• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 11:00
CET 17:00
KST 01:00
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #2312[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over6Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over SC4ALL: II Indiegogo Campaign Announcement No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Team Liquid Map Contest #23 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon
Tourneys
RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16) Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 552 Secret Storm Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
XUN appreciation thread BW General Discussion List of top players active on ShieldBattery Potentially helpful Shield Battery feedback. People still play BW?
Tourneys
$3,000 Sijosae Tier 2,3,4 Cup (Nov 23-24 2026) [BSL23] Ro16 Group B - Saturday 21:00 CET 2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread The PlayStation 5 Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread The Games Industry And ATVI Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Trading/Investing Thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 15548 users

US Politics Mega-thread - Page 2048

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
Prev 1 2046 2047 2048 2049 2050 6095 Next
Now that we have a new thread, in order to ensure that this thread continues to meet TL standards and follows the proper guidelines, we will be enforcing the rules in the OP more strictly. Be sure to give them a complete and thorough read before posting!

NOTE: When providing a source, please provide a very brief summary on what it's about and what purpose it adds to the discussion. The supporting statement should clearly explain why the subject is relevant and needs to be discussed. Please follow this rule especially for tweets.

Your supporting statement should always come BEFORE you provide the source.


If you have any questions, comments, concern, or feedback regarding the USPMT, then please use this thread: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/website-feedback/510156-us-politics-thread
WombaT
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Northern Ireland27497 Posts
January 21 2020 16:15 GMT
#40941
On January 22 2020 00:56 GreenHorizons wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 22 2020 00:41 ChristianS wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:43 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 21 2020 15:13 ChristianS wrote:
On January 21 2020 14:42 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 20 2020 16:22 ChristianS wrote:
On January 20 2020 07:12 Introvert wrote:
On January 20 2020 06:59 Nebuchad wrote:
On January 20 2020 06:52 Introvert wrote:
On January 20 2020 06:34 ChristianS wrote:
[quote]
I’m flattered (I think)! Can’t speak to the state of the thread lately - I had 11,000 unread posts before I decided to just click to the latest page. Had a busy 2019.

I guess part of my point is that “greedy” behavior is usually just as undesirable in a capitalist system as any other. Fraud, embezzlement, theft, or any other scheme in which you can profit by harming others. But sometimes when people condemn greedy behavior in our system, there’s this weird allergic reaction where people decide we can’t criticize the actions of corporations or we’re betraying patriotism or Adam Smith or something.

I’ll give a concrete example. Purdue Pharma is widely credited with creating and profiting from many of the dynamics now referred to as the “opioid crisis.” The specifics depend on who you ask, but the broad strokes are they developed dangerous and highly addictive drugs, lied about their addictiveness and side effects, and generally massaged the healthcare system in whatever ways would maximize sales. Worth noting, though, it doesn’t seem like any of that was illegal. They were simply pursuing profit within the law.

Does capitalism forbid us from condemning their destructive profit-seeking?


Maybe I'm still unclear what you are saying, but non-socialists (even capitalists!) still recognize greed as a vice. It might do in a pinch, but any sustained discussion should drop the word greed, as you above advocated. It's not like "cooperation" doesn't have a large part of it either. Pretty sure everyone who identifies as a capitalist can be found complaining about this or that corporation's behavior quite often


It follows that conversations about capitalism that contain ideas such as "greed is part of human nature" should be dropped, doesn't it? I don't see what they bring if we don't start from the premise that greed is a positive force.

Edit: I think that's what you were saying.


I think I would be ok with that. I have a problem with using greed as a "positive force" as you put it. I assume that many of the same people who would run to "greed" are the same people who say things like "socialism is a fine theory, it just doesn't work." It's almost too easy a way out. Rather than argue for capitalism, they will just argue against socialism. I don't know that such a one-sided focus is sustainable, espeically as those societies that tried it fade further back into history. If being a capitalist meant venerating as virtue that which is vice, it would indeed be wrong.

edit: but to be clear, human fallibility is a core part of American Conservatism which if course includes a capitalist outlook. Human behavior still matters. But I wouldn't argue that greed is good. I'm probably not explaining this very well.

I especially like the bolded section, in part because I think it applies to a lot of argument I see on the right. Modern “conservatives” (yourself excluded, if that wasn’t obvious) often seem pretty unfamiliar with the theoretical and moral underpinnings of conservatism; they’ll use terms like “rule of law” or “limited government” like cudgels, with little regard for what they actually mean.

Again, maybe it’ll be clearer what I mean with a concrete example: I think properly understood, the concept of “rule of law” would dictate a lot of fundamental changes to police procedure and criminal justice that people like GH would praise, and perhaps a majority of Republicans (certainly Trump himself!) would condemn. I find this frustrating. Not just for the hypocrisy of it - nearly everyone is a hypocrite sometimes, and I think people are a little too harsh when they spot it - but because I don’t know what these people’s ideology actually is. If someone calls themself conservative, but doesn’t actually give a shit about rule of law or limited government, well, what the hell are they really?


Fascists, I'd call them fascists.

Heh, maybe that is the category I’m hunting for. Is that what you get when you take conservatism and leach out its moral content?

But then I still don’t understand - why? Why be a fascist? And why lie about it?

To me, the statements “I favor enacting policy X” and “the world would be better overall if policy X were enacted” are inseparable. If you give up the latter, what motivates the former? Why bother leaving your house to vote if you don’t even think that winning the vote would make things better?


A variety of reasons in my view.

One way I understand it is from talking to vets that think/thought the US would be better if it was run like the military. Democracy is for disagreeing with leaders, if you have the right leaders you don't need a democracy, it only slows down progress from that perspective.

Their problem with subservience to the government isn't that it's subservience to a government, it's that THEY will be subservient to a government intended to exploit not-them and they fear it will turn into "them".

It's not a tyrannical government if it's just doing what you would in it's stead if that makes sense?

EDIT: To elaborate a bit, the thousands of bombs we drop, billions in sanctions, exponentially more military spending than any other nation, hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians we kill, etc... isn't fascist tyranny to people because it is not happening to them.

xDaunt elaborated on this as foreign policy operating outside of morality/ethics as opposed to domestic policy. This is typically supported by making a particular type of person (white males) the arbiters of morality, ethics, and domestic justice. So the negative consequences of tyranny and fascism reaches them last.

"First they came for... Then there was no one left to speak for me."

I was also thinking about xDaunt’s “amoral” foreign policy (though I understand he’s not around to defend the position any more). While I’m still baffled by the amorality of it (again, why bother leaving your house to vote? If it’s just self-interest, there must be easier ways to enrich yourself), I can at least see how drawing a sharp line between foreign and domestic is doing a lot of work. If you can be reasonably confident the US will never classify you as “foreign,” you don’t need to worry about it being turned around on you.

I’m a little uncertain how to talk to someone like that, though. I can make arguments about why it’s not actually in our self-interest to fuck over others (fucking up other countries tends to create refugee crises we don’t know how to handle, for example); but that’s also not the point. We shouldn’t massacre civilians because it’s wrong, not because a bit of the gore might splash back on us.

Meanwhile, why pretend to be a “conservative”? I’m not sure how much of it is a ploy (“I can’t admit my real beliefs so I’ll pretend to be something else”) and how much is honest misunderstanding (“wait, conservatism doesn’t mean anybody besides me has zero moral worth? Since when?”). I suspect (in keeping with my sig) it’s more of the latter, but either way I don’t know what to do with it. Take my best guess at what they actually believe, and argue against positions they never actually said aloud? Take them at their word, and keep arguing against the positions they’re defending, but probably don’t actually believe? Try to “educate” them on the “correct” conservative position, even though I don’t identify as conservative? Everything I can think of seems futile or obnoxious or both; I usually just try to disengage.

I was talking with a guy just this past weekend who told me his neighbors were “full-blown Muslims” who “complain that he celebrates Christmas” and need to be “sent back to where they came from” because they picked fruit off the fruit tree in his yard. That guy gets very indignant if you suggest he’s not a conservative; and I don’t think he’s just wearing the “conservative” label as a deception to mask his true beliefs, considering he doesn’t seem to have any shame about expressing his more vile opinions. But I also don’t think that the conservative ideals he’s name-checking would lead to his conclusions, properly understood. So what is there to say to him?


That's going to need to be answered by someone who thinks fascists can be reasoned with or "defeated in the marketplace of ideas" or whatever. I wouldn't hold your breath though.

As to the general "why" of your questions, as Wombat pointed out about Vivax's "nurses need to be poor" (paraphrase) argument the beliefs are hegemonic and incoherent and the people that hold them are able to insulate themselves with people that believe it too.

Wombat won't be able to inform Vivax's hypothetical nurse that he thinks her being poor is the best way to leverage her into taking care of him because proximity to poverty will kill him first. So instead she'll be thankful to have a job not knowing that the precariousness of her survival is a feature, not a bug.

Killing children in the Middle East is obviously wrong but we get away with killing thousands and thousands of them because the hegemonic belief is that it's the best option. Which is reinforced by a cascade of other hegemonic ideas that, like premises in capitalism, people don't critically engage with unless forced to (which is nearly impossible to do, at some level they have to choose to).

Ireland (the South) has a shortage of nurses that they can’t redress because they lose so many to either emigrating to the UK or switching professions entirely.

