|
On March 20 2014 08:03 raynpelikoneet wrote:
thrawn give me something. anything.
It's true what Koshi says, you've not really been yourself in this game. But i don't think it makes you mafia. The problem is when i die there is a high chance you get lynched. So please something, anything.
i know exactly what he means. the problem is that you can't really tell what my thoughts are or something liek that right? and i'm not as involved in the scumhunt as I normally am?
the reason for the latter is dark souls 2, i've been playing in non stop at the expense of this game because it is so much more fun than reading pages of omgus. i kinda have this problem where if i don't immediately jump into conversation right at the very start of the game then it gets hard for me to form reads I fell confident about for a good chunk or maybe even all of D1.
as to the first problem, I can help you there. next time i do a PoE list i'll take notes of my thoughts while making the list and after that there won't be any doubt that i'm town. the PoE i did most recently was a result of about 2 hours or so of careful filter reading and for whatever reason I just didn't care to put my thoughts in the thread.
|
On March 20 2014 07:29 Tehpoofter wrote:
@GT Your entire filter is about HF being scum do you have any town reads? Any reads on other scum? Which of the lurkers is most likely to be a good town later assuming they're town. Like the tunneling you're doing on HF seems scummy someone said earlier having only one read tends to be maf sided I have to agree with that.
thrawn what do you think of this post?
|
OK I am wading through Piles and Piles of meta bullshit whilst catching up with the thread. I am going to ignore meta based cases from this point forward. If you can't explain why someone is mafia based on their actions in this thread you should not be trying to lynch that person as far as I am concerned.
|
On March 20 2014 07:53 Palmar wrote:
Thrawn is mafia for his 3rd townread. I don't believe for a second that anyone following the thread could possibly have his third strongest townread at the time on poof who basically said nothing at the time. There was more than enough content in the thread at the time to come up with a reasonable third townread. Not to mention his first 2 townreads was basically just copying thread sentiment (koshi/rayn). And when I pushed him for not including me he had no reason to think I'm mafia, just that one random list with little explanations from poof is better than everything I had posted up to that point based on different expectations of our play.
It's also super interesting and should not be forgotten that poof's venn diagram was missing some pretty obvious people, I think most notably hopeless and giggle, and it included VE who had at the time basically done jack shit. I'm not entirely sure it makes him scum and apparently he knows VE, but it's worth mentioning.
I actually agree with this on thrawn I don't think I would lynch him today but I think its a good point to look into later. He seemed to know I was town off something else no one was reading me town for could be too much information.
|
On March 20 2014 08:16 DarthPunk wrote:
OK I am wading through Piles and Piles of meta bullshit whilst catching up with the thread. I am going to ignore meta based cases from this point forward. If you can't explain why someone is mafia based on their actions in this thread you should not be trying to lynch that person as far as I am concerned.
I am assuming you are defending Vivax because in my opinion there is no real other case based on meta on anyone, is there?
|
On March 20 2014 08:15 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On March 20 2014 07:29 Tehpoofter wrote:
@GT Your entire filter is about HF being scum do you have any town reads? Any reads on other scum? Which of the lurkers is most likely to be a good town later assuming they're town. Like the tunneling you're doing on HF seems scummy someone said earlier having only one read tends to be maf sided I have to agree with that. thrawn what do you think of this post?
eh, my reaction to that post is that tehpoofter might be questioning the 'scummy guy" because that's what the thread wants to see. and the question "Which of the lurkers is most likely to be a good town later assuming they're town" doesn't seem like a real scumhunting hunting question, more like a nonsensical fake scumhunting question
i guess I am thinking that post is pretty scummy, lol
|
On March 20 2014 08:17 Tehpoofter wrote:Show nested quote +On March 20 2014 07:53 Palmar wrote:
Thrawn is mafia for his 3rd townread. I don't believe for a second that anyone following the thread could possibly have his third strongest townread at the time on poof who basically said nothing at the time. There was more than enough content in the thread at the time to come up with a reasonable third townread. Not to mention his first 2 townreads was basically just copying thread sentiment (koshi/rayn). And when I pushed him for not including me he had no reason to think I'm mafia, just that one random list with little explanations from poof is better than everything I had posted up to that point based on different expectations of our play.
