|
On February 19 2012 09:51 naux wrote:Show nested quote +On February 19 2012 09:45 Zeon0 wrote:
I agree with most of them, but I cant say anything about Keen and Heart, havent seen much games of them. And I dont wanna comment on sC cause i dont think he is that good (imo he is a cheesy ***) but he had serious medical issuses which could easily be the reason for his bad results.
And I dont know about Kiwikaki. He is creative, but is he really good?^^ you dont think Keen is underrated? his super underrated.. sC is cheesy? hahah no way you are crazy if he was healthy and no injuries i would bet my life he would win a GSL.. thats the thing people think KiWiKaKi is just creative but he takes games off insanely good players i just dont think he dedicates his whole time into SC2 thats why you dont see much results from him
I didnt see much of Keen recently. I didnt say he wasnt underrated, i said i cant say anything about him.
if i think of sC i think of 2basing all day long. But its hard to say if he was good if he was healthy, how would we know?
about Polt: i think he is where he belongs to: random good Korean, not absolut top tier though
|
I would probably say EmpireHappy
|
I think we at least can all agree that one player is NOT and never will be underrated and that is IdrA :D
|
United States15275 Posts
On February 19 2012 09:43 naux wrote:
Overrated
Polt
Naama
SjoW
Choya
InCa
XiGua
Tassadar
Underrated
Keen
Heart
Sheth
sC
Feast
KiWiKaKi
LMFAO who overrates TASSADAR of all people? If anything people severely underrate him. All he knows is 1 base and 2 base all-ins but it's not like he's incompetent at pulling them off.
Inca is definitely underrated. He plays risky as fuck all the time, but he's not a DT moron.
Feast is definitely overrated as far as results go.
Kenzy how can you say such mean things about Life? :'(
|
|
|
United Kingdom803 Posts
polt overrated? what the...
polt is godlike. i think he makes mistakes when under pressure, but watching his ladder stream his builds and unit control is rediculous. i've watched almost every stream out there and polt is by far the smartest 'top level' player imo.
i think sjow is underrated. his true power is in tournament environment, he seems more comfortable than anyone under pressure.
|
United States15275 Posts
On February 19 2012 10:12 shizna wrote:
polt overrated? what the...
polt is godlike. i think he makes mistakes when under pressure, but watching his ladder stream his builds and unit control is rediculous. i've watched almost every stream out there and polt is by far the smartest 'top level' player imo.
i think sjow is underrated. his true power is in tournament environment, he seems more comfortable than anyone under pressure.
He's one of the best crisis management players in the scene.
I haven't seen Sjow in forever, where has that dude been?
|
On February 19 2012 10:08 Titorelli wrote:
I think we at least can all agree that one player is NOT and never will be underrated and that is IdrA :D
lol so true.
|
|
|
|
|
On February 19 2012 09:43 naux wrote:
Overrated
Polt
Naama
SjoW
Choya
InCa
XiGua
Tassadar
Underrated
Keen
Heart
Sheth
sC
Feast
KiWiKaKi
I couldn't disagree more. Overrated naniwa,sjow? Noway dude your so wrong there.
Tassadar? huh.. Polt isnt overrated either..
The most underrated player atm is probably Slush and Destiny
|
Can we please refrain from calling players overrated? Before we know it, this will turn into a hate thread about some players. It won't be good. Just stick to the purpose and keep it a underrated thread ^_^
|
Overrated: jjakji, Parting, Violet, Idra, ForGG, Xigua
Underrated: San, QXC, Jinro
|
cant we just make a thread called "Players you think are overrated" or will we get TL bashed by it with a nub-banhammer? it would be cool to have a seperate thread for it.
|
Man a lot of these overrated lists are wayyyy off. anyhow
Underrated: Jinro, Ganzi, IMhappy, and maybe even MKP (serious)
|
I think a lot of players are underrated. People around here seem to think if a player doesn't finish in the top two or three in every tournament they suddenly suck.
IdrA is simultaneously the most overrated and underrated pro there is. He consistently gets in the top ten of most tournaments, with the exception of GSL ... he's not great, but you'd think based on his most ardent 'haters' that he's a steaming pile of crap.
Jinro, QXC, InControl, Sheth, TLO ... all these "mid-tier" pro's are still miles ahead of the average Grandmaster player, imo. You just have to watch their streams and how they play and pay less stock in tournament results.
The only player I think is a bit overrated is Sen ... there's something about his playstyle that is 'shakey' to me.
|
On February 19 2012 10:27 KicKDoG wrote:Show nested quote +On February 19 2012 09:43 naux wrote:
Overrated
Polt
Naama
SjoW
Choya
InCa
XiGua
Tassadar
Underrated
Keen
Heart
Sheth
sC
Feast
KiWiKaKi I couldn't disagree more. Overrated naniwa,sjow? Noway dude your so wrong there. Tassadar? huh.. Polt isnt overrated either.. The most underrated player atm is probably Slush and Destiny
you think SjoW is good?? thats so laughable he loses like all the time from mid tier pros
yeah of course people will debate with NaNiwa being good but i dont know i dont think his "that" great
u think tassadar is good? me putting tassadar was to somebody saying tassadar was underrated.. his clearly terrible
Polt is so overrated? can you explain why you think his not? because what he won a super tournament which he one based his way to victory?
|
On February 19 2012 10:12 shizna wrote:i think sjow is underrated. his true power is in tournament environment, he seems more comfortable than anyone under pressure. Are you kidding me
I don't even bother watching most games with sjow because I know I'm going to spend 30% of the time wondering how in the hell he managed to get supply blocked AGAIN.
Sjow's macro is pretty awful and it holds him back/makes him frustrating to watch. How could he possibly be underrated?
|
|
|
Juan, aka MajOr, xsixwindy
i think people realize hes good, but people always overlook him for his mistakes or bm
ive met him in real life. he gave some his time away for a little interview and chat and he is actually surprisingly nice
extremely good player
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
