Catastrophe Mafia - Page 153

On April 06 2014 06:55 austinmcc wrote:
I, too, possess a penis.

Hey Robik, would you care to chat, except that if either of us wants to use the word "fuck", we have to replacing it with the word "Robitussin"? Specifically, I'm interested in the HF side of this:

On November 24 2012 05:40 syllogism wrote:
I was going to wait until tomorrow so I could see who people are pushing today without me, to an extent, locking down discussion. I don't think it's particularly working though and kita can't wait (whether he is town remains to be seen, but I don't think it's worth the gamble).

I'm fairly certain that sandroba is mafia. He hasn't done anything useful whole game long and he definitely could have. Everything that I've said about him before is still applicable. Even if he has been busy, it was by choice. No one forced him to run for election and he could have at any time dropped out and supported me. If he was town, I think he would have as soon as he figured out that I'm town.

Moreover, his attitude when he came back is still wrong. Instead of attempting to convince me or even address me, he just addresses everyone generally. He claims that I have been paranoid about his alignment in merc mini and that 80+ player game, but that is false or an exaggeration. In the huge game I was, in fact, pushing him for mayor on day 1 (we were both town). In merc mini I was only slightly suspicious because his ability completely broke the game, but I never wanted to lynch him at any point; the only suspicions were voiced over PM.

If he was town, he would be attempting to convince me, not play down my ability to read him accurately. To those who believe sandroba is town, what do you think mafia did on day 1? Who is mafia? Did they really have no one who could have ran and won? Do you think it's kita or acro were the mafia candidates then?

On April 06 2014 06:58 Keirathi wrote:
Okay, already in just the first few pages of syllo's filter from CT, there is a glaring thing missing from him in this game. Syllo and sandro are super good friends, and discuss mafia games between each other all the time and have an uncanny knack for reading each other. In CT, syllo kept poking at sandro trying to get a read on him, and then posted this:



The whole thing is pretty telling of their relationship, but the bolded in particular: why isn't syllo trying to convince sandro that he is town this game? Why does he seem to be avoiding sandro altogether?

Yea, I think syllo is probably scum.

On April 06 2014 07:05 yamato77 wrote:
Even that is too complicated.

The case on Syllo can be distilled to this:

Read his filter. Does that look to you like one of the best town players to ever play the game?

On April 06 2014 06:57 IAmRobik wrote:

Well HF has been scummy all game. The way he's playing this game looks nothing like Heavyweight Champ to me and I'd Robitussin lynch him in a heartbeat if he keeps up this shittastic style of Robitussin play.

On April 06 2014 06:58 Keirathi wrote:
Okay, already in just the first few pages of syllo's filter from CT, there is a glaring thing missing from him in this game. Syllo and sandro are super good friends, and discuss mafia games between each other all the time and have an uncanny knack for reading each other. In CT, syllo kept poking at sandro trying to get a read on him, and then posted this:



The whole thing is pretty telling of their relationship, but the bolded in particular: why isn't syllo trying to convince sandro that he is town this game? Why does he seem to be avoiding sandro altogether?

Yea, I think syllo is probably scum.

On April 06 2014 07:05 LSB wrote:

Don't how how legit is this meta analysis. Can anyone else verify this?

I find it really odd to simply finger someone simply because he didn't really analyze one person out of the other 28. I'll look at his filter though

On April 06 2014 07:15 Keirathi wrote:

You're missing the point. It isn't that he hasn't analyzed sandro, it's that he hasn't *INTERACTED* with sandro. If syllo was town, then (as he mentions in the post I quoted) why wouldn't he be trying to convince the person best able to read him that he was town?


*Note: in case it wasn't clear - in CT, syllo was town and sandro was scum.

On April 06 2014 07:16 WaveofShadow wrote:

Is syllo worried about not being considered town?
Devil's advocate: mebbe syllo doesn't feel that he needs sandro to know he's town?

On April 06 2014 07:08 austinmcc wrote:
I didn't play in or read Heavyweight, is there a specific difference or just overall feel?

I've been worried about him on a different axis, which is mainly just that he's willing to look at past games from EVERYONE (Foolishness posts like this in Shadow, someone in Newbie somethingIV, VA has been explicit in past games that he doesn't like catching up on threads, etc.), but was scummy on DI for a while. And again, while it's super shitty, DI has a well-agree-upon very very very easy to read scum style, which is don't post don't do stuff get killed because you're lololololol obvious. It's out of place to be reading all these past games and commenting on them here, and then be scummy on DI.

His activity is high, I don't dislike most of his comments, but just that and a crappy comparison between his trolling and Palmar's trolling (in defense to marv's voting him for antagonizing you and trolling /w palmar early) are under my skin. I've played against scumHoly before and don't have anything particular in mind that he did that game, he generally looked town and got along until maybe tripping himself up on some crucial votes/reads late.

So what in particular is missing? Beyond that, I think that you should open yourself up to the truth about radiation. X-rays, cancer treatments, ...infrared thermometers? Radiation does a lot of helpful things for mankind. I think you're giving it a bad rap.

On April 06 2014 07:25 Holyflare wrote:
Robik hasn't read a single shitting thing about me or this game. He still called amiko scum even after he claimed 3p rofl. He hasn't said squat about my role. I've been picking out Foolishness posts after everyone who robik seemingly hates but trololol who cares right? Just spout terrible reads and some will be right!

On April 06 2014 07:09 WaveofShadow wrote:
You getting all this Koshi?

On April 06 2014 07:28 IAmRobik wrote:

I HAVE been reading you this game. And I read your last game. I even said "I'd lynch the shit out of Holyfare this game, after we lynch all the mafia" in heavyweight. I'm not getting the same impression this game. You're totally off kilt.