| Forum Index > StarCraft 2 Strategy |
|
MaximumSquid
United States62 Posts
Front page has been updated with a more thorough and complete guide. . . *FAQ section Added *Tips N Tricks section Added *Entire Sections re-written to reflect forum feedback *Videos are now only links instead of hotlinks to help offset the larger size of the post Also thanks for everyone who's supported or tested the build so far! --- RoL: I've added your question to the FAQ and will review your replay a little later this morning when I get time. | ||
|
Markwerf
Netherlands3728 Posts
I can see use for 1 or 2 extra queens as extra non-larvae costing defense against toss (especially against air) but that's it really. If you just make a 3rd or 4th queen they will have uses later at extra expansions, making too much though is a bit of a waste because of guardian shield and their slow speed. Healing is decent, so a few extra can help with that but thats about it really. ZvZ the whole queen massing might be a lot more interesting since the roach nerf though, they basically gotten a 50% damage boost against them (4-2 vs 4-1) so that definately matters. I guess if you have the micro to heal with them a few could find their way in your army, but again mostly when playing defensive. | ||
|
exit
United States6 Posts
Funny enough I have the best success with this strat against Protoss. Sure the Queens aren't doing a ton to guardian shielded, but the queens are your support. The 8-12 roaches are the real workers here. If they wall their choke with bubbles I just wait them out and start teching/sending more roaches. Eventually I'll get through and they *never* have enough defense. Any money they spent on Zealots is practically wasted, only a high amount of stalkers/sentries and good micro sniping high energy queens is effective. Then again I'm certain your theorycrafting is correct. You've obviously played this or against this before and can relate from experience. | ||
|
Mirhi
United States389 Posts
| ||
|
MaximumSquid
United States62 Posts
Macro looked fine in the Replay. . . just a couple of small mistakes. . . You had 4 Queens at 6m40s which is excellent, but you didn't push out right away. The walk on that map is 1m10s so this is what the fight would have looked like at 7m50s: http://img106.imageshack.us/img106/8906/screenshot011e.jpg You would of been at his door with a force almost double his size. . . basically no chance he would have held you off. Pushing with 5 Queens is fine, but is harder to manage a battle at a choke. After seeing that your opponent did not expand at 9m I would have tried breaking threw the destructible rocks on that map instead of the front door. The last thing, and this is very important, is to make sure no unit dies until your Queens have run out of energy. I noticed that you had literally 8 unused heals in that fight and almost a 9th before all your forces fell. --- Markwerf: Guardian shield only reduced incoming ranged attacks by 2. . . I know the queens melee attack has a range of 3, but I was unaware it was actually considered a missile attack. Can anyone confirm this? I usually have the +1 Missile Upgrade by then anyway to cancel it out for my Roaches, but it would be interesting to know. --- Mirhi: Might just be a timing issue. . . Toss are the easiest to catch off guard with the 4 Queen push since they are usually just getting done teching to robotics bay when you start moving out. I've never seen more than 2 immortals by the time I'm at their ramp I posted some earlier snapshots of what an 8m Toss looks like in my second reply on page 1. . . The screenshot of RoL's game is almost exactly what I would expect to see | ||
|
errep
United States2 Posts
http://www.sc2rc.com/index.php/replay/show/1465 | ||
|
Markwerf
Netherlands3728 Posts
I can't say how this fares against the mass sentries yet, might be decent as heal could counteract force field I guess, but toss can delay a huge bit. As for guardian shield reducing queen attack im 99% sure they do. Queens also benefit from ranged attack upgrades and it sais it's a missile attack as well. Given that alot of protoss units have 1 base armor , guardian shield can make it go from 4-1 to 4-3, which is virtually nullifying their damage. I understand their role is partially as a healer but I'm sure more roaches is much more dangerous then queens + roaches. Against T or Z queens are sweet though, just dont use em aggresively against P | ||
|
errep
United States2 Posts
| ||
|
MaximumSquid
United States62 Posts
http://sc2calc.net/ got updated to the most current patch recently and they list a Queen taking 30 attacks to kill a Guardian Shielded Sentry which I also confirmed in game. ( +1 Upgrade helps a lot in this case since you basically double your DPS while the shield is up ) Now I'm used to getting early harassed by Zealots with the Robotics Facility coming later, but if a Protoss player stays in their base they can have it out as early as 5m ( All-be-it a Risky Move ) If that is the case and you scout it when no rush happens you probably would want to run the 5m30s push with the 3 Queens going in first to absorb hits. I do agree with you though that once your opponent gets 3 Immortals it becomes very hard to heal and 4 is almost impossible if they are targeting Roaches | ||
