EPTAlso Cephiro promised us something good by half-way into day 2 and has not delivered yet.
You Only Shoot Once Mafia - Page 45
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
Also Cephiro promised us something good by half-way into day 2 and has not delivered yet. | ||
|
justanothertownie
16320 Posts
But my vote is pretty much set in stone. It is on the biggest wagon (-> consolidation goes towards foolishness) and the person I want to lynch the most. I am not moving it. | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22633 Posts
On May 01 2014 02:19 Blazinghand wrote: Fair enough. I'm down like a clown with lynching Oats. I think we've given Palmar plenty of time and he hasn't delivered, as well. RoL is a fine lynch but honestly I've learned not to expect much from him. The foolishness lynch is, well, utter foolishness. You maf son? | ||
|
Cephiro
Finland1934 Posts
Confirmed Town Club: Cephiro, geript (DEAD), strongandbig (DEAD) Greenish Grasses (Most to least town): austinmcc, justanothertownie, Ace, yamato (DEAD), tehpoofter, WaveOfShadow Neutral Waters (Townier to scummier): VisceraEyes, prplhz, Alakaslam, gumshoe, RebirthOfLegend, VayneOfAuthority Fiery Furnace (Least scummy to scummiest): Caller, Foolishness, Palmar, Koshi, Oatsmaster Joker Category: OdinOfPergo (Slight townread, but I also suspect him to be traitor), Blazinghand (Has traits that make me lean both slightly town as well as slightly scum, however I don't think both he and foolishness would be on the same scumteam) Players I am planning to elaborate on: Blazinghand, Koshi, Foolishness, Caller. On request: Palmar, Oatsmaster (I think most of the things I want to point about these players have been told enough times.) So yeah, there you have it. If you simply agree with some, then nice, but I'd prefer to hear why. If you disagree with some, I won't give a shit about your opinion if you don't give reasoning towards why you disagree. If you want to hear my thoughts about a certain player, explain why, and point out any certain points of importance you're especially interested in knowing my thought process on. On April 28 2014 13:01 Hapahauli wrote: Vote Count! Palmar (1) - Ace strongandbig (13) - Foolishness, Alakaslam, Geript, Palmar, Koshi, VisceraEyes, RebirthofLegend, BlazingHand, Caller, OdinofPergo, WaveofShadow, VayneAuthority, prplhz Oatsmaster (5) - Austinmcc, Alakaslam (1) - Oatsmaster Not Voting (2) - tehpoofter, gumshoe until lynch. With 22 alive, 12 votes are needed to lynch. Above is how I think the lynch went down. I may very well be wrong on something (and most likely am, calling it perfectly would be quite insane), but I'm not interesting in hearing you bash my opinion for "obviously being wrong." If you think something definitely can't be the case, then do tell. My current belief is that there are 5 members in the scumteam + 1 traitor that may or may not have been recruited yet. My assumption is: Koshi, Palmar, Caller, Oatsmaster, Foolishness + OdinOfPergo My main concern about this assumption is including both Palmar and Caller in the team. I like the theory pointed out by WoS early on, and had initial thoughts along the same lines. However I'm not so sure if these two would have the balls to pull it off or not. Palmar's panic reaction seemed genuine, and I can picture it easily in (Caller/Palmar respectively) Scum/Town, Town/Town, Town/Scum situations, but a genuine in panic reaction in a Scum/Scum reaction is something that doesn't add up. With this, I'll be around writing my cases and responding to questions (occasionally and briefly, as I may be needing my available posts today.). I would like to lynch Koshi today. | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22633 Posts
| ||
|
OdinOfPergo
United States840 Posts
In what world does scum recruit me? Like what did they recruit and Slam busses me for lolz? I think Foolish/Oats is probably best. I like Slam and BH as scum too.. hmm That could mean Oats is town though. I think Gumshoe is pretty town atm too. He's not doing much of anything but dang the intro post. He included a pic of his dog and everything. Not sure on Palmar.. his d2 I feel was by far and large better than his d1.. But I really also don't like the whole "never done this in tl history but I'm retracting my statement about rl stuffs" If one of your staples as either alignment is not bringing it up why would it be alignment indicative in the first place? I guess what I'm saying is: why did you feel the need to post it at all instead of just afking per usual? But that being said I feel like I've been tunneled on Palmar this entire game. I don't want him lynched today. Foolish/Oats makes me worry more just because of this pairing happening now.. Foolish is more active.. Oats is per usual mia.. if Foolish/BH/Slam are scum this could either mean Oats buss d2.. or Oats mislynch d2.. case 1) you'll hopfully look better off his scum flip or case 2) he was such a big question mark?? how could you know.. Also I might be able to donate some post to some peoples | ||
