|
On June 11 2015 16:07 yamato77 wrote:
Tubesock why are you convinced Bill is town when literally everyone else thinks he's mafia?
I like Bill because of his commentary on Bugs. I don't think scum Bill Murray would act like he did all of D1. I think he would have been far more decisive and forceful as scum during the second half of the day.
I don't think that he would jump off Lightningstrike if he was a teammate onto stutters like he did. I don't think Bill Murray would not have a plan on how he would conduct himself as mafia.
You really think this world exists?
Stutters695 (3): Tubesock, Bill Murray , LightningStrike
That mafia Bill Murray would do that in an effort to save LightningStrike?
Is the blue kp really that important to have all three mafia on one target?
|
I mean is the blue kp really that important to keep that it is worth having all three mafia off the main wagon?
I mean sure it's possible that we are mafia, but how would that possibly benefit us just to have both survivors under scrutiny? For 1 kp?
|
Yamato I was honestly expecting a bit more than that but it's still an alright answer for now, I guess.
Tube, I'm sorry but I've also done my best not to attack you, personally. It's just a thing of mine. If I start feeling unmotivated, I latch onto the fire that comes from someone scumming/wanting to kill me. Even a statement like that is enough to fire me up. I also got weary that you making that town light comment(clever btw with my name and all) was an attempt at buddying me once you saw I was starting to come back to thread. And I can't help but feel like now you're backtracking.
But if you are in fact town, be glad I'm firing it back up. Ive got filters to dive including yours and its 320 am here. I'll probably actively post here for a while longer to kill time at work but I'll dive tomorrow.
|
11589 Posts
As for what Bill would have done, that argument is complete WIFOM and presupposes that you have some sort of knowledge of how Bill plays scum, which I almost certainly have more of than you.
I do think Bill would play like he did D1 as mafia. He was overall directionless and was playing solely to fuck up the game. He even once claimed he was requesting a replacement in the thread which is basically as low as you get in terms of faking being butthurt.
As far as him having a plan, I immediately direct you to Assassination mafia where mafia BM fires a nuke only hours into D1 without consulting his team whatsoever, and then fires a second nuke at his own teammate once the first one is shot down. No, I don't think Bill has plans as scum, he just plays disruptively and tries to play off WIFOM. Seems pretty effective given you read him town for it, haha.
I also do think that mafia may have at some point wanted to save LS for his KP but may have not succeeded. Like I said earlier, I don't necessarily believe you are mafia but if you were your only play is to vote against WBG so you voting with your scum team isn't all that implausible. Bill can vote wherever he pleases because no one honestly expects him as town to be all that rational and he also probably can't vote with WBG given his play throughout the day.
|
So I'm totally and completely not even mentioned in Foot's filter. Considering we know its GB now, a player who has played with me and coached me as town before, and also played in the only scum game I've ever played on TL, I find it interesting that she hasn't once mentioned me or tried to read me or have me lynched.
Wait a sec. GB IS a she, right? So Tube did in fact know that Foot was a girl before any of us.
Or is GB not a girl and I'm making an ass of myself?
|
11589 Posts
On June 11 2015 16:29 The Shining wrote:
So I'm totally and completely not even mentioned in Foot's filter. Considering we know its GB now, a player who has played with me and coached me as town before, and also played in the only scum game I've ever played on TL, I find it interesting that she hasn't once mentioned me or tried to read me or have me lynched.
Wait a sec. GB IS a she, right? So Tube did in fact know that Foot was a girl before any of us.
Or is GB not a girl and I'm making an ass of myself?
Pretty sure GB is a dude.
|
In that case disregard and LMAO SORRRY GB.
|
Question still stands, though. I know I've been a bit under the radar but I was also inactive as hell D1 the scumgame I won against GB. Y u no acknowledge me this game?
|
On June 11 2015 16:29 yamato77 wrote:
As for what Bill would have done, that argument is complete WIFOM and presupposes that you have some sort of knowledge of how Bill plays scum, which I almost certainly have more of than you.
I do think Bill would play like he did D1 as mafia. He was overall directionless and was playing solely to fuck up the game. He even once claimed he was requesting a replacement in the thread which is basically as low as you get in terms of faking being butthurt.
As far as him having a plan, I immediately direct you to Assassination mafia where mafia BM fires a nuke only hours into D1 without consulting his team whatsoever, and then fires a second nuke at his own teammate once the first one is shot down. No, I don't think Bill has plans as scum, he just plays disruptively and tries to play off WIFOM. Seems pretty effective given you read him town for it, haha.
I also do think that mafia may have at some point wanted to save LS for his KP but may have not succeeded. Like I said earlier, I don't necessarily believe you are mafia but if you were your only play is to vote against WBG so you voting with your scum team isn't all that implausible. Bill can vote wherever he pleases because no one honestly expects him as town to be all that rational and he also probably can't vote with WBG given his play throughout the day.