There’s a breaking point on how much you can squeeze even people with a vocational calling before they end up doing something else.

It’s not purely a wage thing either, it’s both hours worked as well as job security. People can reconcile themself to working a lot if it’s regular and guaranteed, if it’s not and it’s consistently changeable then people can’t even plan a week ahead in terms of social lives and whatnot. I was dating a nurse for a bit and we dropped it because it was utterly unworkable on a schedule sense. Managing 2 times together in 2 months because they switched her rota every week and our schedules took that long to align, just wasn’t workable.

Currently they’re plugging the gap with agency nurses, who cost the state more per hour because the obvious solution of better pay and conditions is not being pursued.
'You'll always be the cuddly marsupial of my heart, despite the inherent flaws of your ancestry' - Squat
TL+ Member
WombaT
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Northern Ireland27497 Posts
January 21 2020 16:31 GMT
#40942
On January 22 2020 01:12 ZerOCoolSC2 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 22 2020 00:39 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:30 ZerOCoolSC2 wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:10 farvacola wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:05 Womwomwom wrote:
Then you're talking about things that basically no one, not even GreenHorizons, is arguing for.

That’s the beauty of shooting at a nebulous target that moves as you wish. This is also a helpful showing of why discussing specific policies is likely a better move than playing endless games of “Whose definition of Socialism/Capitalism/Communism is it anyway?”

I think a lot of posters have been trying to get to that point, but it inevitably gets pushed towards that game anyhow. Would go a long way in conversing were there actual policies and ideas put forth. But it's the Kitty Genovese syndrome all over every time. Someone is waiting for another to take action and no one does. So nothing gets done.


I think one reason specific policy doesn't get discussed is because the first point made about it is that Republicans (or centrist Democrats) won't support it so it's pointless to talk about.

Then comes "well we should replace them" then "but we can't because money in politics" then "then get the money out" then "we can't, they need it to beat Republicans/the people with the power to change take it out are dependent on keeping it in and we can't expect them to act against their self-interests in that way"

Then we circle back to needing a new system to implement policy we all agree is better than what we have. Which brings us to "Socialism never works".

Then complaints that we're talking about socialism and the people in opposition don't know what it is.

EDIT: One benefit to this latest round is that we know that the biggest advocates for capitalism/opponents of socialism don't really know what capitalism is either.

The constant focus on central planning and belief that socialism doesn't have markets as well as the inability to see many problems are capitalism working as intended and the need for supplementary systems like socialist healthcare serve as recent and clear examples this is the case.

I'll be quick.

Let's leave money in politics out of it. It's a wash. Let's focus solely on what policies would be good, how/who would install those policies, and what would be the preferred outcome. It can be mixed markets, social democracy, or capitalism reworked to better serve most rather than few. I think once we set some hard areas with which we can agree upon, then we can move forward.

So for starters: The need to retain/gather absurd wealth is not something that should be condoned since that same absurd wealth is not beneficial to most. A small percentage of wealth redistribution and perhaps "cap on total net wealth" could be advocated? I don't think a lot of people with that kind of money (10s of billions) would allow it to happen, but it can be made possible through capping capital gains.

Redistributing wealth is pointless if you don’t reform other systems at the same time. I’m not particularly in favour of capping wealth arbitrarily either.

I’ll avoid too much specifics, more general strokes in terms of tweaking things without going full socialist market economy.

1. If you want to operate in x country you can’t avoid your tax obligations in said country. You get taxed on whatever you earn in any specific country and whatever their rates are.
2. If you want to live in a country no overshore shit. Go live in the Cayman Islands if you want to put your assets there.
3. Non-domiciles shouldn’t be able to own additional residential property outside of their residence in whatever country.
4. Proper reform of the financial system. Tax the bullshit transactions.
5. A more widespread adoption of the cooperative model over the shareholder method, although not exclusively.
6. Nationalise public transport fully.
7. Nationalise the entire property rental market.
'You'll always be the cuddly marsupial of my heart, despite the inherent flaws of your ancestry' - Squat
TL+ Member
GreenHorizons
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States24527 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-21 16:45:50
January 21 2020 16:43 GMT
#40943
On January 22 2020 01:31 Wombat_NI wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 22 2020 01:12 ZerOCoolSC2 wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:39 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:30 ZerOCoolSC2 wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:10 farvacola wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:05 Womwomwom wrote:
Then you're talking about things that basically no one, not even GreenHorizons, is arguing for.

That’s the beauty of shooting at a nebulous target that moves as you wish. This is also a helpful showing of why discussing specific policies is likely a better move than playing endless games of “Whose definition of Socialism/Capitalism/Communism is it anyway?”

I think a lot of posters have been trying to get to that point, but it inevitably gets pushed towards that game anyhow. Would go a long way in conversing were there actual policies and ideas put forth. But it's the Kitty Genovese syndrome all over every time. Someone is waiting for another to take action and no one does. So nothing gets done.


I think one reason specific policy doesn't get discussed is because the first point made about it is that Republicans (or centrist Democrats) won't support it so it's pointless to talk about.

Then comes "well we should replace them" then "but we can't because money in politics" then "then get the money out" then "we can't, they need it to beat Republicans/the people with the power to change take it out are dependent on keeping it in and we can't expect them to act against their self-interests in that way"

Then we circle back to needing a new system to implement policy we all agree is better than what we have. Which brings us to "Socialism never works".

Then complaints that we're talking about socialism and the people in opposition don't know what it is.

EDIT: One benefit to this latest round is that we know that the biggest advocates for capitalism/opponents of socialism don't really know what capitalism is either.

The constant focus on central planning and belief that socialism doesn't have markets as well as the inability to see many problems are capitalism working as intended and the need for supplementary systems like socialist healthcare serve as recent and clear examples this is the case.

I'll be quick.

Let's leave money in politics out of it. It's a wash. Let's focus solely on what policies would be good, how/who would install those policies, and what would be the preferred outcome. It can be mixed markets, social democracy, or capitalism reworked to better serve most rather than few. I think once we set some hard areas with which we can agree upon, then we can move forward.

So for starters: The need to retain/gather absurd wealth is not something that should be condoned since that same absurd wealth is not beneficial to most. A small percentage of wealth redistribution and perhaps "cap on total net wealth" could be advocated? I don't think a lot of people with that kind of money (10s of billions) would allow it to happen, but it can be made possible through capping capital gains.

Redistributing wealth is pointless if you don’t reform other systems at the same time. I’m not particularly in favour of capping wealth arbitrarily either.

I’ll avoid too much specifics, more general strokes in terms of tweaking things without going full socialist market economy.

1. If you want to operate in x country you can’t avoid your tax obligations in said country. You get taxed on whatever you earn in any specific country and whatever their rates are.
2. If you want to live in a country no overshore shit. Go live in the Cayman Islands if you want to put your assets there.
3. Non-domiciles shouldn’t be able to own additional residential property outside of their residence in whatever country.
4. Proper reform of the financial system. Tax the bullshit transactions.
5. A more widespread adoption of the cooperative model over the shareholder method, although not exclusively.
6. Nationalise public transport fully.
7. Nationalise the entire property rental market.


I don't want to get on this ride (that was the point of the post) but I do want to agree with your first point and just say that's why I think Freireian critical pedagogy is a crucial first step. I don't believe a critical class consciousness can be raised without it and I don't believe we can analyze and deal with the issues you mention and the many more that need to be addressed in the comprehensive way we need to without that critical class consciousness.
"People like to look at history and think 'If that was me back then, I would have...' We're living through history, and the truth is, whatever you are doing now is probably what you would have done then" "Scratch a Liberal..."
WombaT
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Northern Ireland27497 Posts
January 21 2020 16:52 GMT
#40944
On January 22 2020 01:43 GreenHorizons wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 22 2020 01:31 Wombat_NI wrote:
On January 22 2020 01:12 ZerOCoolSC2 wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:39 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:30 ZerOCoolSC2 wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:10 farvacola wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:05 Womwomwom wrote:
Then you're talking about things that basically no one, not even GreenHorizons, is arguing for.

That’s the beauty of shooting at a nebulous target that moves as you wish. This is also a helpful showing of why discussing specific policies is likely a better move than playing endless games of “Whose definition of Socialism/Capitalism/Communism is it anyway?”

I think a lot of posters have been trying to get to that point, but it inevitably gets pushed towards that game anyhow. Would go a long way in conversing were there actual policies and ideas put forth. But it's the Kitty Genovese syndrome all over every time. Someone is waiting for another to take action and no one does. So nothing gets done.


I think one reason specific policy doesn't get discussed is because the first point made about it is that Republicans (or centrist Democrats) won't support it so it's pointless to talk about.

Then comes "well we should replace them" then "but we can't because money in politics" then "then get the money out" then "we can't, they need it to beat Republicans/the people with the power to change take it out are dependent on keeping it in and we can't expect them to act against their self-interests in that way"

Then we circle back to needing a new system to implement policy we all agree is better than what we have. Which brings us to "Socialism never works".

Then complaints that we're talking about socialism and the people in opposition don't know what it is.

EDIT: One benefit to this latest round is that we know that the biggest advocates for capitalism/opponents of socialism don't really know what capitalism is either.

