| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Regina
Netherlands148 Posts
 great show. Tip on close are use the whitera warp prison play to avoid early pressure (obs near ramp, move in with prison when he moves out, kill some scvs move out and keep doing that) i even love to delay warpgate research to get a extreme fast robo up since i dont feel like warp gate research helps alot if it comes 20 sec earlier against terran. Keep the good stuff up ! | ||
|
Consummate
Australia191 Posts
On February 11 2011 08:10 Ratel wrote: Different mechanics =/= easier mechanics protoss buildings cant fly and a nexus cant turn into a murdering infrastructure that can be mass repaired by the workers, also you cant just scan cloaked units or ur opponents base, also you cant just press a button to get more supply if your blocked what i am trying to say is the mechanics are different, each race has its own advantages Apparently you missed the whole macro part of the post since only 1 of your several points are related to my post (the supply depot part). I wasn't saying there is a problem with it, just stating that Protoss's macro mechanics are the easiest to manage. | ||
|
Bonham
Canada655 Posts
On February 11 2011 08:06 Consummate wrote: Since warp gate cool down is universal, its easier managing your army as all your warp gates (if you're warping in at the same time) will be available at the same time, rather than different build times meaning you have to be constantly checking your production facilities to ensure they're building. Not necessarily. If you chrono any warpgates, don't flip your gates over all at the same time, or build new ones "off cycle" (which happens in most games, I would wager), you'd have asynchronous warpgate cooldowns, with as many a different optimal timings as you have gates. Also, protoss players don't always exclusively use gateways – stargates and robo facs work more like factories, barracks (barracksii? Barrackopodes?), and starports. Edit: cleaned up language for greater clarity. | ||
|
DaBears57
United States300 Posts
On February 11 2011 08:17 Consummate wrote: Apparently you missed the whole macro part of the post since only 1 of your several points are related to my post (the supply depot part). I wasn't saying there is a problem with it, just stating that Protoss's macro mechanics are the easiest to manage. Easiest to manage? Have you ever seen any protoss fully utilizing 3 nexus's worth of chrono and keep it down? No, even the best like MC still slip up. In fact, one of the games he was streaming he had full chrono on 2 nexuses at 12 sc2 minutes in. | ||
|
JDeathmetal
Netherlands81 Posts
ok..... hahaha now it's funny again!!! still rolfcoptering! I'm wondering who will be the first to email them and ask: Idra how did you feel when artosis denied you the good old high five? But maybe his expression on his face tells enough but on a serious note, people who say you need a terran and a protoss on the show really don't understand how good these guys are with their understanding of the game, just cause they both main zerg doesn't mean they don't know the other races, I mean common Artosis casts on GOMTV for godsakes, he knows all the builds even before those guys do it. So I think he knows pretty well whats good or bad in the game and what is imbalanced or not, ofc he sees things a bit more from the zerg point of view, but then again he has seen this stuff so many times that by now he knows every viable build thats out there (almost) so please keep this in mind before ranting on about needing more people on the show, ofc that would be fun but it isnt mandatory. Also I believe that in most levels below pro (also in masters etc me being a 2800 master) the mechanics and the relative ease of use of the terran army make terran a real strong race, I play terran on a friends account and im not yet very good at it but im starting to learn more and more of the race and I feel the mech path is really really strong (might call it imba) and with the MMM combo the dropping is so ridicelously strong from time to time, hey my opponent has 3 base --> lets drop in all three keep them hotkeyed Stim and snipe nexus or mineral line. GG I play alot of random so i know the most sorrow of all the races, I hate 4gate toss i hate MMM terran I hate Hydra/Roach timing zerg. Its all part of the game, and most match-ups feel pretty even. Ofc there are maps that do suck (steppes of war terran anyone ?!) | ||
|
Zocat
Germany2229 Posts
On February 11 2011 08:06 Consummate wrote: Since warp gate cool down is universal, its easier managing your army as all your warp gates (if you're warping in at the same time) will be available at the same time, rather than different build times meaning you have to be constantly checking your production facilities to ensure they're building. This is wrong. Different units put the warpgates on different cooldowns. Warp in a zealot - WG cooldown is 28sec. Warp in a stalker/sentry - WG cooldown is 32sec. Warp in HT/DT - WG cooldown is 45sec. Therefore warpgate will only be available at the same time if you always warp in similiar unit types (which is almost impossible / ill advised). | ||
|
Fungal Growth
United States434 Posts