|
Caller
Poland8075 Posts
no one in particular | ||
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
On May 01 2014 04:43 Cephiro wrote: Alright. Read through all the filters and have enhanced my opinions and thoughts. This will only be a list post of my thoughts, I am going to elaborate further on a few people during the next few hours. Why I'm posting the list first is because I want to ask from all of you, is there any specific read of mine you'd like me to elaborate on. Depending on who asks and on what read, I may or may not comply. Confirmed Town Club: Cephiro, geript (DEAD), strongandbig (DEAD) Greenish Grasses (Most to least town): austinmcc, justanothertownie, Ace, yamato (DEAD), tehpoofter, WaveOfShadow Neutral Waters (Townier to scummier): VisceraEyes, prplhz, Alakaslam, gumshoe, RebirthOfLegend, VayneOfAuthority Fiery Furnace (Least scummy to scummiest): Caller, Foolishness, Palmar, Koshi, Oatsmaster Joker Category: OdinOfPergo (Slight townread, but I also suspect him to be traitor), Blazinghand (Has traits that make me lean both slightly town as well as slightly scum, however I don't think both he and foolishness would be on the same scumteam) Players I am planning to elaborate on: Blazinghand, Koshi, Foolishness, Caller. On request: Palmar, Oatsmaster (I think most of the things I want to point about these players have been told enough times.) So yeah, there you have it. If you simply agree with some, then nice, but I'd prefer to hear why. If you disagree with some, I won't give a shit about your opinion if you don't give reasoning towards why you disagree. If you want to hear my thoughts about a certain player, explain why, and point out any certain points of importance you're especially interested in knowing my thought process on. Above is how I think the lynch went down. I may very well be wrong on something (and most likely am, calling it perfectly would be quite insane), but I'm not interesting in hearing you bash my opinion for "obviously being wrong." If you think something definitely can't be the case, then do tell. My current belief is that there are 5 members in the scumteam + 1 traitor that may or may not have been recruited yet. My assumption is: Koshi, Palmar, Caller, Oatsmaster, Foolishness + OdinOfPergo My main concern about this assumption is including both Palmar and Caller in the team. I like the theory pointed out by WoS early on, and had initial thoughts along the same lines. However I'm not so sure if these two would have the balls to pull it off or not. Palmar's panic reaction seemed genuine, and I can picture it easily in (Caller/Palmar respectively) Scum/Town, Town/Town, Town/Scum situations, but a genuine in panic reaction in a Scum/Scum reaction is something that doesn't add up. With this, I'll be around writing my cases and responding to questions (occasionally and briefly, as I may be needing my available posts today.). I would like to lynch Koshi today. I'm having trouble understanding this world where 3 active town members on day 1 (plus one confirmed town who died at night) who each posted their own cases about why strongandbig should be lynched are mafia and not say the ~8 people who have yet to post a case, contribute to the town or post their own thoughts. I'm also having trouble believing that it's in the best interest to the town to kill the people who are posting cases and contributing and just letting those ~8 people get away with doing nothing. So I would be honored if someone can explain to me why the people who sat around on day 1 are all likely town. And ya know, you can do this by responding to the cases already made or by posting your own. | ||
|
Caller
Poland8075 Posts
##:unvote ##:Vote: Foolishness | ||
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
