Pick Their Power Mafia 2 - Page 47

On July 26 2011 20:51 DropBear wrote:
In fact, what makes Lanaia and redFF good lynches?

On July 26 2011 21:00 DropBear wrote:
...... That isn't going to convince me to get behind you.

You didn't answer my question about Wiggles. Why are you so sure he is SK?

On July 26 2011 13:57 Amber[LighT] wrote:


Lol you want to force BC to be role checked which has NOTHING to do with the events of Day 1, YET Jackal [Harry Fucking Potter] gets to go without posting since the idea of having Dropbear claim. Once that happens Jackals posting completely stops. Weird huh?

On July 26 2011 21:00 DropBear wrote:
...... That isn't going to convince me to get behind you.

You didn't answer my question about Wiggles. Why are you so sure he is SK?

On July 26 2011 21:20 Foolishness wrote:

Why not? I randomly picked a person who's relatively inactive and someone who's half trolling and has barely posted anything longer than 3 lines. That's just like you right? You randomly picked between flavor text lynch, policy lynch, and anger lynch right? I mean your reasoning for your vote made a nice bloodstain on my wall. Perhaps you can refresh my memory on why BC needs to die?

I'm going to vote for the troll now, redFF. Should be obvious when you click the filter button what I mean.

On July 26 2011 21:41 DropBear wrote:

I have said before that jackal, the flavour text lynch is a bad idea. It is interesting that he is disappeared but it isn't enough of a reason to lynch him.
I don't know who you mean by the policy lynch and the anger lynch but I'm assuming BC is one of them.

I would like to kill BC for a few reasons.

- Firstly for trying to stop supersoft using a DT check. There is no reason to do this.
- Second, because he is shitting up the thread, arguing wildly about something that isn't really that important. When he was my scumcoach for XVIII he advocated this as an underused and highly effective scum strategy.
- Third, because he is strongly suggesting that supersoft could be Mafia which I now know is impossible. We used this argument of "he killed his scumbuddy to buy town cred" to get Palmar lynched over bumatlarge in PTP1. And it's a ridiculous argument.

If supersoft is also Mafia, then he had no need to kill Tackster. I was saying that supersoft killed him, he could have just gone "yeah sorry guys I suck and I used my ability and now Mafia knows who I am "

- Fourth because of his bizarre chainsaw defence of you early on which immediately set off alarm bells for me.

Additionally, if you want me to vote with you at any point in this game, why not show me some reasoning rather than casting insults?

On July 26 2011 22:10 Foolishness wrote:

1) When the result of the check shows up red and we lynch the person and they flip Green what are you going to do? Kill supersoft?

1a) He flips green. Great, we wasted 2 days minimum and did no scumhunting
1b) He flips red. This is fine since 1 for 1 trade.

When his results turn up green, are you going to kill that person to confirm? No cause that's just silly. So are you going to leave said person alone the rest of the game? If this was a normal game that'd be dandy but this is PTP. There could be framers, roleblockers, heck the mafia may have already converted supersoft to their team by now.

I am for the check but his reasons for not wanting to use it aren't an issue. Let me be clear: BC is worried about the town misusing the information (as am I, that's why I want a check on a random person instead), which is an all too common theme in mafia. His solution to the problem of "the town is going to misuse this information" is preventing the town from getting the information in the first place. Given the track record of the town so far I don't blame him. One mafia is already dead through stupidity why take the chance with a DT check in a game where people have bizarre roles when we can just analyze and let DT's do work later in the game.

And speaking of analyze, redFF is acting just like in BC's game where he flipped red. Make a lot of one liner troll posts, then a 2 paragraph post to try to blend in and/or justify his post, rinse and repeat. That's what he's doing this game too. BC can be held accountable in the near future if he disappears. If he survives this lynch then goes afk we auto lynch him easy. He knows that so no matter what his role is he'll be around. (On the same note, if Jackal continues being afk we should lynch him tomorrow as well.)

2) It's very important whether the check gets used and who it gets used on. I'm banking that one of the people arguing with BC is mafia for the exact reasons you stated.

3) fine, I wouldn't rule it out as impossible since this is PTP mafia, but Occam's Razor says he's town and that's good enough for me.

4) link or it didn't happen. Wait I know this didn't happen so don't bother.

On July 25 2011 14:17 BloodyC0bbler wrote:



Any reason why you chose to rhyme in your last post? Prob a random accidental click of tlpd

On July 26 2011 21:26 Jackal58 wrote:


Ya it is. Work happened. I had to go to Juarez Mexico to rescue one of our aircraft that was loaded with car parts and broken. It happens. That's part of my job. If I can't walk the flight crew through a fix I go and fix it for them. I just got back to the shop. I've been gone for about 20 hours.
I'm going home to get some food and some sleep. If you want to lynch me for having a job feel free. Right now I don't really fucking care.
BC and Amber are the two scummiest people in this game. But you all want to lynch me because ON flipped town. I had nothing to do with his role, his alignmen,t his death, or his flip but I'm fucking guilty because I thought I was preventing town from making a mistake. Lynch me. Don't care. Derps.
I'll be back later.

On July 26 2011 23:04 Amber[LighT] wrote:Scum.

Get checked by Supersoft or ask for a replacement if you're going to come back with excuses about work. I missed 2 lynches in AA because my work schedule doesn't allow me to post at 9 PM but at least I tried to justify every action I made [as scum too].