| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Silvertine
United States509 Posts
On March 15 2012 19:25 tomatriedes wrote: Read the thread. People have been making these arguments in support of Idra. No, they've been arguing that 'faggot' and 'gay' are not comparable to 'nigger', and that is absolutely true. | ||
|
SuperFanBoy
New Zealand1068 Posts
On March 15 2012 19:15 Tobberoth wrote: Have you ever made a mistake in your life? Yeah? I hope no one ever hires you in the future, because making a mistake in the past curses you for life. Oh wait, that's downright dumb. It wasn't a one off mistake.. There is different screenshots from different occasions on which he made these racist remarks. I understand by saying "Oh I lost my temper and I didn't mean what I said" but to do it several times is unacceptable. What he said can not be unsaid, the anger and pain he may have afflicted to people who took offense can not be undone. In life you are responsible for what you do and what you say, people like Martin Luther King Jr. sacrificed their lives to change our perspective on race and equality. If we don't take his comments seriously and allow commentators to say things like that without any repercussions then how can esports be taken seriously? | ||
|
Tobberoth
Sweden6375 Posts
On March 15 2012 19:51 SuperFanBoy wrote: It wasn't a one off mistake.. There is different screenshots from different occasions on which he made these racist remarks. I understand by saying "Oh I lost my temper and I didn't mean what I said" but to do it several times is unacceptable. What he said can not be unsaid, the anger and pain he may have afflicted to people who took offense can not be undone. In life you are responsible for what you do and what you say, people like Martin Luther King Jr. sacrificed their lives to change our perspective on race and equality. If we don't take his comments seriously and allow commentators to say things like that without any repercussions then how can esports be taken seriously? Why can't you take it seriously and then forgive? It was in the past, it was long before EG hired him, WHY is this haunting him now, it's downright stupid! It doesn't even matter if he WAS a racist (he wasn't) but the point is that it was in THE PAST. He shouldn't be punished way after the fact for something he has regretted long since. Don't make it out to be that a caster said "nigger", it's about a caster who said "nigger" in moments of anger in the past. It's just words, and it's words in the past. | ||
|
tomatriedes
New Zealand5356 Posts
On March 15 2012 19:34 Silvertine wrote: No, they've been arguing that 'faggot' and 'gay' are not comparable to 'nigger', and that is absolutely true. You're mixing up opinion with fact there. What people take offense at is subjective and there I'm sure there are many (including myself) who find the words equally offensive. You really thing calling someone a 'fucking faggot' is any better than calling someone a 'fucking nigger'? | ||
|
ZergX
France436 Posts
 ♥ ! | ||
|
khazgore
Norway104 Posts
| ||
|
Forikorder
Canada8840 Posts
On March 15 2012 19:53 Tobberoth wrote: Why can't you take it seriously and then forgive? It was in the past, it was long before EG hired him, WHY is this haunting him now, it's downright stupid! It doesn't even matter if he WAS a racist (he wasn't) but the point is that it was in THE PAST. He shouldn't be punished way after the fact for something he has regretted long since. Don't make it out to be that a caster said "nigger", it's about a caster who said "nigger" in moments of anger in the past. It's just words, and it's words in the past. if it stayed in teh past it ouwldnt be a problem but people on Reddit brought it to the present by posting tons of screenshots and raging about it so it was no longer something that happened in the past it became a problem in the present | ||
|
HiOT
Sweden1000 Posts
| ||
|
silentsod
United States198 Posts
On March 15 2012 20:10 khazgore wrote: Could anyone give me a link to the Vod of the state of the game? i want to hear what he has to say! Orb was well spoken, and from what his statements were on SotG I wouldn't mind if he came back to casting in half a year or so. The highlight, for me, was him admitting his behavior then wasn't justifiable due to the fact that he's playing against another flesh and blood human on the other end. The whole thing showed a level of maturity I hadn't seen from him before. | ||
|
Forikorder
Canada8840 Posts
On March 16 2012 03:09 silentsod wrote: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JCHlTYWnpnM Orb was well spoken, and from what his statements were on SotG I wouldn't mind if he came back to casting in half a year or so. The highlight, for me, was him admitting his behavior then wasn't justifiable due to the fact that he's playing against another flesh and blood human on the other end. The whole thing showed a level of maturity I hadn't seen from him before. it reeked of pre-written sentiments | ||
|
CtrLZerG
United States104 Posts
