Poll, who was going to win this game? - Page 2

On April 08 2011 06:28 suejak wrote:

Did you even read the post? The protoss was complaining about lag.

Can you guys just shut up and watch the replay? If you can't download the replay, then just say so (and shut up).

Stop being so actively counterproductive.

On April 08 2011 06:46 MrGingerKid wrote:


Ah, my fault. I apologize.

I did just watch the replay though and I am sorry to say that toss had the upper hand at the end. While his natural was running low his army composition was much stronger than yours. Even though he was about to run out of money I can almost assure you he was about to attack your front which would've ended the game right away. You had 11 marauders 4 of which were on the other side of the map, 2 more marauders and a viking in production.

The colossus, zealots, and stalkers would've cleaned up the marauders in no time so the vikings wouldn't even have been able to kill one colossus. If you pulled all your scvs you may have barely held, but then ironically he would have more income than you.

Sorry but I'm going to have to go with toss.

EDIT: Just looked at the upgrade situation and the battle may have been closer than I thought, but I still think the colossus would've cleaned up nicely.
2nd EDIT (lol): he had a colossus and enough resources to warp in 5 or so more units.

On April 08 2011 07:05 nuMi22 wrote:
2) I'm not sure you've even watched the replay yourself, he literally only has to A move to the back of your base and it's over. I have no idea why you've posted this on here, it's not even close.

If he A moves to my base the way his army is set up, I will 1shot each unit as it comes streaming in lol... easily.

On April 08 2011 07:11 nuMi22 wrote:


Don't be so facetious, you know exactly what I meant. The fact that you have no reply other than this pathetic attempt proves my points precisely.

On April 08 2011 07:13 KevinIX wrote:
Did you guys honestly watch the replay? The Protoss was not that much bigger than the Terran. If the Terran pulled his scv's he would have just barely won the battle with those medivacs.

Sorry, when someone says "literally BLANK" I usually take them literally.

On April 08 2011 07:18 sekritzzz wrote:
clearly protoss, what could you have done? are u going to heal his collusus to death?

On April 08 2011 07:25 StallingHard wrote:
Is this some sort of ban trap for the mods to see who actually watches the replays? It's pretty clear protoss is going to win. Terran has 11 maras, 8 medivacs, 3 vikings as his effective fighting force vs protoss with 5 zeals, 2 collosi, 16 stalkers. Zeals will tank mara shots while stalkers and collosi proceed to roll your army. Medivacs can't heal things that are being 1-shot. And about that post-game graph, you have so much of your army value tied up in those medivacs, a full 800/800 and they're going to be nigh on useless.

Your armor is what really matters here, because your attack upgrades won't matter a big deal vs the zealot shield wall up front. And taking 3 damage from stalkers and collosi won't be that big a deal (it will be a big deal vs the zealots but they're not going to be doing the damage)

Don't come in here asking for opinions from people and then immediately refute what they say with oh but upgrades. Your upgrades meant nothing against that army comp. If it was an all stalker army I'd say you have a good chance. Unfortunately, b/c of the zealot wall, your lack of marines and vikings, and overabundance of army value in medivacs, you will 100% lose this. Were this a TSL match the refs would 100% give the win to the protoss player.