|
On November 08 2014 17:37 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On November 08 2014 17:31 jaybrundage wrote:On November 08 2014 17:13 Holyflare wrote:On November 08 2014 17:12 Holyflare wrote: Like you can't possibly be thinking that because there's 2 nights and 1 of those nights the kills don't make ANY sense whatsoever at all coming from a single mafia faction. Like 0 sense at all. Then there's night 2 where misder is a claim for 1kp and mafia the other. Where are you getting all these random facts about mafia having extra kp from??? Or alternatively misder is just mafia In that case you would subscribe to CR's theory that they have 1kp and other abilities as well For extra KP? No. There is almost 100% a 3p with the n1 kills, aren't you reading? No, I can't actually read. I do impress myself with how well i can carry on a conversation on the computa tho. + Show Spoiler +Before you say it: MURICA EDUCATION!
So where do you think this 3p went on n2?
|
I'm also uncertain if there's a 3p carrying out kills.
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
Either misder on kirby, bear in mind we've alread had a d5 vig flip and he was only 1kp after 5 cycles! this is 6 whole kp in n2!!! AND the downside was either bs or blocked by something that shouldn't be a block
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
On November 08 2014 17:47 Chairman Ray wrote: I'm also uncertain if there's a 3p carrying out kills.
Yes well you didn't read d1 enough to realise that bh and gb were like the worst possible combination of kills I've seen in a very long time so i take this with a pinch of salr
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
Feel like this conversation isn't really leading anywhere and isn't particularly finding scum so just gonna go try and sleep
Cyaaa
|
Here is an idea what if the 3p already passed. The stupid cat that was presumably part of Kul'Thuzad. It was its own player and if we can recall it mentioned the annihilation of the Horde.
On October 31 2014 13:23 Mr. Bigglesworth wrote:Meeeeeeeow! I, Mr. Bigglesworth, the Supreme Feline, was summoned by my master Kel'Thuzad to help with the annihilation of the Horde. I will use my profound wisdom to analyse a player of your wish every 23 hours cycle.
To vote for a player to be analysed, use the format ##Analyse: Player in this thread (not in the vote thread). The most voted player will be analysed. You can only vote once.
Purr purr purr.
Btw guys I think I know why the cat died. I said no one could read me. It probably blew a fuse trying to analyze me. #BestMislynchNA #StupidCat #Thisisn'teventwitter #HFCartman'sEnglishdouble #TLMafia ##
On November 01 2014 13:11 jaybrundage wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2014 13:08 Oatsmaster wrote:On November 01 2014 12:41 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Why is Jay a coinflip?
I don't understand. I dont know his alignment but he posted a decent amount leading to a more consistent read by an outside party Ha I'll show you no one can read the Best Mislynch NA MWAHAHHAHAHHAHAHHAH + Show Spoiler +
|
On November 08 2014 17:51 Holyflare wrote: Either misder on kirby, bear in mind we've alread had a d5 vig flip and he was only 1kp after 5 cycles! this is 6 whole kp in n2!!! AND the downside was either bs or blocked by something that shouldn't be a block
?? You never presented an alternative.
|
On November 08 2014 17:29 Chairman Ray wrote: If I had to pick a 3p, it would be Oatsmaster just off role speculation.
His name check ability sticks out to me. There is literally nothing that names do in this game, so putting this ability into the game doesn't make sense from a design perspective. Oats even decided to use this ability, while discarding vengeful and ability block, which are two wonderful abilities for either faction. He also decided to keep the martyr ability despite saying that he really doesn't want to use it.
Makes sense if he's 3p with a win-con that has to do with names, and the martyr ability can change his win con.
Maybe Misder could be 3p, but I think mafia is far more likely. Dude I didn't have a choice in which abilities I discarded. Also I'm not getting lynched so vengeful is bad, ability block is for myself which is bad. Sooooo in essence, I got super lucky with the discards.
And seriously you can't even make up a plausible theory how me knowing role names helps me win the game.
|
Ugh...there's some really questionable stuff in Lian's filter, but nothing particularly damning. And his filter is really like....active. Like he's around for the DURATION of the game, just not very prolifically.
