|
On March 30 2013 12:36 layabout wrote:
As far as other scum go i don't see ryu being town after reading his discussion with DP i don't think it was 2 townies shouting at each other.
As far as the final two go It could realistically be any from:
kenpachi glurio doyouhas
I was hoping kenpachi would get vigged. kenpachi has done nothing to make me think he is town and has been voting with very little supporting arguments then afking a lot which is something scum would be more inclined to do.
If you are asking about yourself geript and glurio i would say that:
I am unsure about you DYH. You were carrying out independent analysis early on but your play yesterday furthered mafia objectives not town ones. I feel like glurio could be scum but since glurio wants to lynch kita and ryu who i am confident about i am hesitant to lynch him .I labelled geript towny early on and haven't had reason to change that label.
That is one of my many regrets this game. If I had come back after the 3p claims I would have retracted my vote on you and probably shifted it to kita.
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On March 30 2013 11:14 ThePeashooter wrote:Show nested quote +On March 30 2013 10:40 kitaman27 wrote:On March 30 2013 10:14 ThePeashooter wrote:
So Kita, one thing that has been bugging me. When I asked you to post your thoughts on Wade Fell after putting forth an analysis on him, why didn't you do it? You literally never wrote anything about him at all. I'm curious to how you never thought to mention the most active/scummy/annoying player in the game at least once in your posting? I don't recall. I probably just missed the request since its not like I would purposely ignore something if asked. Day two I was mostly focused on WoS with my big case and then Wiggles after the dt claim. Generally I let early blue claims fix themselves with the night hits and take another look if they're still around latter. BH hadn't really caught my attention while I was looking elsewhere. The one thing that is bugging me is that how few people are willing to defend glurio, yet there are only a couple votes on him. Why didn't he catch your attention? He was blatantly lying and acting like a dipshit the whole game.
I remember taking a look at his filter and noticing how ridiculously spammy it was, but I'm pretty sure he wasn't one of the people I spent time analyzing on day two and I don't recall noticing anything that set off red flags. There were plenty of people I hadn't commented on at that point. In a perfect world I'd be able to write a case on every single player, but with the time restraints I had, WoS was my main time sink early that cycle.
On March 30 2013 11:15 WaveofShadow wrote:
Unvote: DoYouHas
Vote: Glurio
BA-BAM
Does this indicate that you no longer have a scum read on DYH or do you just think glurio has a better chance of flipping?
On March 30 2013 12:30 geript wrote:
Ok, sure whatever, nutter butter.
I have no idea what this nutter butter is, but I approve.
On March 30 2013 11:47 layabout wrote:
Yesterday kitaman27 was pushing for a cosmic lynch and pre-claim he may have been justified in doing so. However post-claim kitaman deliberately ignores the consequences of the claim, which there was plenty of evidence to support and very few reasons to doubt. Yesterday mafia benefitted the most from the lynch and kitman27 was aware of this but chose to push their agenda.
Why? Well he is mafia
##vote kitaman27
Even though Wiggles was town, doesn't mean he is correct. You quoting a dead man rather than coming up with a case yourself shows that you are trying to take advantage of this misguided suspicion.
As for your comment that "Yesterday mafia benefitted the most from the lynch" in reference to cosmic, I already explained how this was false.
The third party team likely comprised of three players, considering you were recruited the first cycle and the person cosmic chose to mason on day three never claimed in the thread.
Assuming there are 3-4 mafia players remaining, even if the mafia/third party overlapped, which I think is likely with you, they still would have had 5-6 votes. With a town mislynch last cycle, like you and cosmic were trying to push, we would have 5-6 townies remaining. Thus, the mafia and third party could have voted together to control the lynch today and achieve a mutual victory. Now how does this sense for mafia to benefit the most from a cosmic lynch?
|
sorry been afk, had to take son to the emergency room. he's fine but I am now just stepping in to vote so mafia doesn't win with me being modkilled 
I am voting for glurio for the sake of consolidation -- he is the candidate my two biggest scum reads (kenpachi and ryu) aren't voting for and my biggest town reads (TPS and geript) are voting for.
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
Sorry to hear about your son. Glad he's ok!
|
On March 30 2013 13:16 zarepath wrote:sorry been afk, had to take son to the emergency room. he's fine but I am now just stepping in to vote so mafia doesn't win with me being modkilled I am voting for glurio for the sake of consolidation -- he is the candidate my two biggest scum reads (kenpachi and ryu) aren't voting for and my biggest town reads (TPS and geript) are voting for.
Agreed good to hear your kid's ok. I'm a big softie now when I hear anything about anyone's kids.
Zare if you're sticking around for a lil' what are your thoughts regarding Ryu/Ken + Show Spoiler +(RYU AND KEN I JUST REALIZED THAT LOL STREETFIGHTER)
Kita DYH is not off my list as of yet but I do think glurio has a better chance of flipping. I had him pegged as scum all game but after we mislynched so many townies I started to doubt myself. I'm going to trust my read on this one.
|
Yah, I've gotten to be more of a softie on babies since doing the OB clinical. Unfortunately my sister-in-law is noticing. I may have to change baby diapers now.
|
Well if we are lynching glurio we need to consolidate
night
|
I don't like how quiet it is...somebody reassure me that it's just because scum can afford to lose somebody rather than because they're content that we're mislynching.
|
|
|
Night 5
And yet another innocent died. Our stunning arrogance had played into the hands of our puppet masters. Glurio the Fool was killed in a silent mob of dispassionate violence.
|
If I am not mistaken, scum has won.
With 2 night kills, town is reduced to 8 players, 4 town and 4 scum. Town has no kill roles or protective roles left. So endgame then I suppose. I'll make a write up unless someone can correct me.
|
And sorry for the modding, couldn't keep up with the flavor and ended up way too busy to keep that going.
|
I doubt there are any more town KP and there clearly isn't a town roleblocker. Even if there were, we have 2 NKs for 2 nights in a row regardless of scum lynch.
Scum QT here
http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/3kPNZtBHBCUs
Out of curiosity can I get the OBS QT link?
|
Welp GG. I played like garb but at least most of the rest of town did too so I feel less guilty.
GG scum you guys did real well.
|
Congratuations Scum!
Kitaman27 the Devil
Geript the Snake
RyuSuzaku the Hero
Layabout the Minotaur
Wade Fell the Messenger
I'll need to read over the final 3 days but my estimation of this game is that town was unprepared to handle an active scumteam, particularly after a streak of games in which scum has played very passively. This is the danger of lynching lurky players or putting unreasonable pressure on a player to play to the effort level YOU expect. Even from an outside perspective, I thought Mr. Wiggles was a very bad mislynch and one of the most obviously protown players in the thread.
Also seems at a glance that kitaman27 might be deserving of MVP for figuring out what cosmicomics was doing through tricking layabout into believing he was converted himself.
|
GG scum.
Sorry for my drop in activity and content, no internet means mainly posting from mobile. Big cases are a real pain on a shitty device.
|
I understand the wiggles lynch, but I agree it's pretty bad. It's a lynch that just 'happened.' His "I'm going to get lynched so here's my reads and you need to follow up on them" was exceptionally pro-town imo. I'm really dying to know why people thought I was town.
|
You should have listened to me Town.
|
|
|
Also, Glurio I thought you actually played pretty decently considering; I'd just like to see 2-3 times the activity. I forget which point it was exactly maybe around when you made the "sheeping vivax" post but definitely by the point when you called me out for tunneling I wasn't sure that we'd be able to mislynch you.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
