it's like a ferris wheel of death that never ends, the first day of mafia. the same shyt always happens Day 1.

the last game I played, any idiot should have been able to see Ver's innocent. However, instead we got MTF as Mayor who wasn't as logical as Ver and, surprise, surprise! was a mafia.

Everyone who played in Ace's Mafia World: do you recall MrBabyHands playing style? Do you recall he barely typed? But yet, he was the one who broke into the other mafia's IRC channel, huh? Clearly he's an intelligent guy, and if he was mafia he would be trying his damnedest not to attract any attention, instead of being in the mix.

This may not be worth much to many, but I've played plenty of games with him and Ace and if they're putting themselves out there, it's for the sake of the Town, and I'd bet they're innocent.

Ver made a very good point when he questioned why everyone is ignoring and/or attacking MBH, when he's arguable the person making the most sense.

As far as Ace, many of you seem to revere him (although I can't imagine why

) but he's making sense too, along with Pyrr (to an extent). However, many of these plans are garbage and put Blues at too great of a risk.

I agree with those who have said let everyone do what they see fit in until clue and behavioral analysis leads us to a place where an "inner circle" can be formed.

The real outside benefit of this is that since there isn't a centralize group running the show, hopefully activity from everyone will be increased; special role or not.

I'm on pg. 24, but I had to take a break from reading to type. brb if anything else needs to be said.

Versatile

United States396 Posts

March 19 2009 04:37 GMT

#543

oh yeah.

##I vote mrbabyhands.

Versatile

United States396 Posts

March 20 2009 01:06 GMT

#672

I'm not a fan of the vigi plan, as I think it hurts us more than it helps us.

First of all, it helps the mafia figure out roles.

Furthermore, what happens if a mafia false-claims vigi? obviously if a mafia is not hit we can't trust said "vigi", what happens afterward? does that person stay on the radar? or do we assume they are innocent from there on?

Or should the case be that any vigi who outs themselves would be expected to be hit by the mafia the very next night?

THEN AGAIN, why would the mafia target a vigi who has used his/her power, and is now essentially a green?

I think this plan just promotes the chance of false-claiming, the very probable killing of innocents and mafia trickery.

Versatile

United States396 Posts

March 21 2009 21:26 GMT

#947

These are things that stuck out to me from day 2, not including things that have already been expressed by others, for fear of being repetitive.

1. Camlito was killed by someone who he thought was a theatre attendant: could this indicted a mafia in some position of authority, whom he trusted, was his killer?

2. Everyone except Incognito has been killed by stabbing or an explosion; with all the creative ways there are to kill people, why would Chu only use these? I think it might be a theme of sorts.

3. As for the mafia personalities, I've come up with:
a. Powerful, dressed in all black, armed man
b. Weak, pathetic fight man
c. Tattooed biker man
d. Person-in-charge w/ bum characteristics

Just some thoughts.

Versatile

United States396 Posts

March 21 2009 21:49 GMT

#951

On March 22 2009 06:38 Pyrrhuloxia wrote:

Show nested quote +

The trash collection attendant killed his victim with his bare hands, not a gun (like with Incognito), or a stabbing or explosion.

hmm, I missed that, thanks.

quick question: what is the virtue of a dbl lynch? I see mandalor is the prime suspect, and there are clues on rice, but are we really ready to vote both of them off today?