|
On August 22 2017 19:57 disformation wrote:
scum record is 1-4 now.
town winrate also decreasing.
think the transition to working full time difnt affect my game in a positive manner.
maybe i should request a coach next game.
*shrugs*
Fwiw I didn't read your posts whatsoever. You were there bc your slot was scummy + PoE.
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
On August 22 2017 20:06 Superbia wrote:Show nested quote +On August 22 2017 19:51 geript wrote:On August 22 2017 19:43 Holyflare wrote:
The elongated day 1 was annoying. Remove that and have a normal day 1 and mafia don't need to start with a rb cos they can shoot whoever they want. I thought about that, but it's tricky. In a normal, you usually get 2.5 power role uses or more. I'm not sure that balances it enough and it makes it far more swingy (cop check vs vest) TBH, I think it's more interesting if you let mafia store KP. So you could no shoot for 2 nights then have 3 KP on N3. The bonus for mafia winning the power up needs to be more. Agreed. Getting a roleblock seems really meh. And it's even difficult to execute because you're essentially giving the town extra info when using the roleblock.
Exactly. Mafia can't ever use a rb because then it's "oh a winner has to have been mafia"
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
All right, day 1 is a normal day with no power ups. We get to lynch who we want and then at night mafia gets to kill who they want. That gives town some vca and mafia a chance to shut down one top town guy. From there you play it like the rest of this game.
No vig though.
If mafia win they should be allowed to see the judge's choices and change one name.
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
Maybe vig will be ok with no rb thing I dunno. Don't think it's necessary.
|
On August 22 2017 20:28 Holyflare wrote:
All right, day 1 is a normal day with no power ups. We get to lynch who we want and then at night mafia gets to kill who they want. That gives town some vca and mafia a chance to shut down one top town guy. From there you play it like the rest of this game.
No vig though.
If mafia win they should be allowed to see the judge's choices and change one name.
Then they're confirmed mafia in the eyes of the judges...
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
On August 22 2017 20:29 Superbia wrote:Show nested quote +On August 22 2017 20:28 Holyflare wrote:
All right, day 1 is a normal day with no power ups. We get to lynch who we want and then at night mafia gets to kill who they want. That gives town some vca and mafia a chance to shut down one top town guy. From there you play it like the rest of this game.
No vig though.
If mafia win they should be allowed to see the judge's choices and change one name. Then they're confirmed mafia in the eyes of the judges...
Hmmmmmmmmmmmm
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
All right. Day 1 is played like a normal day. Then day 2 onwards we vote for a guy to lynch and the majority one dies. Nights mafia gets to kill who they want and day town gets to kill who they want.
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
Get rid of the judges and the winner gets a power and the ability to pick three people. Mafia get one rb.
|
On August 22 2017 19:38 Artanis[Xp] wrote:Okay guys, we agree that the game was town favoured and the swingy sections generally swung towards town this game as the judges had good reads. We're looking towards some ideas to improve upon the setup, but we don't want to start that if most people wouldn't play again. Could you answer the poll? Thanks! Poll: Would you play another game with judges?I played and I wouldn't (5) 45% I played and I would, but it needs significant setup changes (4) 36% I played and I would even without significant changes (1) 9% I haven't played and I would, but it needs significant setup changes (1) 9% I haven't played and I would even without significant changes (0) 0% I haven't played and I wouldn't (0) 0% 11 total votes Your vote: Would you play another game with judges? (Vote): I played and I would even without significant changes
(Vote): I played and I would, but it needs significant setup changes
(Vote): I played and I wouldn't
(Vote): I haven't played and I would even without significant changes
(Vote): I haven't played and I would, but it needs significant setup changes
(Vote): I haven't played and I wouldn't
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
Even if the judges get all three mafia on the first lynch if it's not who town thinks is mafia it's wildly dissatisfying to play in since mentally you're at an impasse until they pick who you want.
|
wait what happened
did we win
|
ok. guess I got carried by HF and judges
gg all!
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
Also copcake I'm sorry for any insults/being annoyed. I had some stuff going on and with the language barrier and just being generally annoyed it got to me a lot.
|
On August 22 2017 20:45 Holyflare wrote:
Even if the judges get all three mafia on the first lynch if it's not who town thinks is mafia it's wildly dissatisfying to play in since mentally you're at an impasse until they pick who you want.
Yeah, I can imagine this being really frustrating. =/
|
On August 22 2017 20:28 Holyflare wrote:
All right, day 1 is a normal day with no power ups. We get to lynch who we want and then at night mafia gets to kill who they want. That gives town some vca and mafia a chance to shut down one top town guy. From there you play it like the rest of this game.
No vig though.
If mafia win they should be allowed to see the judge's choices and change one name.
Give mafia that change-name ability to use on D1 or D2 OR they can have a vest-penetrating shot. I think'd work well for gauging whether they can get a strong townie lynched or if they just shoot them in the face.
|
duly noted btw Koshi, on your big post calling me trash
|
I detested the judges for not giving me what I wanted and now I feel so bad about it
|
People can say I was a bad kill weird kill.
But literally I called the whole scum team with decent reasoning (but btw eversince gave you guys away) in in a qt! I would of been town hero with another day alive.
|
On August 22 2017 21:31 Damdred wrote:
People can say I was a bad kill weird kill.
But literally I called the whole scum team with decent reasoning (but btw eversince gave you guys away) in in a qt! I would of been town hero with another day alive.
I thought you were a weird kill bc geript was my most townread person D1, so I thought he would die for sure
stop dying early when I play with you :D
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
