You should make more posts like that, JAT.

That was not a bad post.

I actually agree with you that a) that first post went nowhere and was way too general, b) his play has not improved since Day 1 and that c) your point about Superbia's read progression with regards to Palmar/ bats is incriminating as hell.

Calix

3379 Posts

October 08 2016 17:04 GMT

#2242

In fact I'm going to check to see why I started town-reading Superbia to begin with.

Calix

3379 Posts

October 08 2016 17:13 GMT

#2243

Man, I don't even remember. Think I just saw Grack's posts about his Superbia town-read and agreed.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 17:21 GMT

#2244

I just town-read him because he was funny and wanted him around. Now I don't mind him eating rope.

+ Show Spoiler [*giggles*] +

On September 29 2016 19:10 Superbia wrote:
I will roll PR or mafia this game.

I can feel it in my bones.

And he probably did not roll PR.

justanothertownie

16324 Posts

October 08 2016 17:24 GMT

#2245

Some metashit - if you aren't interested in this kind of thing even though you should be then ignore it:

Most of the evidence is from H O L Y F * * * E Mafia, which is the last game I played with superbia. He was mafia, I was town.

When he is questioned as mafia he tends to counter it by questioning the accuser while claiming that the latter isn't able to understand his ulterior towny intention. It is almost comically that even his choice of words is more or less the same:

Mafia!Superbia:

On May 25 2016 02:23 Superbia wrote:

Show nested quote +

I find it hard to believe that you are this short-sighted as town.

Why am I asking that question?

Superbia this game:

On October 05 2016 02:35 Superbia wrote:

Show nested quote +

And I still want to know your opinion on Calix.

On October 05 2016 02:44 Superbia wrote:

Show nested quote +

Shortsighted.

Eerily similar, eh?

He also tends to act way overconfident about his ability to lynch his opponents:

Mafia!Superbia:

On May 26 2016 19:20 Superbia wrote:
You're getting lynched before me Jat :D

Superbia in this game:

On October 07 2016 00:18 Superbia wrote:
Though if you keep following the Ritoky "everything you do is mafia because you're mafia" route I'm going to lynch you.

Compare his filters and you find the same hostile attitude in general. I went for him all game like I am doing in this game too. For largely the same reasons. Noone listened to me there either until I got shot.

justanothertownie

16324 Posts

October 08 2016 17:25 GMT

#2246

afk, dinner

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 17:28 GMT

#2247

I'm down for a Superbia shenannie.

[image loading]

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 17:29 GMT

#2248

Also liking the new Jat.

Calix, do you still think Jat is the scummiest player?

Calix

3379 Posts

October 08 2016 17:30 GMT

#2249

NU, if you don't think Palmar/ Superbia are mafia and you think Palmar is town, who do you think Superbia's team-mates are?

Calix

3379 Posts

October 08 2016 17:30 GMT

#2250

No I don't. That was a pretty decent case, my dude.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

October 08 2016 17:36 GMT

#2251

Not the worst case. Palmar has a bigger chance to flip mafia though. 101% chance to be precise.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 17:37 GMT

#2252

Yeah yeah yeah, a pretty good case.

I don't feel strongly about Palmar. I would not say that he is town, but other Koshi's survivalist argument, I can't find reasons to think he is mafia. His two first filter pages gave me town vibes.

Palmar / Super makes sense given their interactions. Damdred would be the other one. Damdred pretty much fits in every scum team as he plays the game so distantly. Maybe Grack.

Calix

3379 Posts

October 08 2016 17:38 GMT

#2253

If you look at Palmar/ Superbia and how they read each other, it's entirely possible that both are mafia.

I can find quotes if people are too lazy, although JAT has already done half the work with the Palmar/ batsnacks thing.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 17:42 GMT

#2254

Heads = Palmar

Tails = Super

*Flips*

Palmar it is.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 17:45 GMT

#2255

[EBWOP]

Heads = Palmar

Tails = Super

*Flips*

[image loading]

Palmar it is.

Calix

3379 Posts

October 08 2016 17:47 GMT

#2256

Quality post, my dude.

So are we all agreed that - assuming Palmar/ Superbia are mafia - that the last scum is basically among Damdred, Grack, Scott?

I feel overly optimistic about the odds of winning right now, lol.

justanothertownie

16324 Posts

October 08 2016 17:50 GMT

#2257

On October 09 2016 02:37 NeverUnlucky wrote:
Yeah yeah yeah, a pretty good case.

I don't feel strongly about Palmar. I would not say that he is town, but other Koshi's survivalist argument, I can't find reasons to think he is mafia. His two first filter pages gave me town vibes.

Palmar / Super makes sense given their interactions. Damdred would be the other one. Damdred pretty much fits in every scum team as he plays the game so distantly. Maybe Grack.

Yes, damdred/scott fit in most teams. But damdreds absence is probably RL related. He is usually telling the truth about these things and he doesn't tend to lurk as mafia either.

Grack could also still be mafia even though I personally thought his posting after he started mafiareading me was not terrible. The fact remains that his vote is on me for no good reason and he is gone. I might be biased but my inclination to call that towny behaviour is very low.

Calix

3379 Posts

October 08 2016 17:52 GMT

#2258

I was told during my mafia game that activity on this site tends to tank during the weekends.

I think it's only relevant because all of the current possibilities have low thread presence, implying that the mafia are passive and aren't disrupting the thread enough,

Checks out.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 08 2016 17:54 GMT

#2259

I agree. I would add in Oats as a last resort. I remember Palmar telling Calix that Oats had a townie post where he posted 3 different ideas in 1 post and said that mafia would have taken the time to structure the post.
Also don't remember Oatsy commenting on either Superbia or Plam.

Be wary, Calix. I am not sold about Plamar being mafia yet. Don't sell the bear's skin before you have caught the bear.

justanothertownie

16324 Posts

October 08 2016 17:54 GMT

#2260

Voted Superbia for now. Palmar is also an option but I would like some marvellosity input on that one. Sheeping him on Palmar has never been a bad thing.