"oh, 75% of the players in the game are just writing sheep posts and not posting their own thoughts. Meanwhile 25% of the players are posting reads/cases, trying to steer town in the right direction, and analyze what the mafia has been doing this whole game. Well, I know that there are more town than mafia in the game because that's how the game of mafia is set up. That must mean all the town players are doing the same thing and are in the 75%, and it must be the mafia who are the 25%." I'm legit trying to figure out the mindset behind this. Cause hot damn so many people are on board with this I'm questioning my own stupidity. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
Honestly it wouldn't surprise me if RoL and Oats are town in this game----for me to be as apathetic as I've been to think that people who normally lurk (like RoL) are similar isn't a stretch. Except of course that apparently this kind of game is the ideal for RoL who hates spam. And I dunno oats is just oats. I'm still pretty damn certain this game is just over, hence the apathy. So much idgaf in this game from me and mostly everyone else, it sucks for the people who are fighting against a brick wall. Like Austin. Also cephiro only pops up with large vomit posts when people remember he's around. Curious coincidence. I'd lynch RoL or ceph or oats today I guess considering I don't have anything useful to add. The BH-foolishness thing seems legit and kinda difficult for even someone like BH to come up with if they were both scum. | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22633 Posts
For some reason this game sucks a bit. I'm playing really badly too. | ||
|
Hapahauli
United States9305 Posts
Vote Count: Foolishness (5) - Koshi, prplhz, justanothertowie, Palmar, Caller Palmar (2) - Ace, VisceraEyes VayneAuthority (0) - Gumshoe (1) - Blazinghand Blazinghand (1) - WaveofShadow Visceraeyes (0) - Oatsmaster (3) - Gumshoe, austinmcc, VayneAuthority RebirthOfLegend (2) - Foolishness, tehpoofter Odinofpergo (1) - Alakaslam Day ends in . There are 19 players alive, and it takes 10 to lynch. | ||
|
austinmcc
United States6737 Posts
On May 01 2014 05:16 Foolishness wrote: I'm having trouble understanding this world where 3 active town members on day 1 (plus one confirmed town who died at night) who each posted their own cases about why strongandbig should be lynched are mafia and not say the ~8 people who have yet to post a case, contribute to the town or post their own thoughts. I'm also having trouble believing that it's in the best interest to the town to kill the people who are posting cases and contributing and just letting those ~8 people get away with doing nothing. So I would be honored if someone can explain to me why the people who sat around on day 1 are all likely town. And ya know, you can do this by responding to the cases already made or by posting your own. On May 01 2014 05:23 Foolishness wrote: Whether Foolishness is mafia or not, this is an entirely legit statement.Really I'm just baffled by this all. Is the logic as follows? "oh, 75% of the players in the game are just writing sheep posts and not posting their own thoughts. Meanwhile 25% of the players are posting reads/cases, trying to steer town in the right direction, and analyze what the mafia has been doing this whole game. Well, I know that there are more town than mafia in the game because that's how the game of mafia is set up. That must mean all the town players are doing the same thing and are in the 75%, and it must be the mafia who are the 25%." I'm legit trying to figure out the mindset behind this. Cause hot damn so many people are on board with this I'm questioning my own stupidity. I cannot think of a case where mafia has just straight up hard-pushed a single target, all together, early on in the day. Maybe this will be the shining example of that, but that is GENERALLY not a go-to strategy. HEY FOOLISHNESS COME ON LET'S TALK. YOU'RE CEPHIRO AND YOU PROMISE SOMETHING BUT YOU DON'T DELIVER. THEN YOU DELIVER THAT POST. YOU'RE PROBABLY OF WHAT ALIGNMENT? I GUESS ALSO JUST GENERAL QUESTION. YOU'VE GOT REBIRTH, PALMAR, WOS, OATS AS MAFIA IN YOUR LAST LISTY POST. THAT'D MEAN THAT YOU'RE ALMOST REVERSE-CEPHIRO-Y? LIKE MOST OF YOUR MAFIA IS ON SNB, BUT THEY'RE ALMOST ALL STRAGGLERS. YOU'RE COOL WITH THE IDEA THAT HALF OR SO OF THE MAFIA TEAM, IN WHAT MAY HAVE BEEN A TOWN V. SCUM LYNCH, JUST...SHEEPS THEIR WAY ONTO SNB? IF I WERE MAFIA I WOULD HAVE BEEN FLIPPING OUT IN QT SAYING THAT WE COULDN'T HAVE A BUNCH OF PEOPLE LIMP ONTO SNB, I'D PUSH FOR A NO LYNCH OR TO THROW MORE VOTES ON SLAM TO TRY AND DRIVE EXTRA CANDIDATES (IF SLAM TOWN). BUT YOUR TEAM BASICALLY LIMPS ONTO A TOWN LYNCH IN A TOWN V SCUM SCENARIO IF OATS IS MAFIA AND THAT'S ... NOT SITTING WELL WITH ME. I LIKE CAPS. On May 01 2014 05:31 WaveofShadow wrote: Hey hey, if you