• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 02:15
CET 08:15
KST 16:15
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11[ASL22] Ro16 Preview: Holy Diver5
Community News
Dark completes military service, returns to SC211[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0Weekly Cups (October 19-25): Clem triples first in 5.0.175
StarCraft 2
General
No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 Serral's getting trashed by New Catsle's Mind Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top? Liquibets sc2 season 30
Tourneys
Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16) RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
Shield Battery Server New Patch List of top players active on ShieldBattery BW General Discussion Top Players of October 2026 (EBPD Rankings) Starcraft:Brood War Discord Servers
Tourneys
2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players [BSL23] Ro16 Group C - Sunday 21:00 CET [$1250] International ShieldBattery League [Megathread] Daily Proleagues
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Nintendo Switch Thread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc List of Game Threads The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Trading/Investing Thread European Politico-economics QA Mega-thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 MLB/Baseball 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 10189 users

Extractor trick and mineral micro demystified - Page 4

Forum Index > StarCraft 2 Strategy
Post a Reply
Prev 1 2 3 4 All
morimacil
Profile Joined March 2010
France921 Posts
June 12 2010 23:13 GMT
#61
I would say its pretty obvious to anyone that microing your workers, for example, DOES give a benefit.
No wasted mining time > wasted mining time, there is really no point in arguing against that.
The real question, however, is: Is it worth it?
I would say it isnt for me, based on my own observations, and these results.
The simple matter that it comes down to is this:
If you do it absolutely perfectly, you gain about 5 minerals. If you mess up, you can lose a lot more than that.
So it simply comes down to this in the end:
If you can do it absolutely perfectly, 100% of the time, and also have the APM to spare doing it, then do it.
If you cant do it perfectly 100% of the time, and/or you would rather focus your attention and apm somewhere else, then the possible 5 mineral gain simply isnt worth it, and you are better off not doing it.
More minerals is always good, but sometimes, 5 minerals simply isnt worth it.

And yes, thats all it is really. There is no "cumulative effect". That doesnt apply to zerg, unless your build wastes larva. (which neither 9OL or ET do).
Stopping the tests early "before the effects can be seen" is bullshit.
If you have 15 drones mining and 1 larva in all cases, letting it go on for longer is not going to show any "cumulative effect over time" or something random like that. No matter what build you used to get there, 15 drones mine at the same speed. If you are 5 minerals ahead, letting the 15 drones mine for 20 more mining cycles isnt going to put you more minerals ahead compared to another build with 15 drones also mining for 20 cycles.

Summing it up:
Splitting workers at the start: not worth it, unless you can do it absolutely perfectly 100% of the time. If done absolutely perfectly 100% of the time, provides an incredibly minor gain.
Microing workers: not worth it, unless you can do it absolutely perfectly 100% of the time and have APM to spare. If done absolutely perfectly 100% of the time, provides an incredibly minor gain.
extractor trick: not worth it when going for a "normal" build, unless you can do it absolutely perfectly 100% of the time. If done absolutely perfectly 100% of the time, provides an incredibly minor gain. Still delays overlord cost, so can still be useful for other reasons (faster scouting drone, faster pool, faster hatch)

If you are going for a scout, pool, and hatch at 12 food or later, dont bother with the ET. Its not worth the APM investment, for a gain of 5-15 minerals, and a potential loss of double to triple that amount, maybe more depending on how bad you screw it up.
Same thing for microing workers and splitting them.
If you actually are able to pull this all off 100% of the time, completely perfectly, and never screwing it up, ever, and have the APM to do it, and enjoy the pressure of putting yourself in a high-risk low-reward sittuation, where you cannot screw up, and also have a relevant build where 5 extra minerals actually makes a difference (lol), then sure, go ahead. If you are at that point, then you probably know what you are doing already better than anyone else, and dont need any advice.
All others: dont do it!
Red Alert
Profile Joined June 2009
United States119 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-06-13 05:37:02
June 13 2010 05:21 GMT
#62
On June 12 2010 23:55 Batch wrote:
I did some tests aswell in which I built 15 drones and checked the minerals at 2:30 (gametime).
The tests were done without any worker microing at all pointing all new drones to the same mineral patch. I ran about 10 tests counting only the runs which went flawless. In the extractor trick runs the extractor where built when I had 75 minerals so I immidiately could build a new drone.

