EPTOnly notable thing other than mobility feedus.
Tribunal Discussion! - Page 8
| Forum Index > LoL General |
|
GARO
United States2255 Posts
Only notable thing other than mobility feedus. | ||
|
Shikyo
Finland33997 Posts
| ||
|
Unentschieden
Germany1471 Posts
On May 22 2011 20:09 lynx.oblige wrote: How do you know if you successfully judge a case other than checking your IP in game? Is there like a record or something somewhere? They intentionally don´t tell you. You get an e-mail with the amount of IP you get but nothing regarding the cases because you are supposed to judge based on what you think is right and not that gives you the most IP. The scenario is that you could notice that you don´t get IP for pardoning "teachers", players that keep telling others how to play better. Thus you get a conflict: pardon behavior that may be annoying but isn´t probatable vs. earning IP. Right now the Tribunal is still in the test phases and is rigged against punishing innocents. I mean, 10 Games with an average of 7 reports... isn´t much of a decision. But what if it´s 3 games with 5 reports each? Should that guy get a warning or is that a case of a premade systematically reporting their enemies? | ||
|
Kratisto
United States199 Posts
| ||
|
BlackPaladin
United States9316 Posts
"8. Understand what "Punish" means "Punish" means that you believe some sort of action should be performed on this player - not necessarily a suspension or ban. It could be a warning or name change." Basically, if they lose their temper and act like an utter asshole, not necessarily troll but simply act like a hotshotgg all game long ripping on some guy (and this happens in 13 games or something retarded like that), then "punish" is acceptable just for them to get something like, a warning. Such as "Shut up, your raging isn't helping this game. Grow up. *slaps wrist*" | ||
|
Phrost
United States4008 Posts
| ||
|
LancerStarcraft
United States235 Posts
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/TjoLt.jpg) I think he wants to know why his team is attacking a tank of some sort? I could be misinterpreting. | ||
|
spinesheath
Germany8679 Posts
On May 23 2011 06:25 Phrost wrote: The thing that bothers me about the tribunal is like I feel each game its own entity. I had a case where 6/10 of them i dont think were entirely punishable but the other 4 were pretty much his fault. Do you punish this person because they broke rules in 4 of the games or do you give them the benefit of the doubt because they had been reported several other times for things that weren't their fault? I personally think that even if it's just one serious offense, you should hit punish. If there are 12 games listed, and 11 are him carrying hard and being nice, and one game he goes 0-30-0 Mobility/Zeal, then I'm going to hit punish. If it's only minor offenses, but many of them, that can warrant a punishment as well. All your judgement of course. You only see a selection of games anyways. I wouldn't assume that those guys get 5+ reports in every single game they play (aside from the ones who do nothing but Mobility/Zeal feed every single game). | ||
|
Jupiter.sKy
United States50 Posts
| ||
|
BlackPaladin
United States9316 Posts
On May 23 2011 06:25 Phrost wrote: The thing that bothers me about the tribunal is like I feel each game its own entity. I had a case where 6/10 of them i dont think were entirely punishable but the other 4 were pretty much his fault. Do you punish this person because they broke rules in 4 of the games or do you give them the benefit of the doubt because they had been reported several other times for things that weren't their fault? (Travian MH side coming out be warned zzzzz) Well with the tribunal, you have to look at them as a whole rather than separate cases imo. For example, the person could have just had bad games 6/10 times, but the other 4 if he's cursing people off, talking trash, intentially just trolling the crap out of everyone, that's still punishable, even if it's just a slap on the wrist by Riot. Remember, different cases but they're all of the same person. I know in Travian if someone did something really minor we'd ban them, wait for them to message us, and then unban them essentially with a slap on the wrist saying don't do it again. I'm sure it will be different with LoL but basically they don't deserve anything severe but they should at least know that it's not acceptable what they were doing. ;o I think out of 12 cases I only pardoned 2, and those 2 were guys literally trying hard, with legit builds (well the one's build was subpar but you could tell he was trying) and even trying to help teach their teammates the game: "Don't be bot while baron's up." But they would get angry, call people noobs, etcetc, you know, regular raging but nothing super srs. None of that stupid fucking mobility + zeal crap "herpderp i'm midddd" and then not say anything for the rest of the game. -_- | ||
|
Senx
Sweden5901 Posts
| ||
|
Irave
United States9965 Posts
On May 21 2011 15:46 Zato-1 wrote: If Riot really plans to reward 4 to 5 IP per correct vote, then... Fuck this. Not being worth my time is one thing, but giving such a pittance of a reward feels kind of insulting >> Oh man thats depressing I just reviewed my first few cases and was going to ask when we get rewarded. Oh well if it really is that bad, at least this was fairly entertaining to do. | ||
|
Ryuu314
United States12679 Posts
On May 23 2011 07:11 Senx wrote: If the guy has a shit ton of leaves/afks.. thats just so much worse than any kind of trash talking in my opinion. While the playing experience might not be very enjoyable, atleast you have a chance to win, not really if you're getting afkers/leavers. yea, afk/leavers or intentional feeders are teh worst. if they're just offensive and verbal you have a /ignore function that works extremely well | ||
|
napo
Romania622 Posts
| ||
|
waffleduck
125 Posts
 | ||
|
Natt
France253 Posts
On May 23 2011 07:18 Irave wrote: Oh man thats depressing I just reviewed my first few cases and was going to ask when we get rewarded. Oh well if it really is that bad, at least this was fairly entertaining to do. I actually read somewhere 500IP max per day. | ||
|
phyvo
United States5635 Posts
| ||
|
Hynda
Sweden2226 Posts
But it seems rather one sided. Don't think I've issued a single pardon yet. I always go through all the games and while I can find sometimes up to 3 games where I would go "Well this is silly, why would you report someone for this" the other 7 are filled with so much shit not even a mother could love that. I know it's supposed to be one sided but I wonder how anyone is going to be pardoned ever, best I've seen is someone get needlesly reported for 7 games but having 3 when he was a complete and utter asshat. But then again, even if it's just 1 game you balls it up, you should be punished. | ||
|
Ryuu314
United States12679 Posts
| ||
|
HazMat
United States17077 Posts
Lynerus[All] [03:50:26]: this one only got 2 Lynerus[All] [03:51:03]: its a jester hat Lynerus[All] [03:51:10]: its 3 points whys this one only got 2. Lynerus[All] [03:51:22]: fail riot Lynerus[All] [03:51:38]: 3rd one should bw white Lynerus[All] [03:51:41]: and in the center edit: Also, finally got my first pardon. It was some dude who had 3 cases of leaving where he had maximum of 2-3 deaths where he says nothing in chat except for "massive lag spike." I feel like riot put this in there to see if people automatically vote punish on everything. | ||
| ||
