Newbie Mini Mafia II - Page 23

On January 07 2012 09:09 Liquid`Sheth wrote:
I haven't read his defense yet at all, I plan on making a big post on him after the night phase is over talking about the defense and such. Hopefully you don't mind waiting until morning.

On January 07 2012 09:05 Probulous wrote:
Jitsu, Tunk, enough with the back and forth. It should be pretty clear you are both town to anyone paying attention. Don't waste your time arguing over a single badly worded post.

You both voted for AKCT before anyone else, that should be enough to ensure that you both did not jump on the wagon. You started it. Save your analysis for people who are possibly scum. This is just spamming the thread and making it difficult to spot other people's posts.

On January 06 2012 10:02 CatsnHats wrote:
@Ceph Jumping on the CatsnHats bandwagon I see. It seems like you trying to get people to spare you on D2 by shifting attention to me.

You quoted me as saying "Even with recent read on Ceph, which I agree with." as evidence that I flip-flopped when I later included him on my scum reads. But you didn't quote the whole post. I said:



I've never flipped on CM, you just didn't include this to make your case. It seems alot of people have a habit of doing that.

And no, you didn't fall off of my list, if you actually read Jitsu's post you aren't mentioned on it, so I didn't include you. Don't worry you're still on it. You're actually at the top of it for D2. That's not OMGUS, it's just that you are top two with CM/Tea and once he's gone you're logically next on the list. My flip from Gretorp to you was to kill the greater of two evils a the moment, since Gretorp's inactivity had left him as a harder read when compared to you. And then I switched my vote from you to Tea because it seemed we were going to be deadlocked, and killing #2 on my list and letting #1 go is much better than letting both #1 and #2 go.

On January 07 2012 09:11 gonzaw wrote:


I don't get what "you" are bickering about here.
You posted that you didn't pay attention to me until now.
I posted that I agreed, and you should have in the first place.

I don't get what's to "nitpick" here...? Or what this has to do with our English (..es? I don't know the plural)...?




Okay, I really want other people to tell me if my "analysis" is "useless".
I don't believe it is.

I try to pick up inconsistencies and odd behaviour from anyone I can, that's how I catch scum.
I picked up yours, and suddenly it's "useless".

Really? So my "analysis" is bad just because I did it on you?





What?

Please, if you find a post from mine similar to yours in terms of fluffiness (or whatever you call it in this forum) be my guest.
I try to be blunt and catch scum, not post "updates of what I feel" or whatever you did.

Also, as you can see, this conversation is not helping anyone.
You are stating things without backing them up (that I have "non-interesting posts" for instance, I don't get what you mean by that).
You are also stating blatantly false things (that I "misunderstood you"), and you are being very apathetic and chlidish in a way (you say you will post your analysis whenever you like, and that you post whatever you like, that you don't care what I prefer, etc).
This doesn't mean that you are scum, but it means that you are being unnecessary helpless and obtuse.





I already posted my analysis, go reread the thread.

On January 07 2012 09:24 Probulous wrote:
Guys, please just drop it.

We haven't heard anything from Hippo, Blurry, Cats (obviously), Cephiro, Xeris or Gretorp. Where are you guys?

On January 07 2012 09:22 Probulous wrote:


You seem pretty certain on surviving the night. You know something we don't?

On January 07 2012 09:37 Tunkeg wrote:
For the rest of you, did you in any way think that gonz analysis of my post after lynch was any good? Did the discussion between me and him bring anything usefull to the table?

On January 07 2012 09:36 Jitsu wrote:



I'm not back and forth'ing with Tunk. XD


RE: Sheth -

What kind of question is that? I post an analysis, than I vote for him, and than you ask me if I think he should be lynched?





Does that look like a newbie post to you?

If I was being accused of Mafia, I would prove my innocence by finding scum. Not by trying the town to lynch myself.

In other words, having the town waste another day to lynch me if I was town is anti-town in and of itself. I think he's banking on the fact that he's trying to pull at our oh-so-tender heartstrings.

Thoughts?

On January 07 2012 09:48 Liquid`Sheth wrote:



Didn't notice you voted on him. Didn't realize you could vote on someone during night phase...

And yes that post was really well done. Thats ONE post of his. (What is OMGUS?) Do the rest look like veteran posts to you? Like his gambit of trying to get himself lynched is stupid. When ProfBA did it, it was stupid too. ProfBA was a veteran though, he had a lot of good posts, he even got elected as something. In what crazy world would we elect this Catsnhats? I don't see him coming up with the same thing as ProfBA... And ProfBA isn't a coach for this. However I don't think it means hes not mafia, I just don't think hes our best read. Give him the rest of this day and I might agree that hes surely mafia, but can you at least agree to give him that time? IdrA is actually a lot nicer then people give him credit for. :[

On January 07 2012 09:50 Liquid`Sheth wrote:
@Jitsu that was my thoughts exactly on those two as well. However you need to go over and read it or re-read it, as do I. Thats the sort of thing that could hide scum too. Just making a filter too long and too full of confusing randomness that we don't want to look at it.

On January 07 2012 09:54 Liquid`Sheth wrote:
Yes

Thanks for vasting my time btw. That is one thing you are good at in this game. And for your analysis after the lynch it is just a quick one, with no real content in it:

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=299955&currentpage=21#403 - Written in a very little methodical way and all you end up with is that you want to pressure three guys. WHAT A GREAT ANALYSIS MAN.

So now is the time I wil just OMGUS you. I am not saying you are scum, I will just say I think you are bad. And until either you make a real case on me, or I feel the urge to make a case on you I will just ignore you, because you are just one big distraction (well, unless you make more really stupid post involving me that I need to correct).