The constant focus on central planning and belief that socialism doesn't have markets as well as the inability to see many problems are capitalism working as intended and the need for supplementary systems like socialist healthcare serve as recent and clear examples this is the case.

I'll be quick.

Let's leave money in politics out of it. It's a wash. Let's focus solely on what policies would be good, how/who would install those policies, and what would be the preferred outcome. It can be mixed markets, social democracy, or capitalism reworked to better serve most rather than few. I think once we set some hard areas with which we can agree upon, then we can move forward.

So for starters: The need to retain/gather absurd wealth is not something that should be condoned since that same absurd wealth is not beneficial to most. A small percentage of wealth redistribution and perhaps "cap on total net wealth" could be advocated? I don't think a lot of people with that kind of money (10s of billions) would allow it to happen, but it can be made possible through capping capital gains.

Redistributing wealth is pointless if you don’t reform other systems at the same time. I’m not particularly in favour of capping wealth arbitrarily either.

I’ll avoid too much specifics, more general strokes in terms of tweaking things without going full socialist market economy.

1. If you want to operate in x country you can’t avoid your tax obligations in said country. You get taxed on whatever you earn in any specific country and whatever their rates are.
2. If you want to live in a country no overshore shit. Go live in the Cayman Islands if you want to put your assets there.
3. Non-domiciles shouldn’t be able to own additional residential property outside of their residence in whatever country.
4. Proper reform of the financial system. Tax the bullshit transactions.
5. A more widespread adoption of the cooperative model over the shareholder method, although not exclusively.
6. Nationalise public transport fully.
7. Nationalise the entire property rental market.


I don't want to get on this ride (that was the point of the post) but I do want to agree with your first point and just say that's why I think Freireian critical pedagogy is a crucial first step. I don't believe a critical class consciousness can be raised without it and I don't believe we can analyze and deal with the issues you mention and the many more that need to be addressed in the comprehensive way we need to without that critical class consciousness.

I believe we’re aligned on that anyway.

To solve whatever problem one first must realise not just that it’s a problem, but why it is a problem and what a potential solution would look like.

That’s somewhat lacking in a lot of modern discourse.

Capitalism isn’t an economic system anymore, it’s culturally ingrained as the norm, the default so any reformation requires a reframing of that.
'You'll always be the cuddly marsupial of my heart, despite the inherent flaws of your ancestry' - Squat
TL+ Member
Velr
Profile Blog Joined July 2008
Switzerland10992 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-21 18:41:46
January 21 2020 18:41 GMT
#40945
On January 22 2020 01:15 Wombat_NI wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 22 2020 00:56 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:41 ChristianS wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:43 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 21 2020 15:13 ChristianS wrote:
On January 21 2020 14:42 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 20 2020 16:22 ChristianS wrote:
On January 20 2020 07:12 Introvert wrote:
On January 20 2020 06:59 Nebuchad wrote:
On January 20 2020 06:52 Introvert wrote:
[quote]

Maybe I'm still unclear what you are saying, but non-socialists (even capitalists!) still recognize greed as a vice. It might do in a pinch, but any sustained discussion should drop the word greed, as you above advocated. It's not like "cooperation" doesn't have a large part of it either. Pretty sure everyone who identifies as a capitalist can be found complaining about this or that corporation's behavior quite often


It follows that conversations about capitalism that contain ideas such as "greed is part of human nature" should be dropped, doesn't it? I don't see what they bring if we don't start from the premise that greed is a positive force.

Edit: I think that's what you were saying.


I think I would be ok with that. I have a problem with using greed as a "positive force" as you put it. I assume that many of the same people who would run to "greed" are the same people who say things like "socialism is a fine theory, it just doesn't work." It's almost too easy a way out. Rather than argue for capitalism, they will just argue against socialism. I don't know that such a one-sided focus is sustainable, espeically as those societies that tried it fade further back into history. If being a capitalist meant venerating as virtue that which is vice, it would indeed be wrong.

edit: but to be clear, human fallibility is a core part of American Conservatism which if course includes a capitalist outlook. Human behavior still matters. But I wouldn't argue that greed is good. I'm probably not explaining this very well.

I especially like the bolded section, in part because I think it applies to a lot of argument I see on the right. Modern “conservatives” (yourself excluded, if that wasn’t obvious) often seem pretty unfamiliar with the theoretical and moral underpinnings of conservatism; they’ll use terms like “rule of law” or “limited government” like cudgels, with little regard for what they actually mean.

Again, maybe it’ll be clearer what I mean with a concrete example: I think properly understood, the concept of “rule of law” would dictate a lot of fundamental changes to police procedure and criminal justice that people like GH would praise, and perhaps a majority of Republicans (certainly Trump himself!) would condemn. I find this frustrating. Not just for the hypocrisy of it - nearly everyone is a hypocrite sometimes, and I think people are a little too harsh when they spot it - but because I don’t know what these people’s ideology actually is. If someone calls themself conservative, but doesn’t actually give a shit about rule of law or limited government, well, what the hell are they really?


Fascists, I'd call them fascists.

Heh, maybe that is the category I’m hunting for. Is that what you get when you take conservatism and leach out its moral content?

But then I still don’t understand - why? Why be a fascist? And why lie about it?

To me, the statements “I favor enacting policy X” and “the world would be better overall if policy X were enacted” are inseparable. If you give up the latter, what motivates the former? Why bother leaving your house to vote if you don’t even think that winning the vote would make things better?


A variety of reasons in my view.

One way I understand it is from talking to vets that think/thought the US would be better if it was run like the military. Democracy is for disagreeing with leaders, if you have the right leaders you don't need a democracy, it only slows down progress from that perspective.

Their problem with subservience to the government isn't that it's subservience to a government, it's that THEY will be subservient to a government intended to exploit not-them and they fear it will turn into "them".

It's not a tyrannical government if it's just doing what you would in it's stead if that makes sense?

EDIT: To elaborate a bit, the thousands of bombs we drop, billions in sanctions, exponentially more military spending than any other nation, hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians we kill, etc... isn't fascist tyranny to people because it is not happening to them.

xDaunt elaborated on this as foreign policy operating outside of morality/ethics as opposed to domestic policy. This is typically supported by making a particular type of person (white males) the arbiters of morality, ethics, and domestic justice. So the negative consequences of tyranny and fascism reaches them last.

"First they came for... Then there was no one left to speak for me."

I was also thinking about xDaunt’s “amoral” foreign policy (though I understand he’s not around to defend the position any more). While I’m still baffled by the amorality of it (again, why bother leaving your house to vote? If it’s just self-interest, there must be easier ways to enrich yourself), I can at least see how drawing a sharp line between foreign and domestic is doing a lot of work. If you can be reasonably confident the US will never classify you as “foreign,” you don’t need to worry about it being turned around on you.

I’m a little uncertain how to talk to someone like that, though. I can make arguments about why it’s not actually in our self-interest to fuck over others (fucking up other countries tends to create refugee crises we don’t know how to handle, for example); but that’s also not the point. We shouldn’t massacre civilians because it’s wrong, not because a bit of the gore might splash back on us.

Meanwhile, why pretend to be a “conservative”? I’m not sure how much of it is a ploy (“I can’t admit my real beliefs so I’ll pretend to be something else”) and how much is honest misunderstanding (“wait, conservatism doesn’t mean anybody besides me has zero moral worth? Since when?”). I suspect (in keeping with my sig) it’s more of the latter, but either way I don’t know what to do with it. Take my best guess at what they actually believe, and argue against positions they never actually said aloud? Take them at their word, and keep arguing against the positions they’re defending, but probably don’t actually believe? Try to “educate” them on the “correct” conservative position, even though I don’t identify as conservative? Everything I can think of seems futile or obnoxious or both; I usually just try to disengage.

I was talking with a guy just this past weekend who told me his neighbors were “full-blown Muslims” who “complain that he celebrates Christmas” and need to be “sent back to where they came from” because they picked fruit off the fruit tree in his yard. That guy gets very indignant if you suggest he’s not a conservative; and I don’t think he’s just wearing the “conservative” label as a deception to mask his true beliefs, considering he doesn’t seem to have any shame about expressing his more vile opinions. But I also don’t think that the conservative ideals he’s name-checking would lead to his conclusions, properly understood. So what is there to say to him?


That's going to need to be answered by someone who thinks fascists can be reasoned with or "defeated in the marketplace of ideas" or whatever. I wouldn't hold your breath though.

As to the general "why" of your questions, as Wombat pointed out about Vivax's "nurses need to be poor" (paraphrase) argument the beliefs are hegemonic and incoherent and the people that hold them are able to insulate themselves with people that believe it too.

Wombat won't be able to inform Vivax's hypothetical nurse that he thinks her being poor is the best way to leverage her into taking care of him because proximity to poverty will kill him first. So instead she'll be thankful to have a job not knowing that the precariousness of her survival is a feature, not a bug.

Killing children in the Middle East is obviously wrong but we get away with killing thousands and thousands of them because the hegemonic belief is that it's the best option. Which is reinforced by a cascade of other hegemonic ideas that, like premises in capitalism, people don't critically engage with unless forced to (which is nearly impossible to do, at some level they have to choose to).

Ireland (the South) has a shortage of nurses that they can’t redress because they lose so many to either emigrating to the UK or switching professions entirely.

There’s a breaking point on how much you can squeeze even people with a vocational calling before they end up doing something else.

