TL Mafia LVII - Page 145

On September 24 2012 09:57 BloodyC0bbler wrote:



TBH I honestly do not feel his claim was "super dumb" as everyone makes it out to be. It was stupid in retrospect but the OP did not indicate that NN were unaware of their alignment and if you read the thread up until I outed him for it no one was attacking him for his claim being fake as hell, but that it was more oddly claimed.

Even before Palmar confirmed they did not know their alignment the town should have realized something was amiss when literally no one else claimed NN to verify mattchews claim. That in its own right should have been the proof to get him lynched barring a mod post. Had it not been for a player such as myself, and any other player who has hosted (very few I believe in this game) near no one else thought to even ask so the claim was only bad given that certain people were almost sure to ask questions.


For the rest of your team play though I think you guys were slightly too passive and should have exerted a bit more control. You guys could have easily pushed a misslynch onto a few people with a bit of effort and when it came down to the lynch snb died in I have no idea well, how you did. Given that a mafia member was required to get you lynched over a townie you could have coasted safely by never having allinson vote for your death thus auto win the game basically.

On September 24 2012 11:19 slOosh wrote:
I enjoyed being bulletproof. Please give me more such roles
I also dunno how the SnB lynch went down but that was fun.

strongandbig
09-04-2012
09:34 AM ET (US)
Here's my plan.

I claim scum in thread and pretend to ragequit. However I say matt's not on the scum team but i'm ragequitting because there's no good players on the scum team and all the scum have slipped already.

Then goodkarma you swap your vote off of mattchew and onto me and try really hard to get people to vote me.

Then town lynches mattchew anyway because they're not morons.

Then during the night phase I reveal my breadcrumb that my ragequit post was fake and claim a vig shot on goodkarma, who suicide bombs.

Alternatively if we want to put even more of our eggs in one basket we could have darthpunk or someone else scummy as fuck do the attempt to swap the vote from mattchew onto me and we could use a scum kp on that person and have me deliver it.

You guys have like three hours to persuade me that we can win normally or else I'm doing it.

On September 24 2012 13:37 strongandbig wrote:


lynching me wasn't a team decision or anything. imallinson just did it while I was off playing dota, and I'm still not sure why he did.

and re the fake nosy neighbor claim, claiming like that is "super dumb" in an open setup where it is actually verifiable. If you're going to do it at all it should only be done either in games where self-aware millers are confirmed to exist or in games with a closed setup like deathnote, where I had just done the exact same thing but where I knew that the hosts wouldn't tell anyone how the miller mechanic worked or even whether there was one.

On September 24 2012 21:56 Toadesstern wrote:

There's absolutely nothing wrong with doing the following via pm:
"sup Palmar, your OP doesn't exactly state it but something in there *include whatever reason here* makes me think the millers/NNs are self-aware. Is that true? I'm kind of considering to claim that"
"no dude they're not"
"kk thanks, almost claimed NN! :p"

I really don't get it how something like we had this game can happen. Matt's definitely the new VE when it comes to claiming I guess.

On September 24 2012 21:57 marvellosity wrote:


Matt has a splendid Normal resumé with LI and LVII

On September 24 2012 23:40 ShiaoPi wrote:


I did as well

1-7 Record now QQ

Also guys sign up for GSL2 mini, DrH's game will take some time to fill up anyway!

On September 24 2012 07:37 Bill Murray wrote:

i thought i had until now

2 days later

On September 25 2012 00:05 ShiaoPi wrote:


Ah well, should probably started to play properly earlier, could have avoided the entire ugly endgame that way
Also, you deserve the win as well. Your angry raging townie act was pretty good!