US Politics Mega-thread - Page 2506
| Forum Index > General Forum |
Now that we have a new thread, in order to ensure that this thread continues to meet TL standards and follows the proper guidelines, we will be enforcing the rules in the OP more strictly. Be sure to give them a complete and thorough read before posting! NOTE: When providing a source, please provide a very brief summary on what it's about and what purpose it adds to the discussion. The supporting statement should clearly explain why the subject is relevant and needs to be discussed. Please follow this rule especially for tweets. Your supporting statement should always come BEFORE you provide the source. If you have any questions, comments, concern, or feedback regarding the USPMT, then please use this thread: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/website-feedback/510156-us-politics-thread | ||
|
farvacola
United States18839 Posts
| ||
|
Schmobutzen
Germany284 Posts
But yeah, in the moment it is a stark contrast to how the leader of the free world should view himself! | ||
|
farvacola
United States18839 Posts
All that said, I don't think historical comparisons like this are especially helpful given that they usually serve as a sort of fool's errand that folks who otherwise agree argue over. A lot of disputes over history end up that way. | ||
|
Schmobutzen
Germany284 Posts
| ||
|
Wegandi
United States2455 Posts
On July 18 2020 18:27 Furikawari wrote: * Your gvt is doing the best that it can to interfere in the vote mailing process, * In several states lead by people aligned with your gvt voting places are closed, strangely enough in areas that are recognized as being in favor of the other party * And to add to all of this, it also targets people that can't really afford to take a day off to vote It looks like a pattern isn't it? We could also speak about how your gvt reprehended police brutality. Oh wait, they didn't... Let's not even talk of what is going on in Portland. We could also speak about how the way your gvt handled covid puts your country in roughly the same category than Russia/Bolsonaro's Brazil. And yeah, this list could go on and on and... Qualifying your political opponent of "terrorist" (or enemy of the people or whatever semantically equivalent) is a well known rhetoric of the fascist gvt. And that's not even considering the fact that this is used to discredit the BLM movement. And btw there is no such things as "antifa terrorism" currently in the USA. Graffiti on courthouse and fed buildings? That's some high profile terrorism right here. (mind you that's what they use as an excuse for wath they are doing in Portland right now). I guess that it was a mistake and you didnt want to imply that fascism isn't bad. Your examples are very narrow and highly partisan. Many western democratic countries don't even have mail-in voting; what does that say about them? Are they too fascist? Why this point of contention when the subject is about expanding mail-in voting (earlier balloting process, improved accessibility, etc.), not contracting what is currently available? Is this like saying the Government is shrinking because instead of a 12% budget increase it's only 3%? As for the other points sure, but it's not limited to one party (just like gerrymandering, a topic I know many folks like to broach, but rarely do so unbiased). It's not like the US is some roller-coaster where a Dem is in power and we're now free, when a GOP is in power the boots on the throats! It's been a steady erosion of our liberties with some victories here and there, but generally American's are less free than we were two decades ago, and two decades less free than decades before, and you get the point. As for police brutality, that is a big problem, again, not limited by party, in fact Biden himself helped bring about the mess we are in so yay, I guess. Thanks Clinton for ya tough on crime BS, Nixon for the Drug War, and foreign policy consensus for the militarization of the police (All chickens always come home to roost as all Empires have shown throughout history). Then again, let's not point too many fingers as France has heavily cracked down on your own civil liberties after your terrorist attacks with new laws similar to our Patriot Act/NDAA and what not. Ya'll even protested a gas tax hike that was supposed to help the environment/fight climate change. Let's not act too high and mighty. What happened in Portland is atrocious. Feds absconding with folks (regardless if they committed a crime or not) in the manner they did is reprehensible, but it's not surprising for anyone watching over the last 30 years. In fact, on the list of bad things its probably not top 15 (yikes). Ruby Ridge, Waco, Wounded Knee, Tuskeegee experiments, etc. Obama unilaterally executing an American citizen, etc. Yadda Yadda Yadda. You want to make it out Orange Man bad, unprecedented, fascism, blah blah (he's just another in a long line of Presidents eroding our liberties). You're just ignorantly misinformed about America and the USG, or so blinded by your partisan/ideology to fail to see the obvious. By the way, last thing anyone should want is Antifa getting anywhere near power. Communism was so bad they had to invent a new word to describe its murdering horrors - democide. PS: You want to hear something funny - France abolished postal (mail in) voting in 1975. Holy shit, ya'll some fanatical fascists. But for Romain Rambaud, a specialist in electoral law, it would be disastrous to implement electronic or postal voting only one month before the election, as it would affect the stability of electoral law. "Voters would have huge difficulty adapting to and trusting this new system,” he writes on his blog, adding that it would introduce huge potential for errors and problems of electoral fraud. ^ lol. | ||