It’s not purely a wage thing either, it’s both hours worked as well as job security. People can reconcile themself to working a lot if it’s regular and guaranteed, if it’s not and it’s consistently changeable then people can’t even plan a week ahead in terms of social lives and whatnot. I was dating a nurse for a bit and we dropped it because it was utterly unworkable on a schedule sense. Managing 2 times together in 2 months because they switched her rota every week and our schedules took that long to align, just wasn’t workable.

Currently they’re plugging the gap with agency nurses, who cost the state more per hour because the obvious solution of better pay and conditions is not being pursued.


Seems to be more of an issue with (anglosaxon)labour laws. Not that everything is fine and dandy here but you come in hells kitchen if you overstep as an employer. In the health sector its also really easy to find another job due to a general shortage. The pay for a teained(!!!) nurse is also not bad.
Mohdoo
Profile Joined August 2007
United States15743 Posts
January 21 2020 18:54 GMT
#40946
Clinton saying no one likes Bernie is perhaps his most significant endorsement yet. The enemy of Clinton is the ally of most voters both left and right
WombaT
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Northern Ireland27497 Posts
January 21 2020 19:03 GMT
#40947
On January 22 2020 03:41 Velr wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 22 2020 01:15 Wombat_NI wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:56 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:41 ChristianS wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:43 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 21 2020 15:13 ChristianS wrote:
On January 21 2020 14:42 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 20 2020 16:22 ChristianS wrote:
On January 20 2020 07:12 Introvert wrote:
On January 20 2020 06:59 Nebuchad wrote:
[quote]

It follows that conversations about capitalism that contain ideas such as "greed is part of human nature" should be dropped, doesn't it? I don't see what they bring if we don't start from the premise that greed is a positive force.

Edit: I think that's what you were saying.


I think I would be ok with that. I have a problem with using greed as a "positive force" as you put it. I assume that many of the same people who would run to "greed" are the same people who say things like "socialism is a fine theory, it just doesn't work." It's almost too easy a way out. Rather than argue for capitalism, they will just argue against socialism. I don't know that such a one-sided focus is sustainable, espeically as those societies that tried it fade further back into history. If being a capitalist meant venerating as virtue that which is vice, it would indeed be wrong.

edit: but to be clear, human fallibility is a core part of American Conservatism which if course includes a capitalist outlook. Human behavior still matters. But I wouldn't argue that greed is good. I'm probably not explaining this very well.

I especially like the bolded section, in part because I think it applies to a lot of argument I see on the right. Modern “conservatives” (yourself excluded, if that wasn’t obvious) often seem pretty unfamiliar with the theoretical and moral underpinnings of conservatism; they’ll use terms like “rule of law” or “limited government” like cudgels, with little regard for what they actually mean.

Again, maybe it’ll be clearer what I mean with a concrete example: I think properly understood, the concept of “rule of law” would dictate a lot of fundamental changes to police procedure and criminal justice that people like GH would praise, and perhaps a majority of Republicans (certainly Trump himself!) would condemn. I find this frustrating. Not just for the hypocrisy of it - nearly everyone is a hypocrite sometimes, and I think people are a little too harsh when they spot it - but because I don’t know what these people’s ideology actually is. If someone calls themself conservative, but doesn’t actually give a shit about rule of law or limited government, well, what the hell are they really?


Fascists, I'd call them fascists.

Heh, maybe that is the category I’m hunting for. Is that what you get when you take conservatism and leach out its moral content?

But then I still don’t understand - why? Why be a fascist? And why lie about it?

To me, the statements “I favor enacting policy X” and “the world would be better overall if policy X were enacted” are inseparable. If you give up the latter, what motivates the former? Why bother leaving your house to vote if you don’t even think that winning the vote would make things better?


A variety of reasons in my view.

One way I understand it is from talking to vets that think/thought the US would be better if it was run like the military. Democracy is for disagreeing with leaders, if you have the right leaders you don't need a democracy, it only slows down progress from that perspective.

Their problem with subservience to the government isn't that it's subservience to a government, it's that THEY will be subservient to a government intended to exploit not-them and they fear it will turn into "them".

It's not a tyrannical government if it's just doing what you would in it's stead if that makes sense?

EDIT: To elaborate a bit, the thousands of bombs we drop, billions in sanctions, exponentially more military spending than any other nation, hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians we kill, etc... isn't fascist tyranny to people because it is not happening to them.

xDaunt elaborated on this as foreign policy operating outside of morality/ethics as opposed to domestic policy. This is typically supported by making a particular type of person (white males) the arbiters of morality, ethics, and domestic justice. So the negative consequences of tyranny and fascism reaches them last.

"First they came for... Then there was no one left to speak for me."

I was also thinking about xDaunt’s “amoral” foreign policy (though I understand he’s not around to defend the position any more). While I’m still baffled by the amorality of it (again, why bother leaving your house to vote? If it’s just self-interest, there must be easier ways to enrich yourself), I can at least see how drawing a sharp line between foreign and domestic is doing a lot of work. If you can be reasonably confident the US will never classify you as “foreign,” you don’t need to worry about it being turned around on you.

I’m a little uncertain how to talk to someone like that, though. I can make arguments about why it’s not actually in our self-interest to fuck over others (fucking up other countries tends to create refugee crises we don’t know how to handle, for example); but that’s also not the point. We shouldn’t massacre civilians because it’s wrong, not because a bit of the gore might splash back on us.

Meanwhile, why pretend to be a “conservative”? I’m not sure how much of it is a ploy (“I can’t admit my real beliefs so I’ll pretend to be something else”) and how much is honest misunderstanding (“wait, conservatism doesn’t mean anybody besides me has zero moral worth? Since when?”). I suspect (in keeping with my sig) it’s more of the latter, but either way I don’t know what to do with it. Take my best guess at what they actually believe, and argue against positions they never actually said aloud? Take them at their word, and keep arguing against the positions they’re defending, but probably don’t actually believe? Try to “educate” them on the “correct” conservative position, even though I don’t identify as conservative? Everything I can think of seems futile or obnoxious or both; I usually just try to disengage.

I was talking with a guy just this past weekend who told me his neighbors were “full-blown Muslims” who “complain that he celebrates Christmas” and need to be “sent back to where they came from” because they picked fruit off the fruit tree in his yard. That guy gets very indignant if you suggest he’s not a conservative; and I don’t think he’s just wearing the “conservative” label as a deception to mask his true beliefs, considering he doesn’t seem to have any shame about expressing his more vile opinions. But I also don’t think that the conservative ideals he’s name-checking would lead to his conclusions, properly understood. So what is there to say to him?


That's going to need to be answered by someone who thinks fascists can be reasoned with or "defeated in the marketplace of ideas" or whatever. I wouldn't hold your breath though.

As to the general "why" of your questions, as Wombat pointed out about Vivax's "nurses need to be poor" (paraphrase) argument the beliefs are hegemonic and incoherent and the people that hold them are able to insulate themselves with people that believe it too.

Wombat won't be able to inform Vivax's hypothetical nurse that he thinks her being poor is the best way to leverage her into taking care of him because proximity to poverty will kill him first. So instead she'll be thankful to have a job not knowing that the precariousness of her survival is a feature, not a bug.

Killing children in the Middle East is obviously wrong but we get away with killing thousands and thousands of them because the hegemonic belief is that it's the best option. Which is reinforced by a cascade of other hegemonic ideas that, like premises in capitalism, people don't critically engage with unless forced to (which is nearly impossible to do, at some level they have to choose to).

Ireland (the South) has a shortage of nurses that they can’t redress because they lose so many to either emigrating to the UK or switching professions entirely.

There’s a breaking point on how much you can squeeze even people with a vocational calling before they end up doing something else.

It’s not purely a wage thing either, it’s both hours worked as well as job security. People can reconcile themself to working a lot if it’s regular and guaranteed, if it’s not and it’s consistently changeable then people can’t even plan a week ahead in terms of social lives and whatnot. I was dating a nurse for a bit and we dropped it because it was utterly unworkable on a schedule sense. Managing 2 times together in 2 months because they switched her rota every week and our schedules took that long to align, just wasn’t workable.

Currently they’re plugging the gap with agency nurses, who cost the state more per hour because the obvious solution of better pay and conditions is not being pursued.


Seems to be more of an issue with (anglosaxon)labour laws. Not that everything is fine and dandy here but you come in hells kitchen if you overstep as an employer. In the health sector its also really easy to find another job due to a general shortage. The pay for a teained(!!!) nurse is also not bad.

Utter bollocks.

User was warned for this post.
'You'll always be the cuddly marsupial of my heart, despite the inherent flaws of your ancestry' - Squat
TL+ Member
Howie_Dewitt
Profile Joined March 2014
United States1416 Posts
January 21 2020 19:10 GMT
#40948
I know that a lot of people have been annoyed at GreenHorizons' "refusal to answer questions and only talk about revolution," and I'm not really sure what side of that argument I fall on. However, I've thought of two questions that I think would be interesting to hear his opinion on that concern policy, and two that he might feel compelled to answer.

1. You mention Friereian critical pedagogy a whole lot, and not many people ever go into detail on it here. What would an education system look like if it was based on that model instead of what you see and the "banking" or "pitcher" model of education in place today, and how would it be applicable to such a large scale as the United States? Additionally, could executive actions and the power the executive branch has over the department of education help move our country onto that path, or must it be done though means outside of the government?