It's also super interesting and should not be forgotten that poof's venn diagram was missing some pretty obvious people, I think most notably hopeless and giggle, and it included VE who had at the time basically done jack shit. I'm not entirely sure it makes him scum and apparently he knows VE, but it's worth mentioning. I actually agree with this on thrawn I don't think I would lynch him today but I think its a good point to look into later. He seemed to know I was town off something else no one was reading me town for could be too much information.
when is later? why not now?
|
Palmar super town for this posts and the other posts like it.
On March 20 2014 03:21 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On March 20 2014 02:48 raynpelikoneet wrote:On March 20 2014 02:45 Palmar wrote:On March 20 2014 02:12 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Palamr Giggletummy not posting a case right after promising to do so is not alignment indicative. There is no reason for mafia to clearly promise posting a case and then just not do it. They know they will be called out of it so what's the point? If mafia calls someone scum they know they are expected to post reasoning for it. It's not like he did not know what to say and just left because he could not follow up his earlier post.
I think it's bad logic to think so. rayn you're a dumbass. Mafia knows they get called out on contradictions, posting reads with no reasoning, lurking and various other things THEY STILL DO. All of these things are really obvious and can be avoided very easily. Yet we still lynch scum based on them all the time. My logic is great. Unless GT flips town in which case it was you bad logic that led to the lynch and I had nothing to do with it. What i am trying to say is that the act in itself is not alignment indicative. The reasons behind them might be. You know, basic stuff. I think you're bad. I propose that everyone who wants to kill giggletummy also announces whether they're agreeing with my reasons or your reasons and then we'll see whose reasons are better. This means that everyone who votes giggle will also say which case he's sheeping. a) Palmar's glorious case about failing to deliver on content. b) rayn's case about some random offhand comment about some irrelevant dude. ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/A39NgFT.png)
He is up there with Rayn and koshi for me.
VE just entered the thread at the point I'm reading and I liked his first post
On March 20 2014 03:15 VisceraEyes wrote:
I'm going to give you my thoughts on his entire filter because he has one and I can.
His intro post is odd because on the one hand it gives "content" which he then needs to explain if asked, but on the other hand it's content that is easily dismissable because A) it's so early and no one has done anything and B) the reasoning he gives is so nebulous and largely non-alignment-indicative that it can pretty much just be taken for what it is - an MSPaint drawing in a forum game. But he /does/ give reasoning so meh.
The weird part is where he states explicitly that he doesn't have a read on me, that he's pinging for a reaction and that you can ignore it. Like, okay fine. So he was pinging me.
But I have to wonder. What is he expecting from me that I must be scum because I'm not already tearing it up. After all, I'm among the first people in the thread in spite of my early disappearance. I was the first to Paint a Painting. THAT early in the game, I'd say most of that stuff is more town-indicative than scum-indicative.
Anyway moving on, he then interjects into the HF-DP discussion to ask HF if DP's read makes him scum, in a way that seems like he's on the DP-town side of things. This is...fine to me. He doesn't ask in a way that makes you think HF looks worse, he feels like he thinks HF and DP are BOTH town, which I sort of agree with.
And he then pockets Vivax hard. Not sure if intentional, but Vivax has said some townie things and I agree that he looks town, so he may have just been overstating it or whatever.
Ultimately I think Banks is PROOOOBABLY town. I just agree with a couple of the things he's saying in what he's not saying, and in spite of him consistently calling me scum I think he's probably town.
I like the stuff he says about Tehpoofter it shows a clear thought process happening and VE actually thinking and using those thoughts to make judgements about peoples alignment which is better than most of the people in this game.
I disagree with him and think Poofter is scummy for his opener and for outright ignoring any followup questions but that posts speaks more to VE's alignment then poofters IMO.
|
On March 20 2014 08:18 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On March 20 2014 08:16 DarthPunk wrote:
OK I am wading through Piles and Piles of meta bullshit whilst catching up with the thread. I am going to ignore meta based cases from this point forward. If you can't explain why someone is mafia based on their actions in this thread you should not be trying to lynch that person as far as I am concerned. I am assuming you are defending Vivax because in my opinion there is no real other case based on meta on anyone, is there?
