Newbie Student Mafia XI - Page 108

On June 20 2015 08:08 Trfel wrote:
Ugh, I guess I really just need to look into everyone.

Rels
ruXxar
Damdred
Kickstart
batsnacks
Trfel
WaveofShadow
Oatsmaster

8 players left, so 6 town and 2 mafia.
There will be 5 town and 2 mafia after the night, and 3 town and 2 mafia if we mislynch again.

That gives us one more mislynch before LYLO. So if we can get down to three suspects, we should be okay.

I sort of feel like mafia is most likely between Rels, ruXxar, and Oatsmaster, though.

Batsnacks, I would appreciate some reasons why you are suspicious of Damdred and WaveofShadow other than POE. How does their play follow mafia motivations?

On June 20 2015 03:50 Trfel wrote:
My past scumreads have been wrong because I've expected Damdred to always play like he does in his best moments. Damdred is certainly a good player, but he doesn't always play to the very high level that he's capable of. (not to pick on Damdred, I'm rarely able to play to my best...)

Damdred and I have turned our last few games together into a yelling match, which is one of the main reasons I attributed to town losing those games. If Damdred were scum here, I would expect him to do the same, as it would be an easy way to sidetrack the thread and there's minimal risk for Damdred. Instead, he does this:Which I don't really see coming from mafia!Damdred.

When Damdred is here, he seems to be willing to lead the thread.

On June 20 2015 09:11 Damdred wrote:
Ie bats will say I'm trying to pocket him and lack suspicion of his play. The only thing I have going for,me is voting on sulp instead of ks and instead of shot fighting with ks and trfel I tried to work with them,and get ks to work with me.

On June 20 2015 09:30 batsnacks wrote:
I pasted 100% of my thought process regarding my POE. I even did a kind thing and cut and pasted it all into one convenient post with bullet points.

Rather than "hey bats do you have anything else?" or "bats your POE sucks please completely change all of your opinions and perspectives because I don't like them" or "bats is unreachable, I will just ignore him"

why not respond to anything I said with reason?

Yeah I've read your 'sulf did this, so town' posts and I'm not particularly enamored of them. I will admit I'm usually not great at reading newbies here so maybe that's why I don't feel like looking into his motivations will yield good results, but to assume that every time Sulf defended someone it makes them town seems a little suspect since there are other cases sulf didn't even comment on due to low activity.

On June 20 2015 09:34 WaveofShadow wrote:

Yeah and since nothing has changed at all in your PoE even though you were clearly wrong on Scott, what I responded with originally still stands:

On June 20 2015 09:45 WaveofShadow wrote:
Alright, but you clearly missed the point of what I said. Your reasons are seemingly based on whatever your specific ideals are for how Sulfurus played his game when in reality you don't know exactly how he played.

In all of your PoE analysis you essentially assume that Sulfurus does not bus anyone, and never townreads fellow scum mates so only those people omitted from most of his posting entirely must be scum. If you don't see why that's faulty even after Scott got lynched than by all means continue, but don't expect me or anyone else to listen to you any further.