2. Would the reinstatement of FDR's fireside chat, adapted to a global medium, help this goal of critical pedagogy or be part of the end goal? I've been thinking about how something like the fireside chat could be very effective on today's digital mediums and help inform the public about what's going on.
Sisyphus had a good gig going, the disappointment was predictable. | Visions of the Country (1978) is for when you're lost.
farvacola
Profile Blog Joined January 2011
United States18877 Posts
January 21 2020 19:17 GMT
#40949
Hell yeah, I am all-in on bringing fireside chat-modeled government-populace interactions back to the forefront.
"when the Dead Kennedys found out they had skinhead fans, they literally wrote a song titled 'Nazi Punks Fuck Off'"
ZerOCoolSC2
Profile Blog Joined February 2015
9079 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-21 20:17:04
January 21 2020 20:16 GMT
#40950
On January 22 2020 01:31 Wombat_NI wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 22 2020 01:12 ZerOCoolSC2 wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:39 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:30 ZerOCoolSC2 wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:10 farvacola wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:05 Womwomwom wrote:
Then you're talking about things that basically no one, not even GreenHorizons, is arguing for.

That’s the beauty of shooting at a nebulous target that moves as you wish. This is also a helpful showing of why discussing specific policies is likely a better move than playing endless games of “Whose definition of Socialism/Capitalism/Communism is it anyway?”

I think a lot of posters have been trying to get to that point, but it inevitably gets pushed towards that game anyhow. Would go a long way in conversing were there actual policies and ideas put forth. But it's the Kitty Genovese syndrome all over every time. Someone is waiting for another to take action and no one does. So nothing gets done.


I think one reason specific policy doesn't get discussed is because the first point made about it is that Republicans (or centrist Democrats) won't support it so it's pointless to talk about.

Then comes "well we should replace them" then "but we can't because money in politics" then "then get the money out" then "we can't, they need it to beat Republicans/the people with the power to change take it out are dependent on keeping it in and we can't expect them to act against their self-interests in that way"

Then we circle back to needing a new system to implement policy we all agree is better than what we have. Which brings us to "Socialism never works".

Then complaints that we're talking about socialism and the people in opposition don't know what it is.

EDIT: One benefit to this latest round is that we know that the biggest advocates for capitalism/opponents of socialism don't really know what capitalism is either.

The constant focus on central planning and belief that socialism doesn't have markets as well as the inability to see many problems are capitalism working as intended and the need for supplementary systems like socialist healthcare serve as recent and clear examples this is the case.

I'll be quick.

Let's leave money in politics out of it. It's a wash. Let's focus solely on what policies would be good, how/who would install those policies, and what would be the preferred outcome. It can be mixed markets, social democracy, or capitalism reworked to better serve most rather than few. I think once we set some hard areas with which we can agree upon, then we can move forward.

So for starters: The need to retain/gather absurd wealth is not something that should be condoned since that same absurd wealth is not beneficial to most. A small percentage of wealth redistribution and perhaps "cap on total net wealth" could be advocated? I don't think a lot of people with that kind of money (10s of billions) would allow it to happen, but it can be made possible through capping capital gains.

Redistributing wealth is pointless if you don’t reform other systems at the same time. I’m not particularly in favour of capping wealth arbitrarily either.

I’ll avoid too much specifics, more general strokes in terms of tweaking things without going full socialist market economy.

1. If you want to operate in x country you can’t avoid your tax obligations in said country. You get taxed on whatever you earn in any specific country and whatever their rates are.
2. If you want to live in a country no overshore shit. Go live in the Cayman Islands if you want to put your assets there.
3. Non-domiciles shouldn’t be able to own additional residential property outside of their residence in whatever country.
4. Proper reform of the financial system. Tax the bullshit transactions.
5. A more widespread adoption of the cooperative model over the shareholder method, although not exclusively.
6. Nationalise public transport fully.
7. Nationalise the entire property rental market.

Just to get the conversation started on proposals is why I mentioned it. A lot of people have mentioned it as something they would like. I wanted to know what they would do to see it come to fruition and what the details (or general framework) would look like. I don't know myself. But this gets us to the meat and bones and gets the political philosophy out of the way as much as possible and forces people to articulate their ideas. We've been fed generalizations and half-ass notions. Now let's say what we think would be the best way and hold firm on those ideas. I believe only then can we really create an open discussion to point at the errors or barriers to getting those done.

I think your quick list is a good summary and we can start picking those apart or adding to it as needed.
Nebuchad
Profile Blog Joined December 2012
Switzerland12622 Posts
January 21 2020 20:21 GMT
#40951
Never heard of this fireside chat and I'm at work, so this is the perfect moment to learn =). Can someone link me something to start?
No will to live, no wish to die
eviltomahawk
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
United States11135 Posts
January 21 2020 20:26 GMT
#40952
On January 22 2020 05:21 Nebuchad wrote:
Never heard of this fireside chat and I'm at work, so this is the perfect moment to learn =). Can someone link me something to start?

The FDR fireside chats? Here's a quick wiki lookup

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fireside_chats
ㅇㅅㅌㅅ
ChristianS
Profile Blog Joined March 2011
United States3319 Posts
January 21 2020 20:42 GMT
#40953
On January 22 2020 00:56 GreenHorizons wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 22 2020 00:41 ChristianS wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:43 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 21 2020 15:13 ChristianS wrote:
On January 21 2020 14:42 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 20 2020 16:22 ChristianS wrote:
On January 20 2020 07:12 Introvert wrote:
On January 20 2020 06:59 Nebuchad wrote:
On January 20 2020 06:52 Introvert wrote:
On January 20 2020 06:34 ChristianS wrote:
[quote]
I’m flattered (I think)! Can’t speak to the state of the thread lately - I had 11,000 unread posts before I decided to just click to the latest page. Had a busy 2019.

I guess part of my point is that “greedy” behavior is usually just as undesirable in a capitalist system as any other. Fraud, embezzlement, theft, or any other scheme in which you can profit by harming others. But sometimes when people condemn greedy behavior in our system, there’s this weird allergic reaction where people decide we can’t criticize the actions of corporations or we’re betraying patriotism or Adam Smith or something.

I’ll give a concrete example. Purdue Pharma is widely credited with creating and profiting from many of the dynamics now referred to as the “opioid crisis.” The specifics depend on who you ask, but the broad strokes are they developed dangerous and highly addictive drugs, lied about their addictiveness and side effects, and generally massaged the healthcare system in whatever ways would maximize sales. Worth noting, though, it doesn’t seem like any of that was illegal. They were simply pursuing profit within the law.

Does capitalism forbid us from condemning their destructive profit-seeking?


Maybe I'm still unclear what you are saying, but non-socialists (even capitalists!) still recognize greed as a vice. It might do in a pinch, but any sustained discussion should drop the word greed, as you above advocated. It's not like "cooperation" doesn't have a large part of it either. Pretty sure everyone who identifies as a capitalist can be found complaining about this or that corporation's behavior quite often


It follows that conversations about capitalism that contain ideas such as "greed is part of human nature" should be dropped, doesn't it? I don't see what they bring if we don't start from the premise that greed is a positive force.

Edit: I think that's what you were saying.


I think I would be ok with that. I have a problem with using greed as a "positive force" as you put it. I assume that many of the same people who would run to "greed" are the same people who say things like "socialism is a fine theory, it just doesn't work." It's almost too easy a way out. Rather than argue for capitalism, they will just argue against socialism. I don't know that such a one-sided focus is sustainable, espeically as those societies that tried it fade further back into history. If being a capitalist meant venerating as virtue that which is vice, it would indeed be wrong.

edit: but to be clear, human fallibility is a core part of American Conservatism which if course includes a capitalist outlook. Human behavior still matters. But I wouldn't argue that greed is good. I'm probably not explaining this very well.

I especially like the bolded section, in part because I think it applies to a lot of argument I see on the right. Modern “conservatives” (yourself excluded, if that wasn’t obvious) often seem pretty unfamiliar with the theoretical and moral underpinnings of conservatism; they’ll use terms like “rule of law” or “limited government” like cudgels, with little regard for what they actually mean.

Again, maybe it’ll be clearer what I mean with a concrete example: I think properly understood, the concept of “rule of law” would dictate a lot of fundamental changes to police procedure and criminal justice that people like GH would praise, and perhaps a majority of Republicans (certainly Trump himself!) would condemn. I find this frustrating. Not just for the hypocrisy of it - nearly everyone is a hypocrite sometimes, and I think people are a little too harsh when they spot it - but because I don’t know what these people’s ideology actually is. If someone calls themself conservative, but doesn’t actually give a shit about rule of law or limited government, well, what the hell are they really?


Fascists, I'd call them fascists.

Heh, maybe that is the category I’m hunting for. Is that what you get when you take conservatism and leach out its moral content?

But then I still don’t understand - why? Why be a fascist? And why lie about it?

To me, the statements “I favor enacting policy X” and “the world would be better overall if policy X were enacted” are inseparable. If you give up the latter, what motivates the former? Why bother leaving your house to vote if you don’t even think that winning the vote would make things better?


A variety of reasons in my view.

