EPTbut this video seems more like the job of a UI designer, rather then an artist.
If I understand the difference between those, ofcourse it doesnt hurt to be good at both
Proposed Design Changes To StarCraft 2's UI - Page 8
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
MostDifferent
Norway124 Posts
but this video seems more like the job of a UI designer, rather then an artist. If I understand the difference between those, ofcourse it doesnt hurt to be good at both | ||
|
Soma.bokforlag
Sweden448 Posts
| ||
|
Amui
Canada10567 Posts
On March 16 2012 08:30 snively wrote: i stopped at 2:59. i just wanna point out, you cant link your match history/score screen with the replay for each game replays are stored on your computer, your match history is stored on your account. this is the reason that you can watch other peoples replays. if you wanted to combine match history and replays like that, blizzard wuold have to save a copy of every single replay ever played, one for each person in a game. the amount of memory it would require would be enormous. ok, ill watch the rest now The link doesn't have to be there for every game. Only when the replay file is available locally I would think, because otherwise you'd have problems where people can see practice games of other pros, which presents a rather obvious problem. | ||
|
MrMotionPicture
United States4327 Posts
| ||
|
Maxd11
United States680 Posts
| ||
|
Sjokola
Netherlands800 Posts
Basicly this and shared replay watching for me. | ||
|
stokes17
United States1411 Posts
I'm pretty astonished at the amount of people being negative in this thread. The OP spent what I can only guess is dozens of hours trying to improve the UI for the Game we all dearly love. And instead of thanking him you say he was too nice to Blizzard and made changes that are too small? Just mind blowing.... Yes if this was the official Heart of the Swarm UI update from Blizzard then I would agree that they didn't address some of the larger foundational flaws with the Interface. But as far as a homemade attempt to demonstrate creative thinking and problem solving within a set of rules (although I don't quite understand how linking replay to match history would work with the way blizzard stores match history vs replay data) I thought you did an outstanding job. On top of that your presentation was absolutely top notch (I've seen numerous PhD presentations that were not as polished.) Fabulous job, I sincerely hope your hard work pays off for you in the manner you hope. Cheers | ||
|
Carl_Sagan
United States226 Posts
| ||
|
Samba
Germany452 Posts
You definitly got my like. | ||
|
ma70
253 Posts
Well, if I was Blizzard I would. This is nice stuff. | ||
|
Utopi
Denmark176 Posts
| ||
|
dmfg
United Kingdom591 Posts
Also I am very much of the opinion that UI designers should not have to worry themselves about "is this easy/possible to do in the code". That's the coder's job. If it turns out to be implausibly hard, then and only then should the coder go to the UI designer and say "hey, X or Y specific thing isn't possible to do. Can we get the same result without doing that?" The UI has to deliver what the end user wants, not what the coder wants. | ||
|
Mohdoo
United States15725 Posts
| ||
|
laLAlA[uC]
Canada963 Posts
| ||
|
Mr.Pyro
Denmark959 Posts
You're not coming up with any original stuff here, no reorganization or original thought in the layout. You're basically saying, hey, wouldn't it be nice if we had this categorization. There is only one thing in the video which i actually liked, from a GUI stand-point, and that was the inclusion of the back button, that's it. The music is a little over the top too, i think. The rest are features that are nice to have, sure, but i don't really see anything original design-wise, and when you say that stuff is easier, you seem to forget that what is 'easier' ... Easier for you? What makes you think most people would think this was easier. What makes you think categories would ever be used? It's not my impression the map bookmarks are being used all that much really. My main issue with your video is that you compliment their GUI design, when in fact the community seems to hate it. Wouldn't it have been better to come up with your own suggestion, and argue as for why your design is better, from some HCI standards? Being a GUI designer, doesn't constitute adding new features - you are told what features are available, and must build the design from that. So build a GUI with the features available to you - or features you know which might be coming. What seems like a totally missed opportunity to me is that you know the Marketplace for maps is coming - why not come up with your own suggestion for that? You moved a few buttons, added a back button, and added a lot of features which are really nice! But that is not GUI design.. In my eyes your main contribution here, is the back button, which is not all that major, although i admit it should have been there from day 1. I'm sorry for being so harsh, i'm not that bad a guy! Edit: After looking up the job on Blizzards website (http://eu.blizzard.com/en-gb/company/careers/posting.html?id=120001J) I think you completely misinterpreted the difference between designer and artist. Your video focuses on design - not art. | ||
|
YuTz
United States119 Posts
| ||
|
alteredsego
United States50 Posts