UUUGGGHHHHHHH. Maybe I'll peruse past games or something. My gut tells me mafia, but I like his Damdred push so it's whatever honestly. Maybe I'm wrong.
|
On November 08 2014 15:37 liancourt wrote:ok since everyone seems to be claiming and all i'll claim my d1 action which was if i forfeited my vote i could halve the number of votes someone received which i didn't. And my n2 action was that if the person i chose died that night that they would still be able to vote on d3 and picked rito. my current scum reads are damdred and misder. Chairman ray needs to fucking read everything and not play the game half assed because i believed that slot to be a apprehensive uncertain noobie playing which i didnt think to be scummy but genuine. So i'm willing to give ray more time to prove himself because i think he can play better from what i heard of him from other players. Damdred has been scummy since day 1 with his day 1 voting stunt and his day 2 "guess the word" shawanigans. i still dont understand why he used that ability day 1 to make it a majority vote which was risky as hell. The end was good in hindsight but the means were very scummy. Moreover, I dont see how u got a scum read on me so suddenly the only explanation i can come up with is this: Show nested quote +On November 07 2014 13:07 Oatsmaster wrote:On November 07 2014 12:57 Holyflare wrote:On November 07 2014 12:48 Oatsmaster wrote: well liancourt is like confirmed scum now man. ##vote Liancourt ? elimination + totally different play from the other game I played with him. Its not hard. Circumstance/CR also seems to be but im more confident in liancourt. Slightly Show nested quote +On November 07 2014 15:01 Damdred wrote: Loan scares the crap out of me honestly, his postings really look so unlike every game I've played with him. Him and Cr are probably scum It just seems ur copying what oats said and trying to find a reason that u see me scummy. And when i ask you to enlighten everyone of how i usually play you just go somewhere else and don't explain. Like do you really want me to be lynched? I even welcomed your case against me but you ddidnt deliver. Scummy. Misder after thinking for a long time and however far fetched it might be I think misder is telling the truth about the chicken and leeroy. Now some of u know the story of leeroy and going full retard in a dungeon on wow. He just went in disregarding any plans. To my knowledge in the video he didn't die (correct me if i'm wrong) but says at the end that he at least got chicken. Now i think that the fact that he has a chicken makes him not die when he goes leeroy. Now, i know the chances of ve giving the chicken to the right person (which is leeroy) is very minimal and if that is the case then ve and misder is probably mafia (kinda like what ray said). However, I believe that ve is a good inventor, he's been giving good inventions out and i don't think anything bad has happened to them. So i think ve got lucky in giving misder the chicken. So in conclusion i'd rather lynch damdred than misder. PS. To those who think i'm playing half heartedly, unusual, uninterested, god knows any other bad attributed words. I've played 3 games here. First game half the people thought of me as scum I tried my fucking best to please everyone and bleed town as best as possible, it wasn't enough. i got lynched and everyone fucking ignored my reads. Second game ended quite fast but nonetheless i was seen as scummy on the first day because i wasn't try harding like the first game. LOL. I was going for a different playstyle because it was tiring doing all the shit for nothing when no one believes u and ignores ur reads. So i played less serious, but i gave reads nonetheless when it was needed. No one really gave a damn then either so and the game ended. third game was resistance. The game kinda imploded on itself but nonetheless i tried give out my analysis I even made the 2 pools splitting scum and hypothesizing that there were 1 and 2 scum in each pool. I was right at least right when I looked at the game when it ended but no one gave a fuck about my 2 pool analysis and disregarded it. So now how do you think i feel when i give reads but they are just ignored? I just didn't try as hard as past games does it really matter since no one gives a damn about my reads up until now. Why now? Oh wait, it's because I'm scummy now for some apparent reason. Now I am at the center of attention lol Are you going to ignore my reads again today? Fuck psycho analyze this post and I want every fucking ppl to respond to me.
Firstly please claim properly with the name of your character as well as the powers that you had if you would.
You are scum reading me based on what exactly? Speculation about powers not actual intentions of postings in game? What did we gain in the extra 24 (25 with daylight savings) we gained information about people in the game and we gained a mafia death, it ended up getting me scum read but thats ok. I claimed my power i did it oh well, its not risky when you have a whole day to consolidate votes on someone risky would be if i changed vote format but did not extend time.
You barely mention my d2 power but seems to play into your scum read, and i'm not sure why it would be I let people know what my power was did not want to say the word but people knew what it was people said the word someone lost their vote.
Scum read on you comes from some of the way you approach the game, you don't give almost any insights your play has been lacking compared to other games even in games you laid back you stiill gave us something to work on and you really looked town in 2/3 of those games really all three. Your play leading up to the lynch where instead of being where we were trying to be involved in shenanigans or anything like that you were posting one or two things up to the last minute on things that were hours old, it took you over 30 hours to develop any form of semblance of case on me and your case boils down power use is bad, seems to parrot oats scum. Thats not a good case, or any way like what you have done in the past it feels like to me.