WOULD lynch one of those people, then the key thing to do is to type it out with a vote in front of it, so that you actually ARE lynching one of those people.Foolishness can I ask how I fit in to all this exactly? Am I 25 or 75? And I am pretty curious as to how Bh's gumshoe lynch fits into your mason QT exactly. Honestly it wouldn't surprise me if RoL and Oats are town in this game----for me to be as apathetic as I've been to think that people who normally lurk (like RoL) are similar isn't a stretch. Except of course that apparently this kind of game is the ideal for RoL who hates spam. And I dunno oats is just oats. I'm still pretty damn certain this game is just over, hence the apathy. So much idgaf in this game from me and mostly everyone else, it sucks for the people who are fighting against a brick wall. Like Austin. Also cephiro only pops up with large vomit posts when people remember he's around. Curious coincidence. I'd lynch RoL or ceph or oats today I guess considering I don't have anything useful to add. The BH-foolishness thing seems legit and kinda difficult for even someone like BH to come up with if they were both scum. Everyone is standing around. Or ... sitting at computers. If you WOULD vote someone who is a legitimate lynch option, DO vote them. If you SEE something, SAY something. Also this game is fine. It's apathetic, but oh well, it'll pick up the moment we lynch some scum or get claims or whatever. We've mislynched a whopping 1 time. That's it. Geript MIGHT have saved someone from a shot last night. We're fine. We post sirens, we lynch some scum, we win the game, ezpz. The above is part at oats, part at everyone who says they'd be willing to lynch x, y, or z. You signed up to play mafia, the game where you lynch people you think are scummy. You lynch them by VOTING them. The OP even tells you how. On April 15 2014 04:45 Ver wrote: Voting rules: 1. Voting is done in this thread . 2. This game uses Extended Majority Lynch (Must have majority by end of deadline, ex. if 3) Use ##Vote: Player or your vote will not be counted. I promise you that if you follow those directions, you can actually stick your vote on someone. There is NO downside. The game is about lynching mafia, with your votes. | ||
|
OdinOfPergo
United States840 Posts
##Donate 3 post to Austin ##Donate post to Jat for now I'm not going to write some long winded case.. I'll omit the things that happened d1. They are in the thread and we've done hashed around at them. Oats d2 though: On April 30 2014 08:45 Oatsmaster wrote: Whats with all these lurkers coming back and calling me scum??? So many sheeples. Poofter why do you keep pussyfooting around about shooting a dude? Shoot or dont, dont wave your gun around trying to scare people. On April 30 2014 09:36 Oatsmaster wrote: So why are only the scummy people voting for me poof? If im so super scum and austins case is based on reality then I should get wrecked right? Funny that its not happening. Maybe its because his case is not right. Which begs the question, what exactly are you sheeping? Is this innocent ignorence or intentional malice? Scummy.. I read Gumshoe (prob town), Austin (like if this guy isn't town gg.), and RoL (Who knows?) So I count only one questionable vote on you at all. On April 30 2014 09:39 Oatsmaster wrote: Dont you have any opinions poof? Seems like you dont want to take responsibility for your shot. Do you think gumshoe is town poof? Seem's like it's possible that if Poof is town and the general sentiment is that you probably shouldn't blast a dude who's not going to flip if you're not 100% sure he's scum.. there was still a decent chunk of d2 at this post.. What's the hurry? What's scummy about waiting for your scum reads to post more so you can be more sure about it? I mean, this is one of the scenario's that you'd think you'd want everyone to be pretty sure of. On April 30 2014 23:33 Oatsmaster wrote: prp im no lurker and you know it. wave so cutie Say's the guy with less post on d2 than me  ##vote: Oatsmaster On April 30 2014 09:41 Oatsmaster wrote: Foolishness is scum too btw in case anyone is still in doubt. this is like the only post you've made that I've cared for at all in the past 42'ish hours. Even the scum Foolish has managed to do more than that. Alls you've done is throw some dirt around.. and then say "this probably scum guy is still probably scum" | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
IF foolishness is scum, so also is Koshi most likely even though that makes very little sense. If foolishness is town Koshi could still be scum but most likely he is t. | ||