On March 16 2012 08:18 snailz wrote: yeah thats why i said "while i see why you would say such a thing" but his suggestions are honestly nothing but a glorified band-aid, it really wont change anything significantly enough for me to go "OMFG hire this guy!!!11" ghost town effect on bnet, and other things that Ashur mentioned are whats important, but blizz declines to adress them edit: to the OP, sorry if i came off strong, its just venting Hey man, I get what you are saying. One reason I just tried to work within the existing UI so much is because that is what the job calls for. Part of the point of the video is to show how I might approach things if I were hired. You know? I don't think they would look favorably on hiring someone that says, "I know how to do everything better than you, and you have been doing it all wrong." Plus as some people have pointed out there may be some reason that some features are not implemented as of right now. I just tried to stick to things that would work well within the existing UI, and that I thought, based on what I know about the system, would be realistic to pull off. Also for the sake of the video I did keep it short and focused around a single point as opposed to trying to cover everything. | ||
|
FeyFey
Germany10114 Posts
| ||
|
WombaT
Northern Ireland26221 Posts
On March 16 2012 09:07 Mr.Pyro wrote: I'm sorry, but i did not at all like it. You're not coming up with any original stuff here, no reorganization or original thought in the layout. You're basically saying, hey, wouldn't it be nice if we had this categorization. There is only one thing in the video which i actually liked, from a GUI stand-point, and that was the inclusion of the back button, that's it. The music is a little over the top too, i think. The rest are features that are nice to have, sure, but i don't really see anything original design-wise, and when you say that stuff is easier, you seem to forget that what is 'easier' ... Easier for you? What makes you think most people would think this was easier. What makes you think categories would ever be used? It's not my impression the map bookmarks are being used all that much really. My main issue with your video is that you compliment their GUI design, when in fact the community seems to hate it. Wouldn't it have been better to come up with your own suggestion, and argue as for why your design is better, from some HCI standards? Being a GUI designer, doesn't constitute adding new features - you are told what features are available, and must build the design from that. So build a GUI with the features available to you - or features you know which might be coming. What seems like a totally missed opportunity to me is that you know the Marketplace for maps is coming - why not come up with your own suggestion for that? You moved a few buttons, added a back button, and added a lot of features which are really nice! But that is not GUI design.. In my eyes your main contribution here, is the back button, which is not all that major, although i admit it should have been there from day 1. I'm sorry for being so harsh, i'm not that bad a guy! Surely he's applying for a position at Blizzard and would be expected to work within their original GUI framework and augment it, I would have thought that was the brief? Your criticism is generally fair though, although I don't agree with it personally (i.e I would find his changes 'easier' even if you wouldn't). Only the aforementioned point I would take proper issue with! | ||
|
alteredsego
United States50 Posts
On March 16 2012 09:07 Mr.Pyro wrote: I'm sorry, but i did not at all like it. You're not coming up with any original stuff here, no reorganization or original thought in the layout. You're basically saying, hey, wouldn't it be nice if we had this categorization. There is only one thing in the video which i actually liked, from a GUI stand-point, and that was the inclusion of the back button, that's it. The music is a little over the top too, i think. The rest are features that are nice to have, sure, but i don't really see anything original design-wise, and when you say that stuff is easier, you seem to forget that what is 'easier' ... Easier for you? What makes you think most people would think this was easier. What makes you think categories would ever be used? It's not my impression the map bookmarks are being used all that much really. My main issue with your video is that you compliment their GUI design, when in fact the community seems to hate it. Wouldn't it have been better to come up with your own suggestion, and argue as for why your design is better, from some HCI standards? Being a GUI designer, doesn't constitute adding new features - you are told what features are available, and must build the design from that. So build a GUI with the features available to you - or features you know which might be coming. What seems like a totally missed opportunity to me is that you know the Marketplace for maps is coming - why not come up with your own suggestion for that? You moved a few buttons, added a back button, and added a lot of features which are really nice! But that is not GUI design.. In my eyes your main contribution here, is the back button, which is not all that major, although i admit it should have been there from day 1. I'm sorry for being so harsh, i'm not that bad a guy! Edit: After looking up the job on Blizzards website (http://eu.blizzard.com/en-gb/company/careers/posting.html?id=120001J) I think you completely misinterpreted the difference between designer and artist. Your video focuses on design - not art. I have worked as an artist in the past, and so at least in my experience... they sort of go hand in hand. And as part of the video didn't I work around the existing artistic them in a way? I mean if I just want to show photoshopped windows to people that is not very interesting, and it does not effect positive change in any way. I guess I wanted to do both with this. I don't think you are being harsh by the way... it is just what you believe. And hey maybe I did miss with the video, but regardless it might lead to the game being better in some way, and maybe I helped to contribute to that. Is that such a bad thing? | ||
| ||