Doesn't matter what happened in other games you are new people don't know how to read you in your first game i scum read you and then i turned on a dime and town read you as did most of the thread and yelled at the vig for taking that shot, in resistance everyone had you as town there was no doubt and people did listen to you but gave up on the game. I think the FF game where you laid back more well that was a shit storm anyway. The point is doesn't matter if people don't listen to you as town in your first few games you keep playing and giving effort and they will read what your saying and paint you as town its just the way it is.
overall I think the case on me is lacking and how ve can say its a good push idk
|
Because all of your actions have been questionable Damdred. I didn't like ur use of ability D1, the D2 word fiasco seems to come from a not-town mindset as well. Like, it all just seems like ur mafia Damdred. And that's my thing too (has been since D1) so that's why I agree with his push. Because it's in line with what I've been thinking all game.
|
Im not sure why the d2 word was a fiasco when i came out straight away and explained what it was?
|
On November 09 2014 00:58 Damdred wrote: Im not sure why the d2 word was a fiasco when i came out straight away and explained what it was? You literally said you got the ability in the night - so why not warn the thread in the night about the word? Like, it seems nitpicky, but that on top of the thing on D1 makes that action questionable to me man. I'm sorry, it just does. Your explanations for things have been lacking too.
And this phase your play can be summed up as "pointedly accusatory" toward me - like this whole Lian thing. Why are you so hung up on whether I mention him or not? If it's some sort of association thing then why aren't you trying to get him lynched to see what's what and THEN accuse me? It all just feels really weird and agenda-pushy to me.
Like I'm not trying to convince you you're mafia or anything, I'm just explaining why I think you're mafia out loud, for the thread.
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
No you hid how it worked entirely
|
And it was stated in the thread N1, DO NOT TALK ABOUT YOUR ABILITIES AT NIGHT IT HELPS MAFIA. So I shut up about my ability and I waited till Day started and came out with it.
Not sure what my explanation for thing shave been lacking.
Because you basically REFUSED to read someone who had been extremely lurky who has not tried to push the game forward before his huge post (which is still debatable) and your only response was I'll do it later. And your read on him was one of the most lackluster responses i've ever seen you give and the only reason you are ignoring him basically is because it helps you push forward your agenda of lynching me.
I'm paranoid of you VE because of your ability skipping a night randomly and then not missing a beat at all, that doesn't make logical sense but it doesn't mean your mafia. I'm paranoid of you because you got into a shit fight with HF for a little bit of pressure which does play towards your town meta, just becuase i'm paranoid of you does not mean your mafia.
|
Like why not make the word "sassafrass" or something no one will ever say? Making it something like "shenanigans" leaves it open for you to choose to warn the thread it's coming or not and it's something someone is just generally LIKELY to say, especially after the D1 we had.
|
On November 09 2014 01:05 Holyflare wrote: No you hid how it worked entirely
Thats not true at all, clarification was made after the conversation had passed and I believe both had already said the word.
|
On November 09 2014 01:07 Damdred wrote: And it was stated in the thread N1, DO NOT TALK ABOUT YOUR ABILITIES AT NIGHT IT HELPS MAFIA. So I shut up about my ability and I waited till Day started and came out with it.
Not sure what my explanation for thing shave been lacking.
Because you basically REFUSED to read someone who had been extremely lurky who has not tried to push the game forward before his huge post (which is still debatable) and your only response was I'll do it later. And your read on him was one of the most lackluster responses i've ever seen you give and the only reason you are ignoring him basically is because it helps you push forward your agenda of lynching me.
I'm paranoid of you VE because of your ability skipping a night randomly and then not missing a beat at all, that doesn't make logical sense but it doesn't mean your mafia. I'm paranoid of you because you got into a shit fight with HF for a little bit of pressure which does play towards your town meta, just becuase i'm paranoid of you does not mean your mafia. I don't care if you like my response about lian, the fact of the matter is that I've never played with the guy and looking at old games is hard work and I'm not in the fucking mood to do it right now Damdred, especially given the fact that he's onboard with one of MY favorite lynches in you. Like, that doesn't make me mafia at all - I concede that it DOES help to push my (super town) "lynch Damdred" agenda, but that doesn't make me mafia. Nothing does. Because I'm town.
|
There is no way i can convince you i'm not mafia honestly VE you already have a pre conceived notion in your head that I am mafia based off my extending the day d1. You became tunneled then and you haven't let it go since.
Also thats like the most wifom statement ve, i'm mafia because i made it a word that people were likely to say, so i could warn people so that I would look towny...its plausible though. I played bad with my powers but I feel like I did contribute to the thread in reads and what not aside from my powers anyway i'll start getting stuff together in case i get lynched
|
United Kingdom30774 Posts
I don't think I've ever seen lian make a case on anyone damd, why you saying he basically does and pushes ppl when that's not true?
|
|
|
|