On March 16 2012 03:09 silentsod wrote: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JCHlTYWnpnM Orb was well spoken, and from what his statements were on SotG I wouldn't mind if he came back to casting in half a year or so. The highlight, for me, was him admitting his behavior then wasn't justifiable due to the fact that he's playing against another flesh and blood human on the other end. The whole thing showed a level of maturity I hadn't seen from him before. I actually agree as well. 6 months should show whether he's grown from this at all. If he has, there really is no reason to keep condemning him. That would only negatively effect the community. Also, the fact that he's willing to accept punishment shows he has a good attitude. He knows he's wrong, he's recognized the root of the problem, and he's decided to grow from it. EDIT: Even if you presume that's the case, that's an extremely cynical point of view, in my opinion. Of COURSE it's scripted. Why would he want to risk saying something else that could put him in hot water? Don't attach bad motives to a person. He's been punished, and he's going to lay low for a while. If he does change from it, and doesn't make another big mistake like this, it wouldn't hurt the community if he came back in several months. I'm honestly not a big fan of Orb. However, the cynicism I've seen from the community in this post really is disappointing. The fact that people actually went to the sponsors in anger really proves that point for me. The community needs to learn from that as well. It's not fair to people who weren't involved when you go to a sponsor that will effect an entire team. That's totally uncool. | ||
|
gEzUS
Canada371 Posts
| ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
On March 16 2012 03:09 silentsod wrote: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JCHlTYWnpnM Orb was well spoken, and from what his statements were on SotG I wouldn't mind if he came back to casting in half a year or so. The highlight, for me, was him admitting his behavior then wasn't justifiable due to the fact that he's playing against another flesh and blood human on the other end. The whole thing showed a level of maturity I hadn't seen from him before. I agree, Orb was pretty great. He brought up all the points that were necessary and took ownership of his mistakes. I have done some dumb stuff in my life, but never infront as many people as he did. I felt bad for him because he did not mean any harm with his ladder rage. But the most important part is that Orb understood that his ladder rage likely did harm someone and that is why a part of the community was angry. I didn't know much about Orb until the show, but he showed a lot of class during all of this. I am more than happy to give him a chance if he gets another chance to cast. | ||
|
Forikorder
Canada8840 Posts
Even if you presume that's the case, that's an extremely cynical point of view, in my opinion. Of COURSE it's scripted. Why would he want to risk saying something else that could put him in hot water? Don't attach bad motives to a person. He's been punished, and he's going to lay low for a while. If he does change from it, and doesn't make another big mistake like this, it wouldn't hurt the community if he came back in several months. im willing to bet he wont change hell jsut use a smurf from now on | ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
As it should. If you are going to say something to a large group of people, you should think about and even practice what you are going to say. It shows that he cared and took the time to line up his thoughts. Do you think other professionals do not do the same thing? Do you think I don't prepare for interviews or intakes with potential clients? | ||
|
Forikorder
Canada8840 Posts
On March 16 2012 03:20 Plansix wrote: As it should. If you are going to say something to a large group of people, you should think about and even practice what you are going to say. It shows that he cared and took the time to line up his thoughts. Do you think other professionals do not do the same thing? Do you think I don't prepare for interviews or intakes with potential clients? what i meant was it sounds like he saids what he thinks we want to hear not what he thinks should be said | ||
|
Jerubaal
United States7684 Posts
| ||
|
Eiaco
170 Posts
| ||
|
Flonomenalz
Nigeria3519 Posts
On March 16 2012 03:20 Plansix wrote: As it should. If you are going to say something to a large group of people, you should think about and even practice what you are going to say. It shows that he cared and took the time to line up his thoughts. Do you think other professionals do not do the same thing? Do you think I don't prepare for interviews or intakes with potential clients? Nah you're supposed to go into an interview completely unprepared and just make stuff up on the fly so that people believe you're being honest with them. But wait, who's to say that you're not just pretending to do an on the spot response in a premeditated attempt to feign honesty? *rolls eyes* | ||
|
FGFGFG
Netherlands21 Posts
On March 16 2012 03:27 Forikorder wrote: what i meant was it sounds like he saids what he thinks we want to hear not what he thinks should be said Of course he doesn't completely mean what he says, and ofc he's not really super-sorry. Why would he be sorry for having a little rage like everyone else, and using 'bad' words almost everyone else uses? He is just saying what he needs to say to please all the people who are 'offended', and move on. Not much else he can do imo... | ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 League of Legends Heroes of the Storm Other Games |
|
Sparkling Tuna Cup
Afreeca Starleague
Light vs EffOrt
OSC
PiGosaur Cup
Kung Fu Cup
The PondCast
Replay Cast
Korean StarCraft League
CranKy Ducklings
GSL
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
