On August 11 2014 12:10 Eden1892 wrote:
The problem is that I'm sure when you're town your arguments actually make sense.

Why in the fuck did you think Poofter and gobble were a scumteam?

Is it so hard for you to wrap your brain around? Both have been super scummy all game. Both have scum read each other with no faltering since day one. Both of them had the most useless reasons to scum read each other. Looked a lot like a bus scenario.

I've asked this before and you didn't answer it as far as I can tell, so I'll ask again. What scum motivation exists for two mafia to hardcore bus each other from halfway through d1? The problem isn't that it's possible but that it's pretty unlikely. It doesn't make sense for mafia to do that here.

I answered it and you ignored it. Look how much you defended them for it. If they are both mafia then it's free pass to end game. Believe it or not I've played a lot of mafia and know

I swear to God I addressed this, I know I was typing a reply to it at some point and I'm gonna be mad if I never actually sent it b/c I was busy irl at the time.

This strikes me as a terribly unproductive attempt to push the scum agenda. In a 3-person game, two of them just intermittently check in, don't do anything to solve the game state, look involved or push discussion, but instead just talk loudly about killing each other without actually making an effort to do so, all in the hopes that someone comes through, kills one of them and townreads the other for it?

It isn't impossible looking strictly at the "tactics" so to speak - the arguments they were employing, the degree to which they were pushing the lynch - but it doesn't paint a coherent "strategic" picture for a scumteam. There's one guy trying to mislead the whole town in a game where the mafia have to force four mislynches to win?

It just doesn't make sense. It's not impossible, but again you were so sure that was a bus and refused to even consider another angle. The confidence you had in them being scum busing from the start was significantly disproportionate to the level of certainty I would expect a townie to have in that argument. And then as it turns out... nope, not busing at all.

The bolded rings fairly true, however.

I would hope! Give the paragraph I linked a reread, I made this argument initially and I think you missed it?

I also brought this up back during n1 when kush was around

I didn't miss it but I suppose I didn't think it's what you meant was the strongest of your arguments? I agree there is some merit to it, but what other examples of this do you have? Can you link the N1 post? Have you read my case yet?

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

August 11 2014 03:49 GMT

#3524

*whoooooosh*

Eden1892

United States5866 Posts

August 11 2014 03:49 GMT

#3525

Also Wave I read your case and yeah it's better than mine. Sorry I missed it earlier, I think I glazed over reading it last night because I was tired and forgot about it, so my bad. Excuses excuses but it's been a busy 24 hrs for me

WaveofShadow

Canada31494 Posts

August 11 2014 03:50 GMT

#3526

Man this is really fucking nice to actually have people to talk to
I truly don't think I can ever play a game with an NA early evening time again.

Eden1892

United States5866 Posts

August 11 2014 03:50 GMT

#3527

On August 11 2014 12:46 Holyflare wrote:
You're wasting your time eden instead of actually analysing the game

Says the guy just calling me scum for no reason lol

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

August 11 2014 03:50 GMT

#3528

Jesus people can't read for shit

WaveofShadow

Canada31494 Posts

August 11 2014 03:51 GMT

#3529

On August 11 2014 12:49 Eden1892 wrote:
Also Wave I read your case and yeah it's better than mine. Sorry I missed it earlier, I think I glazed over reading it last night because I was tired and forgot about it, so my bad. Excuses excuses but it's been a busy 24 hrs for me

Sorry, not good enough.
Like HF said, analysis. What about it is good? Are there problems with it?