I got suspicious when you refused to actually answer anything. You just started swearing and calling stuff WIFOM. It may have been WIFOM but it was hardly a defence. I was sure but I was dead, so it didn't matter

I am not the best at persuading others. Look at my case against Sheth, it makes no sense. I ended up pleading with people. The fact that all three scum voted for him to be killed just shows how bad the lurkers fucked us over.

Anyway, well played. I put a lot of effort into this game and would have liked a win, but I can say that town as a whole was outplayed.

Jitsu

United States929 Posts

January 15 2012 03:42 GMT

#1042

On January 15 2012 12:39 Probulous wrote:
I got suspicious when you refused to actually answer anything. You just started swearing and calling stuff WIFOM. It may have been WIFOM but it was hardly a defence. I was sure but I was dead, so it didn't matter

Seconded. =(

gonzaw

Uruguay4911 Posts

January 15 2012 04:42 GMT

#1043

Well yeah, I know my response to your case sealed the deal about me being scum, although not your actual case.

The thing is that you posted so close to the deadline, and I wanted to respond to your case before you died...

So instead of making a good defence, I just rushed over it posting "fuck fucking fuck" every once in a while >_>

I think you may even see that one of my responses was "This is fucking" and nothing else >_>
I was in such a hurry I forgot to finish that sentence >_>

Here:

On January 13 2012 09:57 gonzaw wrote:

Show nested quote +

This is fucking

EDIT: And I wasn't lying when I mentioned Paper's strawmans and confirmation bias either >_>

It seems that a lot of you use that "storytelling" thing to "pinpoint" mafia.

You quote a post and say "Oh, and here he goes and votes for a townie, which he knows hecause he is scum."
"Oh, and he suspects Blurry's the medic, so he wants him lynched, which is why he voted him there".
"Oh, he knew that Blurry was a newb and used WIFOM, so he used those to push his lynch".

I mean, if you already know I'm scum, that's a good way of justifying my posts (actually Ceph's case against me was the actual story of how I played scum, taking out the "cat's scumbuddy" and "you were making me suspicious!" parts >_> ).

But it's not a very good way of determining if I'm scum or not.
You can do that with any player basicly (unless you find contradictions, in which case he's confirmed townie, or similar).

EDIT2: Also, did the town coaches know who the scumteam was? (as in, were they told who was scum when the game started?).

If not, it would have been a good idea to mindfuck them by asking townie questions and stuff >_>

Cyber_Cheese

Australia3615 Posts

January 15 2012 05:27 GMT

#1044

Well that was interesting, I felt a lot flakier than I should have been, I kinda wish I had been around more for those guys.
They were really active and put A LOT of effort in when they needed to, I really didn't see town winning even at the end of night 1.
//scum coach
other coaches can suck it because my coachings better

Blazinghand

United States25558 Posts

January 15 2012 05:44 GMT

#1045

On January 15 2012 14:27 Cyber_Cheese wrote:
other coaches can suck it because my coachings better

oh snappppppp

I actually really enjoyed watching this game. I think that those town players who didn't lurk actually did quite well. I forgot to mention in my previous post Jitsu, who is as sexy as he is intelligent.

gonzaw

Uruguay4911 Posts

January 15 2012 06:07 GMT

#1046

On January 15 2012 10:45 Cephiro wrote:But since I chose to not read guides but learn the game by playing, Probu's first-day case on me actually helped my play a lot.

Oh another thing.

I read Ver's Guide, and decided to act the opposite of what he said scum usually act >_>

Meh, worked until N3 though...

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

January 15 2012 12:46 GMT

#1047

well played mafia, nicely played Prob, I'm sorry I couldn't be more of a help.

I hope most of the active players this game will come back and play again.

Probulous

Australia3894 Posts

January 16 2012 01:28 GMT

#1048

On January 15 2012 14:27 Cyber_Cheese wrote:
Well that was interesting, I felt a lot flakier than I should have been, I kinda wish I had been around more for those guys.
They were really active and put A LOT of effort in when they needed to, I really didn't see town winning even at the end of night 1.
//scum coach
other coaches can suck it because my coachings better

You had it easy mate!

Coaching a team that is motivated, participating and can ask you any questions they want is much easier than providing general advice.

@Palmar, what are your thoughts on the overall game. Were there any other coaches?

Finally, I don't think I will be playing much more. This takes a huge amount of time and effort which I am may not have in the near future. Maybe a mini game.

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

January 16 2012 05:10 GMT

#1049

I encourage you to continue playing, You showed very real talent. You might ant to try playing in a few different types of games to see if they mesh with you better.

CookieMaker

Canada880 Posts

January 16 2012 19:07 GMT

#1050

On January 16 2012 10:28 Probulous wrote:

Finally, I don't think I will be playing much more. This takes a huge amount of time and effort which I am may not have in the near future. Maybe a mini game.

Word.

Fun game to watch guys! Don't worry about the last-mislynch townies, it would've been a cats-vs-paper final day anyways if gonz had been lynched (which he clearly should have by that point) and then it's all over.

Well played scum! Was fun to read, shame I didn't have the time or energy to defend myself/AKCT from the first-day.