ET: 504-524 minerals
No-ET: 505-535 minerals

As seen we probably need a lot of tests to actually find out the true outcome since the ranges are this wide.

I also glanced at the larvas and I would estimate the ET is worth about 5 (in game) seconds of larva spawn (1/3 larva).

With this result I get the conclusion that I probably will skip the ET since I don't think it's worth the trouble. I got pretty bad micro and while trying to do the trick I probably failed twice as often as I succeeded and lost valuable mining times with missclicks...

I would love seeing a video of somebody with great micro trying this out with gamespeed set on slowest and doing a perfect ET.


if you are getting a 30 mineral discrepancy between "perfect" runs, you aren't doing it very well. When I ran the test I usually had 5 or 0 mineral differences at the 1:40 mark.

btw, what kind of numbers would those be realtime? Not really sure how to see gametime w/out playing an actual game.

On June 13 2010 08:13 morimacil wrote:

extractor trick: not worth it when going for a "normal" build, unless you can do it absolutely perfectly 100% of the time. If done absolutely perfectly 100% of the time, provides an incredibly minor gain. Still delays overlord cost, so can still be useful for other reasons (faster scouting drone, faster pool, faster hatch)

extractor trick is done after the overlord
Tenn
Profile Joined April 2010
Sweden12 Posts
June 13 2010 22:39 GMT
#63
On June 13 2010 08:13 morimacil wrote:
I would say its pretty obvious to anyone that microing your workers, for example, DOES give a benefit.
No wasted mining time > wasted mining time, there is really no point in arguing against that.
The real question, however, is: Is it worth it?
I would say it isnt for me, based on my own observations, and these results.
The simple matter that it comes down to is this:
If you do it absolutely perfectly, you gain about 5 minerals. If you mess up, you can lose a lot more than that.
So it simply comes down to this in the end:
If you can do it absolutely perfectly, 100% of the time, and also have the APM to spare doing it, then do it.
If you cant do it perfectly 100% of the time, and/or you would rather focus your attention and apm somewhere else, then the possible 5 mineral gain simply isnt worth it, and you are better off not doing it.
More minerals is always good, but sometimes, 5 minerals simply isnt worth it.

And yes, thats all it is really. There is no "cumulative effect". That doesnt apply to zerg, unless your build wastes larva. (which neither 9OL or ET do).
Stopping the tests early "before the effects can be seen" is bullshit.
If you have 15 drones mining and 1 larva in all cases, letting it go on for longer is not going to show any "cumulative effect over time" or something random like that. No matter what build you used to get there, 15 drones mine at the same speed. If you are 5 minerals ahead, letting the 15 drones mine for 20 more mining cycles isnt going to put you more minerals ahead compared to another build with 15 drones also mining for 20 cycles.

Summing it up:
Splitting workers at the start: not worth it, unless you can do it absolutely perfectly 100% of the time. If done absolutely perfectly 100% of the time, provides an incredibly minor gain.
Microing workers: not worth it, unless you can do it absolutely perfectly 100% of the time and have APM to spare. If done absolutely perfectly 100% of the time, provides an incredibly minor gain.
extractor trick: not worth it when going for a "normal" build, unless you can do it absolutely perfectly 100% of the time. If done absolutely perfectly 100% of the time, provides an incredibly minor gain. Still delays overlord cost, so can still be useful for other reasons (faster scouting drone, faster pool, faster hatch)

If you are going for a scout, pool, and hatch at 12 food or later, dont bother with the ET. Its not worth the APM investment, for a gain of 5-15 minerals, and a potential loss of double to triple that amount, maybe more depending on how bad you screw it up.
Same thing for microing workers and splitting them.
If you actually are able to pull this all off 100% of the time, completely perfectly, and never screwing it up, ever, and have the APM to do it, and enjoy the pressure of putting yourself in a high-risk low-reward sittuation, where you cannot screw up, and also have a relevant build where 5 extra minerals actually makes a difference (lol), then sure, go ahead. If you are at that point, then you probably know what you are doing already better than anyone else, and dont need any advice.
All others: dont do it!


