sc2 instead of having the stress to compete and put up results in both BW and sc2. But it feels like this is wishful thinking.
Could be that some teams are saying this format is so stupid they're not going to take it seriously anymore, and just focus on being the next season winner.
Plus practicing for OS2L. Very few KeSPA players have a chance of qualifying with the GOM players able to compete. It would be humiliating if the Ro32 in the OS2L were entirely non-KeSPA players. Naniwa's in Korea, and Thorzain might be, and even Stephano might be attracted by a his-if-he-wants-it Code S invite alongside an OS2L. SC2 is a different game from BW, but for a KeSPA player to be knocked out of the qualifiers by a foreigner would be so bad.
So, it's entirely possible, I guess, that they're just going to focus on a full switch now, and try to be ahead of the curve.
This post has been invalidated, apparently. KeSPA doesn't want their precious stars having to play SC2 pros in the qualifiers. ಠ_ಠ
That's humiliating, honestly. If I were a KeSPA player, I'd be pretty embarrassed about being babied like that. For all the Elephant in the Room talk, no one seems to have much confidence in the KeSPA players right now. Must be a bummer. Not only are you forced to play a new game, but you're expected to fail.
I disagree. I think it's smart to do this. One advantage that Kespa players have over most current SC2 pros is their experience in practicing specifically for particular matches. The PL/SL format focuses a lot on preparation. Whereas qualifiers are more about basic skills. I think it's much more likely for a BW veteran to beat an SC2 pro in the ODTs than in the qualifiers.
You are right, in the qualifiers where you have to beat multiple players you don't know anything about, Flash may not be able to advance out of it. But put him in a Bo3 against a Code A player where he has a week to prepare? Flash has a good shot at winning.
On June 15 2012 10:30 Gosi wrote: Yeah I hope not all of them are retirements. Maybe some players just can't handle the hybrid league format and stepped down from the PL lineup to cool down a bit and just practice sc2 instead of having the stress to compete and put up results in both BW and sc2. But it feels like this is wishful thinking.
Could be that some teams are saying this format is so stupid they're not going to take it seriously anymore, and just focus on being the next season winner.
Plus practicing for OS2L. Very few KeSPA players have a chance of qualifying with the GOM players able to compete. It would be humiliating if the Ro32 in the OS2L were entirely non-KeSPA players. Naniwa's in Korea, and Thorzain might be, and even Stephano might be attracted by a his-if-he-wants-it Code S invite alongside an OS2L. SC2 is a different game from BW, but for a KeSPA player to be knocked out of the qualifiers by a foreigner would be so bad.
So, it's entirely possible, I guess, that they're just going to focus on a full switch now, and try to be ahead of the curve.
This post has been invalidated, apparently. KeSPA doesn't want their precious stars having to play SC2 pros in the qualifiers. ಠ_ಠ
That's humiliating, honestly. If I were a KeSPA player, I'd be pretty embarrassed about being babied like that. For all the Elephant in the Room talk, no one seems to have much confidence in the KeSPA players right now. Must be a bummer. Not only are you forced to play a new game, but you're expected to fail.
Until Kespa players are playing SC2 full time, I wouldn't expect them to be consistently better than SC2 pros. It's just an unreasonable assumption.
On June 15 2012 10:30 Gosi wrote: Yeah I hope not all of them are retirements. Maybe some players just can't handle the hybrid league format and stepped down from the PL lineup to cool down a bit and just practice sc2 instead of having the stress to compete and put up results in both BW and sc2. But it feels like this is wishful thinking.
Could be that some teams are saying this format is so stupid they're not going to take it seriously anymore, and just focus on being the next season winner.
Plus practicing for OS2L. Very few KeSPA players have a chance of qualifying with the GOM players able to compete. It would be humiliating if the Ro32 in the OS2L were entirely non-KeSPA players. Naniwa's in Korea, and Thorzain might be, and even Stephano might be attracted by a his-if-he-wants-it Code S invite alongside an OS2L. SC2 is a different game from BW, but for a KeSPA player to be knocked out of the qualifiers by a foreigner would be so bad.
So, it's entirely possible, I guess, that they're just going to focus on a full switch now, and try to be ahead of the curve.
This post has been invalidated, apparently. KeSPA doesn't want their precious stars having to play SC2 pros in the qualifiers. ಠ_ಠ
That's humiliating, honestly. If I were a KeSPA player, I'd be pretty embarrassed about being babied like that. For all the Elephant in the Room talk, no one seems to have much confidence in the KeSPA players right now. Must be a bummer. Not only are you forced to play a new game, but you're expected to fail.
