EPTPuma FIGHTING!
Puma leaves TSL for EG - Page 127
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Trowa127
United Kingdom1230 Posts
Puma FIGHTING! | ||
|
Velr
Switzerland10824 Posts
On July 21 2011 21:03 GGzerG wrote: IMO korean teams will stop sending they're best players to foreign events if they think foreign teams will continue to steal they're top players, just my speculation. lol. Make a fair/good with your players ---> Profit. Don't make a fair/good contract with your players ---> Lose players. Seriously, if Puma can just switch Teams like that, there either was no contract at all or one that allowed him to switch whenever he wants for no/little cost. Blame the Manager, no one else. | ||
|
Telebear
United Kingdom107 Posts
On July 21 2011 20:56 ePdeLay wrote: EG = Real Madrid of starcraft not really... A closer analogy would be chelsea after all of the "tapping up" they've done over the years, not that what eg has done is even in the same league as that | ||
|
Derez
Netherlands6068 Posts
On July 21 2011 20:59 Allscorpion wrote: PUMA is going to make idra the best player in the world. Yea because leaving Korea has proven to be such a succesful way to make it in the SCII scene. I understand it from Puma's pov, he wants to make money after all, but what kind of support can EG actually offer the guy? If Puma stays in Korea, he loses the entire infrastructure in terms of practise that TSL offered him. If he moves to the US, he joins a scene where he is by far the best player in the team and quite probably on the entire server. Short term: Puma gets more money. Long term: He falls behind the rest of the korean scene. | ||
|
Bactrian
Australia176 Posts
| ||
|
ginnipig
Canada84 Posts
On July 21 2011 20:52 starsucks wrote: 1. We have an aspiring player who is somehow affiliated with a team but has no real contract and seems to not get any significant payment from its team. 2. Another team ist interested in this player and offers him a contract and a monthly salary. 3. The player himself decides to sign this contract and is obviously now affiliated to another team which offered more attractive conditions. Now tell me what is wrong with this? What did TSL expect? 1. The player stays because of loyalty in a team which seems to not fully respects his skill or at least doesn't pay him accordingly. 2. EG asks TSL first. Why should they? What would be the advantage? TSL would probably reject the offer or at least claim a significant transfer fee which would be only necessary if there was an existing contract. 3. The manager of TSL could have instantly made a countering offer to puma if he was especially interested in him. He obviously didn't. So what is TSL's point? I understand that they are angry to lose a good player but this is completely their fault and it has nothing to do with an immoral behavior by EG. The strange thing is that I read a news in which TSL claimed to be the first team to pay a regular salary to players. Maybe they've run out of money. Agreed, on more then one LiveonThree SirScoots talked about how players where acquired. There are players that are in binding contracts that get "stolen", even though i dont like that word, by other teams and thats a little shady but happens in the Tech industry a lot, look at Google/Facebook. But in this case it was a player that basically had no contract sorta like a "free agent" and HE can do what ever the hell he wants. If Puma got a great offer from EG and wanted to continue on with his career up, FUCK THATS GREAT! He'll be making more money, traveling to more foreign events an probably playing better in the end having less stress on his plate. Good for Puma. Good for EG. Good for Esports  | ||
|
Jiddra
Sweden2685 Posts
On July 21 2011 20:57 RQShatter wrote: Sir Scoots is such trash. Everything he does is so shady. You think Scoots did this? Was Scoot even at the NASL finals? EG has a owner, Scoot is not him. We don't know who did what, we only have a few words from the coach of TSL. | ||
|
marvin.