|
OdinOfPergo
United States840 Posts
Your main bullet point was my misunderstanding about your shot on Yama. One that if I remember correctly I actually talked about.. to you.. on N1. Odin miss understanding/interpreting something is a trait of scum Odin.. Man that's good to know. I mean otherwise, you know if I played bad all the time people might think I'm actually scum in.. all ... 100% of the games I've played.. This isn't even a meta read by you.. I feel like it's a obvious attempt at trying to push an agenda.. One that involves lynching a town while trying to make yourself look a little better should it actually have worked because I'm at least not strait afking. I'd be fine with your lynch but tbh I don't think it's even possible to try to make it happen today. But that's fine. There is always tomorrow and that will bring more clarity for everyone.. | ||
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
On May 01 2014 05:31 WaveofShadow wrote: Foolishness can I ask how I fit in to all this exactly? Am I 25 or 75? And I am pretty curious as to how Bh's gumshoe lynch fits into your mason QT exactly. Honestly it wouldn't surprise me if RoL and Oats are town in this game----for me to be as apathetic as I've been to think that people who normally lurk (like RoL) are similar isn't a stretch. Except of course that apparently this kind of game is the ideal for RoL who hates spam. And I dunno oats is just oats. I'm still pretty damn certain this game is just over, hence the apathy. So much idgaf in this game from me and mostly everyone else, it sucks for the people who are fighting against a brick wall. Like Austin. Also cephiro only pops up with large vomit posts when people remember he's around. Curious coincidence. I'd lynch RoL or ceph or oats today I guess considering I don't have anything useful to add. The BH-foolishness thing seems legit and kinda difficult for even someone like BH to come up with if they were both scum. It's as you said, you're apathetic and just kinda sitting around watching this game happen. Do I think you're mafia over the other people proposed today? No. But you fit the bill and need to be held accountable. The only reason there's no heat on you is because a boatload of other people are just that much worse than you. I do give you points for actually posting in the thread more than 6 times a cycle (cough RoL, Oats, cough) even though every post your write looks like you had to climb out of a well full of acid to do so. And what do you think about the people who are fighting against a brick wall? Desperate mafia or townies trying to win? | ||
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
On May 01 2014 06:13 Alakaslam wrote: K here is something. IF foolishness is scum, so also is Koshi most likely even though that makes very little sense. If foolishness is town Koshi could still be scum but most likely he is t. I'll reiterate that on day 1 I thought Koshi was town (just based off his posting and thread presence, I never did a hard analysis or anything). tehpoofter brings up some good points though that can't be ignored. I don't think Koshi should be lynched today (and probably not tomorrow either) because there's a handful of other people that need to be taken care of first (myself, Palmar, Oats, RoL, Caller, etc.). | ||
|
Blazinghand
United States25553 Posts
On May 01 2014 06:20 Foolishness wrote: I'll reiterate that on day 1 I thought Koshi was town (just based off his posting and thread presence, I never did a hard analysis or anything). tehpoofter brings up some good points though that can't be ignored. I don't think Koshi should be lynched today (and probably not tomorrow either) because there's a handful of other people that need to be taken care of first (myself, Palmar, Oats, RoL, Caller, etc.). Foolishness is right in that there are bigger fish to fry. Look, I think we can say pretty certainly there's scum amongst the people who like never contributed, voted, and weren't on main wagons at the end of D1, right? We don't want these people alive at LYLO, and our vigis would have shot them by now if they were going to. Realistically speaking I think a guy like Gumshoe is NOT going to play well as town ANYWAYS so even if by some longshot he's town, he was a liability regardless. That being said, as always I am willing to consolidate. We have just a few hours left now so we should all say who we're willing to vote for so we can get an idea of what's possible. Remember, it's majority lynch here. | ||
| ||