I disagree. I think it's smart to do this. One advantage that Kespa players have over most current SC2 pros is their experience in practicing specifically for particular matches. The PL/SL format focuses a lot on preparation. Whereas qualifiers are more about basic skills. I think it's much more likely for a BW veteran to beat an SC2 pro in the ODTs than in the qualifiers.
You are right, in the qualifiers where you have to beat multiple players you don't know anything about, Flash may not be able to advance out of it. But put him in a Bo3 against a Code A player where he has a week to prepare? Flash has a good shot at winning.
I don't know about that. It's true that foreign SC2 tournaments are a billion games a day, but the GSL has a fairly long prep-time. And while KeSPA players may have more ability to prep generally (arguable), I'd imagine SC2 players would be much more capable of prepping for an SC2 match specifically.
On June 15 2012 10:30 Gosi wrote: Yeah I hope not all of them are retirements. Maybe some players just can't handle the hybrid league format and stepped down from the PL lineup to cool down a bit and just practice sc2 instead of having the stress to compete and put up results in both BW and sc2. But it feels like this is wishful thinking.
Could be that some teams are saying this format is so stupid they're not going to take it seriously anymore, and just focus on being the next season winner.
Plus practicing for OS2L. Very few KeSPA players have a chance of qualifying with the GOM players able to compete. It would be humiliating if the Ro32 in the OS2L were entirely non-KeSPA players. Naniwa's in Korea, and Thorzain might be, and even Stephano might be attracted by a his-if-he-wants-it Code S invite alongside an OS2L. SC2 is a different game from BW, but for a KeSPA player to be knocked out of the qualifiers by a foreigner would be so bad.
So, it's entirely possible, I guess, that they're just going to focus on a full switch now, and try to be ahead of the curve.
This post has been invalidated, apparently. KeSPA doesn't want their precious stars having to play SC2 pros in the qualifiers. ಠ_ಠ
That's humiliating, honestly. If I were a KeSPA player, I'd be pretty embarrassed about being babied like that. For all the Elephant in the Room talk, no one seems to have much confidence in the KeSPA players right now. Must be a bummer. Not only are you forced to play a new game, but you're expected to fail.
Until Kespa players are playing SC2 full time, I wouldn't expect them to be consistently better than SC2 pros. It's just an unreasonable assumption.
Well, yes. It's still a little silly and demeaning that they're literally kept separate from the SC2 pros because it wouldn't really be sporting. Years of BW training, and then being told "we're keeping you away from the open qualifiers because ZergBong and a Swedish Warcraft 3 player might show up and we don't want you getting hurt". Just because it's reasonable doesn't make it feel any less sucky, especially since it's kind of an unearned advantage. Swinging this back on-topic, I think a lot of BW players feel pretty shitty, even aside the whole my-game-is-bigger-than-your-game. They're expected to dominate the current crop of SC2 pros, but at the same time they have to be protected from same.
BW pros aren't expect to dominate any longer. Years of training in BW do not strongly correlate with dominating in SCToo today and that should be patently obvious. The elephant in the room was only relevant when the GSL Code S players were still terrible and making mistakes which was over a year ago.
On June 15 2012 20:50 maximuspita wrote: BW pros aren't expect to dominate any longer. Years of training in BW do not strongly correlate with dominating in SCToo today and that should be patently obvious. The elephant in the room was only relevant when the GSL Code S players were still terrible and making mistakes which was over a year ago.
It was never relevant because, as you can see, the BW pros have to have their own learning time with the game even when they can look at the current SC2 pros and see how it's supposed to be played.
Still, I'd bet a lot more on them having what it takes to be at the top in SC2 than in LoL.
On June 15 2012 20:50 maximuspita wrote: BW pros aren't expect to dominate any longer. Years of training in BW do not strongly correlate with dominating in SCToo today and that should be patently obvious. The elephant in the room was only relevant when the GSL Code S players were still terrible and making mistakes which was over a year ago.
It was never relevant because, as you can see, the BW pros have to have their own learning time with the game even when they can look at the current SC2 pros and see how it's supposed to be played.
What? Do you even understand what the Elephant in the Room article tried to imply?
Still, I'd bet a lot more on them having what it takes to be at the top in SC2 than in LoL.