Yes! You understood the essence of what I was trying to achieve with these experiments. The risk of not microing/doing ET perfectly is too big for the effort/APM put in to it and the rewards you're given.

As far as the other posts directed to me, I'll try to answer them tomorrow. I've been busy the last few days and didn't realize this post got such big attention

Cheers,
Tenn

infuzer
Profile Joined May 2010
Sweden30 Posts
June 13 2010 23:21 GMT
#64
@morimacil
Thanks. I've never thought about the cumulative mining effect not existing with zerg!
Red Alert
Profile Joined June 2009
United States119 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-06-14 00:53:11
June 14 2010 00:51 GMT
#65
the extractor trick is super easy, and there's not much else to use your apm on at the time.

here is what you do:
-wait for drone mining minerals closest to geysers to return minerals
-start extractor with that drone
-make drone
-cancel extractor, send drone to the empty mineral patch right next to it
General-Gouda
Profile Joined June 2010
United States45 Posts
June 14 2010 15:52 GMT
#66
The one thing I am not seeing mentioned here is using F1 to send idle workers directly to a mineral deposit instead of allowing the AI to spread them out for you.

I haven't seen any detailed write-ups concerning any benefits for doing that over simply sending them all to one deposit (or splitting them up into groups of 2 or 3). Does anyone have any links to an analysis like this? If not I'll have to see if I can create one and post it.

This is an interesting discussion BTW. Amazing how little benefit you derive from so much extra APM (aside from impressing your opponent with your high APM early in the game I guess).
The Duck goes, "Quack!" The Cow goes, "MOO!" The Ultralisk goes, "OMNOMNOMNOM!"
Batch
Profile Joined May 2010
Sweden692 Posts
June 14 2010 19:12 GMT
#67
On June 13 2010 14:21 Red Alert wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 12 2010 23:55 Batch wrote:
I did some tests aswell in which I built 15 drones and checked the minerals at 2:30 (gametime).
The tests were done without any worker microing at all pointing all new drones to the same mineral patch. I ran about 10 tests counting only the runs which went flawless. In the extractor trick runs the extractor where built when I had 75 minerals so I immidiately could build a new drone.

ET: 504-524 minerals
No-ET: 505-535 minerals

As seen we probably need a lot of tests to actually find out the true outcome since the ranges are this wide.

I also glanced at the larvas and I would estimate the ET is worth about 5 (in game) seconds of larva spawn (1/3 larva).

With this result I get the conclusion that I probably will skip the ET since I don't think it's worth the trouble. I got pretty bad micro and while trying to do the trick I probably failed twice as often as I succeeded and lost valuable mining times with missclicks...

I would love seeing a video of somebody with great micro trying this out with gamespeed set on slowest and doing a perfect ET.


if you are getting a 30 mineral discrepancy between "perfect" runs, you aren't doing it very well. When I ran the test I usually had 5 or 0 mineral differences at the 1:40 mark.

btw, what kind of numbers would those be realtime? Not really sure how to see gametime w/out playing an actual game.

Show nested quote +
On June 13 2010 08:13 morimacil wrote:

extractor trick: not worth it when going for a "normal" build, unless you can do it absolutely perfectly 100% of the time. If done absolutely perfectly 100% of the time, provides an incredibly minor gain. Still delays overlord cost, so can still be useful for other reasons (faster scouting drone, faster pool, faster hatch)

extractor trick is done after the overlord

The extractor trick will always be more effective if being done before starting building the overlord.
I can't think of a single scenario when the extractor trick should be done after the start of the overlord, please enlighten me if there is such a case.
Moonling
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
United States987 Posts
June 14 2010 20:01 GMT
#68
Thanks for the contribution i like the tests and i usually just stick with the 9 ovie no extractor trick it seems to work out better in the long run
1% of koreans control 99% of starcraft winnings. #occupykorea.
Skrag
Profile Joined May 2010
United States643 Posts
June 14 2010 21:09 GMT
#69
On June 14 2010 08:21 infuzer wrote:
@morimacil
Thanks. I've never thought about the cumulative mining effect not existing with zerg!