One way I understand it is from talking to vets that think/thought the US would be better if it was run like the military. Democracy is for disagreeing with leaders, if you have the right leaders you don't need a democracy, it only slows down progress from that perspective.

Their problem with subservience to the government isn't that it's subservience to a government, it's that THEY will be subservient to a government intended to exploit not-them and they fear it will turn into "them".

It's not a tyrannical government if it's just doing what you would in it's stead if that makes sense?

EDIT: To elaborate a bit, the thousands of bombs we drop, billions in sanctions, exponentially more military spending than any other nation, hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians we kill, etc... isn't fascist tyranny to people because it is not happening to them.

xDaunt elaborated on this as foreign policy operating outside of morality/ethics as opposed to domestic policy. This is typically supported by making a particular type of person (white males) the arbiters of morality, ethics, and domestic justice. So the negative consequences of tyranny and fascism reaches them last.

"First they came for... Then there was no one left to speak for me."

I was also thinking about xDaunt’s “amoral” foreign policy (though I understand he’s not around to defend the position any more). While I’m still baffled by the amorality of it (again, why bother leaving your house to vote? If it’s just self-interest, there must be easier ways to enrich yourself), I can at least see how drawing a sharp line between foreign and domestic is doing a lot of work. If you can be reasonably confident the US will never classify you as “foreign,” you don’t need to worry about it being turned around on you.

I’m a little uncertain how to talk to someone like that, though. I can make arguments about why it’s not actually in our self-interest to fuck over others (fucking up other countries tends to create refugee crises we don’t know how to handle, for example); but that’s also not the point. We shouldn’t massacre civilians because it’s wrong, not because a bit of the gore might splash back on us.

Meanwhile, why pretend to be a “conservative”? I’m not sure how much of it is a ploy (“I can’t admit my real beliefs so I’ll pretend to be something else”) and how much is honest misunderstanding (“wait, conservatism doesn’t mean anybody besides me has zero moral worth? Since when?”). I suspect (in keeping with my sig) it’s more of the latter, but either way I don’t know what to do with it. Take my best guess at what they actually believe, and argue against positions they never actually said aloud? Take them at their word, and keep arguing against the positions they’re defending, but probably don’t actually believe? Try to “educate” them on the “correct” conservative position, even though I don’t identify as conservative? Everything I can think of seems futile or obnoxious or both; I usually just try to disengage.

I was talking with a guy just this past weekend who told me his neighbors were “full-blown Muslims” who “complain that he celebrates Christmas” and need to be “sent back to where they came from” because they picked fruit off the fruit tree in his yard. That guy gets very indignant if you suggest he’s not a conservative; and I don’t think he’s just wearing the “conservative” label as a deception to mask his true beliefs, considering he doesn’t seem to have any shame about expressing his more vile opinions. But I also don’t think that the conservative ideals he’s name-checking would lead to his conclusions, properly understood. So what is there to say to him?


That's going to need to be answered by someone who thinks fascists can be reasoned with or "defeated in the marketplace of ideas" or whatever. I wouldn't hold your breath though.

As to the general "why" of your questions, as Wombat pointed out about Vivax's "nurses need to be poor" (paraphrase) argument the beliefs are hegemonic and incoherent and the people that hold them are able to insulate themselves with people that believe it too.

Wombat won't be able to inform Vivax's hypothetical nurse that he thinks her being poor is the best way to leverage her into taking care of him because proximity to poverty will kill him first. So instead she'll be thankful to have a job not knowing that the precariousness of her survival is a feature, not a bug.

Killing children in the Middle East is obviously wrong but we get away with killing thousands and thousands of them because the hegemonic belief is that it's the best option. Which is reinforced by a cascade of other hegemonic ideas that, like premises in capitalism, people don't critically engage with unless forced to (which is nearly impossible to do, at some level they have to choose to).

No, I’m not holding my breath on “convincing” anyone either. Maybe a few years ago I might have thought, “look how wrong this person is! I’m going to crucify this person’s position, and my logic will be so ironclad they’ll have to concede!” These days I think I mostly aim to understand others’ positions better, and maybe spur them to consider their position a little more thoughtfully. I don’t know that convincing them is impossible, but I doubt it is any special talent of mine.

I don’t want to derail the thread too much further (or maybe people like the “ChristianS Asks GH How Fascism Works” show, idk), so for now I’ll just say thank you for your thoughts!
"Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity." -Robert J. Hanlon
Sbrubbles
Profile Joined October 2010
Brazil5776 Posts
January 21 2020 21:34 GMT
#40954
On January 22 2020 01:31 Wombat_NI wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 22 2020 01:12 ZerOCoolSC2 wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:39 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:30 ZerOCoolSC2 wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:10 farvacola wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:05 Womwomwom wrote:
Then you're talking about things that basically no one, not even GreenHorizons, is arguing for.

That’s the beauty of shooting at a nebulous target that moves as you wish. This is also a helpful showing of why discussing specific policies is likely a better move than playing endless games of “Whose definition of Socialism/Capitalism/Communism is it anyway?”

I think a lot of posters have been trying to get to that point, but it inevitably gets pushed towards that game anyhow. Would go a long way in conversing were there actual policies and ideas put forth. But it's the Kitty Genovese syndrome all over every time. Someone is waiting for another to take action and no one does. So nothing gets done.


I think one reason specific policy doesn't get discussed is because the first point made about it is that Republicans (or centrist Democrats) won't support it so it's pointless to talk about.

Then comes "well we should replace them" then "but we can't because money in politics" then "then get the money out" then "we can't, they need it to beat Republicans/the people with the power to change take it out are dependent on keeping it in and we can't expect them to act against their self-interests in that way"

Then we circle back to needing a new system to implement policy we all agree is better than what we have. Which brings us to "Socialism never works".

Then complaints that we're talking about socialism and the people in opposition don't know what it is.

EDIT: One benefit to this latest round is that we know that the biggest advocates for capitalism/opponents of socialism don't really know what capitalism is either.

The constant focus on central planning and belief that socialism doesn't have markets as well as the inability to see many problems are capitalism working as intended and the need for supplementary systems like socialist healthcare serve as recent and clear examples this is the case.

I'll be quick.

Let's leave money in politics out of it. It's a wash. Let's focus solely on what policies would be good, how/who would install those policies, and what would be the preferred outcome. It can be mixed markets, social democracy, or capitalism reworked to better serve most rather than few. I think once we set some hard areas with which we can agree upon, then we can move forward.

So for starters: The need to retain/gather absurd wealth is not something that should be condoned since that same absurd wealth is not beneficial to most. A small percentage of wealth redistribution and perhaps "cap on total net wealth" could be advocated? I don't think a lot of people with that kind of money (10s of billions) would allow it to happen, but it can be made possible through capping capital gains.

Redistributing wealth is pointless if you don’t reform other systems at the same time. I’m not particularly in favour of capping wealth arbitrarily either.

I’ll avoid too much specifics, more general strokes in terms of tweaking things without going full socialist market economy.

1. If you want to operate in x country you can’t avoid your tax obligations in said country. You get taxed on whatever you earn in any specific country and whatever their rates are.
2. If you want to live in a country no overshore shit. Go live in the Cayman Islands if you want to put your assets there.
3. Non-domiciles shouldn’t be able to own additional residential property outside of their residence in whatever country.
4. Proper reform of the financial system. Tax the bullshit transactions.
5. A more widespread adoption of the cooperative model over the shareholder method, although not exclusively.
6. Nationalise public transport fully.
7. Nationalise the entire property rental market.


If you don't mind indulging me, what do you mean by "socialist market economy" exactly? Wikipedia says it's the Chinese model of state-owned companies undertaking for-profit mandates, but it doesn't seem that's what you mean (though I could be wrong).
Bora Pain minha porra!
GreenHorizons
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States24527 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-21 22:12:55
January 21 2020 22:00 GMT
#40955
On January 22 2020 04:10 Howie_Dewitt wrote:
I know that a lot of people have been annoyed at GreenHorizons' "refusal to answer questions and only talk about revolution," and I'm not really sure what side of that argument I fall on. However, I've thought of two questions that I think would be interesting to hear his opinion on that concern policy, and two that he might feel compelled to answer.

1. You mention Friereian critical pedagogy a whole lot, and not many people ever go into detail on it here. What would an education system look like if it was based on that model instead of what you see and the "banking" or "pitcher" model of education in place today, and how would it be applicable to such a large scale as the United States? Additionally, could executive actions and the power the executive branch has over the department of education help move our country onto that path, or must it be done though means outside of the government?

2. Would the reinstatement of FDR's fireside chat, adapted to a global medium, help this goal of critical pedagogy or be part of the end goal? I've been thinking about how something like the fireside chat could be very effective on today's digital mediums and help inform the public about what's going on.


1.It's a bit hard to describe from scratch but presuming others understand the basic differences between the banking model and critical pedagogy it reshapes the entire social construction of education.

People are familiar with the banking model, an example being the forced wrote memorization geography we talked about here before. Critical pedagogy is the formally thought out (pedagogically) conception of what everyone was saying they would prefer.

Chapter 3 of Pedagogy of the Oppressed is what you'll want to read if you want to get into the more gritty details, but generally speaking it's a dialogical engagement where everyone are students and everyone teachers the curriculum is determined by them collectively, and at it's heart it functions to empower people with the steadfast belief that the world is what we make it, not a void we can only reactively adapt to.