In case you aren't noticing, many would be promising BW up and comers who missed out on jumping ship two years ago like MC, Ganzi, MMA, etc are retiring from their soon-to-be-playing-SCtoo teams. Yes, it is true if they were good(an understatement) at BW then they would probably be good at SCtoo. But, right now it isn't any different from saying they would also be good at the piano because of their keyboard skills. Expect more retirements.
i am waiting for next year , wonder how BW section will goes on. hopefully a dream will come true whereby all the korean start their own league and the world is able to join. xD
On June 15 2012 21:36 figq wrote: I keep wondering how long will it take for Starcraft fans to recognize the true BW killer, which isn't SC2, but LoL.
Are you serious ? and if so why ?
Yes, I am. Isn't it obvious that it was LoL that pushed aside both BW and SC2 actually. If not for LoL, there were going to still be BW leagues on OGN. But the share of RTS in Korea shrunk drastically with the invasion of LoL, and so BW was forced out, urgently. LoL also accumulated and keeps accumulating legendary champions from BW and SC2.
/as a side note, they even call their wiki "Leaguepedia", how far can they go with the mimicry of established brands/
On June 15 2012 21:36 figq wrote: I keep wondering how long will it take for Starcraft fans to recognize the true BW killer, which isn't SC2, but LoL.
Are you serious ? and if so why ?
Yes, I am. Isn't it obvious that it was LoL that pushed aside both BW and SC2 actually. If not for LoL, there were going to still be BW leagues on OGN. But the share of RTS in Korea shrunk drastically with the invasion of LoL, and so BW was forced out, urgently. LoL also accumulated and keeps accumulating legendary champions from BW and SC2.
/as a side note, they even call their wiki "Leaguepedia", how far can they go with the mimicry of established brands/
Professional BW collapsed because of a few reasons: match-fixing, IP lawsuits, and the release of SCToo. This created a toxic, volatile environment in BW that chased away all outside sponsors and caused some major ones (Hwaseung and MBC, for example) to pull the plug on their teams. This was WAY BEFORE LoL came into Korea. Stop trying to put the blame on LoL and Riot when they're not to blame. If you're just butthurt because LoL is becoming huge in Korea while SC2 has been stagnant, then take a good long look at what Blizzard did wrong and what Riot did right in Korea.
Your "side note" is completely invalid because every so-called "wiki" out there, including liquipedia, are just specializations of the real wikipedia. Everyone's guilty of mimicry, by your twisted logic.
On June 15 2012 21:36 figq wrote: I keep wondering how long will it take for Starcraft fans to recognize the true BW killer, which isn't SC2, but LoL.
Are you serious ? and if so why ?
Yes, I am. Isn't it obvious that it was LoL that pushed aside both BW and SC2 actually. If not for LoL, there were going to still be BW leagues on OGN. But the share of RTS in Korea shrunk drastically with the invasion of LoL, and so BW was forced out, urgently. LoL also accumulated and keeps accumulating legendary champions from BW and SC2.
It's a little more complicated than that. LoL is getting big in the foreign scene, and easily surpasses SC2 in Korea, but SC2 is a much more intuitive transition for BW players. If BW would switch to LoL, it might as well switch to Halo, because LoL has next to nothing to do with BW.
I wouldn't say that LoL "pushed BW aside", though. What killed BW was primarily Savior. Not just because he tarnished the legacy etc., but because most of the people involved in the scandal were up and comers. The BW scene stagnated for a really long time as a result. Flash has been a Bonjwa longer than the other four combined, I think. When I came back to BW after a long hiatus in SC2 land, the only name I didn't recognize was Soulkey.
The IP lawsuits and SC2 didn't matter that much, in the grand scheme of things, but it also didn't help.
On June 16 2012 05:12 jpak wrote:If you're just butthurt because LoL is becoming huge in Korea while SC2 has been stagnant, then take a good long look at what Blizzard did wrong and what Riot did right in Korea.
Riot had a game with a F2P model and fronted the prize money for tournaments themselves. (Indeed, this is why MLG doesn't carry Dota)
Blizzard had a game with a standard "buy it" model (though, honestly, F2P Starcraft would be horrifically bad), and didn't care about the professional scene at all for about a year beyond going "e-sports!" on occasion.
There was definitely some ball-dropping from Blizz there. In fairness, when LoL came out the Western "e-sports" scene had appeared and it made more sense to cater to it. Blizz only cared about pro SC2 because "Koreans love Starcraft!" is a meme. I think everyone's going to have to step their game up, though, as the competition for a good Pro Game is getting more heated.