United States469 Posts
On July 21 2011 20:52 starsucks wrote: Ok. After reading the new pages with a lot of people calling this "saddening" or "BM" by EG. Can anybody in all honesty explain to me why this should be considered as rude behavior? 1. We have an aspiring player who is somehow affiliated with a team but has no real contract and seems to not get any significant payment from its team. 2. Another team ist interested in this player and offers him a contract and a monthly salary. 3. The player himself decides to sign this contract and is obviously now affiliated to another team which offered more attractive conditions. Now tell me what is wrong with this? What did TSL expect? 1. The player stays because of loyalty in a team which seems to not fully respects his skill or at least doesn't pay him accordingly. 2. EG asks TSL first. Why should they? What would be the advantage? TSL would probably reject the offer or at least claim a significant transfer fee which would be only necessary if there was an existing contract. 3. The manager of TSL could have instantly made a countering offer to puma if he was especially interested in him. He obviously didn't. So what is TSL's point? I understand that they are angry to lose a good player but this is completely their fault and it has nothing to do with an immoral behavior by EG. The strange thing is that I read a news in which TSL claimed to be the first team to pay a regular salary to players. Maybe they've run out of money. It's the fact that TSL invested into Puma. They recruited him, trained him, and then he was taken away from them without any forward notice. You can state the technicalities or state there were no laws or anything of the sort broken - but Korea has been the mecca of E-Sports and the norm was for people to go through management in terms of player relations. To the Koreans, it's just like the Americans went up to Puma with an enticing offer and bought out their own nurtured talent. If Puma stayed on TSL I wouldn't be surprised if he received a salary in the relative future (this is just a guess, but who can disagree after we've seen his skills?). More attractive conditions is rather debatable. He's not going to have as good practice but he's going to have more chances to compete. Would someone rather continue to become better as a player versus make the easy fast money? No one can really say. I'm assuming TSL didn't make a counter-offer because when Puma came back, he already agreed to go to EG. All in all, it's a great acquisition for EG (and a sad loss for TSL) but by essentially buying out a player who was affiliated with a team already the foreigner//Korea relationship isn't going to improve. Hopefully EG can release a statement clarifying some things. | ||
Liquid`Sheth
United States2095 Posts
| ||
|
Sbrubbles
Brazil5776 Posts
Apart from this, SC2 as esport is actually looking like a sport now. | ||
|
Maliris
Northern Ireland2557 Posts
he said they were a joke of an organisation | ||
|
neoenigma
United States243 Posts
On July 21 2011 20:38 Quintum_ wrote: Losing to MC, Zenio, Sen and MMA, god those guys just suck dont they. The definition of foreign mediocrity. Also... Tarson  But that shouldnt happen now that Idra has Puma to train with. I think Puma's TvZ will stay pretty sharp too.So if EG ever has their tournament where you can win a laptop, who will be the final boss? Idra or Puma? xD | ||
|
StarStruck
25339 Posts
My thoughts exactly. There is no written rule between teams. The only organization that does this is KeSPA. Until that day comes teams will continue to fire under the gun. Regardless of what you think. | ||
Antoine
United States7481 Posts
| ||
|
StarStruck
25339 Posts
An incredibly short-sighted decision, but it is his decision nonetheless. | ||
Jibba
United States22883 Posts
"All is fair in love and war" but these are still the underhanded dealings the G7 tried to do away with. Then again, we saw with fnatic-SK that the G7 is completely useless and impotent. Still, it doesn't sit right that they talked to another team's player without their consent (which is required in most professional sports) while he was at a foreign event and thousands of miles away from his team/manager. Then again, EG might've just pissed on their own leg. We know from KeSPA that the Korean team organizations are not toothless like the G7 is. If they want to shut the door on EG, they probably could. | ||
|
MrCon
France29748 Posts
On July 21 2011 21:16 Antoine wrote: good for puma in the short run... horrible decision in the long run. every single player that left korea so far has immediately fallen behind in terms of skill. And Rain just disappeared. Anyway, TSL twitt about this : TSL_korea TSL EG!! that's a lie. Puma Good luck. TSL Everyone you want to be a good gamer. good bye. Has EG made a statement ? What "lie" is it ? | ||
|
Sablar
Sweden880 Posts
Or not. I really don't get the mentality behind the stealing part, but of course it's probably different in Korea. I don't see how it's different from switching jobs from the company you used to work at and got a lot of experience from, but maybe that is frowned upon in Korea as well. Good for EG anyway, but TSL seems to be in trouble. | ||
|
Vivax
22104 Posts
I just hope that in the future money won't play the only role in teams success... | ||
|
Lorch
Germany3690 Posts
Congratz to EG though, it's a great pickup for them and I'm sure if puma decides to move to the states into the team house it will be great for all players involved. | ||
| ||