It doesn't really exist with protoss or terran either, because the "standard" terran and protoss builds (pylon on 9, supply depot on 10) both have a slight delay in early worker production, waiting for the first supply structure to finish.

Since you run into a delay anyway (and since the delay is nowhere near a full second when getting workers to mine first as opposed to building your first worker), it really seems to me that getting 6 workers mining slightly faster is better than starting your first worker sooner, and I ran some tests that seemed to verify this, showing a very slight mineral advantage, and no global worker delay, when starting workers mining first.

Also, unless you have a perfect split, you don't have enough minerals to start building your second worker as soon as the first worker finishes, so you end up delaying worker production anyway.
"Just go *@#$ing kill him!" -- Day[9] "Thanks for being a jackass though! Enjoy your time on the forums!" - Artosis
Tenn
Profile Joined April 2010
Sweden12 Posts
June 14 2010 21:45 GMT
#70
Ok some answers to questions directed at me. I'm curious if you want me to conduct more tests (if so, what tests?) or help me out to get more data to these tests.

On June 15 2010 04:12 Batch wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 13 2010 14:21 Red Alert wrote:
On June 12 2010 23:55 Batch wrote:
I did some tests aswell in which I built 15 drones and checked the minerals at 2:30 (gametime).
The tests were done without any worker microing at all pointing all new drones to the same mineral patch. I ran about 10 tests counting only the runs which went flawless. In the extractor trick runs the extractor where built when I had 75 minerals so I immidiately could build a new drone.

ET: 504-524 minerals
No-ET: 505-535 minerals

As seen we probably need a lot of tests to actually find out the true outcome since the ranges are this wide.

I also glanced at the larvas and I would estimate the ET is worth about 5 (in game) seconds of larva spawn (1/3 larva).

With this result I get the conclusion that I probably will skip the ET since I don't think it's worth the trouble. I got pretty bad micro and while trying to do the trick I probably failed twice as often as I succeeded and lost valuable mining times with missclicks...

I would love seeing a video of somebody with great micro trying this out with gamespeed set on slowest and doing a perfect ET.


if you are getting a 30 mineral discrepancy between "perfect" runs, you aren't doing it very well. When I ran the test I usually had 5 or 0 mineral differences at the 1:40 mark.

btw, what kind of numbers would those be realtime? Not really sure how to see gametime w/out playing an actual game.

On June 13 2010 08:13 morimacil wrote:

extractor trick: not worth it when going for a "normal" build, unless you can do it absolutely perfectly 100% of the time. If done absolutely perfectly 100% of the time, provides an incredibly minor gain. Still delays overlord cost, so can still be useful for other reasons (faster scouting drone, faster pool, faster hatch)

extractor trick is done after the overlord

The extractor trick will always be more effective if being done before starting building the overlord.
I can't think of a single scenario when the extractor trick should be done after the start of the overlord, please enlighten me if there is such a case.


Well I tried to come up with some different scenarios at the start to see what would happen if you did this or that. You're quite right in that the test is more or less useless (as the test's results also confirmed)..

Also, thumbs up for mathematics! It took me a while to follow u, but I think the calculations are somewhat right (although I reckon some tests should be done to see if it actually matches "reality").

Both your calculations and additional tests seems to support that ET can be more profitable, you just need to be very very good at it. I'm going to update the post to reflect this. Thanks!

-----

On June 10 2010 20:32 Cheerio wrote:
1) I always felt like there is no need to micro the drones, AI is good enough. Now I know it, thanks.
2) The extractor trick results appear to be wrong.
3) I play a lot with 11ET>ov>pool and this way et is very much worth doing.
ET efficiency can be very easily calculated. All u need is timings of drones and the fact that drones mine at speed roughly 0,75minerals/second. The bad thing about 10 ov no ET is that it must delay the larva production which leads to all your future drones to spawn at later time which is economically inferior to any loss of minerals because of ET.