Hmmm. He does constantly go back and forth on scumming/towning Bugs a lot. I guess I town him because I think his town comments are him being sarcastic towards Bugs and well avoiding all the attention I'm getting for pushing the most townread player in the game. Bill says multiple times about how Bugs is showcasing doing ad hominem attacks, and using logical fallacies. I agree with him, so I think he's town. /shrug
|
11589 Posts
On June 11 2015 16:36 Tubesock wrote:Show nested quote +On June 11 2015 16:29 yamato77 wrote:
As for what Bill would have done, that argument is complete WIFOM and presupposes that you have some sort of knowledge of how Bill plays scum, which I almost certainly have more of than you.
I do think Bill would play like he did D1 as mafia. He was overall directionless and was playing solely to fuck up the game. He even once claimed he was requesting a replacement in the thread which is basically as low as you get in terms of faking being butthurt.
As far as him having a plan, I immediately direct you to Assassination mafia where mafia BM fires a nuke only hours into D1 without consulting his team whatsoever, and then fires a second nuke at his own teammate once the first one is shot down. No, I don't think Bill has plans as scum, he just plays disruptively and tries to play off WIFOM. Seems pretty effective given you read him town for it, haha.
I also do think that mafia may have at some point wanted to save LS for his KP but may have not succeeded. Like I said earlier, I don't necessarily believe you are mafia but if you were your only play is to vote against WBG so you voting with your scum team isn't all that implausible. Bill can vote wherever he pleases because no one honestly expects him as town to be all that rational and he also probably can't vote with WBG given his play throughout the day. Hmmm. He does constantly go back and forth on scumming/towning Bugs a lot. I guess I town him because I think his town comments are him being sarcastic towards Bugs and well avoiding all the attention I'm getting for pushing the most townread player in the game. Bill says multiple times about how Bugs is showcasing doing ad hominem attacks, and using logical fallacies. I agree with him, so I think he's town. /shrug
Ad hominem and logical fallacies are not scum tells, especially for bugs, lol.
Bill focusing on such an irrelevant point is something against him in my book.
|
On June 11 2015 16:37 yamato77 wrote:Show nested quote +On June 11 2015 16:36 Tubesock wrote:On June 11 2015 16:29 yamato77 wrote:
As for what Bill would have done, that argument is complete WIFOM and presupposes that you have some sort of knowledge of how Bill plays scum, which I almost certainly have more of than you.
I do think Bill would play like he did D1 as mafia. He was overall directionless and was playing solely to fuck up the game. He even once claimed he was requesting a replacement in the thread which is basically as low as you get in terms of faking being butthurt.
As far as him having a plan, I immediately direct you to Assassination mafia where mafia BM fires a nuke only hours into D1 without consulting his team whatsoever, and then fires a second nuke at his own teammate once the first one is shot down. No, I don't think Bill has plans as scum, he just plays disruptively and tries to play off WIFOM. Seems pretty effective given you read him town for it, haha.
I also do think that mafia may have at some point wanted to save LS for his KP but may have not succeeded. Like I said earlier, I don't necessarily believe you are mafia but if you were your only play is to vote against WBG so you voting with your scum team isn't all that implausible. Bill can vote wherever he pleases because no one honestly expects him as town to be all that rational and he also probably can't vote with WBG given his play throughout the day. Hmmm. He does constantly go back and forth on scumming/towning Bugs a lot. I guess I town him because I think his town comments are him being sarcastic towards Bugs and well avoiding all the attention I'm getting for pushing the most townread player in the game. Bill says multiple times about how Bugs is showcasing doing ad hominem attacks, and using logical fallacies. I agree with him, so I think he's town. /shrug Ad hominem and logical fallacies are not scum tells, especially for bugs, lol. Bill focusing on such an irrelevant point is something against him in my book.
From my limited experience, it is a scum tell. HolyFlare and geript did it when they were scum and when I've seen them as town they didn't at all. I understand it's a small small sample size, and won't work for everyone but that judgement is hard for me to shake. anyway, it's neither here nor there.
I'm going to bed. See you guys tomorrow.
|
|
|
I just got home not too long ago. Longass flights with longass delays. At least I'm not stuck in Chicago. 完全
##unvote
##vote The Shining
|
11589 Posts
On June 11 2015 16:49 wherebugsgo wrote:
I just got home not too long ago. Longass flights with longass delays. At least I'm not stuck in Chicago. 完全
##unvote
##vote The Shining
Why are we switching, exactly?
His recent posting has gotten better, not worse.
|
Shining and Onegu not reading thread. Hmmmmm.
|
If I know who the priest is should I say now or should I wait to see if they will give us more clues?
|
Wait till tomorrow, let's see what happens. If you're right on the priest that would mean that there would be a 9/1 ratio by D3.
On June 11 2015 11:28 yamato77 wrote:
Is there a plan for this, Shockey?
Yes.
On June 11 2015 12:04 FreezingFoot wrote:
Can you tell me what are your reads right now and why you want to lynch someone completely out of discussion?
You just answered your own question.
|
Yeah I should probably wait till tomorrow to say who the priest is since I got first action last night and blasphemed him.
|
You may now be dead, bats. Rofl
|
Jesus do you people not read the setup
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
