Insane Mafia - Page 15

On November 01 2010 03:42 youngminii wrote:

No comment.


Doesn't that mean the bodyguard can't get hit at night by scum anyway?

On November 01 2010 03:49 Pandain wrote:


Is it that revealing this will reveal another aspect of your role that can be vital for town? If so, just say that. Because as of now you dodging just makes me incrediably wary of you. If you can't explain in thread, then I would suggest we somehow incorporate youngminii into a pming circle. I'm unsure how to do that however while still trying to get the doc(doc h that is) connected. Also, if the bodyguard can only be lynched it actually would be advisable for the bodyguard to claim so then we don't lynch him. Of course, that seems a bit OP for town so I would think there must be a lynch-related role of changing the lynch target...

Hmm..... if only there was such a role...

*wonder why I'm so suscipcious of you*

On November 01 2010 04:01 Pandain wrote:


Huh missed this. I didn't think a bus driver was able to switch lynches....
And I'm confused by what you mean by "hide during the night."

And I disagree about a role immune to lynches being a town role. To me, a role immune to night hits would be town, a role immune to lynches would be mafia. Who's going to get hit at night? Town(mafia/town if there are vigis)
Who's going to be lynched in day?
mafia/town

A role involving immunity to lynches would almost certainly be a scum role in my eyes. If you can point out another game where it was not, I would be much obliged.


Well let's find out:

Artanis, can a bodyguard be lynched?

On November 01 2010 04:07 youngminii wrote:
Seriously Pandain? The lynch is the town's greatest weapon, you can't make scum immune to lynches without making the game horribly imbalanced.

In any case, why don't you think about it carefully before telling me to claim? If I'm invincible, no one will believe me. If I'm immune to lynches, mafia will kill me. If I'm able to manipulate something, that will make me just as suspicious as I am now.

Stop being an idiot and play the game properly. You always do this over-analytical crap which doesn't work. Go back a step and think before you post. Maybe you should start with the first post where clearly says PMs are not allowed.

On November 01 2010 04:17 youngminii wrote:
He didn't PM me, he seems to be using "why aren't you PMing others" as an argument.




Sorry Pandain, you're not an idiot, your arguments are.


So you're assuming that I can PM people and your argument is that I should be roleclaiming through PMs?

And please, tell me how letting me die is a good thing? Back up your arguments. In any case, your posts have been hugely scummy to me, but then again they always are. I've never been in a mafia game where you've given solid arguments as a townie.

On November 01 2010 04:22 youngminii wrote:

Translation: Aeres is scum and he's making up the role. By answering this question, I would be confirming the existence of the fake role and as such, I can't give a real answer.

Maybe.

On November 01 2010 04:23 infinitestory wrote:

If a lynch-swapping bus driver exists, I'm convinced that would be town, since otherwise we would be almost unable to lynch a mafia (a red lynch-swapping bus driver would always switch the lynch to a townie unless our top two in votes are reds every single time).

However, like I said earlier, that bus driver would have to be certain youngminii is valuable and by extension probably know his alignment. That would indicate either they're both mason-like roles (unlikely, since the bus driver is already a bus driver), or they're both reds. But I've already noted that a red lynch-swapping bus driver would be ridiculously OP. Contradiction.

Therefore, I'm convinced youngminii's role saved him, making him a likely blue.

On November 01 2010 04:24 Veldril wrote:
From what I see of the first day lynch; I think for this game, the top three votes will be taken into account. It is very likely that there is a role that would prevent the "top" voted player to avoid the lynch, be it one time or can use all the game long.

Young's case could be either ways; he has a role that immune to lynch (more likely one time, since permanent immunity is slightly too OP), or he has someone protected him with or without him knowing. We need to get more information before we can conclude which is the case.

Right now, I think it is agreeable that medic should protect veterans first. However; from what I see from Sinquity's role, I think most medics would also be able to cure Murrayitis, which could be a decisive factor in this game. But since we don't have any infected player yet, the curing of Murrayitis is moot for the time being, but it should be discussed more on the next night.

I want to ask you guys something too. Would it be a good idea to analyze the Murrayitis's mechanics and how it would affect the game in the long run? I think I find it's interesting but I'm not sure if other players agree or not.

On November 01 2010 04:46 youngminii wrote:

Why would you say this if you only think there are 2 bodyguards because of dcx's 'claim'?

On November 01 2010 06:45 Pandain wrote:


except I didn't, and I said we should try getting him into contact with a pm circle if he feels he shouldn't share. But fine, you have a good point about it being night. Afterwards, I'm still pushing for him to explain.

I don't want him to claim in thread if it hurts(thus through pms) and I don't even want him to claim entirely. I just want to know why he's not dead. Remember this is insane mafia, we need to make sense of what's happening.

Is it that revealing this will reveal another aspect of your role that can be vital for town? If so, just say that. Because as of now you dodging just makes me incrediably wary of you. If you can't explain in thread, then I would suggest we somehow incorporate youngminii into a pming circle. I'm unsure how to do that however while still trying to get the doc(doc h that is) connected. Also, if the bodyguard can only be lynched it actually would be advisable for the bodyguard to claim so then we don't lynch him. Of course, that seems a bit OP for town so I would think there must be a lynch-related role of changing the lynch target...

On November 01 2010 06:57 Coagulation wrote:
well regardless we need to get to the bottom of the youngminii thing somehow i think thats the point hes trying to make. i still feel like there is a good possibility that his ability is either a red ability or he was saved by a red allie. i dont want this to just blow under the radar

On November 01 2010 07:01 Lexpar wrote:
If I die tonight Doc H is almost definitely scum.