Critical pedagogy isn't like a tech school or something, it's a way of life if that makes sense?

I don't think about the president in relation to critical pedagogy it's much more of a ground up operation. It's mass movement education along the style of the Panther's breakfast program.

2.Like redistributing wealth the fireside chat without the pedagogical underpinnings is pretty useless but generally speaking yeah. The idea is that we're all able to dialogue about the issues of the day in such a way that when we're done we arrive at a more enlightened vision/description of the world.

EDIT: As an example I'd like/think it would be instructive if someone wants to know more about critical pedagogy to pick a page (at random if they wish) from Pedagogy of the Oppressed to ask about/discuss.
"People like to look at history and think 'If that was me back then, I would have...' We're living through history, and the truth is, whatever you are doing now is probably what you would have done then" "Scratch a Liberal..."
WombaT
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Northern Ireland27497 Posts
January 21 2020 22:58 GMT
#40956
On January 22 2020 04:03 Wombat_NI wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 22 2020 03:41 Velr wrote:
On January 22 2020 01:15 Wombat_NI wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:56 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:41 ChristianS wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:43 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 21 2020 15:13 ChristianS wrote:
On January 21 2020 14:42 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 20 2020 16:22 ChristianS wrote:
On January 20 2020 07:12 Introvert wrote:
[quote]

I think I would be ok with that. I have a problem with using greed as a "positive force" as you put it. I assume that many of the same people who would run to "greed" are the same people who say things like "socialism is a fine theory, it just doesn't work." It's almost too easy a way out. Rather than argue for capitalism, they will just argue against socialism. I don't know that such a one-sided focus is sustainable, espeically as those societies that tried it fade further back into history. If being a capitalist meant venerating as virtue that which is vice, it would indeed be wrong.

edit: but to be clear, human fallibility is a core part of American Conservatism which if course includes a capitalist outlook. Human behavior still matters. But I wouldn't argue that greed is good. I'm probably not explaining this very well.

I especially like the bolded section, in part because I think it applies to a lot of argument I see on the right. Modern “conservatives” (yourself excluded, if that wasn’t obvious) often seem pretty unfamiliar with the theoretical and moral underpinnings of conservatism; they’ll use terms like “rule of law” or “limited government” like cudgels, with little regard for what they actually mean.

Again, maybe it’ll be clearer what I mean with a concrete example: I think properly understood, the concept of “rule of law” would dictate a lot of fundamental changes to police procedure and criminal justice that people like GH would praise, and perhaps a majority of Republicans (certainly Trump himself!) would condemn. I find this frustrating. Not just for the hypocrisy of it - nearly everyone is a hypocrite sometimes, and I think people are a little too harsh when they spot it - but because I don’t know what these people’s ideology actually is. If someone calls themself conservative, but doesn’t actually give a shit about rule of law or limited government, well, what the hell are they really?


Fascists, I'd call them fascists.

Heh, maybe that is the category I’m hunting for. Is that what you get when you take conservatism and leach out its moral content?

But then I still don’t understand - why? Why be a fascist? And why lie about it?

To me, the statements “I favor enacting policy X” and “the world would be better overall if policy X were enacted” are inseparable. If you give up the latter, what motivates the former? Why bother leaving your house to vote if you don’t even think that winning the vote would make things better?


A variety of reasons in my view.

One way I understand it is from talking to vets that think/thought the US would be better if it was run like the military. Democracy is for disagreeing with leaders, if you have the right leaders you don't need a democracy, it only slows down progress from that perspective.

Their problem with subservience to the government isn't that it's subservience to a government, it's that THEY will be subservient to a government intended to exploit not-them and they fear it will turn into "them".

It's not a tyrannical government if it's just doing what you would in it's stead if that makes sense?

EDIT: To elaborate a bit, the thousands of bombs we drop, billions in sanctions, exponentially more military spending than any other nation, hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians we kill, etc... isn't fascist tyranny to people because it is not happening to them.

xDaunt elaborated on this as foreign policy operating outside of morality/ethics as opposed to domestic policy. This is typically supported by making a particular type of person (white males) the arbiters of morality, ethics, and domestic justice. So the negative consequences of tyranny and fascism reaches them last.

"First they came for... Then there was no one left to speak for me."

I was also thinking about xDaunt’s “amoral” foreign policy (though I understand he’s not around to defend the position any more). While I’m still baffled by the amorality of it (again, why bother leaving your house to vote? If it’s just self-interest, there must be easier ways to enrich yourself), I can at least see how drawing a sharp line between foreign and domestic is doing a lot of work. If you can be reasonably confident the US will never classify you as “foreign,” you don’t need to worry about it being turned around on you.

I’m a little uncertain how to talk to someone like that, though. I can make arguments about why it’s not actually in our self-interest to fuck over others (fucking up other countries tends to create refugee crises we don’t know how to handle, for example); but that’s also not the point. We shouldn’t massacre civilians because it’s wrong, not because a bit of the gore might splash back on us.

Meanwhile, why pretend to be a “conservative”? I’m not sure how much of it is a ploy (“I can’t admit my real beliefs so I’ll pretend to be something else”) and how much is honest misunderstanding (“wait, conservatism doesn’t mean anybody besides me has zero moral worth? Since when?”). I suspect (in keeping with my sig) it’s more of the latter, but either way I don’t know what to do with it. Take my best guess at what they actually believe, and argue against positions they never actually said aloud? Take them at their word, and keep arguing against the positions they’re defending, but probably don’t actually believe? Try to “educate” them on the “correct” conservative position, even though I don’t identify as conservative? Everything I can think of seems futile or obnoxious or both; I usually just try to disengage.

I was talking with a guy just this past weekend who told me his neighbors were “full-blown Muslims” who “complain that he celebrates Christmas” and need to be “sent back to where they came from” because they picked fruit off the fruit tree in his yard. That guy gets very indignant if you suggest he’s not a conservative; and I don’t think he’s just wearing the “conservative” label as a deception to mask his true beliefs, considering he doesn’t seem to have any shame about expressing his more vile opinions. But I also don’t think that the conservative ideals he’s name-checking would lead to his conclusions, properly understood. So what is there to say to him?


That's going to need to be answered by someone who thinks fascists can be reasoned with or "defeated in the marketplace of ideas" or whatever. I wouldn't hold your breath though.

As to the general "why" of your questions, as Wombat pointed out about Vivax's "nurses need to be poor" (paraphrase) argument the beliefs are hegemonic and incoherent and the people that hold them are able to insulate themselves with people that believe it too.

Wombat won't be able to inform Vivax's hypothetical nurse that he thinks her being poor is the best way to leverage her into taking care of him because proximity to poverty will kill him first. So instead she'll be thankful to have a job not knowing that the precariousness of her survival is a feature, not a bug.

Killing children in the Middle East is obviously wrong but we get away with killing thousands and thousands of them because the hegemonic belief is that it's the best option. Which is reinforced by a cascade of other hegemonic ideas that, like premises in capitalism, people don't critically engage with unless forced to (which is nearly impossible to do, at some level they have to choose to).

Ireland (the South) has a shortage of nurses that they can’t redress because they lose so many to either emigrating to the UK or switching professions entirely.

There’s a breaking point on how much you can squeeze even people with a vocational calling before they end up doing something else.

It’s not purely a wage thing either, it’s both hours worked as well as job security. People can reconcile themself to working a lot if it’s regular and guaranteed, if it’s not and it’s consistently changeable then people can’t even plan a week ahead in terms of social lives and whatnot. I was dating a nurse for a bit and we dropped it because it was utterly unworkable on a schedule sense. Managing 2 times together in 2 months because they switched her rota every week and our schedules took that long to align, just wasn’t workable.

Currently they’re plugging the gap with agency nurses, who cost the state more per hour because the obvious solution of better pay and conditions is not being pursued.


Seems to be more of an issue with (anglosaxon)labour laws. Not that everything is fine and dandy here but you come in hells kitchen if you overstep as an employer. In the health sector its also really easy to find another job due to a general shortage. The pay for a teained(!!!) nurse is also not bad.

Utter bollocks.

User was warned for this post.

It’s not?
'You'll always be the cuddly marsupial of my heart, despite the inherent flaws of your ancestry' - Squat
TL+ Member
BigFan
Profile Blog Joined December 2010
TLADT24920 Posts
January 21 2020 23:20 GMT
#40957
On January 22 2020 07:58 Wombat_NI wrote:
Show nested quote +
On January 22 2020 04:03 Wombat_NI wrote:
On January 22 2020 03:41 Velr wrote:
On January 22 2020 01:15 Wombat_NI wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:56 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 22 2020 00:41 ChristianS wrote:
On January 21 2020 22:43 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 21 2020 15:13 ChristianS wrote:
On January 21 2020 14:42 GreenHorizons wrote:
On January 20 2020 16:22 ChristianS wrote:
[quote]
I especially like the bolded section, in part because I think it applies to a lot of argument I see on the right. Modern “conservatives” (yourself excluded, if that wasn’t obvious) often seem pretty unfamiliar with the theoretical and moral underpinnings of conservatism; they’ll use terms like “rule of law” or “limited government” like cudgels, with little regard for what they actually mean.