No it's the hopeless/Cultured/scooby do bullshit that is hard to understand unless you played in those games.
|
On March 20 2014 03:22 Vivax wrote:Show nested quote +On March 20 2014 03:09 Koshi wrote:On March 20 2014 02:59 Vivax wrote:
Off the bat I would say hopeless, thrawn and giggle are scum. Full reasoning in roughly 6-8 hours when I'm awake and energized. As a preliminary I suggest you look at the timing when thrawn started posting seriously (hint: After Coag flipped, he +1d on Coag and went back to doing nothing previous to that).
Anyone who calls me scum for inactivity gets dumb-or-scum-points. I have a life outside of mafia sometimes, will post schedule if host allows it. Mafia always got crazy much shit to do. Way more shit then town. Fact. I don't even know if I'm allowed to post schedule yet but let me break down my day for you Koshi, since I think you are town and will probably listen to reason. I got up at roughly 5 AM, started reading the thread around that time, caught the train at 7:15, got to anatomy lesson at 8:00 where the dude talked about some guy breaking his tympanum while scratching the inside of his ear with a spaghetti during his cooking by causing a vagus nerve induced coughing reflex while doing so. They had to poull that piece of spaghetti out and it was al dente. Lessons went on until 15:15, last one was social psychology, topic interpersonal attraction, you need a hip to waist ratio of 0,9 to hit on girls, lesson of the day, brunettes in night clubs are considered the most attractive but blondes are hit on most often (lolz) and a bunch of other kinda questionable experiments. Waited for book shop to open so I could borrow a biochemistry book, drove home at 7:08. I'll show you the fucking train route planner on the internet if I have to. And now I'm frankly scared to wade through all of this thread in my condition cause I'd much rather do it while I'm not sleepdrunk lest you want me to post half-assed or fallacious stuff, and I cba to not sleep when I need to to play mafia. So do me a favour and cut me some slack until I can scumhunt properly. Kthxnight.
Don't like this post. If you can write a wall on your schedule you can write a wall on your top scum read. If you know people are at you about activity you have read the thread and therefore should have a scum read.
|
On March 20 2014 03:27 thrawn2112 wrote:
excuse me for not wanting to wade through your early shitposting hf. lately I think you've been really townie but that stuff in the beginning reminded me of all the reasons I hate playing mafia. you were being needlessly antagonistic. i'm not dp, and despite not knowing his alignment I felt bad for him because of how you were playing the bully. you were accusing DP of doing nothng while at the same time, spending all of your energy making sure that he can't get anything accomplished thanks to your constant one liner interjections and useless insults. all of which (the insults and useless one liners) made it really hard for me to judge either of you based the arguments you were having, so I decided I wasn't going to care about your alignments until you guys started doing other things. and that is why I asked you to stfu about dp.
so yes, in the context of my job as a townie I am bad for skimming all of that, but I don't care
This post is really townie. Thrawn unlynchable for me today.
|
Okay DarthPunk has to be town.
|
On March 20 2014 04:02 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On March 20 2014 03:35 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Holyflare do you still think thrawn is mafia? Leaning heavily towards yes
This makes no fucking sense based on thrawns posts prior to rayns question. He is looking pretty town.
On March 20 2014 04:06 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On March 20 2014 04:02 Holyflare wrote:On March 20 2014 03:35 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Holyflare do you still think thrawn is mafia? Leaning heavily towards yes Well this is where we heavily disagree. 
Yep. Rayn is good at mafia :D
|
|
|
for making me doubt HF lol
|
On March 20 2014 04:25 VisceraEyes wrote:
I don't have to do shit friend. I like the lynch and I like both of your reasons. You can't make me choose.
LOL this is really townie from VE.
|
|
|
On March 20 2014 08:41 VisceraEyes wrote:
Caught up DP?
Nah i'm on page 68.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