1) You're welcome
2) Why? Please prove me wrong.
3) The time that the larvas are capped is like less than a few second isn't it? You're right that the larva production will be delayed for future production, it would be interesting to see with how much.



----

On June 11 2010 01:31 Fizbin wrote:
a few things i would like to note. when doing extractor tricks make sure u have enough minerals to instantly make a drone so u can almost instantly cancel making it. the longer the extractor sits not mining the less accurate ur tests will be. another thing to note is drone count. i think 2 minutes isnt enough time to get an accurate graph. good work though. i was persaonly messing around with build tester lastnight and i found 9-10 OL to be the most economic. THE best reason for doing double extractor trick is to build a spawning pool before and OL. thats the only reason to use it imo.


I made sure to have enough minerals, only using drones close to the gas (without any minerals in their hands) and the extractor was only up for maybe 1 second for all tests where I used ET.

And why shouldn't 2 minutes be enough? All the variations are made before that, so if you just keep producing drones you will get a linear growth, the same no matter which build you start off with.

On June 11 2010 05:17 sti wrote:
Seems like you need to do a lot of tests to account for human error. The differences are so tiny.


Exactly! The differences are so tiny, and yet so much effort is put into doing ETs.

But you've got a point, more tests should be conducted (which I clearly stated) to draw definite conclusions on what type of starting build is actually "best".


On June 12 2010 00:44 onmach wrote:
I'm confused about your conclusion on test 4. You say it puts you 10 minerals behind, but your results show that the 10 overlord tests were mining for roughly 4 seconds longer and ended up with minerals that were only 10-15 ahead of 10 overlord extractor. That means that if you can mine more than 10-15 minerals in 4 seconds, you come out way ahead with the extractor trick.


Well it means that a single drone should mine those 10-15 minerals in 4 seconds doesn't it? And it doesn't. Thinking about it, I've made a weird comparison in test 4 since the 10 OL build is clearly worse than 9 OL build. If you compare the extractor trick in test 4 with 9 OL build you see that it is even more clear that it is not viable.

Red Alert
Profile Joined June 2009
United States119 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-06-20 05:50:34
June 20 2010 05:50 GMT
#71
On June 15 2010 04:12 Batch wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 13 2010 14:21 Red Alert wrote:
On June 12 2010 23:55 Batch wrote:
I did some tests aswell in which I built 15 drones and checked the minerals at 2:30 (gametime).
The tests were done without any worker microing at all pointing all new drones to the same mineral patch. I ran about 10 tests counting only the runs which went flawless. In the extractor trick runs the extractor where built when I had 75 minerals so I immidiately could build a new drone.

ET: 504-524 minerals
No-ET: 505-535 minerals

As seen we probably need a lot of tests to actually find out the true outcome since the ranges are this wide.

I also glanced at the larvas and I would estimate the ET is worth about 5 (in game) seconds of larva spawn (1/3 larva).

With this result I get the conclusion that I probably will skip the ET since I don't think it's worth the trouble. I got pretty bad micro and while trying to do the trick I probably failed twice as often as I succeeded and lost valuable mining times with missclicks...

I would love seeing a video of somebody with great micro trying this out with gamespeed set on slowest and doing a perfect ET.


if you are getting a 30 mineral discrepancy between "perfect" runs, you aren't doing it very well. When I ran the test I usually had 5 or 0 mineral differences at the 1:40 mark.

btw, what kind of numbers would those be realtime? Not really sure how to see gametime w/out playing an actual game.

On June 13 2010 08:13 morimacil wrote:

extractor trick: not worth it when going for a "normal" build, unless you can do it absolutely perfectly 100% of the time. If done absolutely perfectly 100% of the time, provides an incredibly minor gain. Still delays overlord cost, so can still be useful for other reasons (faster scouting drone, faster pool, faster hatch)

extractor trick is done after the overlord

The extractor trick will always be more effective if being done before starting building the overlord.
I can't think of a single scenario when the extractor trick should be done after the start of the overlord, please enlighten me if there is such a case.