|
Wegandi
United States2455 Posts
On July 18 2020 21:04 farvacola wrote: Even if we assume that the authoritarian impulse remains relative unchanged from the 60s to now (which is probably a fair assumption), technology facilitates authoritarian behavior in a way that distinguishes today from prior historical contexts, particularly with regards to data collection and privacy. The federal courts are also arguably more closed off to claims against government actors than they were in the 60s as well, though that's a complicated subject. All that said, I don't think historical comparisons like this are especially helpful given that they usually serve as a sort of fool's errand that folks who otherwise agree argue over. A lot of disputes over history end up that way. Well we haven't had a Kent State, so was it worse than or now? Is killing people worse or kidnapping? Thats the thing some things are worse some are better, but the implication of some people is that the current times are always some existential unprecedented era so its a free for all. That shit is just ahistorical and ignorant. (Not saying you are in that boat, but the poster from France sure is) | ||
|
Furikawari
France2522 Posts
On July 18 2020 21:24 Wegandi wrote: Well we haven't had a Kent State, so was it worse than or now? Is killing people worse or kidnapping? Thats the thing some things are worse some are better, but the implication of some people is that the current times are always some existential unprecedented era so its a free for all. That shit is just ahistorical and ignorant. (Not saying you are in that boat, but the poster from France sure is) You sure make a hell lot of assumptions. That being said, considering you're disdain and the tone of your posts, you're not worth the time. | ||
|
Wegandi
United States2455 Posts
On July 18 2020 23:21 Furikawari wrote: You sure make a hell lot of assumptions. That being said, considering you're disdain and the tone of your posts, you're not worth the time. I'm just tired of hypocritical ignorant self-righteous Europeans (who just have to make their opinions known in a US politics thread about US politics). Feel free to ignore me if you want, but remember, Viva La Fascista France (damn, ya'll don't even have mail in ballots like us knuckle-draggers here in the States)! | ||
|
Furikawari
France2522 Posts
And btw, mail ballots is not what Trump is trying to block? Yeah I don't know enough about your politicis probably. And calm down on the personal attacks please. Regarding portland : www.commondreams.org I dunno much about USA politics, but I suppose ACLU is some form of antifa terrorist group... | ||
|
Erasme
Bahamas15899 Posts
On July 18 2020 23:35 Wegandi wrote: I'm just tired of hypocritical ignorant self-righteous Europeans (who just have to make their opinions known in a US politics thread about US politics). Feel free to ignore me if you want, but remember, Viva La Fascista France (damn, ya'll don't even have mail in ballots like us knuckle-draggers here in the States)! Worth noting that if you get your infos from fox news, those ignorants self-righteous europeans who consumes "liberals" news probably know more than you about the current situation of your country. | ||
|
Nouar
France3270 Posts
On July 18 2020 21:18 Wegandi wrote: Your examples are very narrow and highly partisan. Many western democratic countries don't even have mail-in voting; what does that say about them? Are they too fascist? Why this point of contention when the subject is about expanding mail-in voting (earlier balloting process, improved accessibility, etc.), not contracting what is currently available? Is this like saying the Government is shrinking because instead of a 12% budget increase it's only 3%? As for the other points sure, but it's not limited to one party (just like gerrymandering, a topic I know many folks like to broach, but rarely do so unbiased). It's not like the US is some roller-coaster where a Dem is in power and we're now free, when a GOP is in power the boots on the throats! It's been a steady erosion of our liberties with some victories here and there, but generally American's are less free than we were two decades ago, and two decades less free than decades before, and you get the point. As for police brutality, that is a big problem, again, not limited by party, in fact Biden himself helped bring about the mess we are in so yay, I guess. Thanks Clinton for ya tough on crime BS, Nixon for the Drug War, and foreign policy consensus for the militarization of the police (All chickens always come home to roost as all Empires have shown throughout history). Then again, let's not point too many fingers as France has heavily cracked down on your own civil liberties after your terrorist attacks with new laws similar to our Patriot Act/NDAA and what not. Ya'll even protested a gas tax hike that was supposed to help the environment/fight climate change. Let's not act too high and mighty. What happened in Portland is atrocious. Feds absconding with folks (regardless if they committed a crime or not) in the manner they did is reprehensible, but it's not surprising for anyone watching over the last 30 years. In fact, on the list of bad things its probably not top 15 (yikes). Ruby Ridge, Waco, Wounded Knee, Tuskeegee experiments, etc. Obama unilaterally executing an American citizen, etc. Yadda Yadda Yadda. You want to make it out Orange Man bad, unprecedented, fascism, blah blah (he's just another in a long line of Presidents eroding our