I sincerely think a legitimate successor to BW is going to arise in the next 5 years or so. There's so much more reward for it now, that everyone's going to try.
On June 16 2012 05:12 jpak wrote:If you're just butthurt because LoL is becoming huge in Korea while SC2 has been stagnant, then take a good long look at what Blizzard did wrong and what Riot did right in Korea.
Riot had a game with a F2P model and fronted the prize money for tournaments themselves. (Indeed, this is why MLG doesn't carry Dota)
Blizzard had a game with a standard "buy it" model (though, honestly, F2P Starcraft would be horrifically bad), and didn't care about the professional scene at all for about a year beyond going "e-sports!" on occasion.
There was definitely some ball-dropping from Blizz there. In fairness, when LoL came out the Western "e-sports" scene had appeared and it made more sense to cater to it. Blizz only cared about pro SC2 because "Koreans love Starcraft!" is a meme. I think everyone's going to have to step their game up, though, as the competition for a good Pro Game is getting more heated.
I sincerely think a legitimate successor to BW is going to arise in the next 5 years or so. There's so much more reward for it now, that everyone's going to try.
I will just say one thing: PC Bangs. PC Bangs are at the center of Korean gaming and Blizzard screwed up big time by alienating them in the beginning of SC2.
Riot, on the other hand, catered to them by having everything unlocked when someone plays in a Korean PC Bang.
On June 16 2012 05:12 jpak wrote:If you're just butthurt because LoL is becoming huge in Korea while SC2 has been stagnant, then take a good long look at what Blizzard did wrong and what Riot did right in Korea.
Riot had a game with a F2P model and fronted the prize money for tournaments themselves. (Indeed, this is why MLG doesn't carry Dota)
Blizzard had a game with a standard "buy it" model (though, honestly, F2P Starcraft would be horrifically bad), and didn't care about the professional scene at all for about a year beyond going "e-sports!" on occasion.
There was definitely some ball-dropping from Blizz there. In fairness, when LoL came out the Western "e-sports" scene had appeared and it made more sense to cater to it. Blizz only cared about pro SC2 because "Koreans love Starcraft!" is a meme. I think everyone's going to have to step their game up, though, as the competition for a good Pro Game is getting more heated.
I sincerely think a legitimate successor to BW is going to arise in the next 5 years or so. There's so much more reward for it now, that everyone's going to try.
I will just say one thing: PC Bangs. PC Bangs are at the center of Korean gaming and Blizzard screwed up big time by alienating them in the beginning of SC2.
Riot, on the other hand, catered to them by having everything unlocked when someone plays in a Korean PC Bang.
There's that as well. I sincerely think Blizz legitimately did not care about competitive SC2 and were only giving it lip service until after it got big in the foreign scene and they realized there was money in it. Riot is investing HARD in the eSports scene. They want to prevent Dota2 from ever getting off the ground, and they're willing to pour resources into it now to reap the rewards later. SC2 was not intended to be pro-friendly when it came out (SC2 fans can remember maps like Steppes of War being in the game for the explicit reason of being appealing to casuals, and Blizz wanting tiny rush maps in the pool for like a year because casuals wanted it).
And, obviously, free-to-play games = piracy not really a concern = LAN, which is a huge advantage. The only "e-Sport" feature SC2 has going for it is replay copying AI in HOTS (where you load a replay of a pro doing a build, and you can have the computer do that build so you can practice against it). Which is a fucking awesome idea LoL and the rest should steal, but not really enough.
Dota2, as far as I can tell, is just trying to be a good game. I don't think that's actually enough anymore either. It doesn't matter if Dota2 is better than LoL or not, because Riot pays MLG to have tournaments and Valve doesn't.
SC2, if it wants to survive, needs to focus on being a better game. HOTS is a step in the right direction (oracle is good. Viper is good. Tempest seems bad, but it'll make your army more spread out and less "ball"y, so I'm okay with it), but there needs to be more.
Right now, in terms of how seriously they're taking the eSports scene and making a good pro game, Riot >>>>>>Blizzard now > Valve >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Blizzard at the launch of SC2
On June 25 2012 03:05 Piste wrote: I'm too lazy to find out myself this, but has there been announcement for how long will BW be part of proleague? thanks in advance!
Yes there has been, this is the last season with Broodwar in it IIRC.