Cool how you totally dodged my question and instead responded to a minor point. But it's better in every case to build the extractor after the overlord, if you actually know what you're doing.
Skrag
Profile Joined May 2010
United States643 Posts
June 21 2010 17:44 GMT
#72
On June 15 2010 00:52 General-Gouda wrote:
The one thing I am not seeing mentioned here is using F1 to send idle workers directly to a mineral deposit instead of allowing the AI to spread them out for you.

I haven't seen any detailed write-ups concerning any benefits for doing that over simply sending them all to one deposit (or splitting them up into groups of 2 or 3). Does anyone have any links to an analysis like this? If not I'll have to see if I can create one and post it.


WhiteRa has a very unique method of splitting that I don't see anybody else do. He'll select 2 workers at a time and send them to separate patches. He does this *very* quickly, and has obviously practiced it a lot.

But if you watch a replay of him against somebody doing a more typical split, where they select all 6 workers, send them to a single patch, then peel off 3 and send them to a separate patch, WhiteRa's "perfect" 2/2/2 split is always 5-10 minerals behind the 3/3 split, simply because there's an ever-so-slight delay where he has 4 and then 2 workers not moving towards the mineral patches, where the 3/3 peel has all workers moving towards minerals from the very beginning.

Obviously WhiteRa believes he's found a method that works for him, but in the 3 or 4 replays I've paid attention to the split efficiency of his split against a 3/3 peel, he is slightly behind.

However, the specific patches that end up being worked makes a much larger difference than any splitting advantages. Making sure the closer mineral patches are being worked first is far more important than a "perfect split", because a worker on a close mineral patch mines about 10% faster than a worker on a far patch.
"Just go *@#$ing kill him!" -- Day[9] "Thanks for being a jackass though! Enjoy your time on the forums!" - Artosis
darmousseh
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
United States3437 Posts
June 21 2010 18:53 GMT
#73
I think blizzard made this intentional. Even the name is called the "Extractor trick". The extractor trick was used to make up for the deficiency in worker AI and same with splitting. Now that workers have excellent AI, there is no reason to micro manage them most of the time. Instead of spending time microing that, use it to micro your scout.
Developer for http://mtgfiddle.com
kiritaku
Profile Joined June 2010
10 Posts
June 21 2010 19:30 GMT
#74
just did some tests of 9 OL vs 10 OL ET, similar to post... although i think its a real bad idea to pause as your 15th drone comes out, instead we should probably drone up to 15 then check minerals at 3mins or something.

10 OL ET:
264 2:05
254 2:05
274 2:05
259 2:05

9 OL:
255 2:05
275 2:05
265 2:05
260 2:05

also whoever posted about the cumulative mining effect... there IS an effect, because you start with 3 larvae so until you build your first drone you are wasting larvae, which could make building the drone first better... dunno i always did ctrl-f1, click on minerals, build drone, then split off 3. which all happens within about a second anyways.

also previously i have tested the time it takes to get to 500 minerals with 9 ol, 10 ol et, 10 ol... and it seemed like they were all within a split second of eachother, so long-term, as long as you spam out your drones, i think your opening has almost no effect. however, i'm still working to split faster etc...

ah, one more thing, i think we should be looking for the single best result in the opening, rather then for the average result. seems like you want to find the perfect opening and then train yourself to do it everytime... even if its more prone to mouseslips etc. at least thats how i like to play.

mid-level diamond player if anybody cares btw.

Plakk
Profile Joined April 2010
Canada32 Posts
June 22 2010 05:17 GMT
#75
On TEST 1:

Im surprised that you would lose as much as 20 minerals(though it looks more like 10 minerals from the spread) just from sending your workers first instead of building one first. Isnt this mostly based on your how fast you can execute both events?

I would actually expect that sending your workers to mine first is more significant since there are 6 of them compared to the one that is building. I should do a test on this myself and see how it goes.

