|
United States23745 Posts
On January 11 2014 02:58 Balla24 wrote:
@OWB how do you justify having DW as a scum read yet you continue to vote dnyarri even though DW wanted dnyarri lynched yesterday?
I haven't voted yet. I said I was okay with the dnyarri vote but I hadn't committed to it because I wasn't convinced it was completely the right lynch. As I said my suspicion lies on
vote: Day_Walker
Sadly these accusations come at a bad time as I am at work and don't have the time to come up with a concrete defense. I know Balla will say this is like the last game I was scum and I must say the parallels are quite unfortunate. Sorry that my play was wishy washy, it's just the way a play and I realize it's actually poorly suited for wwinning games.
|
My opinion on BigDad:
BigDad is suspicious and currently I don't have problem with lynching him. Since the start of the D2, BigDad has said multiple times that he'd be very happy to lynch me for being lurker, which is ok. Other than that, he doesn't seem to have strong opinions about anyone, saying hes cautious of another mislynch.
About his comment on death of JonnyLaw, BigDad said this:
He facilitated discussion through his aggressive play. Day one for JonnyLaw was pretty full on, check it out. He went after TheChyz, theDragoon, BigDad, Asuna and OWB.
I looked at JonnyLaw's filter and it's clear that JonnyLaw was actively going after BigDad too until theDragoon and later I got all the attention. Yet BigDad didn't mention that. Did he try to hide the fact that he was suspicious too? I would have expected "transparency" from BigDad since he was supposedly promoting it. JonnyLaw's death is easily explained if BigDad is scum.
In his last post, BigDad said this:
I think you've missed what I'm asking Balla24. Let me put it in context, day one I was suspicious of Day_Walker however his posts on lurkers and dnyarri swayed me a little to his side a little more. Since then this is one of the more solid accusations I've read, and it comes from a player who I've had previous doubt for.
Now that Day_Walker voted for onlywonderboy, I'd like to hear BigDad's opinion again, especially since onlywonderboy is under fire now.
|
United States23745 Posts
|
Day 2 vote count:
onlywonderboy (5): TheChyz, chinstrap, suki, Balla24, Day_Walker
Day_Walker (1): onlywonderboy
dnyarri (2): chinstrap, Balla24, BigDad, sidesprang, TheChyz, suki, Day_Walker
Not voting (2): Asuna, dnyarri
Currently, onlywonderboy is set to be lynched.
Deadline is Friday, Jan 10 10:00pm GMT (GMT+00:00) (in ). Voting is mandatory!
If there are errors, please let us know.
|
|
|
On January 11 2014 03:49 dnyarri wrote:
About his comment on death of JonnyLaw, BigDad said this:
<quote>
He facilitated discussion through his aggressive play. Day one for JonnyLaw was pretty full on, check it out. He went after TheChyz, theDragoon, BigDad, Asuna and OWB.
</quote>
I looked at JonnyLaw's filter and it's clear that JonnyLaw was actively going after BigDad too until theDragoon and later I got all the attention. Yet BigDad didn't mention that. Did he try to hide the fact that he was suspicious too? I would have expected "transparency" from BigDad since he was supposedly promoting it. JonnyLaw's death is easily explained if BigDad is scum.
BigDad did mention it?
|
On January 11 2014 03:48 onlywonderboy wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2014 02:58 Balla24 wrote:
@OWB how do you justify having DW as a scum read yet you continue to vote dnyarri even though DW wanted dnyarri lynched yesterday? I haven't voted yet. I said I was okay with the dnyarri vote but I hadn't committed to it because I wasn't convinced it was completely the right lynch. As I said my suspicion lies on vote: Day_Walker Sadly these accusations come at a bad time as I am at work and don't have the time to come up with a concrete defense. I know Balla will say this is like the last game I was scum and I must say the parallels are quite unfortunate. Sorry that my play was wishy washy, it's just the way a play and I realize it's actually poorly suited for wwinning games.
The problem is you could have answered some of Suki's concerns about you last night or beforehand. You didn't so now you can't defend yourself. Gah.
|
On January 11 2014 04:07 Day_Walker wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2014 03:49 dnyarri wrote:
About his comment on death of JonnyLaw, BigDad said this:
<quote>
He facilitated discussion through his aggressive play. Day one for JonnyLaw was pretty full on, check it out. He went after TheChyz, theDragoon, BigDad, Asuna and OWB.
</quote>
I looked at JonnyLaw's filter and it's clear that JonnyLaw was actively going after BigDad too until theDragoon and later I got all the attention. Yet BigDad didn't mention that. Did he try to hide the fact that he was suspicious too? I would have expected "transparency" from BigDad since he was supposedly promoting it. JonnyLaw's death is easily explained if BigDad is scum. BigDad did mention it?
My problem with what bigdad said there was that he didn't conclude anything from Jonnylaw's death. He gave a general statement. He didn't even come up with the fact that mafia might be trying to frame him by killing Jonnylaw. Just cause he mentioned that jonny went after him doesn't mean he's being transparent.
|
@Day_Walker
Well that's awkward. I just didn't notice that... I hope you don't think that I was relying on somebody not seeing it. Of course this somewhat lowers my suspicion, but I'm still willing to lynch BigDad. His playstyle in D2 just seems so scummish to me.
I'd still like to hear his new opinion on you Day_Walker.
|
@OWB, if you're still around and you can't defend yourself, can you at least give your 5 sec read on BigDad?
|
You too Day_Walker. Why or why not BigDad = scum? Since you have more time apparently.
|
|
|
Day 2 vote count:
onlywonderboy (5): TheChyz, chinstrap, suki, Balla24, Day_Walker, dnyarri
Day_Walker (1): onlywonderboy
dnyarri (2): chinstrap, Balla24, BigDad, sidesprang, TheChyz, suki, Day_Walker
BigDad (1): Balla24
Not voting (1): Asuna
Currently, onlywonderboy is set to be lynched.
Deadline is Friday, Jan 10 10:00pm GMT (GMT+00:00) (in ). Voting is mandatory!
If there are errors, please let us know.
|
I think overall I still prefer owb over bigdad just because of my case on him that I made about all of the things he did before the Dragoon vote. However it may just be that I'm just slightly tunnel visioning on him more than bigdad. I think that both owb and bigdad have had useless day 2 posts (maybe a little more on bigdad's side) but that still doesn't overcome argument I made on owb.
|
@Dnyarri, what is your opinion on sidesprang?
|
Need answers. Lynching scum depends on it.
|
Is this what happened last dealine also? Where nobody was here and then suddenly in the last 15 minutes most people show up
|
No because this time I am specifically asking them questions and for some reason they are not here.
|
This is what happens when we spend the beginning of the day discussing the lurker and nothing else. Scum gets to lurk themselves because everybody wants to kill the lurker.
|
ya nobody is wanting to really give their opinion near deadline and its especially important as town to do so because scum might make a slip about something accidentally.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