liberties). You're just ignorantly misinformed about America and the USG, or so blinded by your partisan/ideology to fail to see the obvious. By the way, last thing anyone should want is Antifa getting anywhere near power. Communism was so bad they had to invent a new word to describe its murdering horrors - democide. PS: You want to hear something funny - France abolished postal (mail in) voting in 1975. Holy shit, ya'll some fanatical fascists. ^ lol. Mail-in voting is not controversial in France because we don't have elections on a weekday and people don't have to lose wages to attend. Those that work on sundays have the right to leave as long as necessary to vote with NO wage cut. We also have a national ID card system that makes it easy to vote. We also have an average of 800 to 1000 people per polling station (not voters, population. While the US has around 2000+ people per station average, which makes around 800 voters according to the paper below), which mean usually your polling station is less than 10minutes away by foot. Don't try to take an example that can't be compared. It's just not needed here. In the US one party is actively trying to get people the ability to vote (because it benefits them, of course, not out of kindness of their heart), while the other is actively trying to make things difficult, by removing polling stations, restricting mail-in voting, unregistering batches of people, requiring felons to pay their court dues when there is no system in place to inform them of how many they owe, etc etc etc, the list is pretty long. While some of those measures are justified, they are more often than not abused as best as they can. It's obvious one side has my sympathy more than the other. Elections should be decided fairly. Gerrymandering is a mixed bag, but I do believe it skews towards republicans more. Here is an (old) document with some more information and detailed statistics on the topic of large precincts and voter inconvenience : https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1410/1410.8868.pdf The economic and demographic factors that distinguish Democratic and Republican voters also distinguish their capacity to cope with voter inconvenience. Democratic voters often have more constrained voting schedules and more limited transportation options, and thus less flexibility in managing voting times. There is, in general, a greater loss of votes due to voter inconvenience for the Democratic candidate, than the Republican candidate. | ||
|
WombaT
Northern Ireland26078 Posts
Or elections are scheduled to be on weekends in some places, or holidays are declared for voting, it varies a lot. You could eliminate mail balloting without disenfranchising people if the scheduling is done in such a way. If none of the other measures are employed and mail balloting is restricted then you have a problem. | ||
|
Furikawari
France2522 Posts
| ||
|
Dan HH
Romania9137 Posts
On July 18 2020 21:18 Wegandi wrote: PS: You want to hear something funny - France abolished postal (mail in) voting in 1975. Holy shit, ya'll some fanatical fascists. Mail voting in the US is attempting to solve issues that don't exist in France due to automatic registration, voting on Sundays and virtually no queues outside of foreign consulates. I don't know why there isn't as big of a push for those other solutions as there is for mail voting, but the point of the poster you replied to was that opposition to it stems from not wanting to fix the electoral process by those that benefit from lower/filtered turnout rather than from a lack of necessity as in France. What baffles me about you and Danglars is how you take the appearance of the US more seriously and personally than anyone else here yet at the same time are the most dismissive about fixing the issues that cause those negative appearances. You are more upset with pesky TLers pointing out the willfully broken voting process rather than with the willfully broken voting process existing. | ||
|
Fleetfeet
Canada2606 Posts
On July 19 2020 02:43 Furikawari wrote: And regarding electronic vote, it's a joke, as a software developper I can tell you that I will ALWAYS fight against this. But on the other hand I understand why a guy like Wegandi thinks it's a good thing.... As long as the machine retailer are sold to republicans that is. No need to further the mudslinging imo. "Calm down on the personal attacks please" should apply to both sides. This thread definitely feels left-leaning overall (I fucking approve) but we've had a bit of a history here of bullying out anything that strays right, so I get wary when it looks like it has been decided that Wegandi is on the right and therefore the enemy. Y'all are frustrated and attacking each other personally. No need, friends. You're both super well spoken and capable of defending/debating your points normally. You're also both free to just walk away if that feels better, no harm no foul. (Sorry for the lack of political input. I'm mostly a lurker of this thread, and generally appreciate the discourse) | ||
|
Nouar
France3270 Posts
On July 19 2020 02:56 Dan HH wrote: Mail voting in the US is attempting to solve issues that don't exist in France due to automatic registration, voting on Sundays and virtually no queues outside of foreign consulates. (Just to point out that we have only some form of automatic registration in certain cases, at 18yo for example. After moving we need to register to the town hall on the electoral list, then are sent a voter card -that you do not need to show to vote, only ID-. If you haven't done that, you can't just go to the polling place of your new place, it won't work.) | ||
|
Ben...