|
Stropheum
United States1124 Posts
Especially the ZvZ video. The zerg was on one base, had a spire, hydra den, and a roach warren, yet was only making roaches. Maybe this is because he's too dumb to realize you need 4gas to support hydra/roach? And wtf is with the spire???? Is this copper league or what? Also i noticed that in the second video there was no macro going on at all, so your opponent must have been complete garbage | ||
|
Stropheum
United States1124 Posts
This is a garbage all-in strat. Queens first off, are not very good at attacking or defending, they just can do it. They're good at fending off maybe a single air unit or helping defend a ling rush, but attacking? please. You're making 5 queens??????? 150 minerals and just about the longest build time of any zerg unit and you think this is a viable strategy? that's a 750 mineral investment to an attack, not to mention while you're attacking, guess what? YOU HAVE NO QUEENS IN YOUR BASE. Therefore you're completely giving up your macro ability while you're dedicating yourself to this attack. Think about this: instead of making 5 queens for 750 minerals, make 10 roaches. Then, like an intelligent person, use the correct(read 1 per base) amount of queens to spawn larvae so you can make MORE roaches or actually macro and get up to 2base 4gas so you can add on hydralisks. I really cannot stress how absolutely awful this idea sounds, and how awful those replays are. By the way, the protoss in your replay could've easily had 3 sentries at that time if he wasn't a terrible player and he could've walled you out until he had immortals | ||
|
bountyface
United States95 Posts
On April 12 2010 03:35 squ1d wrote: The first ZvP was retarded. The guy had massed Stalkers vs a Zerg with Roaches - he obviously doesn't know how to play. This strategy would fall to any half-decent player in my opinion. here's idra getting owned by mass stalkers when he has roaches. oh wait, you're better than idra i guess.: | ||
|
Dr_Strange
United States80 Posts
LOL if that was true then no one would fast expand. the point of an expansion is to barely hold out with positioning and travel time on your side in order to gain the benefits of the expansions. its not "mathematically impossible" by ANY stretch of the imagination. Think before you type. One-Base play is made to break peoples expos. If you one-base and can not dent the opponent, you are far behind. | ||
|
MaximumSquid
United States62 Posts
You seem very troubled and confused. . . To my knowledge this thread has not been reposted on the team liquid forums Updates were made to the front page recently though. . . If that is the issue I can offer you this screencap which illustrates what it looked like a day ago: http://img408.imageshack.us/img408/1302/oldanthillpost.jpg As for the build a Queen is always in the production queue when attacking so depending on when you last sprayed for larvae you may not lose any macro. Also to my knowledge this strategy already utilizes all available larvae so 5 Queens will not translate simply into another 10 Roaches. To do this you would need a second hatchery and the gas from another extractor which would set you back 575 mineral + 5 larvae (A maneuver that would be both costly and risky in the early game) With regards to your disrespect to the people I tested against I suppose I could pass on your criticism All I would need is your Beta Account Name so they could follow you up with any additional questions they might have. . . --- bountyface: Good video showing a very under-used strat. . . One of the things that I've discussed about this build with people elsewhere is that because of the Stalkers superior speed and range to Roaches off of Creep it is possible to get ambushed in transition to the enemy base leaving a window of about 40 - 50 seconds where the Toss player has free rein to harass until Zerglings arrive to force the battle. | ||
|
mOnion
United States5657 Posts
On April 16 2010 01:03 Dr_Strange wrote: Think before you type. One-Base play is made to break peoples expos. If you one-base and can not dent the opponent, you are far behind. ya. thats the point. how bout you think before YOU type kk? i get your new so try being a little nicer around here, and you'll get farther. I understand one base play is made to break fast expo. but OP said it would always win. which it wouldnt. dont be a jerk when my point is true. | ||
|
RaiZ
2813 Posts