My ZvZ mentality: My muta micro is better than your muta micro
NETRAT
Profile Joined July 2010
Belarus180 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-07-02 10:08:42
July 02 2010 10:00 GMT
#76
that extractor trick always was confusing to me so i was theorycrafting about it, lets pretend we have a player with lightning reflexes or its just a computer which does everything w/o any delay

+ Show Spoiler +
Game Drones/Cap Gas Order
Time (not food)
Minerals
0:00 6/10 50 0 +Drone
0:11 6/10 50 0 +Drone
0:17 7/10 26.5 0
0:22 7/10 53 0 +Drone
0:28 8/10 34.5 0
0:31 8/10 52.5 0 +Drone
0:39 9/10 50.5 0 +Drone
0:47 9/10 54.5 0 +Drone
0:48 10/10 11 0

_______________________________________ 9-overlord
0:54 9/10 102 0 +Overlord
1:02 9/10 56 0 +Drone
1:19 10/18 121 0 +2xDrone
1:23 10/18 51 0 +Drone
1:30 10/18 53.5 0 +Drone
1:36 12/18 48.5 0
1:37 12/18 57.5 0 +Drone
1:40 13/18 34.5 0 (2 Drones in queue)
1:47 14/18 103 0
1:54 15/18 176.5 0
_______________________________________ 10-overlord
1:00 10/10 101 0 +Overlord
1:25 10/18 188.5 0 +3 drone?
1:33 10/18 248.5 0
1:41 10/18 308.5 0 1:42 13/18 166 0

_______________________________________ extractor trick
0:57 10/10 78.5 0 +Extractor +Drone (you get 18/25 m refund)
1:08 10/10 104 0 +Overlord
1:14 11/10 49 0
1:33 11/18 206 0 +3 drone?
1:41 11/18 272 0
1:50 14/18 196 0

_______________________________________ double extractor trick
1:07 10/10 153.5 0 +2xExtractor +2xDrone (you get 36/50 m refund)
1:16 10/10 107 0 +Overlord
1:24 12/10 67 0
1:41 12/18 220 0 +3 drone?
1:58 15/18 223 0

lines highlighted with red show that even if you can squeeze some extra minerals using extractor trick (272 minerals 11 workers vs 144 minerals 13 workers in 9-OL, so you get 28 extra minerals) you are behind in drone count and this 28 minerals are mined in 3 seconds of game time at this point of the game
it can be viable in case you want to get some super-fast 11-expansion or 11-12 pool, but real players cant perform so well to have perfect timing so i dont think its worth it - its like you can morph some building 5 seconds earlier than you normally would, but your economy would be much worse
and it seems to me you are wasting larvae while pooling resources for ET and afterwards, delaying your overlord, because after it pops-up you shall have more than 150 minerals and use all your larvae for drones so you will be broke on larvae
bulge
Profile Joined July 2010
161 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-07-02 11:09:08
July 02 2010 11:06 GMT
#77
ok i just did a quickie 9 OL vs 10 OL ET

9 OL:
2:05
15 drones
270 mineral

10 OL ET:
2:05
15 drones
279 mineral

it doesn't make sense to me that 9 OL is better. other than the fact that i just discovered canceling a structure costs 6 minerals.

also its on another thread, but spawning with minerals underneath the hatch makes a nice difference. probably why there is variance of 30-40 minerals in some people's tests
PovGosse
Profile Joined May 2010
Belgium6 Posts
July 02 2010 13:29 GMT
#78

it doesn't make sense to me that 9 OL is better. other than the fact that i just discovered canceling a structure costs 6 minerals.

In fact, cancelling a structure costs you 25% of the building cost (which is 6 gold for an extractor).
P00RKID
Profile Joined December 2009
United States424 Posts
July 02 2010 17:17 GMT
#79
On June 15 2010 04:12 Batch wrote:
Show nested quote +
On June 13 2010 14:21 Red Alert wrote:
On June 12 2010 23:55 Batch wrote:
I did some tests aswell in which I built 15 drones and checked the minerals at 2:30 (gametime).
The tests were done without any worker microing at all pointing all new drones to the same mineral patch. I ran about 10 tests counting only the runs which went flawless. In the extractor trick runs the extractor where built when I had 75 minerals so I immidiately could build a new drone.