Again, maybe it’ll be clearer what I mean with a concrete example: I think properly understood, the concept of “rule of law” would dictate a lot of fundamental changes to police procedure and criminal justice that people like GH would praise, and perhaps a majority of Republicans (certainly Trump himself!) would condemn. I find this frustrating. Not just for the hypocrisy of it - nearly everyone is a hypocrite sometimes, and I think people are a little too harsh when they spot it - but because I don’t know what these people’s ideology actually is. If someone calls themself conservative, but doesn’t actually give a shit about rule of law or limited government, well, what the hell are they really?


Fascists, I'd call them fascists.

Heh, maybe that is the category I’m hunting for. Is that what you get when you take conservatism and leach out its moral content?

But then I still don’t understand - why? Why be a fascist? And why lie about it?

To me, the statements “I favor enacting policy X” and “the world would be better overall if policy X were enacted” are inseparable. If you give up the latter, what motivates the former? Why bother leaving your house to vote if you don’t even think that winning the vote would make things better?


A variety of reasons in my view.

One way I understand it is from talking to vets that think/thought the US would be better if it was run like the military. Democracy is for disagreeing with leaders, if you have the right leaders you don't need a democracy, it only slows down progress from that perspective.

Their problem with subservience to the government isn't that it's subservience to a government, it's that THEY will be subservient to a government intended to exploit not-them and they fear it will turn into "them".

It's not a tyrannical government if it's just doing what you would in it's stead if that makes sense?

EDIT: To elaborate a bit, the thousands of bombs we drop, billions in sanctions, exponentially more military spending than any other nation, hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians we kill, etc... isn't fascist tyranny to people because it is not happening to them.

xDaunt elaborated on this as foreign policy operating outside of morality/ethics as opposed to domestic policy. This is typically supported by making a particular type of person (white males) the arbiters of morality, ethics, and domestic justice. So the negative consequences of tyranny and fascism reaches them last.

"First they came for... Then there was no one left to speak for me."

I was also thinking about xDaunt’s “amoral” foreign policy (though I understand he’s not around to defend the position any more). While I’m still baffled by the amorality of it (again, why bother leaving your house to vote? If it’s just self-interest, there must be easier ways to enrich yourself), I can at least see how drawing a sharp line between foreign and domestic is doing a lot of work. If you can be reasonably confident the US will never classify you as “foreign,” you don’t need to worry about it being turned around on you.

I’m a little uncertain how to talk to someone like that, though. I can make arguments about why it’s not actually in our self-interest to fuck over others (fucking up other countries tends to create refugee crises we don’t know how to handle, for example); but that’s also not the point. We shouldn’t massacre civilians because it’s wrong, not because a bit of the gore might splash back on us.

Meanwhile, why pretend to be a “conservative”? I’m not sure how much of it is a ploy (“I can’t admit my real beliefs so I’ll pretend to be something else”) and how much is honest misunderstanding (“wait, conservatism doesn’t mean anybody besides me has zero moral worth? Since when?”). I suspect (in keeping with my sig) it’s more of the latter, but either way I don’t know what to do with it. Take my best guess at what they actually believe, and argue against positions they never actually said aloud? Take them at their word, and keep arguing against the positions they’re defending, but probably don’t actually believe? Try to “educate” them on the “correct” conservative position, even though I don’t identify as conservative? Everything I can think of seems futile or obnoxious or both; I usually just try to disengage.

I was talking with a guy just this past weekend who told me his neighbors were “full-blown Muslims” who “complain that he celebrates Christmas” and need to be “sent back to where they came from” because they picked fruit off the fruit tree in his yard. That guy gets very indignant if you suggest he’s not a conservative; and I don’t think he’s just wearing the “conservative” label as a deception to mask his true beliefs, considering he doesn’t seem to have any shame about expressing his more vile opinions. But I also don’t think that the conservative ideals he’s name-checking would lead to his conclusions, properly understood. So what is there to say to him?


That's going to need to be answered by someone who thinks fascists can be reasoned with or "defeated in the marketplace of ideas" or whatever. I wouldn't hold your breath though.

As to the general "why" of your questions, as Wombat pointed out about Vivax's "nurses need to be poor" (paraphrase) argument the beliefs are hegemonic and incoherent and the people that hold them are able to insulate themselves with people that believe it too.

Wombat won't be able to inform Vivax's hypothetical nurse that he thinks her being poor is the best way to leverage her into taking care of him because proximity to poverty will kill him first. So instead she'll be thankful to have a job not knowing that the precariousness of her survival is a feature, not a bug.

Killing children in the Middle East is obviously wrong but we get away with killing thousands and thousands of them because the hegemonic belief is that it's the best option. Which is reinforced by a cascade of other hegemonic ideas that, like premises in capitalism, people don't critically engage with unless forced to (which is nearly impossible to do, at some level they have to choose to).

Ireland (the South) has a shortage of nurses that they can’t redress because they lose so many to either emigrating to the UK or switching professions entirely.

There’s a breaking point on how much you can squeeze even people with a vocational calling before they end up doing something else.

It’s not purely a wage thing either, it’s both hours worked as well as job security. People can reconcile themself to working a lot if it’s regular and guaranteed, if it’s not and it’s consistently changeable then people can’t even plan a week ahead in terms of social lives and whatnot. I was dating a nurse for a bit and we dropped it because it was utterly unworkable on a schedule sense. Managing 2 times together in 2 months because they switched her rota every week and our schedules took that long to align, just wasn’t workable.

Currently they’re plugging the gap with agency nurses, who cost the state more per hour because the obvious solution of better pay and conditions is not being pursued.


Seems to be more of an issue with (anglosaxon)labour laws. Not that everything is fine and dandy here but you come in hells kitchen if you overstep as an employer. In the health sector its also really easy to find another job due to a general shortage. The pay for a teained(!!!) nurse is also not bad.

Utter bollocks.

User was warned for this post.

It’s not?

Website feedback mate ^^
Former BW EiC"Watch Bakemonogatari or I will kill you." -Toad, April 18th, 2017
GreenHorizons
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States24527 Posts
Last Edited: 2020-01-21 23:39:41
January 21 2020 23:39 GMT
#40958
Another avenue of critical pedagogy might be looking at something like Classic's conscription and investigating if we can find any connections between that and US foreign policy past and/or present.
"People like to look at history and think 'If that was me back then, I would have...' We're living through history, and the truth is, whatever you are doing now is probably what you would have done then" "Scratch a Liberal..."
iamthedave
Profile Joined February 2011
England2814 Posts
January 21 2020 23:39 GMT
#40959
On January 22 2020 01:07 Mohdoo wrote:
There's a neoliberal subreddit. I'm amazed. It seems like everything there is said unironically


The Donald exists. You have to believe the insanity now. Because those guys do.
I'm not bad at Starcraft; I just think winning's rude.
IgnE
Profile Joined November 2010
United States7684 Posts
January 22 2020 01:37 GMT
#40960
On January 22 2020 08:39 GreenHorizons wrote:
Another avenue of critical pedagogy might be looking at something like Classic's conscription and investigating if we can find any connections between that and US foreign policy past and/or present.


What is Classic?
It is terrible to die of thirst at sea. Must you so salt your truth that it will no longer even slake thirst?
Prev 1 2046 2047 2048 2049 2050 6095 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
OSC
22:00
King of the Hill #268
Liquipedia
RSL Revival
22:00
Offline Finals: Playoffs
herO vs RogueLIVE!
Tasteless1740
ComeBackTV 1079
IntoTheiNu 1048
RotterdaM769
TaKeTV 441
IndyStarCraft 413
kabyraGe 156
Rex113
3DClanTV 44
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
Tasteless 1740
RotterdaM 769
IndyStarCraft 413
LamboSC2 184
ProTech143
Rex 113
SHIN 46
BRAT_OK 34
StarCraft: Brood War
Britney 40745
Calm 8234
firebathero 1718
actioN 323
EffOrt 187
Soulkey 144
Hyuk 109
Zeus 108
Mind 93
Dewaltoss 75
[ Show more ]
Hyun 72
Pusan 67
ggaemo 59
Snow 36
PianO 35
sSak 28
Noble 23
Sacsri 19
Hm[arnc] 19
Rock 17
Movie 16
yabsab 11
zelot 11
Barracks 0
Dota 2
Gorgc9141
XaKoH 358
League of Legends
KnowMe54
Counter-Strike
edward141
Super Smash Bros
Mew2King105
Heroes of the Storm
Khaldor367
Other Games
singsing3060
B2W.Neo793
Beastyqt516
febbydoto10
Railgan3
Organizations
Other Games
EGCTV825
StarCraft: Brood War
lovetv 9
[ Show 15 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• HerbMon 32
• ChaeLyn 7
• Michael_bg 3
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
League of Legends
• Nemesis2646
• Stunt439
Other Games
• WagamamaTV386
• Shiphtur296
Upcoming Events
IPSL
1h
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
4h
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
7h
WardiTV Weekly
20h
Ultimate Battle
20h
Bisu vs Light
Kung Fu Cup
1d 19h
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
2 days
The PondCast
3 days
KCM Race Survival
3 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
RSL Offline Finals
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3

Upcoming

CSL Season 23: Qualifier 1
Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
CSL 2026 Winter (S23) - 3v3
CSL 2026 Winter (S23)
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.