On April 15 2010 23:16 bountyface wrote: here's idra getting owned by mass stalkers when he has roaches. oh wait, you're better than idra i guess.: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pETcAm82vXU&feature=popular Stopped to watch after idra fast expanded. Seriously nex time try to follow the build closely before arguing. We're talking about a queen/roach non fast expand build ffs. On April 15 2010 22:58 Stropheum wrote: I don't mean to double post but I think I deserve it since this awful thread got REMADE. This is a garbage all-in strat. Queens first off, are not very good at attacking or defending, they just can do it. They're good at fending off maybe a single air unit or helping defend a ling rush, but attacking? please. You're making 5 queens??????? 150 minerals and just about the longest build time of any zerg unit and you think this is a viable strategy? that's a 750 mineral investment to an attack, not to mention while you're attacking, guess what? YOU HAVE NO QUEENS IN YOUR BASE. Therefore you're completely giving up your macro ability while you're dedicating yourself to this attack. Think about this: instead of making 5 queens for 750 minerals, make 10 roaches. Then, like an intelligent person, use the correct(read 1 per base) amount of queens to spawn larvae so you can make MORE roaches or actually macro and get up to 2base 4gas so you can add on hydralisks. I really cannot stress how absolutely awful this idea sounds, and how awful those replays are. By the way, the protoss in your replay could've easily had 3 sentries at that time if he wasn't a terrible player and he could've walled you out until he had immortals First of all the queens aren't here to attack or defend. They're here to HEAL ! big fucking deal. They can also tank, which is really good if they're focused by a few roaches (not too much though, just enough to heal the queen without letting it die to quickly) Having no queens in our base is perfectly understandable as long as we have the spawn larvae already on the hatch and we're waiting the next queen to do an another one. God that's why i hate posting reps, there'a always someone that know everything and need to criticize our build just because it's far from perfect... We're not here to talk about the leaks but to see how viable it is. It looks strong on ZvZ period. I keep winning with this strat. If you aren't convinced, then just try it before saying anything because i'm 99% sure you haven't played this build order at least 10 times. Yeah you read it right, 10 fucking time in order to fully grasp it. FFS. Gonna grab a drink and chill out. | ||
|
MaximumSquid
United States62 Posts
I didn't say always. . . my reply still implied doubt, but regardless I'm glad you brought it up again. . . Enough testing has been done that hard counters have been found for each race that can be used against this build and are effective enough to allow you to hold off the push and eventually get an expansion out. This is good news since I'll be able to experiment with some of the strategy's natural transitions when before they felt too artificial. --- I'll be posting the Counters and Transitions in the next major update that I make to page one, and hopefully also with some replays or videos that are less blurry. | ||
|
mOnion
United States5657 Posts
On April 16 2010 04:40 MaximumSquid wrote: mOnion: I didn't say always. . . my reply still implied doubt, but regardless I'm glad you brought it up again. . . Enough testing has been done that hard counters have been found for each race that can be used against this build and are effective enough to allow you to hold off the push and eventually get an expansion out. This is good news since I'll be able to experiment with some of the strategy's natural transitions when before they felt too artificial. --- I'll be posting the Counters and Transitions in the next major update that I make to page one, and hopefully also with some replays or videos that are less blurry. as you can tell from my last post using the [quote][quote] function which you havent figured out how to use yet, i wasnt talking to you. i was talking to the person who insulted me for being right ^_^ and you're right that you didnt say always, but you did say mathematically impossible. which is close right? | ||
|
WeSt
Portugal918 Posts
| ||
|
exit
United States6 Posts
A protoss player handled me by massing stalkers and focus firing queens/roaches while blinking his weakened stalkers to the back of his bunch. Was pretty nice. I actually played against a player who went for the queen/roach rush, countered with a 16 zergling attack when he hit midfield and was able to get 2 spine crawlers up. He may have had me if he had pushed but i was able to keep pressure up and get to mutas shortly after. It's still a viable strat against some openings, just like everything, requires you to scout well. | ||
| ||
Maestros of the Game
Group C
Serral vs Percival
SHIN vs ShoWTimE
RotterdaM1595
ComeBackTV
 1313IntoTheiNu
 1158TaKeTV
 647IndyStarCraft
 257SteadfastSC232
BRAT_OK
 123Rex111
[ Submit Event ] |
|
StarCraft 2 RotterdaM StarCraft: Brood War 1595IndyStarCraft 257SteadfastSC  232mouzHeroMarine  163BRAT_OK 123Rex 111UpATreeSC 110ProTech82 elazer 35Dota 2 Counter-Strike Heroes of the Storm Other Games Grubby3923 singsing2021 FrodaN756 B2W.Neo719 C9.Mang0210 mouzStarbuck162 XaKoH 129ArmadaUGS121 Trikslyr51 Mew2King35 MindelVK7 fpsfer  1 |
|
Replay Cast
Replay Cast
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
Maestros of the Game
Clem vs Lambo
Zoun vs SKillous
Replay Cast
Replay Cast
Solar vs Classic
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
Grudge Match
FlaShFTW vs A.Alm
OSC
GSL
herO vs Rogue
Maru vs Cure
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