ET: 504-524 minerals
No-ET: 505-535 minerals

As seen we probably need a lot of tests to actually find out the true outcome since the ranges are this wide.

I also glanced at the larvas and I would estimate the ET is worth about 5 (in game) seconds of larva spawn (1/3 larva).

With this result I get the conclusion that I probably will skip the ET since I don't think it's worth the trouble. I got pretty bad micro and while trying to do the trick I probably failed twice as often as I succeeded and lost valuable mining times with missclicks...

I would love seeing a video of somebody with great micro trying this out with gamespeed set on slowest and doing a perfect ET.


if you are getting a 30 mineral discrepancy between "perfect" runs, you aren't doing it very well. When I ran the test I usually had 5 or 0 mineral differences at the 1:40 mark.

btw, what kind of numbers would those be realtime? Not really sure how to see gametime w/out playing an actual game.

On June 13 2010 08:13 morimacil wrote:

extractor trick: not worth it when going for a "normal" build, unless you can do it absolutely perfectly 100% of the time. If done absolutely perfectly 100% of the time, provides an incredibly minor gain. Still delays overlord cost, so can still be useful for other reasons (faster scouting drone, faster pool, faster hatch)

extractor trick is done after the overlord

The extractor trick will always be more effective if being done before starting building the overlord.
I can't think of a single scenario when the extractor trick should be done after the start of the overlord, please enlighten me if there is such a case.


The reason you build the overlord first is so you get your 12th and 13th drone out sooner. Sure, you get your 11th drone sooner with 10 ET 11 OL, but you delay the 12th and 13th, netting a loss. You also lose larva spawn time, so you also delay the 14th drone.

If your going to ET, do 10 OL then ET. As soon as OL pops you will have 2 larva (12th 13th) and a few seconds or so later pops a 14th larva.

Also, I chose 9 OL as the best opener. You get out your 10th drone a little later, but get your 11th 12th 13th drone out a lot sooner (maybe not a lot sooner for 11th) And you waste 0 larva spawn time. Since you don't waste any larva spawn time with this, you can get use of it by getting the 14th drone in the best time, thus the reason why 9OL is most economic when going 13 OR 14 pool.

With some openings, players will lose larva time as they save up 200 minerals for a pool, then another 50 for a drone. This is because they have between 1 and 2 larva and build up to 3 during the mineral saving time and the re-spawn timer stops on generating more larva. The sooner you get your pool, the more larva you waste, until your income is high enough, which is like 12 drones mining. Wasting larva means delaying future drones (or units) but drones are what you really want to be making in any macro oriented strategy with zerg.

The other advantage of 9 OL is a headstart in scouting with the second overlord, good for spotting cheese or whatever. Not a huge advantage, but when people compare it with 10ol ET they are nearly equal, so there is a slight edge in favor of 9 because you get slightly earlier OL positioning and scouting.

Is there anything I missed here? This is all from pure memory.
"Does your butt hurt? 'cause you fell from heaven once the cast was over?" Artosis
Prev 1 2 3 4 All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 2h 45m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
NeuroSwarm 167
ProTech25
StarCraft: Brood War
Britney 13183
PianO 353
LuMiX 63
Bale 42
sOs 24
Noble 17
Force[name] 6
Dota 2
monkeys_forever413
League of Legends
JimRising 683
Super Smash Bros
Mew2King101
Other Games
summit1g10934
WinterStarcraft534
Happy43
[ Show 11 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• practicex 47
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• lizZardDota2231
League of Legends
• Rush1417
Upcoming Events
SOOP
2h 45m
soO vs FanTaSy
WardiTV Weekly
4h 45m
Replay Cast
15h 45m
Monday Night Weeklies
1d 9h
PiGosaur Cup
1d 17h
The PondCast
2 days
GSL
3 days
Patches Events
3 days
Replay Cast
3 days
KCM Race Survival
4 days
[ Show More ]
RSL Revival
5 days
BSL
5 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
6 days
BSL
6 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Individual League
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
YSL S4
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
SC4ALL II: Brood War
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 6
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.