Canada3485 Posts
On July 19 2020 03:46 Nouar wrote: (Just to point out that we have only some form of automatic registration in certain cases, at 18yo for example. After moving we need to register to the town hall on the electoral list, then are sent a voter card -that you do not need to show to vote, only ID-. If you haven't done that, you can't just go to the polling place of your new place, it won't work.) That's not too different from what we have in Canada, and it works fine. Both systems are magnitudes better than the inconsistent garbage fire that the US has. | ||
|
Gahlo
United States35162 Posts
On July 19 2020 01:29 Furikawari wrote: Yeah, you look very informed. We have postal voting around here. We also have voting through a tier mind you. As for american politics, I follow it more than you assume. And btw, what did trump took yesterday before his talk? It looked like complete nonsense (I mean, even more than usual). And btw, mail ballots is not what Trump is trying to block? Yeah I don't know enough about your politicis probably. And calm down on the personal attacks please. Regarding portland : www.commondreams.org I dunno much about USA politics, but I suppose ACLU is some form of antifa terrorist group... Isn't election day also a holiday there? | ||
|
Wegandi
United States2455 Posts
On July 19 2020 02:56 Dan HH wrote: Mail voting in the US is attempting to solve issues that don't exist in France due to automatic registration, voting on Sundays and virtually no queues outside of foreign consulates. I don't know why there isn't as big of a push for those other solutions as there is for mail voting, but the point of the poster you replied to was that opposition to it stems from not wanting to fix the electoral process by those that benefit from lower/filtered turnout rather than from a lack of necessity as in France. What baffles me about you and Danglars is how you take the appearance of the US more seriously and personally than anyone else here yet at the same time are the most dismissive about fixing the issues that cause those negative appearances. You are more upset with pesky TLers pointing out the willfully broken voting process rather than with the willfully broken voting process existing. I actually don't think the voting process is all that broken outside of felons not being able to vote (and I personally think voting privileges should be much more restrictive (e.g. you should be a taxpayer to be able to vote)). As for your general assertion its very easy in America to register to vote and many places have same day registration you just have to show up to the polling location. I don't think automatic registration does anything significant when to me that just signifies how awful the democratic system itself is where you have to automatically register folks rather than them taking a little bit of effort (like super minimal) to register themselves, but then we give them the power of the vote which has very drastic consequences for not only their fellow citizens but people around the world. Does anyone never connect those two? Like we can't trust people to register themselves, but we can trust them enough to pick folks to wield the power of the USG? Come on. I actually don't care about the appearance of the USG (in fact, I probably have a much worse view of it than everyone here), I just take issue with hypocrits and its especially strong from EU posters who will levy accusations on high from their pedestal when the EU in many cases is worse or has similar problems that they conveniently ignore. It's a bit of a glass house thing. Maybe its just an ingrained reflexive behavior from all your colonizing (and yes that is passive aggressive). As for dismissive about fixing? Lol. I'm a misanthropic anarchist so I find it funny that you'd levy that allegation. It's obvious you're not familiar with my views or posting history. | ||
|
Wegandi
United States2455 Posts
On July 19 2020 02:43 Furikawari wrote: And regarding electronic vote, it's a joke, as a software developper I can tell you that I will ALWAYS fight against this. But on the other hand I understand why a guy like Wegandi thinks it's a good thing.... As long as the machine retailer are sold to republicans that is. It's funny you think I'm a Republican. A republican that's for abolishing the standing army (and who is feverishly anti-war and pro-trade), eliminating all foreign military outposts, legalizing all vices and non-violent "crimes", reinstating nuisance courts and strengthening property rights protections to protect the environment, minimizing policing institutions footprint (I mean, ideally, abolish State-police and the State, with competing market-based judicial, security, and law enterprises, but....I'm a realist), abolishing State-marriage licensing and improving contractual recognition (polygamy arrangements, same-sex, etc.), and having open-borders with voting restriction placements. Yeah, so Republican let me tell you. | ||
| ||