Battle of the Drams Mafia - Page 10

On September 30 2015 22:31 rsoultin wrote:


so?

you're still wrong ^^

you're still biased ^^

you're still not even remotely thinking about why a scum rsoul would ever do this

On September 30 2015 22:33 rsoultin wrote:
he also has multiple times never caught me when i'm scum...he also was scumreading me or at least suspecting me in ippo

he by no means is the authority on reading me by any stretch of the imagination

more importantly, this is CLEARLY a reaction to my scumreading him without evaluating the town vs. scum motivation for doing so, cause if he was being unbiased he'd see there is no scum motivation for this

On September 30 2015 22:34 sicklucker wrote:
lol marv has a 70 page filter in this game WUT DA FAWK

On September 30 2015 22:35 MoosyDoosy wrote:
Actually, where is Rels. What do you think about rsoultin?

On September 30 2015 22:41 rsoultin wrote:
like seriously...he was right on me LATE my first scumgame after realizing i'd hard pocketed him...i was previously his top town

that is the only time i'd say is comparable to this one and it's not remotely similar? just because the one time he tunneled me he was right doesn't make him right now @.@ he's not one of the better players at reading me by a longshot. course there really aren't any lol

the point is actually evaluate his case and decide from there

his case is just that i changed my read on him and nitnoidisms from earlier that he'd already dropped and were tonal

it's not a case on scum, and it's not strong, but regardless you should want to evaluate it for yourself @.@

On September 30 2015 22:48 rsoultin wrote:
also literally EVERY SINGLE TIME you attempt to use the "i'm never certain on anyone so this says something" argument like you did in gaiden

it's not a real argument

your case is still weak as shit

other mafia, go

On September 30 2015 23:03 Rels wrote:

'cause your case is based on the fact that she townread you, then scumread you when you made no posts in between

On September 30 2015 23:07 Rels wrote:

OK true. That was my interpretation of the case. Then all this talking about rsoultin townreading you earlier means nothing

On September 30 2015 23:10 rsoultin wrote:
you are literally scumreading me for changing my read

that is it

that is your whole case

On September 30 2015 18:34 marvellosity wrote:

no, not really. if you can't see it, i don't care. i'm probably not gonna get her lynched anyway.

but making me her top town (or one of two at least, going by the first post) into questioniing what i've been pushing, and specifically SAYING TO DAMDRED THAT DAMDRED THINKS I AM LOCK TOWN. well no - so does she according to her posts... why is she putting this on damdred?

she's asking her top townread about her other top townread saying her top townread is doing asinine things and bleh

On September 30 2015 19:00 marvellosity wrote:
Just to make it clear exactly why my suspicions were aroused on rsoultin, in posts that literally no-one can have missed at the start of my filter:





yet rsoultin describes my push as asinine because it was only about wanting her to post stuff she only does as town.

Well, yes, of course, but it's pretty obvious from what came before that isn't why i put her vote on her. I put my vote on her BEFORE i made the comment about making townie posts

QED

On September 30 2015 19:03 marvellosity wrote:
also, the fact remains that rsoultin hasn't made a single post that she can't make as mafia. i'd be happy for someone to prove me wrong, but "tone" isn't good enough.

On September 30 2015 19:11 marvellosity wrote:
The massive switch is definitely part of it. It's also the way it's framed. Putting the responsibility on Damdred for Damdred's hard townread on me when she previously supposedly had one. My posts being good enough for a top 2 townread into describing me as a non-entity. Describing her vote on me as having had the desired reaction because it made me react and look town (where did that go?). [b]Describing my push on her at the start of the game in a way that puts what I did in a very bad light, and a very incorrect light.

I would think if she was suddenly suspicious of me (as town) she would at least have CHECKED, cursorily, the reasons for my mafiaread on her at the start of the game, but no. Instead it's "asinine" (when it wasn't)