On February 11 2011 08:39 DaBears57 wrote: Yeah...people underestimate how difficult it is to keep on top of CB's (or avoid getting 'energy blocked').Easiest to manage? Have you ever seen any protoss fully utilizing 3 nexus's worth of chrono and keep it down? No, even the best like MC still slip up. In fact, one of the games he was streaming he had full chrono on 2 nexuses at 12 sc2 minutes in. This actually indirectly would make a great show idea... What units and races are the most APM friendly and how does this affect balance between races and between units? Important topic because APM even for the best pro's is scarce. Many protoss get energy blocked...many zerg (including Idra) miss injection cycles... Contrary to popular belief, warpgate micro for toss is a pain because you have to switch screens and lose your current selection which always multiples your actions per minute. They could then talk about possible solutions... Auto-inject for queens? Hatchery icons (like the warpgate icon) where each hatchery changes a color when it can support more larvae. Auto-cb (where you 'rally' it to a building with a shift option for multiple 'rallies'/auto CB's)...a higher energy cap, so players don't get burned as much for getting energy blocked...maybe the key combo ALT-CB extends your chrono-boost for twice the time but cost twice the energy...perhaps even stackable CB's? To alleviate warp-gate APM (fellow toss know what I'm talking about) it would be nice if buildings could auto-append newly created units to a designated control group (so say my selected stargate automatically adds my new voids/phoenixes to say ctrl-group 3 which saves a TON on APM)...being able to warp units onto the mini-map would be cool too. Should overlords get their own rally option? Should creep tumors have an-auto spawn ability (just shift queue a highway destination and the tumors go into auto-cancer mode)? People forget how big APM is when it comes to discussions on race balance. I think it would be a cool topic... | ||
|
Fanciful
United States59 Posts
If they continue to to use a video format they can do a few things to improve the production value: less head room ![[image loading]](http://piczasso.com/i/24958.png) this is an uncomfortable amount of head room ![[image loading]](http://piczasso.com/i/o04ej.png) this is an example of better framing edit down the content 50+ minutes of content is a lot, especially during one continuous shot. I like how they broke the show up into two sections this time. unfortunately their opinions get lost in the overwhelming amount of content. Instead of talking for a hour using only train of thought as a guide why not make shorter videos with specific ideas. add an extra camera point one at Artosis and point the other at Idra. with two cameras you have the ability to edit a conversation and improve viewer engagement with shot reverse shot. With an extra camera you don't need someone to babysit the cameras; this show can stay a two man show. ![[image loading]](http://piczasso.com/i/kw5ex.png) "Artosis, how do you feel about vanilla ice cream?" ![[image loading]](http://piczasso.com/i/j34u4.png) "You have no right to ask me about Vanilla ice cream..." ![[image loading]](http://piczasso.com/i/zoub7.png) "Sorry to upset you, may we hi five?" ![[image loading]](http://piczasso.com/i/usut3.png) "kay" On February 11 2011 10:48 wonderwall wrote: Perhaps it might be a better idea to turn it into a podcast. At the moment there is no distinct visual medium which requires the use of video. If you perhaps cut away to replays illustrating what you are saying it might improve the video medium. As a simple example take the colossus episode. Talk about the problem with corruptor's where either you kill all the colossi but you don't have a ground army left over and instead just have 10 corruptors wiggling about. *Show a replay of this happening in a PvZ engagement at high food with Artosis and Idra talking over it* Or the problem where your corruptors just evaporate instantly and your ground army gets murdered by colossi. *Show a replay of this happening in a PvZ engagement at high food with artosis and idra talking over it* These are just a few suggestions to cheaply improve the show. | ||
|
ledarsi
United States475 Posts
It is amazing that you are being so professional about this show, and finally there is a place for truly top caliber players to make their opinions known in a productive manner. I know there are some people who are mindless dissenters, but rest assured that you can safely ignore them. The rest of us know you are not just QQing, this is something much deeper and more important. On top of that the show is actually very educational about the mindset of the best players in the world about the structure of the game, which is something I have not seen anywhere else. Keep it up! | ||
|
Hane
France210 Posts
On February 11 2011 08:39 DaBears57 wrote: No, even the best like MC still slip up. In fact, one of the games he was streaming he had full chrono on 2 nexuses at 12 sc2 minutes in. Sometimes, keeping CB is a part of your plan, in case of rush. That's not so hard to keep nexus mana low since you want to make colossus/vr or you have 2forges. Back to the video, i feel that MM is quite balanced, BUT MMM is an other story imo. Since you have 4 medivacs you can multi drop, and that's really more scary than any mm push. | ||
|
bole
Serbia164 Posts
i am more for soft conters then for hard conters... i think that blizz should nerf hard conters...it will made gameplay more fun to play and it will need more skill 2 play... also if they bring back (replace hard conters) with soft it will game where you have comeback... | ||
|
Sabu113
United States11046 Posts
You dont even have to look away from your army while you're macroing. We have other buildings that produce too. Plus chrono is every bit as intensive as mules/scan if not more. -.- Really really curious about this 1 gate FE that is so safe. Love to see a rep that i can jack this from. | ||
|
wonderwall
New Zealand695 Posts
As a simple example take the colossus episode. Talk about the problem with corruptor's where either you kill all the colossi but you don't have a ground army left over and instead just have 10 corruptors wiggling about. *Show a replay of this happening in a PvZ engagement at high food with Artosis and Idra talking over it* Or the problem where your corruptors just evaporate instantly and your ground army gets murdered by colossi. *Show a replay of this happening in a PvZ engagement at high food with artosis and idra talking over it* | ||
Jibba
United States22883 Posts
Chilling. Also, I'd like to see a new show unrelated to SC2 called Artosis, Animals N' Friends! | ||
|
MagicGunner
United States78 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + ![[image loading]](http://i51.tinypic.com/1zxprb4.png) and Artosis super troll edition. + Show Spoiler + ![[image loading]](http://i53.tinypic.com/rktpqc.png) | ||
|
sureshot_
United States257 Posts
Perhaps it might be a better idea to turn it into a podcast. At the moment there is no distinct visual medium which requires the use of video. If you perhaps cut away to replays illustrating what you are saying it might improve the video medium. I absolutely agree. I think these episodes could incorporate a variety of in-game footage/replays to demonstrate visually the topic at hand. It would also make the viewing experience much more satisfying. In terms of content, once again I thought this was a really great discussion and covered, in general, the complexity of the TvP match up. I would really love to see Blizzard mess around in the PTR with terran and protoss upgrades (their accessibility to be more specific). I have to agree with Idra though, I definitely think Terran has the early game MUCH, much easier compared to Protoss, however the strength of force fields and sentry + gateway play its more than possible to deal with. I really hope though for the sake of lower level play that the difficulty between early game Terran and Protoss is addressed because, to be honest, Terran early game is the reason why 3 racks all ins are so common at lower level play (and so successful). Closing this difficulty gap could possibly be an example of Blizzard balancing SC2 for lower level play, while not significantly damaging the TvP match-up. | ||
|
KawaiiRice
United States2914 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + ![[image loading]](http://imgur.com/J1IYg.jpg) ![[image loading]](http://imgur.com/fzAkN.jpg) ![[image loading]](http://imgur.com/nDeef.jpg) ![[image loading]](http://imgur.com/2IOLt.jpg) n_n Hope episode 3 is more about tvp D: edit: grr why is the picture thing too big edit: fixed :> | ||
|
Worm Shoes
United Kingdom22 Posts
So i'll say this 1) It would be really cool if you got a terran player to sit with you guys and add their input too AND it would widen the discussion. but my main point.. 2) I've always said that C.shells and stim marauders are TOO good at what they do and believe that they should have one or the other...not both! but that aside do you think that the upgrade for either stim or C.shells should be obtainable once you've built a factory or an engineering bay? Also you know what i would love to see?...Marines only able to shoot ground and need an upgrade to shoot ground AND air!!!...yes i play Zerg lol  That would help an early scouting Overlord after the ramp is blocked so there's a little less guess work :p | ||
|
terranghost
United States980 Posts
On February 10 2011 14:06 McMonty wrote: You guys didnt mention EMP at all. If you rely on sentry energy to hold off an attack, and a single ghost EMPs your sentries, it is game over. You do realize that teching up to ghosts costs200 gas and 80sec of game time. Not to mention the 3 less scvs on minerals because you will probably need a second geyser to get that ghost to go with one of your pushes. This equates to 3 less marauders in your push just for that one ghost and if the sentries aren't all bunched up then you have not done as much damage as you wanted to do. You can always use it on the clumped up ground forces but since you built ghosts you have a lower marauder count making guardian shield all the more affective. | ||
|
WhiteDog
France8650 Posts
By the way, I think everybody is missing the point in trying to search for one unit or one unit mix that is or not "imbalanced". The feeling of imbalance that many are facing from SC2 as something to do with timings. The tech tree is loled, everybody can tech expand in the most safe fashion (except zerg), while taking a third or a fourth, like Lalush explained us, is risky AND don't give almost anything maccro wise. Nerfing any unit will certainly mess up any late game match up. What people need to look at is how to make certain things harder to get in the game, and others easier (mutas go out after thor drop... warpgate is too easy researched, stim shield concussive are so overpowered and come so early, and so on...). PS: Hey Jibba, what's the music you used for yor AmerIdrA Beauty Remix, seems great. | ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Britney Stormgate  26840Calm  7370Rain 3326Sea  2263Shuttle 1801EffOrt 1754Stork 485actioN 388ggaemo 273Light 248[ Show more ] Dota 2 Counter-Strike Heroes of the Storm Other Games B2W.Neo2919 DeMusliM434 crisheroes428 hiko241 ArmadaUGS217 Fuzer  205SortOf158 XaKoH  157QueenE53 Rex29 |
|
Road to EWC
Replay Cast
SC Evo League
Road to EWC
Afreeca Starleague
BeSt vs Soulkey
Road to EWC
Wardi Open
SOOP
NightMare vs Wayne
Replay Cast
Replay Cast
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
